Guest questioning-calvin Posted February 8, 2008 Posted February 8, 2008 Hi I'm a Reformed Christian who's in the process of possibly converting to Roman Catholicism. However the issue plagued with the most misunderstandings I think is justification. To me lots of Catholicism makes sense with scripture and I know that tradition and scripture are never supposed to be contradictory, however I guess my question is, how can you as a Catholic read Romans 1-8 and NOT believe in Justification by Faith - I know James takes down Sola Fide/Faith ALONE, but it seems that Paul seems to only care about faith in this letter, any help in understanding this would be better. The way I've had it explained by Catholics is: God gives grace, then we have faith and are 'partially justified' or some kind of justification takes place, but then good works retain our justification - to me that just sounds like 'earning your salvation' and it also feels like every time you sin you are about to lose your salvation. And as you become closer to God and you struggle more in being holy, that almost makes all of your sins Mortal sins because you struggle and contemplate them and then when you give in, it's theoretically worse than if you just gave in in the beginning. Maybe I've understood the whole scheme wrong - probably, I'm not that smart - but it just doesn't seem to me like when you read Romans you see Justification by faith and works. And I know that individual opinion is meaningless to you guys because you have the Magesterium, and I'm just a heretic, so obviously it wouldn't feel right to me. But it's just my understanding while I belive it is possible to me that once you've entered into God's family of the New Covenant, every sin is a kick out the door of God's house, and if you die on your way to confession then tough luck. I'm sure many Catholics cringe at what I've written, and I'm really sorry, I am seeking and therefore liable to make huge mistakes, but to me the whole Romans thing, and the losing your salvation thing over one sin, doesn't make sense - and that may be because I just don't understand. Please help me clarify my understanding. Thank you.
Pio Nono Posted February 8, 2008 Posted February 8, 2008 JMJ 2/8 - St Jerome Emiliani questioning-calvin, The best way to approach this is twofold: 1.) The best modern description of what the Catholic Church teaches on justification was written, oddly enough, by the Anglican Bishop of Durham, N.T. Wright, in his book [i]What Saint Paul Really Said[/i]. I send you to his chapter on justification (with special commentary on Galatians/Romans) as a source. For a more classical understanding, I send you to the Council of Orange (6th century, I think) and the [i]Decree on Justification [/i]from the Council of Trent (1545-1563). 2.) When Catholics speak with Protestants about justification, often the two sides don't realize that they're probably talking past each other. In the Protestant mind, Catholics talk of meriting justification/salvation; in the Catholic mind, Protestants conflate justification and salvation. Here's how it works for a Catholic - [indent]a.) God redeemed humankind in the blood of Christ, shed on the Cross. Jesus became sin for us to cleanse us from our sin. b.) God sends a prevenient grace upon each person which makes that person agreeable in His sight; this grace moves the individual to make a free act of faith. c.) The individual, by the grace of God, makes an act of faith and receives the sacrament of Baptism. d.) By receiving Baptism, the individual (i) becomes a new creation with the indwelling of the Holy Trinity and (ii) is incorporated into the Church. According to Paul in Galatians/Romans (cf. N.T. Wright), [i][b]justification [/b]is the incorporation of the individual believer into the Church of Jesus Christ[/i]. This is the belief of the Catholic Church. e.) Through good acts (of which God is the first cause and I am the second cause), the grace of faith and the indwelling of the Trinity grow within me; this is called [i][b]sanctification[/b][/i]. Through evil acts (of which I am the first cause), this grace and indwelling diminish; if these acts cause me to fall out of communion with the Church (mortal sin), I lose my justification and incur [i]damnation[/i]. Through the grace of God and sacramental Confession, I am restored to communion with the Church [i]and thus to my justification[/i]. By the way, if I mortally sin and die with the intention to confess (but without the ability), I am treated as if I had confessed. f.) At the end of my life, if I persevere in adhering to the grace of faith and the indwelling of the Trinity, I am judged and found to be just [i]by the unfrustrated merits of Jesus Christ present in my soul by grace[/i]. Then, I am invited to reign in the Kingdom - this is [i][b]salvation[/b][/i].[/indent] Let me know if this doesn't help. I'd love to drop the word "separated" in front of "brother" in your regard. Yours, Pio Nono
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now