Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Brokeback Mountain: Well, I Finally Saw It


Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

A few months back there was a topic here at phatmass about whether or not it was a sin to watch Brokeback Mountain. I opined that I wasn't really sure if it was a sin, but questioned why anyone would find a movie about gay cowboys at all interesting. Didn't the Village People already do this after all? Well, I got suckered in to watching the DVD tonight by a friend and let me confirm: gay cowboys [i]are[/i] boring.

My evening all started after I finished my workout, and went to eat dinner with some of my friends. One of them had to return a video to the library afterwards so we went with him to see if there was anything else to rent. Lo and behold my friend pulls Brokeback Mountain from the shelf. At first I laugh, thinking he has to be kidding, but he was dead serious. "Dude, there's alot of jokes people make about this movie. Might as well see it and get what they're talking about." he said, adding that he had seen the movie a couple times before. Seemed like a fairly decent reason to watch it, and besides what the hell else am I going to do on a Monday night?

**SPOILER WARNING** HIGHLIGHT FOLLOWING TEXT TO READ SPOILERS FROM BROKEBACK MOUNTAIN

[spoiler]I would have had a more entertaining time ironing my uniform. Their relationship starts when they herd sheep together, form a relationship no deeper then friends, and then for some bizarre reason, start having sex. One second they were just hanging out the next...well you know. I didn't get any real deep romance emitting this from the get-go. What a great way to convince your audience that these two are meant to be :rolleyes:.

Since there's no actual romantic relationship between the two the story focus on the drama and struggle of being gay. Now I'm not exactly sure why I should care about this, much less find displaying this on my television screen entertaining. Never once, throughout the plot do we see either of the two question why they are having sex in the first place. Maybe, just maybe, if they had kept their kept their relationship at "friends" they wouldn't have had as many problems.

Just my two cent on it. Going to bed now.[/spoiler]

Edited by Justin86
Posted

I saw it as being hurtful towards their wives and family that they had to hide their sexuality. If they were straight up with their sexuality, then they could have spared their wives the torment that they put them through.

I mean, the wife's father hired people to beat him to death by the side of the road and he died drowning in his blood. Heath Ledger's character's wife was devastated when she found out.

I rather a man leave me alone and allow us to be friends if he has those feelings towards men... eventhough he doesn't want to admit it. It makes it easier in the long run.

Posted

I've never seen it, but I don't think it can be good...

Posted

if the USCCB gave it an "O," it has to be bad.

Theologian in Training
Posted

[quote name='29908' post='1459160' date='Feb 11 2008, 12:20 PM']An O?
What does that even mean?[/quote]

Morally Offensive.

In other news, I have been feeling horrible all day (think I have a stomach virus) this news made it all the worse...I have no desire to see two gay men, be they cowboys, police officers, construction workers, or, dare I even say, priests (I saw that horrible movie "Priest" thinking it would be good, it was downright disgusting!)

What a way for Heath Ledger to be remembered, as a gay cowboy....

filiusInFilio
Posted

the USCCB also gave Nacho Libre an "O" rating and that was made by nickelodeon

......not saying anything against the Bishops but there's a huge difference between watching gay cowboys and a friar that wrestles to win money for orphans

Posted

[quote name='Da T Films' post='1459154' date='Feb 11 2008, 11:13 AM']if the USCCB gave it an "O," it has to be bad.[/quote]
Not really. The movie Equilibrium got an O. The reason they cite? Because the use of the term "cleric" was deemed as an intentional stab at religious institutions. And apparently it's too violent, even though there is no blood in the film and a movie like Braveheart got no such rating. :annoyed: They seem to give ratings based more on how much or how little the movie promotes Catholicism and nothing else.

I still have to see it, but if I do I'm not going to be watching it thinking about how the people in the film are sinning. Rather, I'll look at it with their struggle in mind. Actively gay or not, it was very difficult to be gay when the movie was set, and even still today. I think that that message was what the movie intended to send.

Posted

I've seen it too. Now it was a well-made movie, but not sure it deserved Best Picture or all the praise for it being an amazingly romantic movie, because it wasn't. Like a lot of you have said, there really was no romantic relationship between the men. They used each other for sex. And they were both also married, in romantic relationships with women they loved, and had beautiful children that they loved. I see it as adultery and infidelity for simply sex. Both wives were hurt, one caught it happening, etc. Not very admirable.

Other than that, it was kind of boring.

""Actively gay or not, it was very difficult to be gay when the movie was set, and even still today. I think that that message was what the movie intended to send.""

I do agree with the above sentence though.

Posted

[quote name='Theologian in Training' post='1459194' date='Feb 12 2008, 02:59 AM']What a way for Heath Ledger to be remembered, as a gay cowboy....[/quote]
It's how everyone remembers the Village People.

Posted

[quote name='filiusInFilio' post='1459214' date='Feb 11 2008, 12:18 PM']the USCCB also gave Nacho Libre an "O" rating and that was made by nickelodeon

......not saying anything against the Bishops but there's a huge difference between watching gay cowboys and a friar that wrestles to win money for orphans[/quote]
I love Nacho. Do you guys think that's bad? My wife doesn't like it. Brokeback never appealed to me. That storyline doesn't interest me. I would have this opinion no matter what my beliefs.

Posted

[quote name='Theologian in Training' post='1459194' date='Feb 12 2008, 02:59 AM']In other news, I have been feeling horrible all day (think I have a stomach virus) this news made it all the worse...I have no desire to see two gay men, be they cowboys, police officers, construction workers, or, dare I even say, priests (I saw that horrible movie "Priest" thinking it would be good, it was downright disgusting!)[/quote]
Yeah it was really gross. Jake Gyllenhaal also made similar facial expressions that he made when he played Donnie Darko and that part creeped me out too.

The whole movie was creepy and gross.

Posted

I thought it was WEIRD and it made me uncomfortable because of the sexual scenes but I wouldn't call it "gross" so much as I would call it heartbreaking on every level.

Posted

[quote name='Alycin' post='1459677' date='Feb 12 2008, 05:46 PM']I thought it was WEIRD and it made me uncomfortable because of the sexual scenes but I wouldn't call it "gross" so much as I would call it heartbreaking on every level.[/quote]
The sex scene was disgusting. Some of the noises...

Posted

Oh, and as far as it being heartbreaking, eh. When Jake Gyllenhaal's character died I felt the sadness I would whenever I hear that someone died from hate, but not really anything above that. His character was just so boring, it was hard for me to feel heartache.

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

[quote name='Loyola' post='1459490' date='Feb 11 2008, 10:59 PM']I love Nacho. Do you guys think that's bad? My wife doesn't like it. Brokeback never appealed to me. That storyline doesn't interest me. I would have this opinion no matter what my beliefs.[/quote]

I loved Nacho Libre as well. It's kinda slapstick, but I love Jack Black and appreciate his humor. I'm surprised it got an "O".

Posted

[quote name='Justin86' post='1459486' date='Feb 11 2008, 08:54 PM']It's how everyone remembers the Village People.[/quote]

Building Erector
Seaman
Police Officer
Native American
Cowboy
Leatherman

:rolleyes:

Posted

There's no way in hell, I'd walk into a video shop and rent this...I'd be embarrassed as hell. And also...why would I want to watch two guys kiss and...potentially do other stuff...

Ughh....give me The princess diaries instead o.0

Posted

Nacho Libre was a stupid movie that I [i]always[/i] every time I watch it(and I've tried several times) I fall asleep to. I just don't find it interesting at all.

Posted

[quote name='S][N' post='1471743' date='Mar 1 2008, 08:35 AM']
There's no way in hell, I'd walk into a video shop and rent this...I'd be embarrassed as hell. And also...why would I want to watch two guys kiss and...potentially do other stuff...

Ughh....give me The princess diaries instead o.0[/quote]
Hahaha!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...