JustaServant Posted February 12, 2008 Posted February 12, 2008 I feel like Rip Van Winkle coming out of a twenty year sleep, so if this has been asked before, please forgive me. What is the Society of St. Pius X? Is it a schism?
Theoketos Posted February 13, 2008 Posted February 13, 2008 Very briefly it is a priestly society that was formed by French ArchBishop Lefevbre who did not like the reform of the liturgy or the teaching of Vatican II on religious Liberty (though he signed all the documents). At the very least the ArchhBishop who founded the society and ordained priests with the permission of the Vatican was in schism. It is very likely that all subsequent priests who belong to the society are also in schism. However, two things make the situation murky. One: Laity may not belong to the Society of St. Pius X, so those who attend such may not necessarily be in schism. (Though it is a dangerous thing to attend such Masses for a variety of reasons.) And secondly, there have been (possible contradicting) confusing comments coming from the commission that deals with the SSPX. It is important to note that the SSPX claim not to be in schism and officially claim loyalty to Pope Benedict XVI seeing him as the true Pope and successor of Peter. Their masses are typically very beautiful and valid, though arguably illicit. There are other groups which are even more radical then the SSPX. (E.G. SSPV) This is to say they are not sedevacantists. And lastly for my two cents. It seems after reading Yves Congar (a big shot dead French Theologian) on the subject that most of the issues have to do with the French Church Politics and less to do with theology. I have read much of the late Archbishop's works and listen to much of the Current head of the Order has had to say. By the last two men I have not been much impressed. Their arguments are not intellectually stimulating, and so a little disappointing because I always expect to be challenged because I am a very traditional Catholic who loves the extraordinary form (a.k.a the Tridentine Mass, a.k.a the Old Latin Mass, a.k.a the Mass of Pope John XXIII, a.k.a. a whole bunch of other cool names) I do not find it easy to talk to people who are attached to the society. However this may be entirely my fault, again however this stereotype of rigidity has been expressed by many peers without my prompting. Just look at the responses of some of us here.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now