Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Female Referee Removed From Game By Sspx


Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='Deb' post='1463404' date='Feb 15 2008, 01:26 PM']St. Mary's should be banned. If this is what they are teaching their students, they will have a very hard time once they are out in the real world. Unless they are all going to be Priests or Religious, they are most likely going to be working for a woman at some point.
It is a load of B.S. This is basketball folks, not a monastery. What a bunch of turds.[/quote]

+

This is so interesting. I think it very much represents the idea of much of the left today: We don't agree with it (in the name of tolerance and diversity, usually), so, let's ban it! Self-contradictory to say the least. Freedom of conscience, even in error.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='Veritas' post='1463406' date='Feb 15 2008, 02:30 PM']+

I'm not saying their hermeneutics are accurate, but given this text and others, the position is understandable or at least arguable. Here is a quote from the NAB from 1 Timothy, Chapter 2:

11
A woman must receive instruction silently and under complete control.
12
I do not permit a woman to teach or to have authority over a man. 4 She must be quiet.
13
For Adam was formed first, then Eve.
14
Further, Adam was not deceived, but the woman was deceived and transgressed.
15
But she will be saved through motherhood, provided women persevere in faith and love and holiness, with self-control.

[url="http://www.usccb.org/nab/bible/1timothy/1timothy2.htm"]http://www.usccb.org/nab/bible/1timothy/1timothy2.htm[/url][/quote]
lol. HOW did they miss 16 years of being taught by nuns???

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1463410' date='Feb 15 2008, 01:34 PM']lol. HOW did they miss 16 years of being taught by nuns???[/quote]

+

GREAT question!

Posted

[quote name='Veritas' post='1463408' date='Feb 15 2008, 01:32 PM']+

This is so interesting. I think it very much represents the idea of much of the left today: We don't agree with it (in the name of tolerance and diversity, usually), so, let's ban it! Self-contradictory to say the least. Freedom of conscience, even in error.[/quote]


Please, you can't tell me that the rest of the Catholic world would consider this a valid reason to toss an official out of a game. If you can't play like the other boys, then you don't play at all. It is not self-contraditory at all and has nothing to do with the dictates of the Catholic Faith. It is just anal.

goldenchild17
Posted

I can see both sides of the argument so I don't have an opinion. I think veritas is bringing up some interesting points that really aren't being properly addressed.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Deb' post='1463427' date='Feb 15 2008, 01:52 PM']Please, you can't tell me that the rest of the Catholic world would consider this a valid reason to toss an official out of a game. If you can't play like the other boys, then you don't play at all. It is not self-contraditory at all and has nothing to do with the dictates of the Catholic Faith. It is just anal.[/quote]

+

Actually, this isn't about Catholic or non-Catholic. It's about religious freedom and the rights of conscience perhaps even the rights of assembly and self determination. The claim, "if you can't play like the other boys, you don't play" begets the question, where do we draw the line? Now, if the coalition decides this presence of male and female refs is non-negotiable, they have the right to do so, and this group has the right to exclude themselves. But then, this team also has the right to form their own league with all men or all women.

* May I request the exclusion of graphic, unpleasant terms in the future? They add nothing to your argument.

Edited by Veritas
Posted

BUt we are not talking about men. We are talking about boys, high school boys.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='Mercy me' post='1463774' date='Feb 15 2008, 10:00 PM']BUt we are not talking about men. We are talking about boys, high school boys.[/quote]
And high school kids have been taught by nuns for a very long time.

Posted

Exactly! And boys are expected to obey their elders. The same is not true of men who are expected to lead families. Their position doesn't make sense to me.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

I doubt FoxNews has any reason to report this story other than to show how absurd this religious fanatics are. I hardly care about this supposedly news worthy story, and I care even less about FoxNews' perspective on it.

Posted

I think that it is newsworthy. Look at the discussion it has sparked. As to a slant on the story it seemed to me to be rather straight down the middle. Trust me I expect a slant when it comes to media and religion. They didn't try to tar all Catholics with this and the tone was, in my opinion, fair.

Fox has been far and away the least biased of all the major media sources when it comes to the church. They even have a weekly opinion column written by a priest in Rome, Father Jonathan Morris a Legionary of Christ. Hardly, the type of column you expect from a major media source.

Excelsior1027
Posted

This story just showed up over on the American Papist blog. The post brings up another important side to the story. Here be the link:

[url="http://www.americanpapist.com/2008/02/commentary-sspx-hs-refuses-to-allow.html"]http://www.americanpapist.com/2008/02/comm...s-to-allow.html[/url]

Posted

In my opinion, the most interesting and best part of the article:

[quote]Campbell did not return phone calls seeking comment Wednesday.

However, she told The Kansas City Star that she was "dumbfounded" by the incident but that she is not angry at the school. She said she does not want the situation to go any further than it already has.

"This issue was going to come up eventually," said Campbell, 49, a retired Albuquerque, N.M., police officer who now lives in Ozawkie, Kan. "I just happened to be the person who was there this time.

"It's kind of a sticky situation. It needs to be looked at carefully, slowly, with all the facts."[/quote]

Posted

+

Here's what American Papist has to say about the other side:

There is, however, like there typically is in these cases, another side to this story.

Consider, for instance, the testimony of this person who has direct contact with the situation:
To all of those who think this is a load of backward Kansas garbage, it is...at least the way it is represented. But I happen to know many of the parents and their children at this academy, and I can tell you, they are extremely upset.

Apparently, it was reported that she couldn't ref the game because she would have authority over them. THAT IS NOT WHY. It is because the school has a policy of not playing sports with women (a ref on the basketball court is almost as involved as the players) They believe that because women are naturally weaker than men, they should be protected and treated better than men. They believe that sports diminishes the respect (due to women by virtue of their femenine nature) in the eyes of the boys. It is not about control or subjection or anything like that. In fact they have many females at the school - teachers, secretaries, nuns, administration, monitors,etc...and support women whole-heartedly.

Just to clarify, the ref was completely cool with it. When the AD explained quite simply that they prefer males to ref/coach the boys and females to ref/coach the girls she understood the situation completely. It was her fellow ref that made the big stink and misquoted or misrepresented the whole situation. - "ilduce42"

The same individual links to this article (which I'm guessing she wrote), which explains why St. Mary's chose to forfeit a football game rather than have its boys play against a girl on the opposing team.
Granted, the issue of women playing contact sports with men is not what is in question here. And extending a prohibition against male-female contact sports to prohibiting female refs is both silly and offensive.
I don't think, however, you can read misogyny into the school's actions. More likely it is represents a misguided attempt to respect the diginity of women. And that intention is a good one. It would be nice if the SSPX folks would post a note somewhere explaining their decision.
Or it will come out anyway when they get sued.

Thoughts?

Posted

After reading the blog, I at least understand the basis for their decision, even it I disagree with it.

Posted

So was Hitler. Bad argument - you bought propaganda.

[quote name='St. Benedict' post='1463294' date='Feb 15 2008, 07:26 AM']Just go to the SSPX website and read the FAQs on the left hand for their view using Canon Law - it is highly convincing.[/quote]

Posted

Even though I'm not SSPX, I agree with the decision - I think St. Paul would too.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='brendan1104' post='1463953' date='Feb 16 2008, 12:56 AM']Even though I'm not SSPX, I agree with the decision - I think St. Paul would too.[/quote]
So you go to a school taught only be males?

Posted

No, but it'd be better than the bunch of feminist, secularist carp that I'm getting now.

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1464170' date='Feb 16 2008, 09:58 AM']So you go to a school taught only be males?[/quote]

Posted

[quote name='brendan1104' post='1463947' date='Feb 15 2008, 11:54 PM']So was Hitler. Bad argument - you bought propaganda.[/quote]

Seeing an intelligent reflection on Canon 1323 & 1324 is not propaganda.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...