mommas_boy Posted February 21, 2008 Posted February 21, 2008 (edited) I'm going to have a hard time framing the precise and subtle implications of this question, but I will do my best. I am asking my question here because I know that responses are closed except to moderators and the ilk, and because I believe that the proper answer to this question requires a very careful balance. A little background before I continue: (1) I am pretty well-formed intellectually in my Catholic Faith, and I'm very familiar with Catholic teaching on homosexuality, homosexual activity, and the moral distinctions between the two. I am also very familiar with the psychological nature of homosexuality. In short, I don't need a primer on Catholic sexual morality in its regards to homosexuality. (2) I am student teaching this semester and have a sophomore girl in my class who is a lesbian, which is what prompted my question. On to my question. We as educators are taught to go out of our way to affirm diversity in the classroom. One of the primary interpretations that I have of this is that when I show examples, my examples should portray people of all walks of life. I am showing pictures of romantic couples, and in particular, focusing on the relationships as they get together and break up (readers' digest: I am teaching about different kinds of chemical reactions, which consist of making and breaking bonds, hence the reference). So, what is the morality of me depicting a homosexual couple? Let's unpack this (please continue to read; I know that this is long). First, there is the American culture. American culture teaches the issue as a dichotomy. The first side says that homosexual [b]orientation[/b] is a sin. This side is bad because it teaches people who are gay to hate themselves for their orientation. In turn, this effect contributes to the high suicide and depression rates amongst people who are gay. On the other hand, there is the other side of the culture that teaches that gays should not feel ashamed of their orientation (this is good), and also encourages homosexual activity (this is bad). As always, we as Catholics are speaking a language that the rest of the world simply doesn't understand, and when the world tries to translate it, they hear the wrong thing entirely. Catholics don't see the issue as quite so much of a dichotomy. We see homosexual [b]activity[/b] as sinful, but the [b]orientation[/b] as a struggle to be overcome that of itself is not sinful. That said, it is still a [b]struggle to be overcome[/b], and this point cannot be diminished. Clearly, the Catholic view of this is FAR too complicated to be taught [i]in passing[/i] with simply showing a picture of a homosexual couple, or with the absence of such a picture. If I include the picture, my class (and my specific student) hear "Gay is good"; this isn't quite right. On the other hand, the absence of the picture is more conspicuous than you might think, at least to a student who is struggling with their orientation (she is in PRIDE, and is most likely taught to be critically aware of media that she sees on this topic, if she isn't already naturally). It's certainly not enough to set some student over the edge, but it is one more tic-mark to build toward the kind of resentment that many gays have toward the established culture. Please let me know what you think. Thank you very much for your help. Blessings! PS: Forgive the title; it's not quite what I mean, but I couldn't come up with anything better. Edited February 21, 2008 by mommas_boy
Theoketos Posted February 21, 2008 Posted February 21, 2008 As a fellow educator... I submit that showing a romantic couple for the sake affirming diversity is to condone homosexual behavior. We should give as much freedom to our students as we can. Diversity is a good thing, but only to an extent. This would be a good example of line not to cross. However, especially in the context of higher education and advanced pyschology, talking about the chemical reactions experienced in a homosexual relationship would be appropriate. It would be especially interesting to contrast those homosexual couples' chemical and biological reactions to those of a heterosexual couple.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now