cappie Posted February 27, 2008 Posted February 27, 2008 Controversy has erupted once again over whether priests and religious leaders are subject to mandatory reporting laws after a "priest" at an evangelic Christian church in Melbourne did not report a child sex abuse confession. The Herald Sun reports the priest will not be charged over not reporting the assault despite the confessor striking again. The case has stirred debate over the role of the churches in handling confessions by lawbreakers and raised questions about whether religious leaders should be subject to mandatory reporting obligations. Teachers, doctors, nurses and other professionals are legally bound to report suspected sex abuse cases. Social commentator Fr Bob McGuire said in theory a priest offering his own help would be the right course of action. However, in practice, this was relinquishing responsibility. "Priests are not qualified to handle such sensitive matters," Fr McGuire said "It may not be legally mandatory reporting (for priests), but it would be morally mandatory reporting - even if it was my brother. "It's a civil society's expectation," he said. Child abuse prevention group Childwise's Bernadette McMenamin said priests should be covered by the same mandatory reporting rules. "With all good intentions, offenders have been protected by churches," she said. "I believe everyone should report abuse. It's their moral duty. If it takes mandatory reporting to make sure, that's how it will have to be."
scardella Posted February 28, 2008 Posted February 28, 2008 Hrm... have they ever heard of the seal of confession? Hello!?
goldenchild17 Posted February 28, 2008 Posted February 28, 2008 For the good of the people, apparently even this can be broken...
Alycin Posted February 28, 2008 Posted February 28, 2008 This is why separation of church and state is important.
premed_jakey Posted February 28, 2008 Posted February 28, 2008 The sacrament of reconcilliation is sacred and beautiful. I cant believe people cant understand that and want to break that trust between confessor and priest
jeffpugh Posted February 28, 2008 Posted February 28, 2008 I can. Seriously though, the thing about this is there are other moral implications than "reporting a criminal to the authorities". Priests are not teachers or nurses per se. They have a different role in society. The church doesn't protect criminals. Absolution shouldn't even be given unless the confessee says he/she would hand him/herself in. Am I correct here?
MissScripture Posted February 28, 2008 Posted February 28, 2008 Do they realize that they're not going to be any further ahead, because if criminals know they will be reported, they just won't confess!
Scofizzle Posted February 28, 2008 Posted February 28, 2008 [quote name='Sacred Music Man' post='1470339' date='Feb 27 2008, 09:48 PM']I can. Seriously though, the thing about this is there are other moral implications than "reporting a criminal to the authorities". Priests are not teachers or nurses per se. They have a different role in society. The church doesn't protect criminals. Absolution shouldn't even be given unless the confessee says he/she would hand him/herself in. Am I correct here?[/quote] A priest can deny absolution if he believes the confesor is not truly repentent, but a preist cannot asign a penance that will publicly reveal the sinners sin.
CatherineM Posted February 28, 2008 Posted February 28, 2008 There are times that I am supremely grateful that the priesthood was not open to me. I really don't know how I would handle the situation if I had to be a confessor.
Kitty Posted February 28, 2008 Posted February 28, 2008 This whole seal of confession thing does not really make sense to me. So, say this child rapist came into confession and confessed his sins. He said that he raped a young girl. He says the Act of Contrition and is forgiven. And the priest should not tell anyone about this?? This does not seem like something God would approve of.
Scofizzle Posted February 28, 2008 Posted February 28, 2008 [quote name='Kitty' post='1470500' date='Feb 28 2008, 01:52 AM']This whole seal of confession thing does not really make sense to me. So, say this child rapist came into confession and confessed his sins. He said that he raped a young girl. He says the Act of Contrition and is forgiven. And the priest should not tell anyone about this?? This does not seem like something God would approve of.[/quote] God is about forgivenes. The preist might not give absolution. They may suggest that turning yourself in would show true remorse, but he cannot make this his pennance as it would publicly identify his sin. This is truely God's work. He forgives all and loves all. Even the pedophiles.
T-Bone _ Posted February 28, 2008 Posted February 28, 2008 [quote name='MissScripture' post='1470394' date='Feb 27 2008, 08:39 PM']Do they realize that they're not going to be any further ahead, because if criminals know they will be reported, they just won't confess![/quote] It's not just that. Think of a teenager who is being abused. He doesn't want to get his abuser into any sort of trouble. He knows that if he confesses, the priest will have to report it. So he doesn't confess. This puts his soul in danger.
cathoholic_anonymous Posted March 1, 2008 Posted March 1, 2008 [quote name='T-Bone _' post='1470509' date='Feb 28 2008, 08:22 AM']It's not just that. Think of a teenager who is being abused. He doesn't want to get his abuser into any sort of trouble. He knows that if he confesses, the priest will have to report it. So he doesn't confess. This puts his soul in danger.[/quote] You are right. I have a good friend who was sexually abused by a much older man when she was a child and young teenager. When she got to know me better and came to Mass with me a few times, she said that she would love to be a Catholic just for the sake of being able to say anything you needed to say to another human being and be able to trust them totally for once.
Hirsap Posted March 1, 2008 Posted March 1, 2008 The Summa Theologica [Supp., Q11, Article 3; [url="http://www.newadvent.org/summa/5011.htm"]http://www.newadvent.org/summa/5011.htm[/url]] says something very interesting on this matter, I read a while back: [quote]Further, the reason why a man is bound to keep secret what he hears in confession, is because[b] he knows them, not as man but as God knows them[/b]. But the priest alone is God's minister. Therefore he alone is bound to secrecy.[/quote] emphasis mine. As a human, the priest knows nothing what was revealed to him, for he acts as Christ. It's Christ acting in the Sacrament. That's sort of what I gather.
farglefeezlebut Posted March 1, 2008 Posted March 1, 2008 IMO, if a person confesses to a serious crime, their penance should be to turn themself in to the police.
Autumn Dusk Posted March 1, 2008 Posted March 1, 2008 The problem here, is really the idea of a child "confessing" a sin that is not theirs. Mandatory reporting becomes sketchy here. Priests need more training in a desperate way. Fact is there is a problem and it NEEDS appropriate attention. I speak from experience on this, and realize the pain that could of been spared me if a priest had known what to do.
S][N Posted March 1, 2008 Posted March 1, 2008 Can't believe how some people just completely overlook the fact that this could save lives, in the literal and non-literal sense. From an ex-Catholic perspective and having grown up with the sacraments, I understand how one can be offended by this. But then at the sametime one cannot just ignore the facts that a priest, pastor etc, not telling the Police about such persons leaves the public open to serious danger. For example. If I had a daughter who was raped, and this guy went to confession just days earlier telling a priest he doesn't know if he can stop. I'd want that priests head on a plate not to mention every Church authority. I think in any circumstances, the seal of the confession must be broken if life is in danger. And it's pretty hypocritical of people to be Pro-Life against abortion but then have a problem with a priest telling police about a murderer, rapist or pedophile.
cathoholic_anonymous Posted March 1, 2008 Posted March 1, 2008 [quote name='S][N' post='1471796' date='Mar 1 2008, 05:18 PM'] Can't believe how some people just completely overlook the fact that this could save lives, in the literal and non-literal sense. From an ex-Catholic perspective and having grown up with the sacraments, I understand how one can be offended by this. But then at the sametime one cannot just ignore the facts that a priest, pastor etc, not telling the Police about such persons leaves the public open to serious danger. For example. If I had a daughter who was raped, and this guy went to confession just days earlier telling a priest he doesn't know if he can stop. I'd want that priests head on a plate not to mention every Church authority. I think in any circumstances, the seal of the confession must be broken if life is in danger. And it's pretty hypocritical of people to be Pro-Life against abortion but then have a problem with a priest telling police about a murderer, rapist or pedophile.[/quote] As somebody has already said, making it compulsory for priests to become whistleblowers would just prevent criminals from going to confession. It wouldn't actually cause a reduction in this type of crime - especially when you consider that criminals who 'don't know if they can stop' are highly unlikely to be going to Confession anyway. To receive absolution, you have to have what the Church calls 'a strong purpose of amendment' - the will to turn your life around. When I confessed that I had been unkind to a friend, the priest told me (independently of my penance) that I had to put things right with my friend, and because I was repentant, I did so. I [i]wanted[/i] to do so. If a criminal intends to go on committing crimes, he can't receive the absolution - Confession isn't like an advance cheque that pays off your sins for the next month. If a criminal is truly sorry and wants to confess, the confessional should still not be treated as the precursor to a prison interview room. Being able to trust that God loves him and that there is another human being who is going to listen without probing or judging could be the strength that the criminal takes away from the confessional, the strength to turn himself in to the police. If he knows that the priest is just an (untrained and ill-qualified) extension of the law, that lesson in trust - so crucial to anybody who is turning away from a life of sin - would be lost. And how is it possible for anybody to repent properly unless they know that someone, somewhere is willing to trust them and to believe whole-heartedly that they have it in them to make amends? After the confession is over, the priest could of course offer to accompany the penitent to the police station, and the penitent might accept. However, the priest would not be doing that in his capacity as a confessor, but as a pastoral figure.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now