Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Yesterday and today, I've been debating two people on whether it's possible to both love the sinner and hate the sin. Both are in favor of gay marriage, and one of them, who I'm guessing is gay, responded by saying that anyone who thinks gay sex is sinful is a bigot and a straight supremacist. He compared "straight supremacy" to white supremacy. I responded by saying that the two are quite different, as blackness is an innate quality with no corresponding behavior, unlike homosexuality. Christians oppose homosexual behavior. Of course, what followed was claims that homosexuals [b]are[/b] their behavior, that they cannot control their behavior, unlike straight people. :blink: Then, of course, there were more accusations of bigotry and straight supremacy in the place of actual, valid argumentation. The end.

Good times, good times. . . :yawn:

Posted

I absolutely believe that you can love the sinner while fighting against the sin. I had a lot of clients who were dying of AIDS in the 1980's. A lot of lawyers wouldn't touch them, literally or figuratively. I had a rule that I didn't want to hear how they had gotten the disease, even if they actually knew, and I wanted to hear nothing about their lifestyle. I attended many funerals at the gay church, but I did not received their communion, obviously. I made it clear that I was Catholic, and tried to treat them with compassion, but did not condone their choices. I would help them with wills and disability filings, but not with partnership contracts or adoptions.

Posted

Yeah, I agree. I don't understand why they'd think we'd lie about loving the sinner and hating the sin.

Fidei Defensor
Posted

The only issue I have with the "love the sinner, hate the sin" mentality is that to some, the "sin" that people hate is actually an intimate part of their being. They can't necessarily separate themselves from what others consider to be a sin. So in essence, to them anyway, if one hates their sin, they are hating them.

Just a different viewpoint.

Posted

[quote name='fidei defensor' post='1472461' date='Mar 2 2008, 06:51 PM']The only issue I have with the "love the sinner, hate the sin" mentality is that to some, the "sin" that people hate is actually an intimate part of their being. They can't necessarily separate themselves from what others consider to be a sin. So in essence, to them anyway, if one hates their sin, they are hating them.

Just a different viewpoint.[/quote]

That's exactly what they were arguing, actually. I've explained that the same would apply to premarital sex between heterosexuals, but they didn't think the two were comparable.

Posted

Homosexuals being unable to control their actions is one of the most insulting concepts I have ever heard.

Posted

[quote name='T-Bone _' post='1472468' date='Mar 2 2008, 07:16 PM']Homosexuals being unable to control their actions is one of the most insulting concepts I have ever heard.[/quote]

You know, I sort of thought that as well. They were trying to stick up for homosexuals, but ironically, I found that that argument had the opposite effect. To say homosexuals are incapable of making behavioral choices is almost like saying that they're mere animals, which is completely untrue, of course.

Fidei Defensor
Posted

[quote name='T-Bone _' post='1472468' date='Mar 2 2008, 05:16 PM']Homosexuals being unable to control their actions is one of the most insulting concepts I have ever heard.[/quote]
I understand what you are saying here, and at face value, I agree. But what it doesnt address is the level of connection between one's person and identity (who they feel they really are) and how they act. Quite often, homosexuals are told that they aren't sinning by "being" gay but by acting on their desires. But in their view, they can't pretend to not be gay, they can't deny who they feel they are.

I realize you disagree with that. But to a person who lives with this reality, things are quite different. To them, it's their identity. It would be the same as you denying your Catholic identity. It's something important to you. You may feel that to be an unfair comparison, and I understand, but you have to start with a fair base of understanding here. You have to accept that to a homosexual, their orientation is part of their identity, it's not just a behavior they can stop doing. That's why they don't feel the "hate the sin, love the sinner" thing is fair to them because they don't differentiate between their identitiy and behavior.

Sexual acts are another thing, but that's not in argument.

Posted

[quote name='fidei defensor' post='1472496' date='Mar 2 2008, 08:02 PM']You have to accept that to a homosexual, their orientation is part of their identity, it's not just a behavior they can stop doing. That's why they don't feel the "hate the sin, love the sinner" thing is fair to them because they don't differentiate between their identitiy and behavior.[/quote]

That's the thing, though. Why do homosexuals have a hard time differentiating between their identity and their behavior when many heterosexuals do not? I'm straight, and it's part of my identity, but I can definitely see the difference between my orientation and my actions.

Fidei Defensor
Posted

[quote name='BeenaBobba' post='1472518' date='Mar 2 2008, 06:30 PM']That's the thing, though. Why do homosexuals have a hard time differentiating between their identity and their behavior when many heterosexuals do not? I'm straight, and it's part of my identity, but I can definitely see the difference between my orientation and my actions.[/quote]
That's true, and I accept that legitimate distinction. But how do you feel about two men "dating" or living together because of their orientation? Leaving out things that are sinful for anyone, homosexual or heterosexual, sometimes they feel discriminated against because of other things that aren't necessarily sinful, but are look upon as bad.

Posted

[quote name='fidei defensor' post='1472521' date='Mar 2 2008, 08:33 PM']That's true, and I accept that legitimate distinction. But how do you feel about two men "dating" or living together because of their orientation? Leaving out things that are sinful for anyone, homosexual or heterosexual, sometimes they feel discriminated against because of other things that aren't necessarily sinful, but are look upon as bad.[/quote]

Yeah, in my discussion with them, I tried to point out that I certainly don't think I'm less of a sinner than anyone. I do sinful things on a daily basis, unfortunately. I also tried to point out that as a Christian, I try not to have a them vs. us mentality when it comes to homosexuals, since there is no them. We're all God's children, and we're all sinners. I'm no better than they are. Since we all sin, it's a necessity to differentiate between the sin and the sinner, otherwise we'd hate everyone, even ourselves.

Posted

I think what may bother some about public symbols, has to do with the idea of "public scandal." My 85 year old mother has been living with a man for over 20 years now that she is not married to. What we used to call living in sin. He is impotent because of the heart medication that keeps him alive (thank you so much for sharing mom), and they live in separate bedrooms, so technically, she isn't sinning. The appearance and example set though, certainly scandalizes some, my brothers and my Godmother especially so. That's why we feel so uncomfortable with public displays of affection between those with same sex attraction. It is not a condemnation of the person, it is a discomfort with way it represents.

Fidei Defensor
Posted

[quote name='BeenaBobba' post='1472566' date='Mar 2 2008, 06:58 PM']Yeah, in my discussion with them, I tried to point out that I certainly don't think I'm less of a sinner than anyone. I do sinful things on a daily basis, unfortunately. I also tried to point out that as a Christian, I try not to have a them vs. us mentality when it comes to homosexuals, since there is no them. We're all God's children, and we're all sinners. I'm no better than they are. Since we all sin, it's a necessity to differentiate between the sin and the sinner, otherwise we'd hate everyone, even ourselves.[/quote]
I definitely agree with the distinction part, it's necessary and true. I'm just saying, some things get lost in translation, so to speak, and it comes off as hate. You just have to understand the other side of the issue, too.

blovedwolfofgod
Posted

[quote name='T-Bone _' post='1472468' date='Mar 3 2008, 01:16 AM']Homosexuals being unable to control their actions is one of the most insulting concepts I have ever heard.[/quote]

hey man, didnt you know that homosexuality is, like, totally this crazy virus cooked up by none other than THE MAN, to keep us down. It completely removes all sense and reason from human beings and forces, yes, i said FORCES us to attack anything of the same gender because its a debilitating and DEHUMANIZING illness. Then THE MAN uses it to get votes, and create legislature for his party, and then tries to kill them off with another virus. totally.


but seriously, thats pretty insulting to say homosexuals cannot control their actions.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

For some homosexuals however, if you are not enthusiastically endorsing their choices it must mean you "hate" them, and then you are automatically called homophobic etc.

blovedwolfofgod
Posted

which will be an accurate statement if i ever go to prison.

Spamity Calamity
Posted

I feel that using your sexual orientation as identity is pretty weak.

Posted

[quote name='fidei defensor' post='1472496' date='Mar 2 2008, 06:02 PM']I understand what you are saying here, and at face value, I agree. But what it doesnt address is the level of connection between one's person and identity (who they feel they really are) and how they act. Quite often, homosexuals are told that they aren't sinning by "being" gay but by acting on their desires. But in their view, they can't pretend to not be gay, they can't deny who they feel they are.

I realize you disagree with that. But to a person who lives with this reality, things are quite different. To them, it's their identity. It would be the same as you denying your Catholic identity. It's something important to you. You may feel that to be an unfair comparison, and I understand, but you have to start with a fair base of understanding here. You have to accept that to a homosexual, their orientation is part of their identity, it's not just a behavior they can stop doing. That's why they don't feel the "hate the sin, love the sinner" thing is fair to them because they don't differentiate between their identitiy and behavior.

Sexual acts are another thing, but that's not in argument.[/quote]

I totally am of the same mind set as you. I am not sure how to pull apart being homosexual and acting homosexual. And I am not even living in a gay body. I am not sure how to say to someone that they are wrong having a loving relationship with someone, even if it is not actively having sex. I wish I knew a better way to express this. When I say it is like adultery, then my gay friends tell me that is absolutely is not. Adultery is sex outside of marriage. People who are straight are not expected to wait to have sex with their loved one forever. They are just waiting. Gay people are expected never to have that intimacy. Not only that, but they are expected to never fall in love (relationship wise), and if they do, they are expected to ignore that love. I can only imagine how hard that is.

I love the sinner, hate the sin, and sympathize with the misunderstanding I guess.

Posted

[quote name='Spamity Calamity' post='1472943' date='Mar 3 2008, 12:21 PM']I feel that using your sexual orientation as identity is pretty weak.[/quote]

I don't agree. Your sexuality is a central part of human nature. It is only natural to have such an intimate part of you as an identifying feature.

Posted

Whenever I was presented with the argument that heterosexuals don't have to forgo licit sex because they can marry, but homosexuals aren't allowed the same, I remind them that it isn't just homosexuals that are expected to remain celibate. You can be "born" a pedophile or made one by your background, and we also would expect that person to remain celibate. And please no hate mail, I know there is a difference between being born with a same sex attraction, and being born with some type of serious deviance.

Sexuality is the strongest part of our beings. We can't help but have that be public.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...