Guest TMS1213 Posted March 3, 2008 Posted March 3, 2008 My question to anyone who may be of assistance. I have read a great deal of information regarding the New Rite of Ordination that questions whether or not priests ordained in this Rite are even in fact, "valid" priests. Everything I've seen points in the direction that they are not. Any info to the contrary would be graetly appreciated. One other thing, I was told by a priest of the SSPX that there is a question as to the validity of the New Rite of Confirmation. I was confirmed at age 28 by my parish pastor on the Easter vigil. Is there anything about this scenario which invalidates the sacrament. Thank you
Thy Geekdom Come Posted March 3, 2008 Posted March 3, 2008 The SSPX is currently in schism from the Church. I wouldn't put any trust in their leadership or members to give you correct theology. The Novus Ordo Ordination and Confirmation rites are entirely valid. God bless, Raphael
KnightofChrist Posted March 3, 2008 Posted March 3, 2008 Technically the SSPX are not in schism, at least according to [url="http://www.renewamerica.us/columns/mershon/070410"]Cardinal Castrillón[/url] but the belief that the New Ordination Rite is not valid it seems that would be a schismatic belief. And the SSPX Bishops are excommunicated. [url="http://www.renewamerica.us/columns/mershon/070807"]SSPX in schism? You can believe Fr. Newman... or you can believe the Church[/url] [url="http://rorate-caeli.blogspot.com/2006/03/ecclesia-dei-sspx-priests-and-faithful.html"]Ecclesia Dei: SSPX priests and faithful are not "excommunicates"[/url]
Knight of the Holy Rosary Posted March 3, 2008 Posted March 3, 2008 In regards to the priests of the SSPX ...are the sacrament they celebrate illicit? I was never sure...perhaps since the Bishops that ordained them are excommunicants this effects the lawfullness of their sacraments?
goldenchild17 Posted March 3, 2008 Posted March 3, 2008 [quote name='TMS1213' post='1472796' date='Mar 3 2008, 03:25 AM']My question to anyone who may be of assistance. I have read a great deal of information regarding the New Rite of Ordination that questions whether or not priests ordained in this Rite are even in fact, "valid" priests. Everything I've seen points in the direction that they are not. Any info to the contrary would be graetly appreciated. One other thing, I was told by a priest of the SSPX that there is a question as to the validity of the New Rite of Confirmation. I was confirmed at age 28 by my parish pastor on the Easter vigil. Is there anything about this scenario which invalidates the sacrament. Thank you[/quote] There are a number of groups not currently in communion with Rome that do believe the new rites of ordination (as well as consecration of bishops), confirmation, and consecration of the Eucharist are invalid. I believe they are invalid too, but we don't normally have discussions like that on this forum. There are quite a few people qualified to try to answer any questions you might have come across though, who I'm sure would be happy to help you out through private message or email.
goldenchild17 Posted March 3, 2008 Posted March 3, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Knight of the Holy Rosary' post='1473011' date='Mar 3 2008, 02:19 PM']In regards to the priests of the SSPX ...are the sacrament they celebrate illicit? I was never sure...perhaps since the Bishops that ordained them are excommunicants this effects the lawfullness of their sacraments?[/quote] According to Rome they have a valid Mass and valid consecration, but it is illicit since they don't currently have Rome's permission to offer Mass or other sacraments. Edited March 3, 2008 by goldenchild17
Guest TMS1213 Posted March 3, 2008 Posted March 3, 2008 [quote name='goldenchild17' post='1473014' date='Mar 3 2008, 04:28 PM']There are a number of groups not currently in communion with Rome that do believe the new rites of ordination (as well as consecration of bishops), confirmation, and consecration of the Eucharist are invalid. I believe they are invalid too, but we don't normally have discussions like that on this forum. There are quite a few people qualified to try to answer any questions you might have come across though, who I'm sure would be happy to help you out through private message or email.[/quote] Thank you for your input. I apologize if I brought up a topic I shouldn't have. Any info you could provide with reference to where I might inquire would be of great help. Thank you again
Era Might Posted March 3, 2008 Posted March 3, 2008 From the Council of Trent: [quote]If any one says that the received and approved rites of the Catholic Church, accustomed to be used in the solemn administration of the sacraments, may be despised or omitted by the ministers without sin and at their pleasure, or may be changed by any pastor of the churches to other new ones, let him be anathema. --Seventh Session, Canon 13 on the Sacraments in General[/quote]
Laudate_Dominum Posted March 3, 2008 Posted March 3, 2008 [quote name='Era Might' post='1473065' date='Mar 3 2008, 05:16 PM']From the Council of Trent: [quote]If any one says that the received and approved rites of the Catholic Church, accustomed to be used in the solemn administration of the sacraments, may be despised or omitted by the ministers without sin and at their pleasure, or may be changed by any pastor of the churches to other new ones, let him be anathema. --Seventh Session, Canon 13 on the Sacraments in General[/quote] [/quote] I could see a sedevacantist turning this around. 1. Read in its proper historical context this canon applies to the traditional Roman rite and goes against Protestant liturgical innovations. 2. The new rites mimic said Protestant innovations. 3. This canon applies to the "received" rites which means that which has been handed on by tradition but to a sedevacantist the new rites are anti-traditional fabrications. 4. The liturgical reform "despised" and "omitted" the authentic liturgy and no pastor (even the Pope) has the right to do this (anathema sit). I just don't think a sedevacantist would accept the idea that this canon somehow vindicates the new liturgical rites. Not really sure what the response would be but trying to put myself in those shoes this would be my first thought. Plus there are other canons from Trent that could be invoked which seemingly condemn certain aspects of the liturgical reform.
goldenchild17 Posted March 3, 2008 Posted March 3, 2008 (edited) [quote name='TMS1213' post='1473048' date='Mar 3 2008, 03:02 PM']Thank you for your input. I apologize if I brought up a topic I shouldn't have. Any info you could provide with reference to where I might inquire would be of great help. Thank you again[/quote] L_D is right. There is another board where some of the members here are discussing it:http://z11.invisionfree.com/OGame_L33t_Aliance/ If you want you could check that out and ask whatever questions you wanted or just follow along the discussion. That way I can give you one side of the argument and the others would be able to give the other side. also, my email address should be in my profile. If you send me a message I can hook you up with other places where you can read and inquire about your questions. I just can't post them on this message board. peace Edited March 3, 2008 by goldenchild17
goldenchild17 Posted March 3, 2008 Posted March 3, 2008 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1473110' date='Mar 3 2008, 04:29 PM']I could see a sedevacantist turning this around. 1. Read in its proper historical context this canon applies to the traditional Roman rite and goes against Protestant liturgical innovations. 2. The new rites mimic said Protestant innovations. 3. This canon applies to the "received" rites which means that which has been handed on by tradition but to a sedevacantist the new rites are anti-traditional fabrications. 4. The liturgical reform "despised" and "omitted" the authentic liturgy and no pastor (even the Pope) has the right to do this (anathema sit). I just don't think a sedevacantist would accept the idea that this canon somehow vindicates the new liturgical rites. Not really sure what the response would be but trying to put myself in those shoes this would be my first thought. Plus there are other canons from Trent that could be invoked which seemingly condemn certain aspects of the liturgical reform.[/quote] those are a few concerns. I wouldn't be one to argue that they are bad because they cannot be changed though, because they have been, over time.
jeffpugh Posted March 3, 2008 Posted March 3, 2008 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1473054' date='Mar 3 2008, 04:06 PM']what about SMM's board?[/quote] Lawl, L_D building the rep' on my geekzone [quote name='goldenchild17' post='1473123' date='Mar 3 2008, 05:50 PM']L_D is right. There is another board where some of the members here are discussing it:http://z11.invisionfree.com/OGame_L33t_Aliance/ If you want you could check that out and ask whatever questions you wanted or just follow along the discussion. That way I can give you one side of the argument and the others would be able to give the other side. also, my email address should be in my profile. If you send me a message I can hook you up with other places where you can read and inquire about your questions. I just can't post them on this message board. peace[/quote] Well, to be honest, I don't mind the traffic on the board... it's been the most we've had in months! But, I want to let you know that my board isn't a place where we go to get away from the PM rules on the subject. I do welcome newcomers, but I reccomend that those who do not have much theological background, etc stay away from participating in discussion here... to be honest this is some "Catholic vs Catholic" discussion, but it's the sort where we sit down and put the cards on the table and talk about the "differences" we have (that really aren't supposed to be). Now I also wanna keep this little project on the DL a bit partly for my rep' as well. I don't wanna get a warn or something by channeling any sort of scandal. That's all I gotta say. Peace.
Era Might Posted March 3, 2008 Posted March 3, 2008 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1473110' date='Mar 3 2008, 05:29 PM']I just don't think a sedevacantist would accept the idea that this canon somehow vindicates the new liturgical rites. Not really sure what the response would be but trying to put myself in those shoes this would be my first thought.[/quote] I think it is theologically true to say that the Church cannot promulgate invalid Sacramental rites. For anyone who accepts that the Church headed by Pope Benedict XVI is the true Catholic Church, then the validity of her Sacramental rites is absolutely necessary and intrinsic to her Divine mission. From "Mediator Dei": [quote]It follows from this that the Sovereign Pontiff alone enjoys the right to recognize and establish any practice touching the worship of God, to introduce and approve new rites, as also to modify those he judges to require modification.[/quote] Note that Pope Pius XII bases the legitimacy of rites on the authority of the Church. Nobody has any authority to declare what is and is not a valid Sacramental rite except the Church.
goldenchild17 Posted March 4, 2008 Posted March 4, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Era Might' post='1473149' date='Mar 3 2008, 05:42 PM']I think it is theologically true to say that the Church cannot promulgate invalid Sacramental rites. For anyone who accepts that the Church headed by Pope Benedict XVI is the true Catholic Church, then the validity of her Sacramental rites is absolutely necessary and intrinsic to her Divine mission. From "Mediator Dei": Note that Pope Pius XII bases the legitimacy of rites on the authority of the Church. Nobody has any authority to declare what is and is not a valid Sacramental rite except the Church.[/quote] Just wanted to say that I completely agree that the Church cannot promulgate invalid or even evil Sacramental rites. This is one of the reasons I don't agree with the SSPX position since they accept Benedict XVI and yet don't fully accept the Novus Ordo Sacraments. Edited March 4, 2008 by goldenchild17
Laudate_Dominum Posted March 4, 2008 Posted March 4, 2008 [quote name='Era Might' post='1473149' date='Mar 3 2008, 07:42 PM']I think it is theologically true to say that the Church cannot promulgate invalid Sacramental rites. For anyone who accepts that the Church headed by Pope Benedict XVI is the true Catholic Church, then the validity of her Sacramental rites is absolutely necessary and intrinsic to her Divine mission. From "Mediator Dei": Note that Pope Pius XII bases the legitimacy of rites on the authority of the Church. Nobody has any authority to declare what is and is not a valid Sacramental rite except the Church.[/quote] Of course I agree with you but my point was that this kind of argumentation wouldn't resolve the sedevacantist issue because the presumed invalidity of the new rites is seen as a proof of the invalidity of recent Popes. The fact that Pope Paul VI declared these rites legitimate is seens as a proof that he was not legitmate. At least that's how it seems to me but I'm no expert on sedevacantist arguments.
Laudate_Dominum Posted March 4, 2008 Posted March 4, 2008 [quote name='goldenchild17' post='1473159' date='Mar 3 2008, 08:00 PM']Just wanted to say that I completely agree that the Church cannot promulgate invalid or even evil Sacramental rites. This is one of the reasons I don't agree with the SSPX position since they accept Benedict XVI and yet don't fully accept the Novus Ordo Sacraments.[/quote] Yeah, that's what I thought the sedevacantist position would say. It seems more consistent than the position many traddies take in rejecting the new rites but accepting the post-Vatican II Church. I fully accept the post-Vatican II sacramental rites and I don't question the legitimacy of the Church but I believe that the way the reform was carried out was questionable in many ways and ought to be reconsidered in light of the mayhem of recent decades.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now