the_rev Posted March 9, 2008 Posted March 9, 2008 I remember once reading an article by a Catholic apologist (Mark Shea rings a bell) where he says sometimes he can not bring himself to say Lord hear our prayer after some ridiculous petitions. He also made mention that sometimes people don't even pay attention to the prayers of the faithful and just say it because everyone else is, maybe you lost focus etc. But do we really think about what we are or just have prayed for. I started this thread before the server crash and saw it had six responses but I wasn't able to see them. So if you responded to that, what did you say? Feel free to partake in this new discussion. If you know of the article I speak of please let me know where I can read it in its full context. This is what I recollect about the article though.
picchick Posted March 10, 2008 Posted March 10, 2008 I did read the last responses and I will give my response here. I think that you should pray for everyone's prayer. I mean someone's might be "stupid" like the example for the sick cat. However, that prayer is important to them. As long as it isn't "Lord please send your wrath and punishment upon my boss for firing me." then I think it is ok. What is the harm for bothering Jesus with little nonsense? I think God has big enough shoulders to handle everything.
prose Posted March 10, 2008 Posted March 10, 2008 I certainly would hope people would pray for my own intentions, even if they thought they were ridiculous, as I would always pray for theirs. Prayers of the faithful are for everyone, not just for the ones we deem "good enough" to pray for. That is the crux of community prayer. We gather together to pray for all of our intentions. Besides when the priest says "For these and all that are in our hearts", do you refrain in case someone has a "stupid" prayer in their heart? No. I think it would be selfish to go to a place where we come together as a Church family, and only pray for those we deem appropriate.
MissScripture Posted March 10, 2008 Posted March 10, 2008 [quote name='the_rev' post='1474449' date='Mar 8 2008, 10:10 PM']I remember once reading an article by a Catholic apologist (Mark Shea rings a bell) where he says sometimes he can not bring himself to say Lord hear our prayer after some ridiculous petitions. He also made mention that sometimes people don't even pay attention to the prayers of the faithful and just say it because everyone else is, maybe you lost focus etc. But do we really think about what we are or just have prayed for. I started this thread before the server crash and saw it had six responses but I wasn't able to see them. So if you responded to that, what did you say? Feel free to partake in this new discussion. If you know of the article I speak of please let me know where I can read it in its full context. This is what I recollect about the article though.[/quote] I think it was actually an article by George Weigel. And just to clarify, the "ridiculous" was not "stupid" in the sense of judging what is important (like a sick cat or something), but along the lines of some of the ways we pray for government/political things. I don't remember his exact example he used, though.
scardella Posted March 10, 2008 Posted March 10, 2008 The only ones that I would refrain from are ones that don't seem to reflect the faith. I might refrain from one that prays for the abolition of the death penalty (kinda still muddled on that one), and I definitely would refrain on one that prays for the "liberation" of women so they could become priests.
Laudate_Dominum Posted March 10, 2008 Posted March 10, 2008 [quote name='scardella' post='1474988' date='Mar 10 2008, 01:20 PM']The only ones that I would refrain from are ones that don't seem to reflect the faith. I might refrain from one that prays for the abolition of the death penalty (kinda still muddled on that one), and I definitely would refrain on one that prays for the "liberation" of women so they could become priests.[/quote] Amen. I've opted to observe a moment of prayerful silence during some petitions that I found to be tacky to the point of inappropriate. For example, praying that the Red Sox win a game or something. If I can't pray for an intention in honesty I'd rather not lie with my words. hehe.
MissScripture Posted March 10, 2008 Posted March 10, 2008 Here is the article: [url="http://www.beliefnet.com/story/44/story_4484_1.html"]http://www.beliefnet.com/story/44/story_4484_1.html[/url] Here is a thread from when it was posted on PM: [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=64639&hl=Lord+Don't+hear+prayer"]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?s...9;t+hear+prayer[/url]
Deb Posted March 10, 2008 Posted March 10, 2008 I don't think I ever heard an intention that I thought was ridiculous so can't really say what I would do.
Ash Wednesday Posted March 10, 2008 Posted March 10, 2008 I have refrained before. I remember a specific incident where a friend and I were visiting one of her friends over the weekend and attending mass at a parish in Berkeley (yeah, enough said.) They had members of the congregation voice their own petitions and one angry lefty sounding woman petitioned for women to be allowed into the priesthood. I pursed my lips and probably had a strange look on my face -- my friend noticed I didn't look too pleased. I think what bothered me most of all wasn't the fact that she said this, or that the congregants responded with "Lord hear our prayer"... it was that the officiating priest himself said it as well.
picchick Posted March 10, 2008 Posted March 10, 2008 I mean as long as the prayer were not sinful or wrong. I agree with the woman priest thing. A big no for that. I pray for everything...yes including Notre Dame to win. Not really the Red Sox. I am not a baseball fan. But if your heart is in the right place what does it matter? It is a conversation with God. God might not care about sports but why would it matter if I slip a prayer for my fav football team? I pray for an end to abortion and such so I don't think He minds.
Deb Posted March 10, 2008 Posted March 10, 2008 [quote name='picchick' post='1475091' date='Mar 10 2008, 05:35 PM']I mean as long as the prayer were not sinful or wrong. I agree with the woman priest thing. A big no for that. I pray for everything...yes including Notre Dame to win. Not really the Red Sox. I am not a baseball fan. But if your heart is in the right place what does it matter? It is a conversation with God. God might not care about sports but why would it matter if I slip a prayer for my fav football team? I pray for an end to abortion and such so I don't think He minds.[/quote] I think that a petition brought before the congregation should be in keeping with the reverence for the mass. If you want to slip a prayer to God for your fav football team, it would be best if you saved that for your private prayers. The woman who offered up a prayer for women to become Priests should have kept hers to her private time also.
picchick Posted March 10, 2008 Posted March 10, 2008 [quote name='Deb' post='1475100' date='Mar 10 2008, 05:43 PM']I think that a petition brought before the congregation should be in keeping with the reverence for the mass. If you want to slip a prayer to God for your fav football team, it would be best if you saved that for your private prayers. The woman who offered up a prayer for women to become Priests should have kept hers to her private time also.[/quote] Oh I agree, I am sorry I didn't clarify. I wouldn't say, "God please let Notre Dame win this weekend." During Mass. But maybe just maybe during the silent part, I'll pray for it in my heart. That way any USC/Michigan/Purdue fans in the congregation would unknowingly be praying for the enemy.... Again, sorry I didn't clarify. Meg
CatherineM Posted March 10, 2008 Posted March 10, 2008 I can't remember ever hearing a prayer in church I couldn't go along with. I did regret one later. We prayed for a hurricane that was forecast to make a direct hit on us not to, and it did veer away at the last hour to hit a much less populated area, but still, I felt like we had prayed for someone else's misfortune.
the_rev Posted March 10, 2008 Author Posted March 10, 2008 [quote]Here is the article: [url="http://www.beliefnet.com/story/44/story_4484_1.html"]http://www.beliefnet.com/story/44/story_4484_1.html[/url] Here is a thread from when it was posted on PM: [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?s...9;t+hear+prayer"]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?s...9;t+hear+prayer[/url][/quote] Thank you very much for finding this! I couldn't find it because I thought it was written by mark shea! Having it written by George Weigel will drive my point home to the person I was discussing this. It was also a similar political intention I did not pray for because I didn't agree with it as a student of political science. Thanks very much for finding this Miss Scripture.
MissScripture Posted March 11, 2008 Posted March 11, 2008 [quote name='the_rev' post='1475178' date='Mar 10 2008, 06:46 PM']Thank you very much for finding this! I couldn't find it because I thought it was written by mark shea! Having it written by George Weigel will drive my point home to the person I was discussing this. It was also a similar political intention I did not pray for because I didn't agree with it as a student of political science. Thanks very much for finding this Miss Scripture.[/quote] No problem.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now