Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='T-Bone _' post='1478010' date='Mar 16 2008, 09:46 AM']If a presidential candidate attended a church headed by a white supremacist, would everyone have such a cavalier attitude?[/quote]

But the issue isn't that he attended this type of church, it is that he is a member of this church and has been for more than 20 years. He married him and baptized his children. This preacher has put forth some very hateful rhetoric that mirrors what his wife has written. Part of the process for the election of a president is to know who it is that you are voting for. Since he has little voting record we must look at those closest to him as closes friends and associates often have similar views.

Posted

[quote name='kujo' post='1477293' date='Mar 14 2008, 12:53 PM']Let's be fair here guys. Just because this idiot says saltine-crazy things, doesn't mean that Obama believes or supports them. Still, Obama needs to get out front on this stuff and denounce these things and tell this preacher to stop linking himself to Obama like this.[/quote]
I'll be fair. I won't hold this against him. I'll just judge him based on his voting record regarding life issues.






oh wait, that's right. :)

Posted

[quote name='Justin86' post='1478085' date='Mar 16 2008, 10:07 AM']That would be a definite "no". Even if he advocated "change".[/quote]
What?? You mean "change" can ever not be good??!

Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' post='1477285' date='Mar 14 2008, 12:27 PM']guess who else is a part of that same congregation? :whistle:

hint: it's a big Obama supporter!
it's Oprah![/quote]

I heard that she left that church back in the early 90's

Posted

[quote name='kujo' post='1477595' date='Mar 15 2008, 11:42 AM']The point is that I think we need to realize that perhaps Obama looked at this man as a father figure, or at least a spiritual elder. Right or wrong, he is close with this man. Again, I think he should cut all ties with him, not only for the sake of his political career, but for his soul as well; however, as someone mentioned before, we are electing [b]the President of the United States of America[/b], not a pope or a theologian. We need a man/woman who will make sound decisions on a vast array of issues, from budgets to foreign policy to troop reductions to healthcare plans.[/quote]
An important part of being President of the United States is making decisions. Did Obama show good judgment being so closely tied to a man filled with hate speech for so long? No. So how can we trust his judgment on national issues?

The second qualification we expect of the president is integrity. He says he was not a witness to any of the hate speeches. Now he admits to hearing them and simply disagreed with them. Which is it? Witnessed or not?

desertwoman
Posted

During the speech, he kept saying former preacher. So..... he's not his preacher anymore, or he no longer preaches?

Posted

[quote name='desertwoman' post='1479605' date='Mar 18 2008, 09:40 PM']During the speech, he kept saying former preacher. So..... he's not his preacher anymore, or he no longer preaches?[/quote]
I believe he retired recently, like last month. Forced? I don't know.

Obama tries to rationalize his preacher's behavior by saying we all having a pastor we disagree with. Um, I have never heard from any priest say stuff so objectionable. Obama, the "Well he did it too!" excuse doesn't fly with me.

Posted

[quote name='kamiller42' post='1479841' date='Mar 18 2008, 11:12 PM']I believe he retired recently, like last month. Forced? I don't know.

Obama tries to rationalize his preacher's behavior by saying we all having a pastor we disagree with. Um, I have never heard from any priest say stuff so objectionable. Obama, the "Well he did it too!" excuse doesn't fly with me.[/quote]

:yes:

Posted

[quote name='kamiller42' post='1479540' date='Mar 18 2008, 06:42 PM']An important part of being President of the United States is making decisions. Did Obama show good judgment being so closely tied to a man filled with hate speech for so long? No. So how can we trust his judgment on national issues?[/quote]

We cannot. Politics aside, this man does not have good judgment.

[quote]The second qualification we expect of the president is integrity. He says he was not a witness to any of the hate speeches. Now he admits to hearing them and simply disagreed with them. Which is it? Witnessed or not?[/quote]

Witnessed, then lied about. Is he lying about disagreeing with the statements? I'm afraid that he is.

Posted

[quote name='T-Bone _' post='1479852' date='Mar 19 2008, 02:05 AM']We cannot. Politics aside, this man does not have good judgment.[/quote]
The fact he tried to rationalize his preacher's antics by saying these sort of things happen in every church or synagogue should be offense to anyone who heard the speech. He degraded everyone's church to lift up his own preacher's offensiveness. Yet, no outrage. I guess people don't care to have their pastors insulted like this. I have read a lot commentary on this, and I feel like I am the only one saying "Not in my church have I heard such hatred." (Ok, Byron York @ National Review comes pretty close.) There is something obviously theologically flawed with your church Obama.

Obama doesn't care who gets burned in defense of Mr Wrong. Obama will even throw his grandmother under the bus to protect him.

[quote]Witnessed, then lied about. Is he lying about disagreeing with the statements? I'm afraid that he is.[/quote]
He lied about Mr Wrong. He lied about talking to Canada about NAFTA. He showed poor judgment with Rezco. Obama is flawed and dangerous.

fides quarens intellectum
Posted

On the one hand, i'm glad that this is finally getting press coverage. On the other, it's too late to make a difference, and will all be forgotten by November.

Posted
:smokey: As far as Catholics in the 1930s go, my dad's family moved back to Milwaukee from Hot Springs,Ark.
He mentioned how at St.Boniface they were charging admission to the church.Yes,that's right admission before you could go in and go to mass. I'm not making this up,and have read and heard about other churches doing the same because they needed money during the depths of the Depression. Even though my dad had been baptized there,and it was the main church for German Catholics like our family,my grandfather told them what he thought about the idea, and the family went to another parish instead for mass. My grandfather was a man who was not afraid to tell
a priest ,nun or even a bishop what he thought ,and they could like it or lump it as far as he was concerned. He never called his sister,my great aunt,Sister Mary Generose ,by her religious name. He always called her by her birth name,Eva. When told by one of his other sisters,that wasn't right, he replied "She's been my sister alot longer than she's been a nun"". A catholic in those days didn't have to stay at some parish if they didn't want to.My grandfather certainly didn't.

Obama stays at this church because he wants to,and probably never admit to anyone publicly that he goes along and believes in much of what his pastor says.
I know John hagee of San Antonio endorsed John McCain,but i know McCain doesn't go to Cornerstone Church,and will undobtly drop if he hasn't already Hagee like a hot potato.
Posted

Dude, I really don't understand why people (::cough cough REPUBLICANS::) are harping on this. Honestly, why is this an issue? Isn't there something in the Constitution about not requiring a religious litmus test? Aren't you guys tired of the BS that the press regurgitates to us and expects us to care about?

Please, please move on. It was a mistake. Obama denounced the comments.

Done. Over.

The real question is not what church Obama (or anyone else) goes to, but what we're going to do about healthcare, the sinking economy, the prosecution of the War on Terror, how are we going to restore our moral integrity in the world, why are people still going to bed hungry in America....

When you take stock of your priorities, is this issue even in the top 10? If it is, you may need to drink a few and try to figure out why.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='kujo' post='1483082' date='Mar 24 2008, 02:49 PM']Dude, I really don't understand why people (::cough cough REPUBLICANS::) are harping on this. Honestly, why is this an issue? Isn't there something in the Constitution about not requiring a religious litmus test? Aren't you guys tired of the BS that the press regurgitates to us and expects us to care about?

Please, please move on. It was a mistake. Obama denounced the comments.

Done. Over.

The real question is not what church Obama (or anyone else) goes to, but what we're going to do about healthcare, the sinking economy, the prosecution of the War on Terror, how are we going to restore our moral integrity in the world, why are people still going to bed hungry in America....

When you take stock of your priorities, is this issue even in the top 10? If it is, you may need to drink a few and try to figure out why.[/quote]
Why are we harping on this???? Its an issue because Obama says this man mentored him for 20 YEARS, and married him and baptised his children. Would you let a racist baptise your children or marry you? Would you be proud to say a racist was your mentor and hero? If Obama spent 20 years in a mosque hearing these things the country would be up in arms, but because its a protestant group it gets a free pass? Because its a black group it gets a free pass? BS! Sin is sin is sin, and racism is a sin, no matter what color preaches it.
And I am a pro-life Democrat.

Posted

although what this preacher said was deffitenly wrong, it still doesnt dimiss the fact the way blacks have been treated in this country. it still doesnt erase the fact that alot of these people have ancestors in their family who were slaves and mistreated. God doesnt condone slavery. He doesnt look back on that and think it was ok. there are many racist in all churches and just because you dont hear about it doesnt mean it doesnt exist. i dont agree with this preacher but im not going to judge him on this alone and say he is a evil racist man. i love america and am blessed to be liveing here but that still doesnt change what has happened in the past. it still doesnt change the fact that this preacher probally had family who couldnt use the same restroom as whites or drink out of the same water fountian. mabey he's stuck in the past but sometimes the past is really difficult to get over.

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1483104' date='Mar 24 2008, 03:24 PM']Why are we harping on this???? Its an issue because Obama says this man mentored him for 20 YEARS, and married him and baptised his children. Would you let a racist baptise your children or marry you? Would you be proud to say a racist was your mentor and hero? If Obama spent 20 years in a mosque hearing these things the country would be up in arms, but because its a protestant group it gets a free pass? Because its a black group it gets a free pass? BS! Sin is sin is sin, and racism is a sin, no matter what color preaches it.
And I am a pro-life Democrat.[/quote]

I feel that Obama's association with this guy smells of elderberries. Plain and simple. But I don't believe that he is guilty of the sins of his mentor.

Posted

[quote name='kujo' post='1483082' date='Mar 24 2008, 12:49 PM']Dude, I really don't understand why people (::cough cough REPUBLICANS::) are harping on this. Honestly, why is this an issue? Isn't there something in the Constitution about not requiring a religious litmus test? Aren't you guys tired of the BS that the press regurgitates to us and expects us to care about?

Please, please move on. It was a mistake. Obama denounced the comments.

Done. Over.

The real question is not what church Obama (or anyone else) goes to, but what we're going to do about healthcare, the sinking economy, the prosecution of the War on Terror, how are we going to restore our moral integrity in the world, why are people still going to bed hungry in America....

When you take stock of your priorities, is this issue even in the top 10? If it is, you may need to drink a few and try to figure out why.[/quote]
The law can't bar a man from being president on account of his religion, but there's certainly nothing that says that we the voters can't take a candidate's beliefs and who he chooses as a spiritual leader into account when choosing a commander-in-chief.
There's nothing that says we must throw all considerations of character and moral principle out the window when placing a vote.

And don't kid yourself - if some Republican candidate had a blatantly racist, anti-American pastor, you'd never hear the end of it from the media (along with many solemn editorials on the bigotry inherent in conservatism, no doubt).

And frankly, while I don't consider it completely irrelevent, I consider this pastor among the least of the reasons not to support Obama. This is a man who constistantly supports abortion and even infanticide, has stated he is a against a literal interpretation of the Constitution (making clear the type of liberal activist scum he would appoint to the Supreme Court), gives active support to the "gay" agenda, and sees more socialism as the cure to all our ills. His extreme left-wing voting record in the Senate speaks for itself.
If you're concerned about "restoring our moral integrity in the world" and think Obama is your man, all I can say is you have an odd idea of "moral integrity."

Posted (edited)

[quote name='kujo' post='1483082' date='Mar 24 2008, 01:49 PM']Dude, I really don't understand why people (::cough cough REPUBLICANS::) are harping on this. Honestly, why is this an issue? Isn't there something in the Constitution about not requiring a religious litmus test? Aren't you guys tired of the BS that the press regurgitates to us and expects us to care about?[/quote]
What was religious about Mr. Wrong's comments? The government gave black people AIDS? America deserved 9/11? America is the US of KKK A? Mr. Wrong's comments go far beyond any religious disagreement. Must be why the IRS is investigating him and the church's tax free status. (Yea, I know nothing will become of it. The IRS can be intimidated.)

[quote]Please, please move on. It was a mistake. Obama denounced the comments.

Done. Over.

The real question is not what church Obama (or anyone else) goes to, but what we're going to do about healthcare, the sinking economy, the prosecution of the War on Terror, how are we going to restore our moral integrity in the world, why are people still going to bed hungry in America....[/quote]
In order to discuss those issues, we need to know the sensibilities of the one in charge are putting forth agendas. If Obama wants to be president, the one, we have to examine his sensibilities: the awareness of events around him (how could he have missed this hate for 20+ years?), his judgment (why did he stay? Why didn't correct Mr. Wrong if they are as close Obama says they are?), and his role as protege (how much of Mr. Wrong's sermons over the years have influenced Obama?).

Obama denounced the comments while excusing the pastor and himself as a result. He raised Mr. Wrong up by tearing everyone else down, including you and me and your parish priests!

Edited by kamiller42
Posted

[quote name='kamiller42' post='1479841' date='Mar 19 2008, 12:12 AM']Obama tries to rationalize his preacher's behavior by saying we all having a pastor we disagree with. Um, I have never heard from any priest say stuff so objectionable. Obama, the "Well he did it too!" excuse doesn't fly with me.[/quote]
Consider yourself lucky. I have heard a few ordained Roman Catholic priests say things just as, if not more, objectionable.

Posted

I had to turn the news off today, I'm getting sick of hearing about this story. Is it just me or is everything turning personal in the election......

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...