Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Vatican Good Friday Sermon On Ecumenism


Recommended Posts

Posted

Father Raniero Cantalamessa, the preacher of the Pontifical Household, gave a sermon on Ecumenism. You can read the full article [u][url="http://www.zenit.org/article-22129?l=english"]here[/url][/u]

An excerpt:
[color="#4169E1"]"The extraordinary thing about this way to unity based on love is that it is already now wide open before us. We cannot be hasty in regard to doctrine because differences exist and must be resolved with patience in the appropriate contexts. We can instead 'be hasty' in charity and already be united in that sense now."[/color]

I have mixed feelings towards the article and so I'd like to quote some passages from Pope Pius XII's encyclical, Mortalium Animos, which can be read in full [u][url="http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/pius_xi/encyclicals/documents/hf_p-xi_enc_19280106_mortalium-animos_en.html"]Here[/url][/u]:
The quotes are in BLUE:

[color="#0000FF"]4. [b]Is it not right, it is often repeated, indeed, even consonant with duty, that all who invoke the name of Christ should abstain from mutual reproaches and at long last be united in mutual charity? Who would dare to say that he loved Christ, unless he worked with all his might to carry out the desires of Him, Who asked His Father that His disciples might be "one."[1] [/b]And did not the same Christ will that His disciples should be marked out and distinguished from others by this characteristic, namely that they loved one another: "By this shall all men know that you are my disciples, if you have love one for another"?[2] [b]All Christians, they add, should be as "one": for then they would be much more powerful in driving out the pest of irreligion,[/b] which like a serpent daily creeps further and becomes more widely spread, and prepares to rob the Gospel of its strength. These things and others that class of men who are known as [b]pan-Christians[/b] continually repeat and amplify; and these men, so far from being quite few and scattered, have increased to the dimensions of an entire class, and have grouped themselves into widely spread societies, most of which are directed by non-Catholics, although they are imbued with varying doctrines concerning the things of faith. This undertaking is so actively promoted as in many places to win for itself the adhesion of a number of citizens, and [i]it even takes possession of the minds of very many Catholics and allures them with the hope of bringing about such a union as would be agreeable to the desires of Holy Mother Church, who has indeed nothing more at heart than to recall her erring sons and to lead them back to her bosom[/i]. But in reality beneath these enticing words and blandishments lies hid a most [b]grave error[/b], by which the [b]foundations of the Catholic faith are completely destroyed[/b].

5. Admonished, therefore, by the consciousness of Our Apostolic office that We should not permit the flock of the Lord to be cheated by [b]dangerous fallacies[/b], We invoke, Venerable Brethren, your zeal in avoiding this [b]evil[/b];...

8. [b]This being so, it is clear that the Apostolic See cannot on any terms take part in their assemblies, nor is it anyway lawful for Catholics either to support or to work for such enterprises[/b]; for if they do so they will be giving countenance to a [b]false Christianity[/b], quite alien to the one Church of Christ. Shall We suffer, what would indeed be iniquitous, the truth, and a truth divinely revealed, to be made a subject for compromise? For here there is question of defending revealed truth...

9. These pan-Christians who turn their minds to uniting the churches seem, indeed, to pursue the noblest of ideas in promoting charity among all Christians: nevertheless how does it happen that this charity tends to injure faith? Everyone knows that John himself, the Apostle of love, who seems to reveal in his Gospel the secrets of the Sacred Heart of Jesus, and who never ceased to impress on the memories of his followers the new commandment "Love one another," [b]altogether forbade any intercourse with those who professed a mutilated and corrupt version of Christ's teaching: "If any man come to you and bring not this doctrine, receive him not into the house nor say to him: God speed you."[/b][18] For which reason, since charity is based on a complete and sincere faith, the disciples of Christ must be united principally by the bond of one faith...

10. So, Venerable Brethren, it is clear why this Apostolic See has never allowed its subjects to take part in the assemblies of non-Catholics: [b]for the union of Christians can only be promoted by promoting the return to the one true Church of Christ of those who are separated from it, for in the past they have unhappily left it[/b]...[/color]


Compare and contrast this with Ut Unum Sint. Both documents are of equal weight.

Posted

St Maximilian Kolbe's opinion of ecumenism:

[color="#FF0000"]“[b]There is no greater enemy of the Immaculata and her Knighthood than today’s ecumenism[/b], which every Knight must not only fight against, but also neutralize through diametrically opposed action and ultimately destroy. We must realize the goal of the Militia Immaculata as quickly as possible: that is, to conquer the whole world, and every individual soul which exists today or will exist until the end of the world, for the Immaculata, and through her for the Most Sacred Heart of Jesus.”[/color]

Entry of Diary dated April 23, 1933. Cited from The Immaculata Our Ideal, p. 37

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

Notice that St. Maximilian Kolbe said "today's" ecumenism. I think a part of the problem with radical traditionalism and ecumenism is that ecumenism meant something different than what the Church means by it. This would not be the first time in Church history that poor understandings of definitions (and, admittedly, there are misunderstandings on different sides of the ecumenical argument) has thrown a wrench in the works. In Nazi Germany, there was an attempt on the part of the state to incorporate parts of Christian religion into their pagan aryanism, as well as the other way around. There was an attempt to convince Christians that their goals were the same as the Nazi goals. The Church's definition seems much more to be the idea of peaceful co-existence so that, as the other world religions walk in peace with Christianity, they will begin to see the appeal of Christianity and convert (but this cannot be done without first settling other religions into peaceful relations...the more the world religions are distracted by war and hatred, the less time they can devote to true theology and honest reasoning, which will point them inevitably to Christ). Christ would never say that He and the Gentiles, in reality, shared a common faith, but He and His saints would go to Gentiles and treat them peacefully in hopes that they would eventually see the Christan faith as true, which they largely did. Both these approaches are often called "ecumenism," but only the latter truly is. Further, Jesus would never had made any converts if He spent all His time talking about how absolutely inferior the other religions were, how none of them were even at all open to truth or conversion or goodness, or how we should not associate with them. Anti-ecumenism is anti-Christian. If we are to believe that we can reason with other religions, then we'd better believe their not entirely unreasonable; if we are to believe that we can point other religions to the full truth, then we'd better believe they have at least a little truth to stand on; and having these beliefs, we'd better be open to dialogue...not to admit that we're wrong, far from it, but to discuss openly with those who have human dignity and the gifts of reason, and need to be shown the way.

No one can convince me that Pope Pius XII was against that.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Raphael' post='1481784' date='Mar 22 2008, 04:07 PM']The Church's definition seems much more to be the idea of peaceful co-existence so that, as the other world religions walk in peace with Christianity, they will begin to see the appeal of Christianity and convert (but this cannot be done without first settling other religions into peaceful relations...[/quote]

Raphael, that interpretation of ecumenism doesn't involve altering our expression of faith, which is occurring in our very day. One can be charitable and still hold on to Catholic truth and fully express the faith. What's happening today is that "unity" is holding primacy over evangelization, and this only serves to maintain separation rather than real unity. Real unity is only found *in* the Catholic Church in communion with Christ's Vicar, the Pope. Any "unity" that is based off watering down Catholic truth to make it more palatable, or creating a "common denominator" with our denominations, is what Pope St Pius XII was condemning. Real Ecumenism must ultimately have this aim, to bring Protestants and Schismatics back into the Church. The dialogues we get into ought to be a means to achieving this, not an end in themselves. Otherwise we're building some kind of world religion instead of bring back souls to the True Church.

Edited by mortify
Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='mortify' post='1481908' date='Mar 22 2008, 09:00 PM']Raphael, that interpretation of ecumenism doesn't involve altering our expression of faith, which is occurring in our very day. One can be charitable and still hold on to Catholic truth and fully express the faith. What's happening today is that "unity" is holding primacy over evangelization, and this only serves to maintain separation rather than real unity. Real unity is only found *in* the Catholic Church in communion with Christ's Vicar, the Pope. Any "unity" that is based off watering down Catholic truth to make it more palatable, or creating a "common denominator" with our denominations, is what Pope St Pius XII was condemning. Real Ecumenism must ultimately have this aim, to bring Protestants and Schismatics back into the Church. The dialogues we get into ought to be a means to achieving this, not an end in themselves. Otherwise we're building some kind of world religion instead of bring back souls to the True Church.[/quote]
Please tell me where the Magisterium of the Catholic Church has altered our faith. Sure, some "theologians" have attempted it, but they could not accomplish it, because they do not have the power, and while most Catholics may believe the Church to be something it is not, that does not change it.

Nowhere has the Catholic faith changed on account of ecumenism or anything else. The Magisterium is committed to clinging to the authentic faith of the Church and is entirely against watering anything down.

You imply that what we have done is "watered down the faith" or "created a common denominator." In reality, these two are quite different. The first would affect the substance of the faith, changing it from what it is into something else. The second simply takes a more basic aspect of the faith, something on which we may agree with non-Catholics, as a basis to lead them to see the more detailed faith, with all the other aspects fully intact. This is what we do with children in catechesis, as well. We teach them things like "God is a family: Father, Son, and Holy Spirit," not "God is the one nature found in three distinct persons, not split in three, nor shared, but wholly belonging to the three all at once, to each entirely." We don't teach schoolchildren the Quicumque, until perhaps they are ready for it. So it is with our separated brethren. They have been apart from the true faith for a long time, such that they have difficulty swallowing it as it is, and so we give them "the milk of faith" and not solid food, so that they can accept the simpler things and build up to the greater things. This is the method of St. Paul. If you have a problem with it, take it up with him.

I'm sorry, but your view is founded on your personal experiences, whatever they may be, and you seem to think from those experiences that the faith has been altered, but it is the same as it has always been.

God bless,

Micah

Posted

[quote name='Raphael' post='1481950' date='Mar 22 2008, 08:18 PM']Please tell me where the Magisterium of the Catholic Church has altered our faith. Sure, some "theologians" have attempted it, but they could not accomplish it, because they do not have the power, and while most Catholics may believe the Church to be something it is not, that does not change it.[/quote]

Peace Micah,

I said our *expression* of the faith has been altered, not the Faith itself or any dogma. Changes in the Liturgy serve as the greatest examples.

[quote]Nowhere has the Catholic faith changed on account of ecumenism or anything else. The Magisterium is committed to clinging to the authentic faith of the Church and is entirely against watering anything down.[/quote]

The expression of the faith has changed. Compare pre and post Vatican ii books.
[quote]You imply that what we have done is "watered down the faith" or "created a common denominator." In reality, these two are quite different. The first would affect the substance of the faith, changing it from what it is into something else. The second simply takes a more basic aspect of the faith, something on which we may agree with non-Catholics, as a basis to lead them to see the more detailed faith, with all the other aspects fully intact. This is what we do with children in catechesis, as well. We teach them things like "God is a family: Father, Son, and Holy Spirit," not "God is the one nature found in three distinct persons, not split in three, nor shared, but wholly belonging to the three all at once, to each entirely." We don't teach schoolchildren the Quicumque, until perhaps they are ready for it. So it is with our separated brethren. They have been apart from the true faith for a long time, such that they have difficulty swallowing it as it is, and so we give them "the milk of faith" and not solid food, so that they can accept the simpler things and build up to the greater things. This is the method of St. Paul. If you have a problem with it, take it up with him.[/quote]

Friend, no need for straw man arguments, I have no beef with St Paul, and I agree with you for the most part. There's no problem with explaining the faith so long as we don't deny or hide the truth. I personally disagree with the changes being done to the Good Friday Prayer, I think this shows just how far the Vatican is willing to go to preserve "dialogue." True dialogue starts with admitting what we believe: that we have the truth and we hope for the conversion of all people, including the Jews. Sure, explanation is required but if this isn't being done, then what is being accomplished? We're either promoting indifferentism or we're working towards some world religion. Try to hide the fact that we desire the conversion of Jews confuses the faithful and makes only encourages separation.


Peace in Christ

Posted (edited)

Here is another example of a Jewish Rabbi threatening to terminate inter religious dialogue if we do not further alter the Good Friday Prayer. In other words, these Rabbis want us to alter our expression of the faith to point where we no longer hold on to truth:

[b]German Jewish leader criticizes Pope over prayer[/b]
Fri Mar 21, 2008 11:51am EDT
[url="http://www.reuters.com/article/topNews/idUSL2167492020080321?feedType=RSS&feedName=topNews&rpc=22&sp=true"]Link to article[/url]

[quote][color="#0000FF"]BERLIN (Reuters) - The leader of Germany's Jewish community said on Friday she was surprised Pope Benedict could have allowed a new version of a Good Friday prayer for the conversion of Jews.

Charlotte Knobloch, president of the Central Council of Jews in Germany, told Reuters Television she could not fathom Pope Benedict putting forward the new decree because he experienced discrimination against Jews in Germany as a young man.

(...)

[b]Jews criticized the new version because it still says they should recognize Jesus Christ as the savior of all men. It asks that "all Israel may be saved" and Jews say [u]it keeps an underlying call to conversion[/u] that they had wanted removed.[/b]

Knobloch said that she could not envision a continuation of the i[b]nter-religious dialogue[/b] as long as the old prayer stands.

"The inter-religious dialogue has suffered an enormous setback because of this version and I assume that one will find a way very soon to continue the dialogue, but at the moment I don't see it happening," she said.

"As long as the Catholic Church, that is to say Pope Benedict, does not return to the previous wording, I assume that there will not be any further dialogue in the form that we were able to have in the past," Knobloch said.[/color][/quote]


The Jews do need Jesus, and we shouldn't be afraid to say it.

Edited by mortify
Posted

Getting back to the topic of Fr. Cantalamessa:

"We cannot be hasty in regard to doctrine because differences exist and must be resolved with patience in the appropriate contexts. We can instead 'be hasty' in charity and already be united in that sense now."

I don't see where he says that doctrine can be set aside. That holding fast to our faith is not important. I don't even see where he says we should abstain from mutual reproaches as Pius XII warns about.

We are Catholic therefore we always take a "both and" stance as Dr. Regis Martin would say. We must both love them and reproach them. I don't see Fr. Cantalamessa saying anything different. He is saying don't be [b]hasty[/b] to reproach, reproaching [b]must[/b] happen, but it must happen at the proper time and in the proper place. Be hasty to love because the proper time and place to love is [b]always[/b].

Please notice how Fr. Cantalamessa says that differences exist and "[b]must be resolved[/b] with patience in the appropriate contexts."

Is it always loving to reproach? No. I have protestant friends, if all I ever did was tell them where the doctrine they held was wrong... they wouldn't be my friends.

It seems to me that Pius XII is saying we cannot stop at charity. We cannot stop with the same kind of love our Protestant brothers and sisters bring to our door, we must reject that kind of love because it does not include a deep desire to be united under the one true Church. I don't think Fr. Cantalamessa is saying that we can stop at charity though. I think that Fr. Cantalamessa understands that true charity in the eyes of the Catholic Church includes conversion.

All in all... I don't see any discrepancies between the preaching of Fr. Cantalamessa and the guidance of Pius XII

Posted

JMJ
3/23 - Resurrection of Our Lord

Surrexit Christus, alleluia!

I need to read the whole of Fr. Cantalamessa's sermon before making any judgments. However, I will say that I don't see anything wrong [i]prima facie[/i] with what he has said. We cannot rush things in regard to doctrine; that's exactly what Protestant ecumenism does. In some sense, this can be seen as a critique of those Protestant forms of "communion" or "ecumenism". However, we [i]can[/i] be hasty with regards to authentic forms of love, because authentic love never misdirects. It always (a) looks like the Cross and (b) leads to the Cross.

But again, I reserve judgment until I can read the whole thing.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

I was thinking the same thing as Pio Nono on this one. Good call Pio. I would also reaffirm that "I reserve judgment until I can read the whole thing."

I've read a couple books by Fr. Cantalamessa and on the whole they were quite good; but I will admit that at times there were gestures towards Protestantism that were distasteful to me - I wouldn't say they were heretical, just not my bag.

Posted

Christos voskrese! Voistinu voskrese!

Posted

He is risen!

Friends, if there are differences in doctrine we can't claim to be achieving unity. Unity means sharing one faith, the same sacraments, and being in communion with the Pope. Any notion of unity that is outside of the Catholic Church is not genuine and only serves to lengthen separation. This is what Pope St Pius XII was getting at, and he said it ultimately leads to indifferentism.

[color="#0000FF"]"Let them therefore return to their common Father, who, forgetting the insults previously heaped on the Apostolic See, will receive them in the most loving fashion. For if, as they continually state, they long to be united with Us and ours, why do they not hasten to enter the Church, "the Mother and mistress of all Christ's faithful"? Let them hear Lactantius crying out: "The Catholic Church is alone in keeping the true worship. This is the fount of truth, this the house of Faith, this the temple of God: if any man enter not here, or if any man go forth from it, he is a stranger to the hope of life and salvation. Let none delude himself with obstinate wrangling. For life and salvation are here concerned, which will be lost and entirely destroyed, unless their interests are carefully and assiduously kept in mind."
section 11[/color]
Mortalium Animos

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

mortify,

I believe that I share your concerns but it can be a delicate matter because there is no doubt a valid form of ecumenism. Personally I embrace ecumenism in the proper sense with respect to the Orthodox Churches and am more skeptical, and certainly less enthusiastic, when it comes to the Protestant ecclesial communities and in particular the fringe sects. I believe that rapprochement with the Orthodox is a viable goal and in some ways a real imperative, but I'm not sure how to interpret ecumenical relations with the various Protestant traditions and I share your concern towards dubious and doctrinally indifferent forms of "ecumenism." Still, I am inclined to give the benefit of the doubt so far as Fr. Cantalamessa's homily is concerned (which I've yet to read in full unfortunately).

Posted

[i]Mortalium Animos[/i] was written by Pope Pius XI.

Posted

ZE08032104 - 2008-03-21
Permalink: [url="http://www.zenit.org/article-22128?l=english"]http://www.zenit.org/article-22128?l=english[/url]
Good Friday Sermon of Father Cantalamessa

"The Tunic Was Without Seam"

VATICAN CITY, MARCH 21, 2008 (Zenit.org).- Here is a translation of the sermon delivered today by Capuchin Father Raniero Cantalamessa, preacher of the Pontifical Household, at the Good Friday liturgy in St. Peter's Basilica.

* * *

"When the soldiers had crucified Jesus, they took his clothes and divided them into four shares, a share for each soldier. They also took his tunic, but the tunic was without seam, woven in one piece from the top down. So they said to one another, 'Let's not tear it, but cast lots for it to see whose it will be,' in order that the passage of Scripture might be fulfilled that says: 'They divided my garments among them, and for my vesture they cast lots'" (John 19:23-24).

It has always been asked what the evangelist John wanted to say with the importance that he gives to this particular detail of the Passion. One relatively recent explanation is that the tunic alludes to the vestment of the high priest and that with this, John wanted to affirm that Jesus died not only as king but also as priest.

It is not said in the Bible, however, that the tunic of the high priest had to be seamless (cf. Exodus 28: 4; Leviticus 16:4). For this reason the most authoritative of the exegetes prefer to stick to the traditional explanation, according to which the seamless tunic symbolized the unity of the disciples.[1] It is the interpretation that St. Cyprian already gave: "The unity of the Church," he writes, "is expressed in the Gospel when it is said that the tunic of Christ was not divided or cut."[2]

Whatever be the explanation that one gives to the text, one thing is certain: The unity of the disciples is, for John, the purpose for which Christ dies. "Jesus had to die for the nation, and not only for the nation, but also to gather into one the dispersed children of God" (John 11:51-52). At the Last Supper he himself said: "I pray not only for them, but also for those who will believe in me through their word, so that they may all be one, as you, Father, are in me and I in you, that they also may be in us, that the world may believe that you sent me" (John 17:20-21).

The glad tidings to proclaim on Good Friday are that unity, before it is a goal to be sought, is a gift to be received. That the tunic is woven "from the top down," St. Cyprian continues, means that "the unity brought by Christ comes from above, from the heavenly Father, and because of this it cannot be broken apart by those who receive it, but must be received in its integrity."

The soldiers divided "the clothes," or the "the cloak," ("ta imatia") into four pieces, that is, Jesus' outer garments, not the tunic, the "chiton," which was the inner garment, which was in direct contact with his body. This is also a symbol. We men can divide the human and visible element of the Church, but not its deeper unity, which is identified with the Holy Spirit. Christ's tunic was not and can never be divided. It too is of a single piece. "Can Christ be divided?" Paul cried out (cf. 1 Corinthians 1:13). It is the faith we profess in the Creed: "I believe in the Church, one, holy, catholic and apostolic."

* * *

But if unity must serve as a sign "so that the world believe," it must also be a visible, communitarian unity. This is the unity that has been lost and must be rediscovered. It is much more than maintaining neighborly relations; it is the mystical interior unity itself -- "one body, one Spirit, one hope, one Lord, one faith, one baptism, one God Father of all" (Ephesians 4:4-6) -- insofar as this objective unity is in fact received, lived and manifested by believers. A unity that is not endangered by diversity, but enriched by it.

After Easter the apostles asked Jesus: "Lord, are you at this time going to restore the kingdom to Israel?" Today we often address the same question to God: Is this the time in which you will restore the visible unity of the Church? God's answer is also the same as the one Jesus gave to the disciples: "It is not for you to know the times or seasons that the Father has established by his own authority. But you will receive power when the Holy Spirit comes upon you, and you will be my witnesses" (Acts 1:6-8).

The Holy Father recalled this in a homily he gave on Jan. 25 in the Basilica of Saint Paul Outside the Walls at the end of Christian Unity Week: "Unity with God and our brothers and sisters," he wrote, "is a gift that comes from on high, which flows from the communion of love between Father, Son and Holy Spirit in which it is increased and perfected. It is not in our power to decide when or how this unity will be fully achieved. Only God can do it! Like St Paul, let us also place our hope and trust 'in the grace of God which is with us.'"

Today as well, the Holy Spirit will be the one to lead us into unity, if we let him guide us. How was it that the Holy Spirit brought about the first fundamental unity of the Church, that between Jews and pagans? The Holy Spirit descends upon Cornelius and his whole household in the same way in which he descended upon the apostles at Pentecost. So, Peter only needed to draw the conclusion: "If then God gave them the same gift he gave to us when we came to believe in the Lord Jesus Christ, who was I to be able to hinder God?" (Acts 11:17).

For a century now, we have seen the same thing repeat itself before our eyes on a global scale. God has poured out the Holy Spirit in a new and unusual way upon millions of believers from every Christian denomination and, so that there would be no doubts about his intentions, he poured out the Spirit with the same manifestations. Is this not a sign that the Spirit moves us to recognize each other as disciples of Christ and work toward unity?

It is true that this spiritual and charismatic unity is not enough by itself. We see this already at the beginning of the Church. The newly formed unity between Jews and Gentiles was immediately threatened by schism. In the so-called Council of Jerusalem there was a "long discussion" and at the end an agreement was reached and announced to the Church with the formula: "It is the decision of the Holy Spirit and of us..." (Acts 15:28). The Holy Spirit works, therefore, also through another way, which is that of patient exchange, dialogue and even compromise between the different sides, when the essentials of the faith are not in play. He works through human "structures" and the "offices" put in action by Jesus, above all the apostolic and petrine office. It is that which today we call doctrinal and institutional ecumenism.

* * *

However, experience is convincing us that even this doctrinal ecumenism is not sufficient and does not advance matters if it is not also accompanied by a foundational spiritual ecumenism. This is repeated with ever greater insistence by the major promoters of institutional ecumenism. In this centenary of the institution of the week of prayer for Christian unity (1908-2008), at the foot of the cross we would like to meditate on this spiritual ecumenism, on what this spiritual ecumenism is and how we can make progress in it.

Spiritual ecumenism is born through repentance and forgiveness and is nourished by prayer. In 1977, I participated in a charismatic ecumenical congress in the U.S., in Kansas City, Missouri. There were 40,000 participants, half of them Catholic -- Cardinal Suenens among them -- and half from other Christian denominations. One evening, one of the leaders of the meeting began speaking at the microphone in a way that, to me, at that time, was strange: "You priests and pastors, weep and mourn, because the body of my Son is broken. ... You laypeople, men and women, weep and mourn, because the body of my Son is broken."

I began to see people around me fall to their knees, one after another, and to weep with repentance for the divisions in the body of Christ. And all of this went on while a sign reading "Jesus is Lord" went up from one part of the stadium to the other. I was there as an observer who was still rather critical and detached, but I remember thinking to myself: If one day all believers shall be reunited in one single body, it will happen like this, when we all are on our knees with a contrite and humiliated heart, under the great lordship of Christ.

If the unity of the disciples must be a reflection of the unity between Father and Son, it must above all be a unity of love, because such is the unity that reigns in the Trinity. Scripture exhorts us to "do the truth in love" -- "veritatem facientes in caritate" (Ephesians 4:15). And Augustine affirms that "one does not enter into the truth if not through charity" -- "non intratur in veritatem nisi per caritatem."[3]

The extraordinary thing about this way to unity based on love is that it is already now wide open before us. We cannot be hasty in regard to doctrine because differences exist and must be resolved with patience in the appropriate contexts. We can instead "be hasty" in charity and already be united in that sense now. The true, certain sign of the coming of the Spirit, St. Augustine writes, is not speaking in tongues, but it is the love of unity: "Know that you have the Holy Spirit when you allow your heart to adhere to unity through sincere charity."[4]

Let us reflect on St. Paul's hymn to charity. Each verse acquires a contemporary and new meaning if it is applied to the love of members of different Christian denominations in ecumenical relations:

"Love is patient…
Love is not jealous…
It does not seek its own interests…
It does not brood over injury… (if necessary, of the injury done to others!)
It does not rejoice over wrongdoing but rejoices with the truth (it doesn't rejoice over the difficulties of other Churches, but delights in their successes)
It bears all things, believes all things, hopes all things, endures all things" (1Corinthians 13:4ff.).

This week we have accompanied a woman to her eternal rest -- Chiara Lubich, the founder of the Focolare Movement -- who was a pioneer and model of the spiritual ecumenism of love. She showed that the pursuit of unity among Christians does not lead to a closing to the rest of the world; it is rather the first step and the condition for a broader dialogue with believers of other religions and with all men and women who are concerned about the fate of humanity and about peace.

* * *

"Loving," it has been said, "does not mean looking at each other but looking together in the same direction." Even among Christians loving means looking in the same direction, which is Christ. "He is our peace" (Ephesians 2:14). It is like the spokes of a wheel. Consider what happens to the spokes of a wheel when they move from the center outward: As they distance themselves from the center they also become more distant from each other. On the contrary when they move from the periphery toward the center, as they come closer to the center, they also come nearer to each other, until they form a single point. To the extent that we move together toward Christ, we draw nearer to each other, until we are truly, as Jesus desired, "one with him and with the Father."

That which will reunite divided Christianity will only be a new wave of love for Christ that spreads among Christians. This is what is happening through the work of the Holy Spirit and it fills us with wonder and hope. "The love of Christ moves us, because we are convinced that one has died for all" (2 Corinthians 5:14). The brother who belongs to another Church -- indeed every human being -- is "a person for whom Christ died" (Romans 14:16), as he has died for me.

* * *

One thing must move us forward on this journey. What is in play at the beginning of the third millennium, is not the same as what was in play at the beginning of the second millennium, when there was the separation of East and West; nor is it the same as what was in play in the middle of the same millennium when there was the separation of Catholics and Protestants. Can we say that the way the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father or how justification of the sinner comes about are the problems that impassion the men of today and with which the Christian faith stands or falls? The world has moved beyond us and we remain fixed by problems and formulas that the world does not even know the meaning of.

In battles in the Middle Ages there was a moment in which, after the infantry, archers and cavalry had been overwhelmed, the melee began to circle around the king. There the final outcome of the fight was decided. Today the battle for us also takes place around the king. There are buildings and structures made of metal in such a way that if a certain neuralgic point is touched or a certain stone is removed, everything falls apart. In the edifice of the Christian faith this cornerstone is the divinity of Christ. If this is removed, everything falls apart and faith in the Trinity is the first to go.

From this we see that today there are two possible ecumenisms: an ecumenism of faith and an ecumenism of incredulity; one that unites all those who believe that Jesus is the Son of God, that God is Father, Son and Holy Spirit, and that Christ died to save all humankind, and an ecumenism that unites all those who, in deference to the Nicene Creed, continue to proclaim these formulas but empty them of their content. It is an ecumenism in which, in its extreme form, everyone believes the same things because no one any longer believes anything, in the sense that "believing" has in the New Testament.

"Who is it that overcomes the world," John writes in his first letter, "if not those who believe that Jesus is the Son of God?" (1John 5:5). Sticking with this criterion, the fundamental distinction among Christians is not between Catholics, Orthodox and Protestants, but between those who believe that Christ is the Son of God and those who do not believe this.

* * *

"On the first day of the sixth month in the second year of King Darius, the word of the LORD came through the prophet Haggai to the governor of Judah, Zerubbabel, son of Shealtiel, and to the high priest Joshua, son of Jehozadak…: 'Is it time for you to dwell in your own paneled houses, while this house lies in ruins?'" (Haggai 1:1-4).

This word of the prophet Haggai is addressed to us today. Is this the time to concern ourselves with that which only regards our religious order, our movement, or our Church? Is this not precisely the reason why we too "sow much but harvest little" (Haggai 1:6)? We preach and we are active in many ways, but we convert few people and the world moves away from Christ instead of drawing near to him.

The people of Israel heard the prophet's reproof; everyone stopped embellishing his own house and began to work together on God's temple. God then sent his prophet again with a message of consolation and encouragement, which is also addressed to us: "But now take courage, Zerubbabel, says the Lord, and take courage, Joshua, high priest, son of Jehozadak, And take courage, all you people of the land, says the Lord, and work! For I am with you, says the Lord of hosts" (Haggai 2:4). Take courage, all of you who have at heart the cause of the unity of Christians, and go to work, because I am with you, says the Lord!

--- --- ---

[1] Cf. R. E. Brown, "The Death of the Messiah," vol. 2, Doubleday, New York 1994, pp. 955-958.
[2] St. Cyprian, De unitate Ecclesiae, 7 (CSEL 3, p. 215).
[3] St. Augustine, Contra Faustum, 32,18 (CCL 321, p. 779).
[4] St. Augustine, Sermons, 269,3-4 (PL38, 1236 s

[Translation by Joseph G. Trabbic]

Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1482409' date='Mar 23 2008, 01:38 PM']Personally I embrace ecumenism in the proper sense with respect to the Orthodox Churches and am more skeptical, and certainly less enthusiastic, when it comes to the Protestant ecclesial communities and in particular the fringe sects.[/quote]
I tend to agree with this viewpoint. The Orthodox have a theological and liturgical patrimony that goes back to the foundations of the Church in the first millennium. Their theological views cannot be ignored, nor should they be required to update their tradition to fit into a Western Scholastic framework. Unity in communion must not be confused with uniformity.

Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1482411' date='Mar 23 2008, 02:46 PM'][i]Mortalium Animos[/i] was written by Pope Pius XI.[/quote]

I'm glad someone looked at the link! Thanks for the correction.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='mortify' post='1482030' date='Mar 22 2008, 11:37 PM']Peace Micah,

I said our *expression* of the faith has been altered, not the Faith itself or any dogma. Changes in the Liturgy serve as the greatest examples.
The expression of the faith has changed. Compare pre and post Vatican ii books.[/quote]

First, I'm sorry if I seemed to have an attitude last night. It's not personal, it's just that it upsets me how often this argument comes up. When it comes to ecumenism, I just trust the Church to know what she's doing...not that you don't, but debating over these things seems fruitless to me.

Second, I'd like to know which books we are to compare. If you're talking about religion textbooks, say, the Baltimore Catechism versus the texts of Sadlier, then of course the Baltimore Catechism wins hands down. If you're comparing the Baltimore Catechism and the CCC, though, I have a problem with that. The CCC uses very explicit language, expresses the faith quite well. However, there is clearly a lack of using proper Catholic vocabulary and faith expression in most textbooks and theology manuals nowadays.

Lastly, while the liturgy has changed, I don't see that there has been a significant change of expression in the original languages. I think we have a poor English translation, but I think the Latin of the Novus Ordo is quite a genuine expression of our faith.

[quote]Friend, no need for straw man arguments, I have no beef with St Paul, and I agree with you for the most part. There's no problem with explaining the faith so long as we don't deny or hide the truth. I personally disagree with the changes being done to the Good Friday Prayer, I think this shows just how far the Vatican is willing to go to preserve "dialogue." True dialogue starts with admitting what we believe: that we have the truth and we hope for the conversion of all people, including the Jews. Sure, explanation is required but if this isn't being done, then what is being accomplished? We're either promoting indifferentism or we're working towards some world religion. Try to hide the fact that we desire the conversion of Jews confuses the faithful and makes only encourages separation.
Peace in Christ[/quote]

I'm sorry, I was not trying to create a straw man...perhaps just misreading your argument. Forgive me. I agree that dialogue begins with stating all we believe (honesty being the basis of any relationship or mutual communication), but I think that leading another to agree with us involves our putting out our very most basic core beliefs and building up in dialogue from there, as I've already described. Obviously, that doesn't involve watering down the faith, but simply explaining it simply to begin with.

As for the prayer for the Jews, that's not really in the area of ecumenism, but interfaith relations. Nevertheless, I like the revisions. I don't think that the change was intended to hide the fact that we desire the conversion of the Jews, or that it actually does hide that fact. I think the change was to remove a word which has become inflammatory. "Blindness" is a very strong word, as I think anyone will admit. In other times, it may have been less strong, when blindness was more common and it simply meant "inability to see," but now it tends to mean something more finger-pointing and mean-spirited in many parts of the world. That may not be your experience, but it is my experience. I think that the Vatican wanted to retain the basic idea of the old meaning, i.e. that the Jews are unable to see that Christ is Lord and that we pray for their conversion, without using a word that has changed in its connotation over the last century or so. The new prayer seems to me to be praying still for the conversion of the Jews, that they may embrace Christ. The essence of the prayer has therefore not changed. I personally think it's a bit silly to get so upset about the literal expression of the faith if the new expression is just as clear about the essence of the faith.

[quote name='mortify' post='1482042' date='Mar 23 2008, 12:07 AM']Here is another example of a Jewish Rabbi threatening to terminate inter religious dialogue if we do not further alter the Good Friday Prayer. In other words, these Rabbis want us to alter our expression of the faith to point where we no longer hold on to truth:

[b]German Jewish leader criticizes Pope over prayer[/b]
Fri Mar 21, 2008 11:51am EDT
[url="http://www.reuters.com/article/topNews/idUSL2167492020080321?feedType=RSS&feedName=topNews&rpc=22&sp=true"]Link to article[/url]
The Jews do need Jesus, and we shouldn't be afraid to say it.[/quote]

Did the pope further alter the prayer? No. To me, it seems that the pope isn't afraid to say that the Jews need Jesus, so why are we arguing as if he is?

Posted

Question for anybody to answer, but especially Mortify and Raphael if they are into that.

How does a Catholic obey the below verse?

"If any man come to you and bring not this doctrine, receive him not into the house nor say to him: God speed you."

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...