Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='dUSt' post='1487727' date='Mar 29 2008, 01:18 PM']If you don't believe me, then just pick the one that has the better looking mom.[/quote]

Bwahaha! That's just wrong, man! :lol:

Posted

In all seriousness, it seems like you're in quite a predicament. I'd hate to be on either side of your situation. I've never been simultaneously in love with two guys before, but I'm sure that having feelings for two people is pretty unpleasant all the same. Hypothetically speaking, if I ever found out that a guy I was dating was talking to his ex-girlfriend and was in love with her, I think that'd be the end of the relationship.

Does your ex-girlfriend know that you're in a relationship? I mean no offense to her (or to you), but if she keeps trying to sway you when she knows that you're in committed relationship, it [i]could[/i] possibly signify that she has a lack of respect for you, your girlfriend, and/or your relationship. It'd be one thing for her to tell you how she feels about you once after breaking up, but it's quite another thing to keep intruding and pestering. Well, I can't judge her, really, but perhaps she truly has regrets about breaking up with you. On the other hand, maybe she just enjoys the challenge and the chase. Anyhow, you two obviously broke up for a reason. People and situations change, but maybe it'd be helpful if you thought about all the pros and cons of your past relationship with her. If you were to get back together with her, would things still be problematic? Do you think the issues that caused you two to break up would still be there and unresolved? You don't have to answer those questions if you don't want to; they're just questions to think about.

Also, are you truly happy in your relationship with your current girlfriend, or are there problems and doubts under the surface? Objectively speaking, which girl would make the better, more devoted girlfriend?

At any rate, I'll say a prayer for you. :)

Posted

First - can someone fix my spelling in the title. I cringe when I see it. I was tired ok?

Second, I practice a policy of 100% information, at least as much as I can. Both of them know what is up, and they know one another.

Which would be a better girlfriend? Probably the current one, the previous has demonstrated that she is capable of hurting me. And she has had since serious relationships.

I dont know. Deals with God are not kosher, are they? :(

Posted

[quote name='Monoxide' post='1487885' date='Mar 29 2008, 04:16 PM']Second, I practice a policy of 100% information, at least as much as I can. Both of them know what is up, and they know one another.[/quote]

That's good that they both know what's going on. What do they think of each other?

[quote]Which would be a better girlfriend? Probably the current one, the previous has demonstrated that she is capable of hurting me. And she has had since serious relationships.[/quote]

At this point, all you can do is pray that you make the right decision.

Posted

Well they are less friendly than they were once.

Would it be wrong to go based on 'purity' quantitatively?

Posted

I still think you should take a short relationship break before you make your decision, but that's just me.

Posted

I think that is actually unreasonable in this case. Since cirumstance has us all separated, I have all the time in the world to think.

Posted

[quote name='Monoxide' post='1487894' date='Mar 29 2008, 04:24 PM']Would it be wrong to go based on 'purity' quantitatively?[/quote]

Well, from a Catholic perspective, you'd want to go with the girl who respects your decision to stay pure. What both girls did in the past isn't really relavant, per se, since God is forgiving (and since the past is the past), but some people would rather be with someone who has less "experience," so I suppose it's a matter of personal preference.

Posted

I was just horrified by a post on here about the husband and wife spending the wedding night coming to terms with one another, and all the other others. If you know what i mean. Essentially I feel like I steal from future husband whomever it may be by even thinking about either of them.

Posted

[quote name='Monoxide' post='1487894' date='Mar 29 2008, 03:24 PM']Would it be wrong to go based on 'purity' quantitatively?[/quote]

Meaning one is a virgin and the other isn't? If that were the case, I think it would be wrong to reject the non-virgin if you yourself are not a virgin and leave the virgin for a fellow virgin. If you yourself are a virgin, however, I see no problem using that as a standard (personally, I encourage it).

But the above aside, ask yourself this:

1) Why is your x-gf "bothering" you? Would you consider it "harassment"?
2) If you have feelings for the x-gf, what are they and why? What was the reason that the two of youse broke up in the first place? You need to answer these questions before you get more serious (I mean considering marriage) with either of them.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

If the world were going to end tomorrow, which girl would you think to call first , and why.

Posted

cmotherofpirl that is interesting.

I think I would call my mother actually :P

No if the world were going to end I would probably be found in a Church somewhere - like several billion others I suspect. If I could take one to church with me is the question...

Yes. I know which one I would take. The reasons are not helpful though. I would take the one that I am currently involved with because I fear that she depends more upon me in that aspect. Is it my place to be making decisions based on my impression of how it would effect the very souls of others?

Posted

[quote name='Monoxide' post='1487966' date='Mar 29 2008, 04:39 PM']Is it my place to be making decisions based on my impression of how it would effect the very souls of others?[/quote]

I think how our decisions affect the souls of others is something we ALL should take into account (to a certain extent).

Posted

Hmm. I think my problem is knowing that whichever I choose, chances are I will be hurting someones spiritual life. Not to mention my own.

God never said it would be easy!

Posted

Maybe I could, ya know, just [i]borrow[/i] some of your game.

Posted (edited)

You can have one of my loves, if you can find a way to take it. --- and if we could decide which :P

Edited by Monoxide
littleflower+JMJ
Posted

[quote name='Monoxide' post='1488056' date='Mar 29 2008, 06:09 PM']Hmm. I think my problem is knowing that whichever I choose, chances are I will be hurting someones spiritual life. Not to mention my own.

God never said it would be easy![/quote]

Although you might hurt someone, it will make them stronger in the end.

Have you ever asked the question of "which one would I want raising my future children and being the mother to them?" or "which one would I want to be my future wife?"

Not really for the m-word yet? Well, Although you don't mention marriage right now, the purpose of dating (or courting which I like better) is to discern if you and her are meant to be together in marriage and is a good way to help any relationships.

However, in the end, whichever one you pick you really need to cut the connection to whichever you do not choose. And you really need to choose which one...because you can never really grow with the one your with until you do and being emotionally involved with both of them is unfair to the girls, but most importantlly to you :( .

littleflower+JMJ
Posted

[quote name='Monoxide' post='1488344' date='Mar 29 2008, 08:11 PM']You can have one of my loves, if you can find a way to take it. --- and if we could decide which :P[/quote]

sounds like we need one of these!!
:boxer:

[img]http://www.lifelounge.com/resources/IMGDETAIL/thumbwar.jpg[/img]

Posted

You could always revert to the famous last resort of a list of pros and cons for each girl. I know people who have made serious decisions with this method...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...