Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

What if some future pope (clearly Benedict would never), and this is not entirely unfeasible, were to attempt to introduce ordaining married men to the priesthood in the Roman Church? I could very much see some pope deciding to do this to please the modernists whilst feeling he gave enough of a nod in the way of the traditions of the Church by perhaps forbidding priests who left the priesthood to be married from re-entering it and clearly forbidding priests who were already ordained from marrying.

so... my question is to all the married, soon to be married, or planning to one day be married guys out there: would you ask yourself if you might have an additional vocation to the priesthood if a pope did do this? On the one hand, it'd be uber weird... but on the other hand, you'd have to consider all the arch-liberal anti-traditional people that might start lining up to become priests... perhaps God would intend for some good traditional orthodox fellas to come in and balance them out so that it did not prove to be a total disaster for the Church.

personally, I would consider it if it happened at a time when I was married. Perhaps a rule would be imposed, as I think a rule should be imposed if this were to happen, that married priests can only say mass after abstaining from sex from their wife for the one day or two days before doing so such that married priests ought only to regularly say Sunday mass and mass on Holy Days of Obligation, and not weekday masses. If such a rule were not in place and I were to be in a position to consider this, I would seek a situation in which I could follow such a rule, and then I'd want to say the Extraordinary Form of the Roman Rite. It would definitely make sense if they were doing it to combat the vocational crisis to have such a rule, because it's not like the priest:laity percentages are really suffering anywhere as regards weekday masses.

I don't know though... what do you all think? I really don't think it's that unfeasible that it could happen; it certainly won't happen with Benedict but you never know with some of the other cardinals out there what kind of plan might strike their fancy were they to be given papal power... Cardinal William Levada does happen to be at Ratzinger's old post right now :ninja:... though an American Pope is about as likely as an Easter Bunny Pope.

LouisvilleFan
Posted

There's nothing weird about it, although tha' celibate priesthood is somewhat integral tha' culture oven tha' Latin Rite. Still, there is already a provision ordaining married pastors oven other denominations who enter tha' Church, obviously tha' Eastern Rites ordain married men, Andy many married men AARRGGH!!! already ordained as permanent deacons.

As tha' other concerns, we already/2 a lot oven lax/liberal priests, so it doesn't seem like there'd be much oven a difference there. I don't think YOU!!!'d see a mad rush oven liberal activist married men into tha' priesthood. After all, an increasing number oven our bishops Andy seminaries AARRGGH!!! orthodox.

More realistically, tha' pope could grant bishops a limited provision ordaining married men. example, setting minimum limits age Andy tha' time vey've been married. 'dis would avoid tha' conflicts thesis come wit' trying balance fatherly Andy pastoral responsibilities Andy prevent stressing a relatively young marriage. A plan like 'dis would allow tha' Church tap into tha' tha' growing numbers oven retired men (not mention their wives, who would surely be more involved in parish ministry as well). oven course, ordaining even more older men might inadvertedly discourage some young men who could get tha' feeling vey don't "fit" in tha' priesthood.

But at any rate, any such change in discipline would best be done gradually, though I'm in tha' boat thesis tha' Church could find ways oven building up tha' Church through lay ministry. It doesn't do any good gain a few more priests if most laypeople remain clueless about what following Christ is about.

LouisvilleFan
Posted

Hmm... funny... real funny. <_<

Posted

lol apparently tha' fiddler has been set change common dUSt is handsomer than me... dUSt is going all out April geniuses Day :lol:

dUSt is handsomer than me. = w o r d s
tha' = t h e
wit' = w i t h
AARRGGH!!! = a r e
oven = o f

in any event, good points I suppose... ninja ninja ninja ninja ninja what!?!?!?!?!? I meant by it being weird is thesis tha' Latin Church's culture is so intricately drenched in tha' celibate priesthood, it really would be weird those oven us hooty hoo henry thesis kind oven culture.

I donno, I kind oven think thesis it is entirely feasible thesis we might end up wit' a pope hooty hoo would make a drastic change saying thesis seminaries were now free accept married men.

note self: do not start serious conversions on April geniuses Day. :ninja: :cyclops: :lol:

farglefeezlebut
Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1490514' date='Apr 1 2008, 08:28 PM']in any event, good points I suppose... ninja ninja ninja ninja ninja what!?!?!?!?!? I meant by it being weird is thesis tha' Latin Church's culture is so intricately drenched in tha' celibate priesthood, it really would be weird those oven us hooty hoo henry thesis kind oven culture.

I donno, I kind oven think thesis it is entirely feasible thesis we might end up wit' a pope hooty hoo would make a drastic change saying thesis seminaries were now free accept married men.[/quote]


You REALLY picked the wrong day to post this topic.

LouisvilleFan
Posted

Or rather, I picked the wrong day to reply :detective:

Posted

I knew a married priest in Tulsa years ago. He'd been a protestant minister. I can't remember which denomination now. They had him doing chaplain work. I don't think it would ruin the church.

Archaeology cat
Posted

I don't think it would ruin the Church, but I'd rather keep celibate priests, personally. Maybe it's just because, in my years as a Protestant, I can't remember really seeing ministers who were able to devote the necessary time to both their ministry and their family. One or the other suffered. And priests are so busy, I don't see how they'd have time to have a family. So that's my $0.02.

goldenchild17
Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1490427' date='Apr 1 2008, 12:14 PM']though an American Pope is about as likely as an Easter Bunny Pope.[/quote]
[img]http://media.southparkstudios.com/media/ss/1105ss_bunnypope_thumbnail.jpg[/img]

Galloglasses
Posted

Well our Byzantine Brethern can get married. Lets looks at the Orthodox Church Priests can get married and have families, however, if they seek Bishop-hood, they are required to remain celibete to devote their entire lives to God and His Church, which I think is a delightful compromise. It won't ruin the Church but Liberals inside and outside the Church would go crasy, those on the inside would want further change, those on the outside would criticise the Church of hypocracy going back and citing 'Papal Infallibility' and so on and so forth.

It won't ruin the Church but these days is the WRONG time for it to be allowed, especially as we're currently coming away from the sex scandal shadow, (the secular world values not frogiveness)

I'm not sure how I personally feel about it, but it's Il Papa's call.

Posted

I'm really glad it isn't my call.

Archaeology cat
Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1491345' date='Apr 2 2008, 09:56 PM']I'm really glad it isn't my call.[/quote]
Yeah, glad it isn't my decision, either.

Posted

Here is a question:
Would the pope be infalliable then if he allows married men to become priests? And from there what is stopping him from pleasing the modernists to the point of allowing women priests? Then in response to the "vocation" crisis, what about allowing married women to become nuns?

These sound very wierd to me. I think because my view on these vocations are a way of life rather than a job. When you are a priest you are married to God and to the Church. When you are a married man/woman you are married to your spouse and family. When you are a nun you are married to God.

The rule that you made concerning abstaining from sex before saying Mass. This just doesn't seem to make sense in my mind. To me, it seems that a person cannot serve two vocations well. As a married man, sex is their "job" so to say. Their vocation to marriage includes sex to procreate. However, a priest is to Mass as part of his vocation. Plus, how does a man spend enough time with his family while caring for his parish family, ie hearing confessions, saying Mass, anointing the sick?

Posted

You don't quite understand how infallibility works. It is only used on very narrow grounds. It doesn't include everything that comes out of the pope's mouth. Priest celibacy is not doctrine, it is a discipline. The faithful are even allowed to disagree with items of discipline, but we are encouraged to faithfully examine our conscience about the issue.

Posted

priestly celibacy isn't infallible, it's a discipline. it is possible to allow married men to be ordained, but not to allow ordained men to be married and remain clerics (which is contrary to Canon 3 of the First Ecumenical Council of Nicaea)

an all male priesthood is an infallible teaching and no pope can change it.

theoretically, I personally do not believe a Pope could allow ordained men to marry and remain clerics... this is unprecedented in the Church and I see it as contrary to a standing discipline, if not a teaching, of the First Council of the Church.

my thoughts on celibacy before offering mass are inspired by the East, who do not have weekday Divine Liturgies the way we have Daily Mass. periodic abstinence does not mean one is incapable of being in their vocation; people who use NFP practice periodic abstinence; I could say if I wished that they clearly couldn't follow their married vocation because serious reasons prevented them from having children, but I don't (for all cases at least). Periodic abstinence for a priest to purify and distinguish himself prior to saying Mass would make perfect sense.

TNSeminarian
Posted

I hesitate to answer because this can be a loaded question, but at the same time as an aspirant to the priesthood I think that its appropriate to answer.

I don't think that priests should be married within the Roman tradition. There can be some carryover from different traditions, but I think on the whole it is inappropriate to bring something from say, the Byzantine tradition into our own. Now I know that priests at one time were married within the Roman tradition, but it has been a significant amount of time since that has been common practice. Bearing that in mind I don't think that such a change should be taken lightly (I'm not trying to insinuate that it has been taken lightly in previous comments).

My main disagreement with it though is the significance of the nuptual metaphor within the priesthood and the actual nuptuals for the married man. A priest is an alter Christus and acts in persona Christi. As such within that context a priest is, like Christ, bound to the Church in a manner which is likened to marriage. Without trying to sound critical of traditions wherein priests are allowed to be married, I would like to posit that it is as nearly necessary as it can be that a priest be unmarried. Christ Himself was not married and dedicated Himself completely to His bride, Holy Mother Church. A priest as an alter Christus is called to imitate Christ as perfectly as he is able, by the grace of God and through the aid of Our Lady and all of the saints. By the priest taking on Christ in the unique way he does in ordination, it seems to me that it is necessary for the priest to dedicate himself to Holy Mother Church in the radical and complete way that Christ did, in order to more perfectly imitate Him.

It was already mentioned that a married priest would be split between too many different places, and I agree wholeheartedly. A married man's primary goal to fulfill his vocation is the procreation of children and their education and upbringing in the Faith and the mutual growth with his wife toward sanctity. A priest has his own children in his flock and it does not seem to me that it would be terribly easy for a priest to fulfill both vocations. If he neglects his flock to bring up his children he sins and if he neglects his children for the sake of his flock then he sins in not giving them what they need. Furthermore his relationship with his wife would likely suffer because he could not give her his all as a non-priest could. Now I'm not saying that it isn't possible for it to work, but it would be incredibly impractical for a priest to be married.

I know that this hasn't been terribly precise, or theologically profound, but as a seminarian this is my opinion (N.B. I will not, and do not claim that this is Doctrine).

LouisvilleFan
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Galloglasses' post='1491297' date='Apr 2 2008, 04:36 PM']Well our Byzantine Brethern can get married. Lets looks at the Orthodox Church Priests can get married and have families, however, if they seek Bishop-hood, they are required to remain celibete to devote their entire lives to God and His Church, which I think is a delightful compromise.[/quote]

That's a common error, but ordained men cannot get married in any Catholic or Orthodox Church (unless the bishop laicizes them). Eastern Christians follow basically the same discipline with priests that we have with permanent deacons: married men are permitted to ordination, but they promise not to marry again.

Also, I think celibate priests in the East are pretty rare, so the normal practice is to choose bishops/metropolitans from the monasteries.

Plus, we might do well to consider that the East has their own set of problems resulting from a mostly married priesthood and metropolitans who lived much of their lives in monasteries.

Edited by LouisvilleFan
LouisvilleFan
Posted (edited)

[quote name='picchick' post='1491550' date='Apr 2 2008, 10:11 PM']Plus, how does a man spend enough time with his family while caring for his parish family, ie hearing confessions, saying Mass, anointing the sick?[/quote]

Unfortunately, the same way a man pastors four parishes with a 40 minute drive between each: not as well as he'd like.

But we work with limited resources, so we have to choose priorities. Is the discipline of a mostly celibate priesthood more important to the Church at the expense of having more priests, or does the Church choose to have more priests available (along with their wives) for the laypeople at the expense of losing a powerful and beautiful sign of the nuptial meaning of priesthood?

We can't have it both ways, but we show what we l0ve by the things we sacrifice for it.

Edited by LouisvilleFan
Posted

Is it all or nothing? Can a pope open x number of spots for married men and then close the door again?

LouisvilleFan
Posted

Possibly, which is more or less what I described earlier: allowing married men of a minimum age to be ordained in order to widen the available pool without drastically changing the Latin Rite's culture or introducing the difficulties associated with pastors juggling parish and family responsibilities.

But that, again, has its down sides. It's only a temporary solution, as most of these older men wouldn't be able to serve the Church for more than 15 or 20 years, if they're lucky. Plus, after the Baby Boomer generation, that pool of older men will disappear.

The only long term solution is to promote a culture of faithfulness to Christ and the Church, with young Catholics passionately searching for their vocation and following God in whatever direction he leads. Let God take the lead and everything will be just fine.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...