SJP Posted April 5, 2008 Posted April 5, 2008 Is anyone familiar with the work of Catehrine Pickstock or John Milbank? On the surface, they seem to be doing some fantastic work, especially in the area of liturgy and philosophy.
Laudate_Dominum Posted April 6, 2008 Posted April 6, 2008 I know of John Milbank and his bag but I have not read any of his works. I have read some of Catherine Pickstock's book "After Writing" and I loved it (until I purchase my own copy I'm not likely to finish it). I actually have most if not all of her published books on my amazon wish list and I think she rocks. I can identify very much with what she is apparently trying to do and I hope to get more acquainted with the pertinent literature but at this point I'm a n00b. Why do you ask exactly?
SJP Posted April 8, 2008 Author Posted April 8, 2008 I have been fascinated by their work for some time now. At first, I was somewhat sceptical due to the fact that they are both Anglican. However, upon further investigation their theories seem to be thoroughly Catholic (at least from a philosophical standpoint.) But, I'm too new to their work to come to any final judgments about the "orthodoxy" of Radical Orthodoxy. The following site has an audio link which features an interview with both Milbank and Pickstock. It's at the top of the page. Check it out; plenty of good discussion should follow! [url="http://web.ncf.ca/aj624/radicalorthodoxy.html"]http://web.ncf.ca/aj624/radicalorthodoxy.html[/url]
Laudate_Dominum Posted April 8, 2008 Posted April 8, 2008 [quote name='SJP' post='1494596' date='Apr 7 2008, 09:12 PM']At first, I was somewhat sceptical due to the fact that they are both Anglican. However, upon further investigation their theories seem to be thoroughly Catholic (at least from a philosophical standpoint.) But, I'm too new to their work to come to any final judgments about the "orthodoxy" of Radical Orthodoxy.[/quote] Same here but I'm still skeptical. Well, critical might be a better word. From what I've read of Pickstock there are some sweet ideas that are very much in line with Catholicism but at the same time she is quite clear that she does not accept Roman Catholicism. For one thing Pickstock argues in favor of women priests and anything saturated with post-modern jargon causes me to be a bit skeptical. haha.
SJP Posted April 8, 2008 Author Posted April 8, 2008 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1494862' date='Apr 8 2008, 12:40 PM']Same here but I'm still skeptical. Well, critical might be a better word. From what I've read of Pickstock there are some sweet ideas that are very much in line with Catholicism but at the same time she is quite clear that she does not accept Roman Catholicism. For one thing Pickstock argues in favor of women priests and anything saturated with post-modern jargon causes me to be a bit skeptical. haha.[/quote] Agreed!
SJP Posted April 8, 2008 Author Posted April 8, 2008 (edited) Despite some of the unfortunate positions that both Pickstock and Milbank hold, they still have some fantastic insights in a variety of areas. The first time I was exposed to Pickstock was through an essay written by Adam Deville (TOWARD A CULTURE OF LEISURE, LITURGY AND LIFE: Prolegomena to Reconstructing the Eucharistic Foundations of Western Technocratic Civilization.) A fantastic work in its own right [url="http://www.execulink.com/~dtribe/blog/Deville%20Toward%20a%20Culture%20of%20Leisure%20Liturgy%20and%20Life.pdf"]Link[/url] The essay and Pickstock's contribution to it have done more for my understanding of the "redemption of time" and its link to liturgy than any other work that I've read. Here is an excerpt from Deville's essay: This salvific in-breaking of Christ restores to us the gift of time and strips away the abstraction which denies our relation to natural cycles and the world, in the process making us feel impotent to act meaningfully in our seemingly technologically determined world: liturgical time is tilted away from any delimited or inscribed attainment, and, in its prefatory casting, implicitly offers a critique of the violence of an immanentist construal of time which claims to obtain an 'arrival,' and perforce closes off the potential of human action. For although the time of liturgy is forever 'before,' this does not humiliate the possibility of human action, but rather exposes the dishonesty of any claim that ethical action consists in discrete accomplishments, or that action stands on its own, outside an anticipation of its ultimate eschatological consummation. The liturgy reminds us that all our actions, even those of the past, do not exceed the status of that which is going-to-happen, although this establishes rather than erases the possibility of action.70 In contrast with the traditional Mass, Pickstock says that contemporary liturgies are incapable of accomplishing this because they have incorporated and "ironically perpetuated certain features of the truly secularlizing modern epoch. For example, they imposed such anachronistic structural concepts as 'argument,' 'linear order,' 'segmentation,' 'discrete stages,' and the notion of 'new information' outside 'linguistic redundancy' or repetition." Edited April 8, 2008 by SJP
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now