Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

I recently found out that one of my friends has been cutting herself. I don't know what to do. She told me tonight, but I am at an utter lost as to what to do. What should I do?


Thank you and God Bless
Also, please keep her in your prayers.

missionseeker
Posted

[url="http://www.twloha.com"]http://www.twloha.com[/url]

cathoholic_anonymous
Posted

I have numerous friends with mental health difficulties, some of whom are seriously ill. Two of these people self-harm. Another two have required long-term hospitalisation in a psychiatric ward.

You can't be their saviour. At the beginning, especially if somebody is a close friend, it's tempting to believe that recovery is a short walking distance away and with your support and encouragement the friend will reach it in no time. I fell into this trap. Then you start to get despondent and worry that you're being a bad friend when you realise that this isn't going to happen.

Your friend needs to see a doctor and arrange to get proper help from a therapist experienced in self-injury or other qualified professional. She may be reluctant to go at first, as cutting is probably her way of coping with other difficulties in her life. Encourage her to take this step. Offer to go with her to the doctor if you like. But don't let your conversation with her become dominated by her problem - go on being the same friend you've always been. This is what she needs from you, your friendship, and this is all you are qualified to give her.

She and you are in my prayers. :console:

Posted

Self hurting is a lot more common than most people realize, even among males, although it is still primarily a female thing. It is about control. For people who don't feel like they control their lives, they will do this as something they can control. There are also people who do it because they are emotionally numb, and feeling the pain means they are feeling something. It is not a minor thing, and can't be dealt with casually. It takes serious therapy to get at the underlying issues. The fact that they have reached out to you is important. Encourage them to get to get professional help, and be willing to listen. That's about all you can do. That and just be a friend.

Posted

thank you guys soo much.


She said that after seeing the looks on mine and her boyfriends face, she would never do it again. I know how hard the road can be to recovery, but I have faith in her. She is always going to be my friend and I'm not going to let this get in the way. Since I think she is going to stop, I don't think I'm going to tell an adult. If it continues, I am going to. Thank you so much for you prayers, but also, please keep on praying.

cathoholic_anonymous
Posted (edited)

[quote name='vbbabespx' post='1493392' date='Apr 6 2008, 06:59 AM']thank you guys soo much.
She said that after seeing the looks on mine and her boyfriends face, she would never do it again. I know how hard the road can be to recovery, but I have faith in her. She is always going to be my friend and I'm not going to let this get in the way. Since I think she is going to stop, I don't think I'm going to tell an adult. If it continues, I am going to. Thank you so much for you prayers, but also, please keep on praying.[/quote]

Vba, you still need to tell someone. You also shouldn't let her make promises like that. A lot of self-harmers feel very guilty when they realise that those they care about the most have been hurt by their illness, and they frantically resolve to stop cutting. The trouble is that if they are ill enough to be self-harming they usually [i]can't[/i] stop without good medical help. Cutting isn't really the issue here - it's just an outward manifestation of an inside problem. And if your friend does end up cutting again (I don't like to say it, but she probably will - I have a lot of sorry experience in this area) she may be too afraid to tell you and her boyfriend due to shame at breaking her promise and fear of upsetting you. She will end up in a cycle of guilt, guilt, guilt. And guilt fuels sef-harm.

The therapists of one of my friends advised her never to promise to stop cutting for the sake of other people, as she would just get worse if the day came when she couldn't keep her promise. Furthermore, she needed to learn to stop self-injury for her own sake, not just because it upset those around her. This meant real engagement with the past events and problems that had led her to start self-harming. That can rarely happen without the help of appropriately trained professionals. Please help to get your friend to the doctor. Gently pressing her to get help doesn't mean that you don't trust her or have faith in her promises - it means that you recognise the severity of mental illness and what it can do to a person.

Edited by Cathoholic Anonymous
cathoholic_anonymous
Posted (edited)

On a separate note, could the moderators think about taking the April Fool's replacement thing off Phatmass? It gets annoying and frustrating when you're trying to reply to a serious thread.

Edited by Cathoholic Anonymous
melporcristo
Posted (edited)

JMJ

Know she's in my prayers.
I will offer up Mass for her this week.

I struggled with this for a few years in high school. And I'm going to tell you if it wasn't for my friends telling my parents and if it wasn't for the Eucharist, I wouldn't be here today.
So she needs to tell her parents or guardian and you can't stop praying for her. Offer up sacrifice for her.

In Christ,
Melissa

Edited by melporcristo
Posted

If you try to protect herby not telling anyone, she will only get hurt more. Cutting is an addiction, like any drug addiction, she will probably need help to stop.

icelandic_iceskater
Posted

Coming from personal experience here- be careful not to give her too much sympathy cause then its becomes easy to self injure for the attention. (it got to the point where I was) Use empathy instead. And a huge ditto to what C. A. said "Cutting isn't really the issue here - it's just an outward manifestation of an inside problem." Overall just be there for her and show her how much you care about her. Prayers for you and your friend.

Posted

Your friend needs help and needs to see someone as soon as possible. It is not easy to just stop doing it, she may take to hiding what she is doing. Empathy is the thing, right on that. Do not be fussing over her, she needs to face up to her issues and get the help she desperatly needs. Insist she call a counselor tommorrow, there are many places she can go to. This is not a thing you keep hidden because you think you are helping her that way.
Prayers!!
Alicemary

Posted

I agree with everything Catholic Anonymous has said.

I'm sorry about your friend, it must be very worrying for you. But please don't assume that she'll be able to stop just like that - perhaps some people do but I've never met any of them! And even if you do, it doesn't solve the problem, so it's likely to just end up coming out in another way. If she knows that you don't expect her to do it again, and that you think everything is fine, she may just not talk to you about it. Encourage her to talk to someone, to see a counsellor, something. If you have to, tell someone yourself.

Pray for her / with her. Be there for her, but do set limits, and do continue just being a friend, that's really all you can do.

Take care, I hope things go okay and your friend can begin to move forwards. I also used to self-harm, so if you ever have any questions, please feel free to ask.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

A cutter trying to stop on their own is the same as an alcoholic not taking that next drink. Doesn't happen. Something major is wrong or the cutting would not have started on the first place. She needs professional help immediately. You can be her friend but not her therapist. Tell.

farglefeezlebut
Posted

I have to agree with what CA said. I am in a similar situation myself. It's not something you can just stop.

Posted

Thank you everyone for responding.



She has only cut herself 3 times. And I made sure to tell her that she can't stop because she feels guilty about hurting me. She feels more guilty because she doesn't have an explanation as to why she is doing it. As weird as this may sound, I think the devil is really pushing her to keep on self-harming herself because it began during Holy Week, actually, two days before our Lord's crucifixtion. She has this mindset that because she already had mortal sinned, then by doing this, it wouldn't make matters worse. Everyone is right saying that I need to tell someone and I know I should. But she is my best friend. I know that things will get better if I tell someone and that the underlying problem would get resolved, but there really is no underlying problem other than stress due to homework.











ahhhhhhh!














I need to tell someone....








please pray for me so that i get the strength to tell someone and pray for her that she can come to the realization that what she is doing is harming herself, a daughter of God created in the image of Him.


THank you and God Bless

Posted

What she may be telling you and what she may be doing could be two different things. You have no objectivity, you are a friend, and right now you are an enabler. Sometimes you must admit there are things that you alone cannot handle. This girl needs help now and you have an obligation to get help for her, or at least. If she will not, then you will have to deal with that when it comes up. And trust me, people generally do not tell even real close friends the 'real' reason. We all carry heartaches that we rarely share. It is not you job to analyze her, leave that for the professionals. One does not do this kind of thing on a whim, it is well planned out or at least thought out for awhile. Sometimes being a friend means doing hard things for your friend, you need to open your mouth.

Posted

You have to tell, even if it means a loss of friendship or closeness at this time. You say there is no underlying reason but of course there is. You just don't know what it is. It may be something she has never even been able to voice or acknowledge even to herself. Please get her some help.
I shall pray for you both.

cathoholic_anonymous
Posted

I second what Alicemary has said.

[quote name='vbbabespx' post='1494697' date='Apr 8 2008, 05:47 AM']She feels more guilty because she doesn't have an explanation as to why she is doing it.

I know that things will get better if I tell someone and that the underlying problem would get resolved, but there really is no underlying problem other than stress due to homework.[/quote]

You are probably too worried and upset for your friend to see the inconsistency here. Either she has no explanation for what she's doing (or, as is more likely, she just can't articulate the explanation) or she is cutting because of homework stress. Most people who self-harm have a mess of frightening thoughts and emotions that they don't feel able to express in any other way than through hurting themselves. The physical pain gives them some temporary relief, a focal point. While it is possible for something relatively simple like homework stress to trigger self-harm, more serious reasons will have been building up for quite some time - usually unseen by everyone.

Therapy will give your friend a chance to explore what led her to begin cutting. She may not even know the answer herself just yet, so don't ask her if she's keeping anything back from you and expect her to have a sensible reply. People who self-injure know that something hurts, but without appropriate help they will rarely be able to tell you what it is - any more than somebody suffering from an undiagnosed tumour would be able to tell you what is the matter with them beyond, "I'm in a lot of pain."

Also, be wary of ascribing your friend's problems to Satan. Would you do the same thing if she had started showing symptoms of a physical illness during Holy Week? There is still an unfortunate tendency to assume that mental health problems are some murky diabolical preserve. They're not. They are medical conditions like any other, and they need medical treatment.

[quote]ahhhhhhh!
I need to tell someone....
please pray for me so that i get the strength to tell someone and pray for her that she can come to the realization that what she is doing is harming herself, a daughter of God created in the image of Him.
THank you and God Bless[/quote]

She already knows that she is harming herself. She may already know that she is a daughter of God. And that knowledge probably just makes her feel ten times worse. Farglefeezlebut, the girl who posted above, is a very great friend of mine who is currently struggling with self-injury and related difficulties. FFB knows that God loves her and this knowledge is frightening. It's frightening because she feels wretched and ill and sometimes she just wishes that she could go to sleep and never wake up. For the sake of her earthly parents, who love her, she'd like to be better. For the sake of her heavenly Father, who loves her more, she'd like to be better. The fact that this can't happen makes her feel guilty and ungrateful. That is not what you want your friend to feel right now.

I will pray that you find the courage to talk to someone about your friend. God bless. :sign:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...