Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Generation Gap Shapes American Catholics


Recommended Posts

Posted

[url="http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/23970574/"]Generation gap shapes American Catholics[/url]
[b][i]Pope Benedict XVI will see divisions during U.S. visit[/b][/i]

[quote]NEW YORK - In his visit this month to the United States, Pope Benedict XVI will find an American flock wrestling with what it means be Roman Catholic.

The younger generation considers religion important, but doesn't equate faith with going to church. Many lay people want a greater say in how their parishes operate, yet today's seminarians hope to restore the traditional role and authority of priests.

Catholic colleges and universities are trying to balance their religious identity with free expression, catching grief from liberals and conservatives in the process.

Immigrants are filling the pews, while whites are leaving them. Nearly one-third of U.S. adult Catholics are now Hispanic, and they worry about being considered a separate, ethnic church.[/quote]

Posted

So much for the "new spring time" of the Church.

Posted

1. If Hispanics worry about being considered a separate ethnic Church then they need to abolish Spanish Masses in the United States.

2. Hispanics aren't really "filling the pews" anymore than whites. All the Catholic Hispanics I've met haven't been any more devoted to their faith than the whites. They have the same chance of being the nominal Catholics we've come to expect from whites.

3. I thought everyone knew that JP2's "new springtime" was really just a reference to global warming. ;)

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='mortify' post='1493004' date='Apr 5 2008, 03:46 PM']So much for the "new spring time" of the Church.[/quote]
"The blood of martyrs is the seed of Christians."

Naturally, for a new springtime to occur, there must be a new sowing of seed, and I don't think the current culture hostile to Christianity is opposed to making martyrs of those who are devout, at least white martyrs.

JPII predicted a new springtime. First the seed must be sown, then grace will have to rain from the heavens, until the Sun of Justice rises in our hearts. Springtime will come, but there is as yet much work to do.

God bless,

Micah

fides quarens intellectum
Posted

This is a call to action, not despair or complaining. The New Springtime won't happen unless people are willing to give their lives to it.

Posted

[quote name='Raphael' post='1493178' date='Apr 5 2008, 07:18 PM']"The blood of martyrs is the seed of Christians."[/quote]

All too right. Of course, we might not be far off from that, in unexpected places and times.

Vincent Vega
Posted

[quote]Many lay people want a greater say in how their parishes operate,[/quote]
Oh. See, where I come from, we call these 'Presbyterians'.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

They write as though, opposed to youth, the older generation cared about going to church -- which generation are they talking about? Our grandparents?

The older generation, i.e. baby boomers, aren't exactly known for their traditional churchgoing ways, either.

farglefeezlebut
Posted

[quote name='Justin86' post='1493015' date='Apr 5 2008, 10:00 PM']Hispanics aren't really "filling the pews" anymore than whites. All the Catholic Hispanics I've met haven't been any more devoted to their faith than the whites. They have the same chance of being the nominal Catholics we've come to expect from whites.[/quote]


I'm neither agreeing nor disagreeing. However, there are millions of Hispanic Catholics in America. You can't make a definitive statement based just on the one's you've hapenned to meet, especially as I suspect most of them will be concentrated in the area you live and your home may not be a representative sample.

Posted

[quote name='Ash Wednesday' post='1494348' date='Apr 7 2008, 06:29 PM']They write as though, opposed to youth, the older generation cared about going to church -- which generation are they talking about? Our grandparents?

The older generation, i.e. baby boomers, aren't exactly known for their traditional churchgoing ways, either.[/quote]

Bingo.

Which I found amusing about this article, out of the many inaccuracies.

fides quarens intellectum
Posted

[quote name='USAirwaysIHS' post='1494310' date='Apr 7 2008, 03:26 PM']Oh. See, where I come from, we call these 'Presbyterians'.[/quote]

:lol_roll:

We have a new pastor, and his whole thing is, "We are not congregationalists - we are Catholic!"

Ash Wednesday
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Paladin D' post='1494356' date='Apr 7 2008, 05:37 PM']Bingo.

Which I found amusing about this article, out of the many inaccuracies.[/quote]

Also -- the Catholicism of many hispanics is cultural Catholicism, so it's hard to compare with average American Catholicism as well, as far as the motivation behind devotion or church attendance. So to me it seems hard to guage if one group is more "devout" than the other, when the ways average Americans and immigrants approach the faith may be different. To me it would seem that there are more hispanics filling the pews in proportion to average Americans simply because U.S. the population of hispanics is rising.

Edited by Ash Wednesday
Posted

[quote name='Ash Wednesday' post='1494419' date='Apr 7 2008, 07:46 PM']Also -- the Catholicism of many hispanics is cultural Catholicism, so it's hard to compare with average American Catholicism as well, as far as the motivation behind devotion or church attendance. So to me it seems hard to guage if one group is more "devout" than the other, when the ways average Americans and immigrants approach the faith may be different. To me it would seem that there are more hispanics filling the pews in proportion to average Americans simply because U.S. the population of hispanics is rising.[/quote]

'Cultural Catholicism' also was prevelant during the wave of European immigrants that came to the States in 19th and early 20th centuries. Hispanics are just the new wave of immigrants of our time.

Posted

All depends on what you mean by a "new springtime" I can say this much: I grew up in the early 80's with liberal nuns and whacked baby-boomers at the helm. Youth groups were about pizza and soda. You could not find a monstrance with a metal detector, let alone a monstrance with the Blessed Sacrament therein. Any good Catholic books were to be found in junky used bookstores. Much HAS changed for the better. If I had not had JPII, I may not have still been a Catholic now. I see many signs for hope, signs that the media would not be attentive to, like heroic sanctity. We need saints, period.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

I agree with you, Vin. Recent younger ordained priests have shown a tendency to be more orthodox than the ones ordained during the boomer generation. Not to mention the Motu Proprio and emerging interest in reviving the latin mass.

Prayers for our Church.

Posted

[quote name='Ash Wednesday' post='1494348' date='Apr 7 2008, 04:29 PM']They write as though, opposed to youth, the older generation cared about going to church -- which generation are they talking about? Our grandparents?

The older generation, i.e. baby boomers, aren't exactly known for their traditional churchgoing ways, either.[/quote]
It was the baby-boomers who largely began defecting from or dissenting with the Church in large numbers. Presented with the wishy-washy watered-down religion of their elders, of course many of the younger generations were given no solid foundation, and now are lost, and effectively or actually stop being Catholic.
While this is true in much of the Church, I think there is a growing Catholic revival in areas in which orthodoxy is taught and practiced.

In places where "liberal Catholicism" dominates, things will only get worse.
If my only experience of Catholicism were wishy-washy "liberal Catholicism," it's doubtful I'd currently have anything at all to do with the Church.

I think the media likes to present "liberal Catholicism" as the wave of the future - as if the direction of the Church will be decided by those who don't bother to go to church.
And unfortunately, I also think too many "conservative Catholics" prefer wallowing in gloom and despair to evangelizing.

[quote name='Ash Wednesday' post='1494419' date='Apr 7 2008, 05:46 PM']Also -- the Catholicism of many hispanics is cultural Catholicism, so it's hard to compare with average American Catholicism as well, as far as the motivation behind devotion or church attendance. So to me it seems hard to guage if one group is more "devout" than the other, when the ways average Americans and immigrants approach the faith may be different. To me it would seem that there are more hispanics filling the pews in proportion to average Americans simply because U.S. the population of hispanics is rising.[/quote]
The number of hispanics in my town has risen sharply over the past couple decades, yet hardly any of them can be seen in our Catholic church.
I'm afraid most hispanics are simply "culturally Catholic" but don't actually practice the faith for the most part. Of course many Americans are "cultural Catholics" too.

Posted

I got this in my Ecclesiology class today from Joseph Eagan's book, "Restoration and Renewal: The Church in the Third Millennium." The church will be radically demographically different than the church in the recent past. He lists several key things. "1. no longer a ‘Western’ Church but a Church of the poor in impoverished
countries – “Of more than one billion Catholics by the year 2000, roughly twothirds
will live in Africa, Asia, Central and South America. Since the majority in
these continents are poor, the Catholic Church will increasingly be a church of
the poor.”
2. free church – “Catholics will more and more make their own free conscience
decisions to remain in the church or to leave it.”
3. spiritual church – “…that satisfies the deeply felt religious needs of its
members, that nourishes them with the Word of God in the Bible, as well as
with sacraments, that provides faith communities in which to find and
experience God.”
4. ecumenical church – “…since the Catholic Church’s relation to other
Christian churches will change as faith and theological agreement become
ever more evident and the consequent scandal of separation in an
increasingly secular world becomes more intolerable.”
5. church of the laity – “…the third millennium will be the age of the laity and of
lay ministry, profoundly altering present church structures and relationships.”
6. church of young people – “Finally, it will be a church of young people, at
least in the Third World, where 42% of the population is under 15 years of
age!”

That 42% under the age of 15 is staggering. I think the church can go for renewal or schism.

Posted

[quote name='Justin86' post='1493015' date='Apr 5 2008, 05:00 PM']1. If Hispanics worry about being considered a separate ethnic Church then they need to abolish Spanish Masses in the United States.[/quote]

True. I think if Hispanics are concerned with being respected in America, they need to start speaking English and stop waving the flags of other countries.

catholicinsd
Posted

[quote name='Justin86' post='1493015' date='Apr 5 2008, 04:00 PM']1. If Hispanics worry about being considered a separate ethnic Church then they need to abolish Spanish Masses in the United States.[/quote]

I have agree with Justin on this. Foreigners will never learn English if we keep catering to this handicap.

Posted

My Godparents were from Mexico, but they only spoke English in their homes, and attended English only masses. Of course there were no Spanish masses then. All 5 of their kids got advanced college degrees. If they had only spoke Spanish at home, I'm not sure the same would have happened. Immigration isn't easy. It wasn't easy for me, and they at least mostly speak English up here, but most of the time, people will tell you that they immigrated to give their kids a chance at a better life. If that is so, then you have to give them the best chance to succeed, learn English. They in no way lost their cultural heritage by doing so.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...