loudogswife Posted April 6, 2008 Posted April 6, 2008 I was going online for some catholic marrage advice and I came across thiswebsite.I found it horribly disturbing and mad me very angry. I wanted to email back but I did'nt know what was true and what was not. Check out the link and you will see what i'm talking about. Any comments? [url="http://www.liberalslikechrist.org/Catholic/Churchvsex.html"]http://www.liberalslikechrist.org/Catholic/Churchvsex.html[/url]
thessalonian Posted April 7, 2008 Posted April 7, 2008 Most of it is true but for the wrong reasons. It is because the CC sees the great dignity of the human person that it finds that contraception and divorce and abortion etc. etc. are wrong. It is because it recognizes the different, but equally great roles of men and women that it has a male preisthood. The great dignity given to the Mother of Our Lord (and our Mother) is enough evidence to refute some gender bias against women (not to say that there are not those in the Church who have such biases but not in accord with Church teaching). if you want to understand how the Church views the great dignity of the human person I suggest you go to www.christopherwest.com. He does an excellent job of explaing JP II's Theology of the Body which tells us that we are made in the image and likeness of God and why sexual deviance that the Church has every right to speak out against is so damaging to the human person.
thessalonian Posted April 7, 2008 Posted April 7, 2008 1) No Mary did not HAVE to. It is simply stated by the Church that it was fitting for her to. The evidence of the Ark of the covenant and it's parrellel with Mary gives ample reason to believe it. The Ark was made of the purest of materials and no man could touch it or they would die. 2) Again she didn't HAVE to but knowing the reverence Jews had for God such that they would not even touch the Ark, imagine Joseph knowing that Mary had had GOD in her womb! 3) One only need read JP II's theology of the body and cuddle with my weeble and wub and responsibility to realize he was hardly a prude about sexuality and to understand that this claim is nonsense. Again Jesus did not have brothers and sisters because Mary was the spouse of the Holy Spirit. Joseph would have been in great awe of that. 4) Yes if one knowingly and willingly engages in such behavior it is gravely sinful. There are concerns over habbit however that may lessen the effects. The fact is however that M is against the dignity of the human person and degrades the individuals ability to enter in to relationships. 5) Birth control is a sin against God's call to accept the blessings of children. It says "I know better than you God how many blessings in the form of children I should have". 6) Killing is killing. What they forget in all these accusations is the great mercy the CC bestows in the sacrament of reconcilliation. 7) Remarriage is a mortal sin. One who "divorces" is still married and so for them to remarry is adultery. This person wants to say thers is no sin. 9) Nope. Not all Stem Cell research is wrong. Just that that destroys embryo's which are human persons. 10) The Church recognizes the role of men and women and that Jesus chose twelve men as apostles even though he greatly streched the envelope of equality in his day. 11) Nonsense. Priests can be married in the Eastern Rites of the Roman Catholic Church. FACT. There are even married priests in the latin rite who came in from different denominations. The idea about celibacy however is so that they can fully serve God and not be divided between God and family. Once again Mr. West has a lesson on this at his website that is highly recommended. Celibacy is good because Marriage is a great good that is given up for God, to fully serve him. 12) Actually it's not marriage as marriage is life giving but yes, homosexual relationships according to scripture are an abomination. 13. Nope. Marriage is considered a SACRAMENT. That in itself refutes this nonsense. Again theology of the body shows what nonsense this statement is.
prose Posted April 7, 2008 Posted April 7, 2008 I don't bother with people and sites like that. People who don't understand the "why" of things often skew the "what". And it is very important to them to justify their own sins.
Lena Posted April 7, 2008 Posted April 7, 2008 so they claim the catholic church is obsessed with "everything sexual," yet they write an entire web page devoted to sex?.....
Galloglasses Posted April 7, 2008 Posted April 7, 2008 [quote name='Lena' post='1494200' date='Apr 7 2008, 12:24 PM']so they claim the catholic church is obsessed with "everything sexual," yet they write an entire web page devoted to sex?..... [/quote] Hit the nail on the head there.
rizz_loves_jesus Posted April 8, 2008 Posted April 8, 2008 I know this is going to sound horrible, but I kind of agree with them when they said that the Church frowns upon sex, even inside marriage. The Church's attitude it that celibacy is "more pure" than marriage, and the Council of Trent declared that celibacy is preferred rather than marriage... this bothers me, and if the site is telling the truth about what past popes said about marital sex, then I don't know what to do.
CatherineM Posted April 8, 2008 Posted April 8, 2008 Does anyone know if this guy is Catholic, or something else. It does seem like he has some sexual/sexuality issues to be so worried about how screwed up we supposedly are about it.
Kitty Posted April 9, 2008 Posted April 9, 2008 [quote name='rizz_loves_jesus' post='1495141' date='Apr 8 2008, 06:29 PM']I know this is going to sound horrible, but I kind of agree with them when they said that the Church frowns upon sex, even inside marriage. The Church's attitude it that celibacy is "more pure" than marriage, and the Council of Trent declared that celibacy is preferred rather than marriage... this bothers me, and if the site is telling the truth about what past popes said about marital sex, then I don't know what to do.[/quote] I'm thinking on a similar level.
Vincent Vega Posted April 9, 2008 Posted April 9, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1495154' date='Apr 8 2008, 05:54 PM']Does anyone know if this guy is Catholic, or something else. It does seem like he has some sexual/sexuality issues to be so worried about how screwed up we supposedly are about it.[/quote] He sounds like an 'ex'-Catholic. It seems to me that people like this are most likely to have been Catholic at one point, but so poorly catechised that they misunderstood and misconstrue the truth so much that they leave the Church. (If I thought those things we true, I'd leave the Church too!) The worst part is, if they have been taught this (mis)information, they won't believe anyone who tries to correct them most time. I don't care if you don't agree with the teachings of the Holy Mother Church (well, everyone should, other debate, not how I mean it), but if you're going to disagree, at least disagree with the real teachings. All we can do about this is pray for the understanding of this clown.
MissScripture Posted April 9, 2008 Posted April 9, 2008 If Catholics think sex is bad how do you explain the massive families?
JoeyP Posted April 9, 2008 Posted April 9, 2008 There is so much anti-Catholic croutons out there it is amazing. And most of it is the most unintelligent garbage i have ever read and some of it actually makes sense. It doesn't even bother me anymore. By the grace of God i know have been able to discover the Catholic Church and know what it teaches. I feel sorry for people who never get to discover the Church. I feel so fortunate and i often wonder why me? Why was i so privaleged(sp?) to have the grace to discover the Catholic Church and why others never get to see it or fed and believe the lies even though a lot of them are believable. It could easily have been me being one of those people out there who bash the Church and believe the anti-Catholic stuff. I often wonder why me, in a good way that i am Catholic. At the same time I am sick of the anti-Catholic stuff and don't even care to try and tell people the truth because all it does is cause arguments which no one wins. I know we are supposed to evangelize but i just cannot get myself to debate religion with Catholic bashers or even Protestants that just believe the the Catholic Church is wrong.
cathoholic_anonymous Posted April 9, 2008 Posted April 9, 2008 Some Vatican theologians have actually released quite a fearless new book on sex and sexual pleasure. There is [url="http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/news/2004/10/31/wvat31.xml"]a reasonably good article about it here[/url]. The book (currently available only in Italian) is titled [i]It's a Sin Not to Do It[/i] and its purpose, according to one of the authors, is to emphasise 'a very different and positive side of Church doctrine'. The article isn't perfect - the journalist assumes that all this is something entirely new, when St John Chrysostom was preaching cheerfully on the same subject hundreds of years ago - but I think it will pique people's curiosity and do something to dispel the myths about the Church's take on sex. Kitty and Rizz, it's important to realise that while Church authorities talk about all kinds of things (a quick glance at Zenit for any given day will tell you that) there is a tendency for the mainstream media only to pluck out the 'spicy' topics - e.g. the ones that will sell more papers. It makes it look as though all the Church ever talks about is sex, which is far from the case. It is true that some Catholics (including senior cardinals and bishops) have held negative attitudes about sex and the body in the past. Even though Jansen and his followers were condemnded, their way of thinking has proved to be a insidious taint that will take many years to get rid of completely. What we must remember is that Catholicism preaches a bodily resurrection: our bodies are blessed, holy, and loved so much by God that He saw no shame in becoming Incarnate. We have rules in place to protect that blessedness, to show our respect for our bodies, but they certainly aren't there to inculcate distaste over sex and physical pleasure.
Pontifex Posted April 26, 2008 Posted April 26, 2008 [quote name='loudogswife' post='1493531' date='Apr 6 2008, 11:28 AM']I was going online for some catholic marrage advice and I came across thiswebsite.I found it horribly disturbing and mad me very angry. I wanted to email back but I did'nt know what was true and what was not. Check out the link and you will see what i'm talking about. Any comments? [url="http://www.liberalslikechrist.org/Catholic/Churchvsex.html"]http://www.liberalslikechrist.org/Catholic/Churchvsex.html[/url][/quote] Yes, it is Catholic bashing. The Church is very much pro sex and always has been. We are pro sex within the proper boundaries. Those proper boundaries are what get underneath the skin of the blind and those who are seeking to justify their lifestyles when they fall outside of the lines. Sex is beautiful. Sex is also very powerful and the way in which we co-create with God. It is to be respected and protected. Please don't let the blind pull you off center. We live in crazy world. In Christ, Fr. Pontifex
the 13th papist Posted April 26, 2008 Posted April 26, 2008 After taking Christian Marriage, Sexual and Medical Morality, and Love, Virue and Sin; i can say that the Catholic Church has one of the most exhaulted views of sex. It believes that it is so special and so powerful, that it ought to be seen in light of this and not be treated as anything lower than it is. It is true however that many members in the church have had negative views about sexuality, but thats the thing, those people were not the Magisterium, they didn't think infaliably, they were just private (poor) theologians. we also have an interesting mix of puritanism and pornography in america that offers one of the most skewed views of sexuality, so people in that context are often misguided. 4, 5, and 12 - proper theological anthroplogy of the the body, like say, JPII's theo of the body would answer this, but even a secular, unbiased look at the physical and psychological make up of the human person would show that homosexual acts, and the urge are not just disordered, but harmful to the people and society. the context of ST. Paul writing that is that he thought that the second coming was going to be soon, like within his generation. so if Christ was coming that soon, it would make sense that Christians stay single and devote their life intirely to Christ through preaching the gospel and such. (hindsight shows that the second coming didnt happen when it was expected and the Christian communities thought, "hey, we should probably make some little Christians.")
RandomProddy Posted April 26, 2008 Posted April 26, 2008 [quote name='thessalonian' post='1494194' date='Apr 7 2008, 07:19 PM']7) Remarriage is a mortal sin.[/quote] Widows?
Galloglasses Posted April 26, 2008 Posted April 26, 2008 [quote name='RandomProddy' post='1510259' date='Apr 26 2008, 06:19 AM']Widows?[/quote] No Widows can remarry, because if their Husband is dead, then the Marriage has been completed in faith and grace. 'Till Death do us part', and the widow or widower is free to Marry again, its only if the person has divorce does remarrying become a sin. 'What God has brought together, let man not seperate'
XIX Posted April 26, 2008 Posted April 26, 2008 [quote name='rizz_loves_jesus' post='1495141' date='Apr 8 2008, 07:29 PM']I know this is going to sound horrible, but I kind of agree with them when they said that the Church frowns upon sex, even inside marriage. The Church's attitude it that celibacy is "more pure" than marriage, and the Council of Trent declared that celibacy is preferred rather than marriage... this bothers me, and if the site is telling the truth about what past popes said about marital sex, then I don't know what to do.[/quote] All the Church says is that celibacy is a higher calling than marriage. This isn't because sex is bad (God invented sex, duh! ). It's because sex is good--indeed, it is incredibly awesome. It is about as close to heaven as we'll ever be while we're on earth, with the exception of receiving the Sacraments of the Church. It's worth mentioning that something like two-thirds of the Church's wirtings on sexuality have come from Pope John Paul II. The splendor of sex is basically the whole reason why celibacy is so celebrated. For one, celibates sacrifice a tremendous gift, and as is such, gain equally tremendous graces. It's like fasting--giving up food is a sacrifice that brings us closer to God. Does that mean that food is evil? Of course not. You're giving up something good for the sake of something better. Celibacy is similar to this. Secondly, sex isn't just something Catholics do for fun. Almost invariably, a couple does have fun having sex and that's fine, but it's not the purpose. Ultimately, sex points towards God. Sex is a foretaste of the Beatific Vision. So in marriage, you are hopefully connecting with God by seeing God in your spouse. As a guy, I have a deep appreciation for the beauty of women, for they reflect the perfect beauty of the Creator. Married people, in a sense, behold God through their spouses. And their children--the husband-wife-child connection of sex creates a truly Trinitarian view of sex! If sex was bad or if it was just something recreational, then celibacy would be nothing special. But sex is a great gift [i]from[/i] God, so celibacy is a great gift [i]to [/i]God. The problem is that we live in a comparative society. We like to compare one thing to another, we try to put others down by pointing out someone else who does better, we try to compare ourselves to others just to see how we stack up. We're the same way with sex. Women compare their bodies to whatever supermodel is on billboards everywhere. Men want to see if they can measure up to the wild sex lives of other guys. We think that being better than our peers makes us good, and being worse than our peers makes us bad. [b]The results of this mentality are disastrous. And as a result, we tend to think that marriage is taught to be an unworthy vocation because it's not as high of a calling as the celibate life. On the contrary, celibacy is a higher calling because sex is so great to begin with. Marriage isn't as high a calling as the priesthood, but that still leaves plenty of room for marriage to be a wonderful vocation.[/b] Unfortunately, I can barely begin to refute what's on the website, because the volume of its propaganda is staggering. But as far as Innocent III saying, "The consummation of marriage never takes place without the flames of lust.": Innocent III wrote [i]De quadripartita specie nuptiarum,[/i] which, among other things, stressed the sacramentality of marriage. I haven't delved into that particular document and nor do i plan to, but that certainly doesn't sound like something the Pope would say if he really believed that "The consummation of marriage never takes place without the flames of lust." My best guess is that particular quote was either taken horribly out of context, or that it just got lost in translation. Or both. Otherwise, JP2 would be going directly against the previous popes of the Church. And despite what some people may say, there's simply no way he could do that. I wasn't able to find anything on Pope Leo III, but the quote there is extremely vague also. Probably taken out of context/lost in translation. And think about this: is speaks volumes that they didn't cite any of the Pope's quotations. So it makes it impossible for me to take them seriously. If they want to show me an actual quote and cite that quote so that I can actually research their material, then I might start to begin to go in the generaly direction of possibly taking them seriously. But they haven't, so I won't. Hope this post helps clarify a few things! Any questions, feel free to PM me. Pax, Jonathan
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now