Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

I've been asked about a certain period during what I guess would be the Roman Inquisition. The time frame is 1568, and the issue is this:

[quote]On February 16, 1568, a sentence of the
Inquisition condemned all the inhabitants of the Netherlands to death as
heretics. From this universal doom only a few persons, especially named,
were excepted; and a proclamation of the king, dated ten days later,
confirmed this decree of the Inquisition, and ordered it to be carried
into instant execution, without regard to age, sex, or condition. This
is probably the most concise death-warrant ever framed. Three millions
of people, men, women, and children, were sentenced to the scaffold in
three lines.[/quote]

I requested a source for this information, but have yet to hear back from this person. I've tried looking this up using various methods on the internet and have only come up with this same exact quote in a few places, nothing concrete and nothing that could be cited as authoritative so far.

Any ideas if this actually happened? Or the situation surrounding it? Thanks in advance!

Posted

[quote]What did the Inquisition do in the Netherlands?

In 1522 Charles V, as part of his campaign on behalf of Catholicism, set up a special tribunal in the Spanish Netherlands to try and hold back the tide of Protestantism. It was variously reformed by his son Phillip II and is thought to have been responsible for about 2,000 executions in the period up until the Dutch Revolt in 1572. Even Phillip II himself admitted it was ‘much less merciful’ than the inquisition back home in Spain. During and after the revolt the inquisition was portrayed as the enemy of political as well as religious liberty, despite the fact that most of its victims had been Anabaptists who were also viciously persecuted by orthodox Protestants.

(Source: page 148 Peters; see also Geoffrey Park The Dutch Revolt 1992)
[url="http://www.bede.org.uk/inquisition.htm"]http://www.bede.org.uk/inquisition.htm[/url][/quote]

See the Defense Directory, as well. If his assertion were true we would all learn about it in High School. At the time, 3,000,000 deaths would have pretty much wiped the Netherlands out.

thessalonian
Posted (edited)

Never heard about it. It is possible that the alleged decrees were made but I hightly doudt that they were carried out, i.e. three million people went to the scaffold. One does not neccessitate the other. I highly doudt if this is the case that the Vatican wrote the actual condemnation. More likely as with most inquisitions it gave the government permission to excercise their right to keep order by the sword if neccessary as stated in Romans 13. Heresy in many countries was a capital crime punnishable by death. Killing the soul by leading others astray was taken seriously and on the same level as murder of the body. I have a book called "Salvation at Stake" written by a protestant, but is very fair. Likely it will have something on this and I will try to look it up.

It is good to remember that Protestants used these methods of keeping order and "purifying" the religion of a country as well. It was not by coincidence that Europe religion primarly changed with the borders of the countries. A king decided what religion he was and then made it happen for the country. Look at Englands Penal laws. 200 preists were killed there and freedom of religion was nonexistent when the protestants took power. Even in America the Mass was forbidden in New England until Rhode Island allowed it, which scandalized the rest of the colonies.

God bless

Edited by thessalonian
thessalonian
Posted

Perhaps what is likely is that an edict by the King was declared condemning the hersy of Calvinism. The condemnation was approved by the vatican. The King declared a punishment (not approved by the vatican per se, nor denied because of Romans 13, the vactican even today stays out of the penalty parts of the law but does make statements as to morality of laws). The writer of your claim decides there were 3 million Calvinists in the country and so all of them were condemned to the scaffold by the Rome. This is the common way of historical revisionism. Don't get in to the details and make general statements about everything. Again, I am quite sure that nowhere near 3 million went to the scaffold.

Posted (edited)

Never heard of that...but I would definitely question its authenticity for two basic reasons
a) there is no indication of why [i]eveyone[/i] in the Netherlands was deemed a heretic
b)from whence came the current inhabitants of the Netherlands if the vast majority of the population were wiped out?

I also just have a feeling that the obliteration of (nearly) an entire country would've maybe made a cameo somewhere in my history education-imperfect as it may be.
The most famous Inquisition is of course, the Spanish Inquisition, which I can say a bit more about. The SI is often brought up by anti-Catholics as proof of the maniacal, evil ways of the Church. However, I was a Spanish major in college and in my Civilization of Spain class (in a secular school, btw) we were taught that recent research indicated that most of the statistics and general knowlege about the Inqusition were products of anti-Spanish English propaganda and were largely overblown. I don't mean to say that the SI is anything to praise; my point is that history is often misrepresented (or completely fabricated) to validate an ideology or agenda, so I'm very skeptical about something like this.

And, why the Netherlands? Tulips and wooden shoes just seem so harmless...herectics? Come on! :)

Good for you for asking for the source-Catholics need to start calling people on nonsense like this.

Edited by Tinkerlina

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...