Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

Hi all. I'm a bit of a newbie here. I've grown up in a Baptist church and attend an evangelical university. I've been attending Mass at one of the local parishes on Sunday nights. I've been reading a couple of books including Rome Sweet Home by Scott Hahn. After I got done reading that book and after reading a few chapters in another book, I just couldn't believe what I had just read...I mean, for the past year I've been asking big questions about faith and nothing in my evangelical background could convince me simply because there are too many different opinionism within protestant/evangelical circles. It frustrated me that I couldn't know the Truth because everyone in the protestant/evangelical circles were all claiming to have the Truth. When I got done reading the book by Hahn, I felt this incredible amazement at what I had just read. For the first time, I felt confident that the doctrines he describe (Catholic) are Truth because they have been survived the centuries. At this point, I feel that it would be intellectually and spiritually dishonest for me to stop investigating the Catholic Church and going to Mass. I feel that I have been convinced to some degree that the Catholic Church does hold the Truth. Quite simply: I want to be Catholic, to develop a love for the liturgy, to develop a love for the rich heritage and Tradition, to take part in the Eucharist. I have long prayed to have a real enconter with God, and the Eucharist is something that I'm still trying to understand, but it I believe it is quite possibly the answer to my prayers.

But at the same time, I'm overcome with some pretty serious doubts that I'm trying to work through. Can anyone help me work these out? I'm sorry if some of them are the typical protestant-problems with the Catholic Church questions...

Infallibility of teachings...I know that this is kind of strange for me to ask since I have already mentioned how I feel that the Church does possess the Truth. But at the same time, looking at history, the Church hasn't been completely right in all regards. I know that the Church hasn't declared infallibility in all areas.

Infallibilty of the Pope...along the lines of the teachings. I'm just not convinced that a human can be infallible in certain areas (those which he declares to be infallible). Also, one of my friends who is deeply involved in theology (from a protestant perspective) mentioned that the idea of papal infallibility is very recent (e.g. 1800s if I remember correctly).

The disagreements between Catholics in regards to Vatican II...I guess this is troublesome for me because this is exactly what I am trying to get away from in my protestant/evangelical world...that is, one Church united. I haven't read too much about Vatican II.

The seemingly knee-jerk "excommunicate them" attitude by some Catholics...I think I saw this best exemplified just the other day when I was on here reading about the pro-Choice Catholic lawmakers in the US government and how some people said they should be excommunicated. My question is, who are we to judge who should and who shouldn't be excommunicated. I guess I fear the idea that simply because someone doesn't line up on a particular issue means that they're subject to excommunication...what about grace and concern for those who may not line up with Church teachings? Shouldn't we try to love them back into the Church rather than reject them outright and say that they are not welcome here? (granted...it is abortion which is a pretty singificant issue in the Catholic Church, but I hope that you get my drift...)

The Catholic Canon Law...can someone explain to me how this functions within the Church. At what point does the Canon Law become Pharisaical in nature? I am very concerned about small things becoming big issues...making mountains out of mole hills.

Liturgical abuse...does the grounds for considering something a liturgical abuse come from the Canon Law? I guess on a very general level (and I think this is because I've grown up in evangelical praise and worship services) I'm concerned about those who say that we can't have praise and worship songs...or contemporary worship songs in Mass. The Mass that I go to does sing song written by people such as Matt Maher (who has written songs for the liturgy, e.g. Kyrie, Lamb of God). Why is it so wrong to have praise and worship songs in Mass....granted there are some pretty poorly written P&W songs, but there are also some very good ones. How is the Church going to attract people, like myself, who are used to contemporary songs into a Mass where they only sing hymns or chants? What if I believe that I can worship God using contemporary music? Is there a point at which contemporary music becomes okay? I mean, wasn't the music that was written in past centuries considered contemporary for their time? I guess my biggest fear is that worship becomes regulated act where there is no room for freedom. I understand the need for guidance and to ensure that we are not dishonouring God, but can't God be honoured by the songs that are written in the day...whether it be in the 2nd century or the 21st century?

I've heard it said that you're either Catholic or your not...in other words, some people claim to be Catholic, but they may disagree with certain teachings of the Church. Does that mean they are not Catholic? Are there certain "essentials" that must be agreed upon but "non-essentials" that are negotiable? For me, the biggest concern is my position on abortion. I would consider myself to be a pro-life person...in fact one thing that is particularly attractive about the Church is its consistent ethic of pro-life. But at the same time, I don't think that conservative lawmakers have the corner on exactly how to reduce abortions. I would say that some more liberal lawmakers (who may be pro-choice) want to reduce abortions by ensuring that the economic needs of the mothers are met (which is one reason why some mothers do get abortions). So would I be sinning if I voted for a liberal law maker who considers themselves to be pro-choice (but not necessarily pro-abortion in the sense that they want more and more abortions...rather they want to see the number of abortions drop and those abortions that are performed done in a safeway rather than having women go to back alleys in unsantiary conditions to get abortions). Is it okay to be politically liberal (but not necessarily pro-choice and pro-homosexual marriage; perhaps civil-unions, but not marriage) and still be Catholic?

I'm sure I'll start to think of a few more things as soon as I post this topic.

But I am really looking forward to hearing back from people on this.

Like I said, I have this inner sense that I cannot turn away from what I've learned about the Catholic Church, but there are still many mountains for me to overcome before I can truly commit myself to being a part of the Catholic community of Christians.

P.S. I am just finishing up exams at my university so I may not reply right away...but please bear with me.

Thank you!!!!!

Sdenko

Edited by sdenko
Saint Therese
Posted

I am a convert; I've been a Catholic about eleven years. I want to tell you that these doubts you are having are normal, and not necessarily bad. They also don't necessarily mean that you are going in the wrong direction.
I converted after I left home and went to college. My family had not been religious at all, in fact I still struggle with the secular skepticism that permeated the family. But I have to say I never knew that such love, joy and peace were possible before my entrance into the Church. And since my conversion I have come to know Jesus as I never thought possible.
Some things are harder to accept for some people than others. The Catholic devotion to the Blessed Virgin was a hard thing for me to accept, but not just for doctrinal reasons. It seems to me that several of the issues you mentioned you have doubts about are concerning the authority of the Church and the authority of the Pope.
I realy recommend reading the writings of the Church fathers.
I would be happy to continue speaking with you about this. My advice is: Don't be afraid of the struggle of faith because it can bear such amazing fruit. The fact that you are seeking the Truth is a sure sign that God is indeed working in your desires and yes, even your doubts.
God is with you and He will not lead you astray. I will definitely be praying for you!

Posted

First off, the church is perfect and the does hold the truth, but that doesn't mean that all the people in it or who run it are perfect. It is not just the pope who can produce a teaching that is considered infallible, certain councils of bishops can also produce infallible teachings. I assure you that they do not take these things lightly. Think of how you would feel trying to wrestle with that kind of decision. We have believed from the earliest time that the Holy Spirit will protect the church from error. You can read that in the writings of St. Irenaeus of Lyon, St. Augustine, and St. Vincent of Lerins.

I would highly recommend reading Richard Gaillardetz's book "By What Authority?" It will explain to you how the hierarchy of the church works, and what we have to believe, and which things we are allowed to question. There are four levels of doctrine in the church. Dogma is the core, and you must believe those things. The outer layer is for items of church discipline like priestly celibacy, where you are allowed to disagree with the church, but you are still called to examine your conscience and try to believe.

You have made a big step just in knowing the truth when you hear it. I have known two former Protestant ministers who have converted. They both told me their questions of their old denominations started when the read the writings of the Early Church fathers. Read Ignatius, Irenaeus, and Clement, and then come back with more questions. My favorite quote from St. Irenaeus is, "Here is the beginning and the end of life: faith is the beginning, the end is love; and when the two blend perfectly with each other, they are God. Everything else that makes for right living is consequent upon these."

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1503058' date='Apr 18 2008, 11:26 PM']First off, the church is perfect and the does hold the truth, but that doesn't mean that all the people in it or who run it are perfect. It is not just the pope who can produce a teaching that is considered infallible, certain councils of bishops can also produce infallible teachings. I assure you that they do not take these things lightly. Think of how you would feel trying to wrestle with that kind of decision. We have believed from the earliest time that the Holy Spirit will protect the church from error. You can read that in the writings of St. Irenaeus of Lyon, St. Augustine, and St. Vincent of Lerins.

I would highly recommend reading Richard Gaillardetz's book "By What Authority?" It will explain to you how the hierarchy of the church works, and what we have to believe, and which things we are allowed to question. There are four levels of doctrine in the church. Dogma is the core, and you must believe those things. The outer layer is for items of church discipline like priestly celibacy, where you are allowed to disagree with the church, but you are still called to examine your conscience and try to believe.

You have made a big step just in knowing the truth when you hear it. I have known two former Protestant ministers who have converted. They both told me their questions of their old denominations started when the read the writings of the Early Church fathers. Read Ignatius, Irenaeus, and Clement, and then come back with more questions. My favorite quote from St. Irenaeus is, "Here is the beginning and the end of life: faith is the beginning, the end is love; and when the two blend perfectly with each other, they are God. Everything else that makes for right living is consequent upon these."[/quote]

Thank you to both for your replies. I will definitely take a look at the book by Gaillardetz.

Can either of your recommend some starter books that are written by the Church Fathers? I have Augustine's City of God, On Christian Doctrine, and Confessions for a university class, so I could start with those, but I'm wondering if there are any other ones I should take a look at.

Thanks!

Posted

+

The Didache! :)

Also, check-out The Catholicism Answer Book by Fr. John Trigilio. It would be immensely helpful! (I'm a convert for not dissimilar reasons! )

God Bless!
V

Posted (edited)

[quote name='sdenko' post='1502984' date='Apr 18 2008, 09:13 PM']Hi all. I'm a bit of a newbie here. I've grown up in a Baptist church and attend an evangelical university. I've been attending Mass at one of the local parishes on Sunday nights. I've been reading a couple of books including Rome Sweet Home by Scott Hahn. After I got done reading that book and after reading a few chapters in another book, I just couldn't believe what I had just read...I mean, for the past year I've been asking big questions about faith and nothing in my evangelical background could convince me simply because there are too many different opinionism within protestant/evangelical circles. It frustrated me that I couldn't know the Truth because everyone in the protestant/evangelical circles were all claiming to have the Truth. When I got done reading the book by Hahn, I felt this incredible amazement at what I had just read. For the first time, I felt confident that the doctrines he describe (Catholic) are Truth because they have been survived the centuries. At this point, I feel that it would be intellectually and spiritually dishonest for me to stop investigating the Catholic Church and going to Mass. I feel that I have been convinced to some degree that the Catholic Church does hold the Truth. Quite simply: I want to be Catholic, to develop a love for the liturgy, to develop a love for the rich heritage and Tradition, to take part in the Eucharist. I have long prayed to have a real enconter with God, and the Eucharist is something that I'm still trying to understand, but it I believe it is quite possibly the answer to my prayers.[/quote]

Cool. God has initiated this; you've heard his voice of Truth. And you are responding. Very good.

[quote]But at the same time, I'm overcome with some pretty serious doubts that I'm trying to work through. Can anyone help me work these out? I'm sorry if some of them are the typical protestant-problems with the Catholic Church questions...[/quote]

That's alright. There are answers.

[quote]Infallibility of teachings...I know that this is kind of strange for me to ask since I have already mentioned how I feel that the Church does possess the Truth. But at the same time, looking at history, the Church hasn't been completely right in all regards. I know that the Church hasn't declared infallibility in all areas.[/quote]

Why would God leave infallible government documents without an infallible government by which they may be correctly interpreted and enforced? Moreover, we have no basis to know by faith that the documents are infallible if we do not presuppose the infallibility of the Church. See: [url="http://www.geocities.com/militantis/solascriptura.html"]http://www.geocities.com/militantis/solascriptura.html[/url]

[quote]Infallibilty of the Pope...along the lines of the teachings. I'm just not convinced that a human can be infallible in certain areas (those which he declares to be infallible). Also, one of my friends who is deeply involved in theology (from a protestant perspective) mentioned that the idea of papal infallibility is very recent (e.g. 1800s if I remember correctly).[/quote]

Christ means "anointed"; i.e., Jesus is Messiah, the anointed Son of David - the rightful king. The Davidic kings had prime ministers who metaphorically "held" the "keys of the kingdom" (that is, the sovereign authority of the king himself) that belonged to the king. Compare Is. 22:22 and Matt. 16:18-20. See anything familiar? Christ is appointed Peter as prime minister and changes his name to reflect that new position. The office of prime minister is just that: an office. And an office has successors, all of which hold the authority that the office gives them. The role of the prime minister was (and continues to be) to maintain unity, order, and government while the king was (and continues to be) "away". When Christ returns in his directly perceivable form, there will be no longer a reason for the prime minister's supreme authority, for the king who he represents will be back to reign forever. Amen.

See also: [url="http://www.salvationhistory.com/Online/Advanced/advcourse2_home.cfm"]http://www.salvationhistory.com/Online/Adv...ourse2_home.cfm[/url]

[quote]The disagreements between Catholics in regards to Vatican II...I guess this is troublesome for me because this is exactly what I am trying to get away from in my protestant/evangelical world...that is, one Church united. I haven't read too much about Vatican II.[/quote]

If I understand you correctly, this is not a disagreement in doctrine but in cultural and disciplinary practice; competing preferences of tradition and progression. Where there are doctrinal differences, those who disagree with or abandon dogmas of the Church are Protestants, even if they disagree; they have placed themselves outside of full communion with the Church. This does not mean they cease to be Catholic, only that they cease to fully embrace all that Church is.
[i]
[quote]The seemingly knee-jerk "excommunicate them" attitude by some Catholics...I think I saw this best exemplified just the other day when I was on here reading about the pro-Choice Catholic lawmakers in the US government and how some people said they should be excommunicated. My question is, who are we to judge who should and who shouldn't be excommunicated. I guess I fear the idea that simply because someone doesn't line up on a particular issue means that they're subject to excommunication...what about grace and concern for those who may not line up with Church teachings? Shouldn't we try to love them back into the Church rather than reject them outright and say that they are not welcome here? (granted...it is abortion which is a pretty singificant issue in the Catholic Church, but I hope that you get my drift...)[/quote]
[/i]

Excommunication is a last resort penalty for someone who is in persistently unrepentant and public sin - or for someone who has deliberately committed a particular heinous mortal sin. The goal of excommunication is a loving one; to bring the soul into repentance and the Father's loving arms in the confessional.

[quote][i]The Catholic Canon Law...can someone explain to me how this functions within the Church. At what point does the Canon Law become Pharisaical in nature? I am very concerned about small things becoming big issues...making mountains out of mole hills.[/i][/quote]

No kingdom or government can function without laws; otherwise there would be chaos. Generally, you don't [i]need [/i]to know about canon law...until a serious question or situation arises where the law is required; such is its purpose. That is where canon lawyers come in.

[quote]Liturgical abuse...does the grounds for considering something a liturgical abuse come from the Canon Law? I guess on a very general level (and I think this is because I've grown up in evangelical praise and worship services) I'm concerned about those who say that we can't have praise and worship songs...or contemporary worship songs in Mass. The Mass that I go to does sing song written by people such as Matt Maher (who has written songs for the liturgy, e.g. Kyrie, Lamb of God). Why is it so wrong to have praise and worship songs in Mass....granted there are some pretty poorly written P&W songs, but there are also some very good ones. How is the Church going to attract people, like myself, who are used to contemporary songs into a Mass where they only sing hymns or chants? What if I believe that I can worship God using contemporary music? Is there a point at which contemporary music becomes okay? I mean, wasn't the music that was written in past centuries considered contemporary for their time? I guess my biggest fear is that worship becomes regulated act where there is no room for freedom. I understand the need for guidance and to ensure that we are not dishonouring God, but can't God be honoured by the songs that are written in the day...whether it be in the 2nd century or the 21st century?[/quote]

Read the current pope's book, [i]Spirit of the Liturgy[/i]. Try not to sweat the small stuff.

[quote]I've heard it said that you're either Catholic or your not...in other words, some people claim to be Catholic, but they may disagree with certain teachings of the Church. Does that mean they are not Catholic? Are there certain "essentials" that must be agreed upon but "non-essentials" that are negotiable? For me, the biggest concern is my position on abortion. I would consider myself to be a pro-life person...in fact one thing that is particularly attractive about the Church is its consistent ethic of pro-life. But at the same time, I don't think that conservative lawmakers have the corner on exactly how to reduce abortions. I would say that some more liberal lawmakers (who may be pro-choice) want to reduce abortions by ensuring that the economic needs of the mothers are met (which is one reason why some mothers do get abortions). So would I be sinning if I voted for a liberal law maker who considers themselves to be pro-choice (but not necessarily pro-abortion in the sense that they want more and more abortions...rather they want to see the number of abortions drop and those abortions that are performed done in a safeway rather than having women go to back alleys in unsantiary conditions to get abortions). Is it okay to be politically liberal (but not necessarily pro-choice and pro-homosexual marriage; perhaps civil-unions, but not marriage) and still be Catholic?[/quote]

I think I already covered this question above. Anyone who has been validly baptized is a Catholic. Forever.

Edited by Ziggamafu
MC IMaGiNaZUN
Posted

[quote name='sdenko' post='1502984' date='Apr 18 2008, 10:13 PM']Infallibility of teachings...I know that the Church hasn't declared infallibility in all areas.
Infallibilty of the Pope...along the lines of the teachings. I'm just not convinced that a human can be infallible in certain areas Also, one of my friends who is deeply involved in theology (from a protestant perspective) mentioned that the idea of papal infallibility is very recent[/quote]

One case that comes to mind is Galileo. For me, this was a major stumbling block to my faith. So I did some research. Galileo made some accurate scientific predictions, however, by the standard of the scientific method, they were a bit of a stretch at the time. For a scientific person, it would have been reasonable to contradict him on scientific terms, But Galileo was right all along. However, he was not right, in the manner in which he blatantly insulted the pope, and the church in his published work. The Pope and Galileo were like two children fighting in the sand box.
Really Papal Infallibility only covers areas of faith and morals, not science. And Papal Infallibility is not by virtue of the person, it is by virtue of the Papal Office. So only in certain circumstances can the Pope even be allowedto make an infallible statement. There are also instances of infallibility in the variety of Church Ecumenical Councils held throughout the centuries. These formulated and precisely defined the doctrines we take for granted today. I would recommend reading up on these Councils.
That would not stop some representatives of the Church making fallible statements or teachings.

[quote name='sdenko' post='1502984' date='Apr 18 2008, 10:13 PM']The disagreements between Catholics in regards to Vatican II...I guess this is troublesome for me because this is exactly what I am trying to get away from in my protestant/evangelical world...that is, one Church united. I haven't read too much about Vatican II.[/quote]

The disagreements typically have to do with interpretations. It is clear to me that some people have their own agendas looking into Vatican II. Many Americans, fresh out of the Civil Rights Movement, now openly protesting the War in Vietnam, along with the Culture Climate, believed that this would be the beginning of a series of reforms in the church which would eradicate classism, clerricalism, etc. and bring the church into the modern world. They were not interested in the issues, or the Movement of the Holy Spirit, but their own agendas.
On the other hand, there were those who carefully considered the tradition, and believed that the council belittled the tradition.
I am beginning to find myself appreciating the tension. I have found that some of these people who hold to a radical traditional conservative interpretation of the Council sometimes have no ability to understand people who come from different backgrounds, nor do they have the ability to engage any culture outside of themselves. And of course, those who rightfully want to help make the Gospel rellevant to this culture, can get lost in any sort of new popular trend that sweeps across the culture. The tension does actually bring balance I find.


[quote name='sdenko' post='1502984' date='Apr 18 2008, 10:13 PM']The seemingly knee-jerk "excommunicate them" attitude by some Catholics...I think I saw this best exemplified just the other day when I was on here reading about the pro-Choice Catholic lawmakers in the US government and how some people said they should be excommunicated. My question is, who are we to judge who should and who shouldn't be excommunicated. I guess I fear the idea that simply because someone doesn't line up on a particular issue means that they're subject to excommunication...what about grace and concern for those who may not line up with Church teachings? Shouldn't we try to love them back into the Church rather than reject them outright and say that they are not welcome here? (granted...it is abortion which is a pretty singificant issue in the Catholic Church, but I hope that you get my drift...)[/quote]

Excommunication these days is typically reserved for people who make a public defiance of Church teaching. In order that people may not be mislead by their example the excommunication is given to them.

[quote name='sdenko' post='1502984' date='Apr 18 2008, 10:13 PM']The Catholic Canon Law...can someone explain to me how this functions within the Church. At what point does the Canon Law become Pharisaical in nature? I am very concerned about small things becoming big issues...making mountains out of mole hills.[/quote]

The Church never set up Canon Law in order to get people into heaven, nor to attain holiness. Canon Law was never meant to make people good. It is grace through Jesus Christ that transforms them into goodness.
In our experience of being the world's oldest standing institution, we have learned the importance of spelling things out clearly. This includes doctrine, morals, etc. Law has to do with the practices. We have a Canon Law so we can know what practices are justifiable. The Pharisee's problem was, that they saw a bare minimal practice of the law as leading one to holiness. We see as participating in the Paschal Mystery of Jesus Christ as leading to Holiness. Canon Law is just because we have so many humans :)

[quote name='sdenko' post='1502984' date='Apr 18 2008, 10:13 PM']Liturgical abuse...does the grounds for considering something a liturgical abuse come from the Canon Law? I guess on a very general level (and I think this is because I've grown up in evangelical praise and worship services) I'm concerned about those who say that we can't have praise and worship songs...or contemporary worship songs in Mass. The Mass that I go to does sing song written by people such as Matt Maher (who has written songs for the liturgy, e.g. Kyrie, Lamb of God). Why is it so wrong to have praise and worship songs in Mass....granted there are some pretty poorly written P&W songs, but there are also some very good ones. How is the Church going to attract people, like myself, who are used to contemporary songs into a Mass where they only sing hymns or chants? What if I believe that I can worship God using contemporary music? Is there a point at which contemporary music becomes okay? I mean, wasn't the music that was written in past centuries considered contemporary for their time? I guess my biggest fear is that worship becomes regulated act where there is no room for freedom. I understand the need for guidance and to ensure that we are not dishonouring God, but can't God be honoured by the songs that are written in the day...whether it be in the 2nd century or the 21st century?[/quote]

You are right. In the entire history of the Church, there had been the practice of using contemporary music. Why do people write church hyms? To be used today, not five centuries from today. Who is going to care about some five century old song that was never used. In many monasteries, the music used at liturgy was composed by the monks or nuns themselves. So I dont understand the repulsion for contemporary music.
Some people do believe however, that the use of instruments like guitars, trivializes the music. I can see that, especially with some of these happy clappy liturgies i have gone to. But I dont know that there has ever been a time where only the organ was the instrument used in church. certainly in a Cathedral or Basilica that could afford to put that sort of thing up. But what about for the millions of Catholics around the world, that cannot ever reasonably afford a decent organ, would not a simple guitar be used to lift their minds up to God? Or perhaps drums? The organ is just not practical in many cases, although it is preferrable.

[quote name='sdenko' post='1502984' date='Apr 18 2008, 10:13 PM']I've heard it said that you're either Catholic or your not...in other words, some people claim to be Catholic, but they may disagree with certain teachings of the Church. Does that mean they are not Catholic? Are there certain "essentials" that must be agreed upon but "non-essentials" that are negotiable? For me, the biggest concern is my position on abortion. I would consider myself to be a pro-life person...in fact one thing that is particularly attractive about the Church is its consistent ethic of pro-life. But at the same time, I don't think that conservative lawmakers have the corner on exactly how to reduce abortions. I would say that some more liberal lawmakers (who may be pro-choice) want to reduce abortions by ensuring that the economic needs of the mothers are met (which is one reason why some mothers do get abortions). So would I be sinning if I voted for a liberal law maker who considers themselves to be pro-choice (but not necessarily pro-abortion in the sense that they want more and more abortions...rather they want to see the number of abortions drop and those abortions that are performed done in a safeway rather than having women go to back alleys in unsantiary conditions to get abortions). Is it okay to be politically liberal (but not necessarily pro-choice and pro-homosexual marriage; perhaps civil-unions, but not marriage) and still be Catholic?[/quote]

It is always a sin to vote for a pro-choice position intending that pro choice position to be legislated.
If we could have a majority of pro life members in the Supreme Court, that makes me happy enough.
There is an arguement that voting for a liberal may indeed bring about more social welfare programs that could statistically reduce abortions, by reducing the young woman's desperation by granting her more options, whereas voting for a conservative will only eliminate the legality of abortion, but not help the baby once he/she is born.
Personally i think the two party system is entirely screwed up. I do not believe either party will ever consistently promote church teachings. They are slow moving, promoting party agendas that have been around for too long. They are more interested in the political financial backers, then in what the majority of the people want.

SHALOM
Bro Mark

thessalonian
Posted

A limited infallibility is not at all illogical or unlikely. You believe it yourself when you assent to the scriptures being the Word of God, yet acknowledge that they are words written by men. That God didn't write them and then hand them to a man for publication. THerefore a man while writing these things was infallible for the period of time that they were written. This is called divine inspiration. In fact the divine inspiration occured both at the time that the words were spoke and then later when they were written. For instance Elizabeth when fill with the spirit cried out "blessed are you among women and blessed is the fruit of your womb Jesus" she was speaking infallibly at that moment. When the High Preist Caiphas said that "it is better for one to die for the many" in John 11 and 18 the scriptures tell us that this man spoke not on his own but through the spirit, infallibly. Now here was a man who willingly condemned Christ to death. This shows that even sinful men can be infallibe at times.

Now as for the papacy, we see in Matt 16:18 that Jesus says "WHATEVER you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven". God cannot bind a lie and so this "WHATEVER" tells us that if something fits the definition of infallibility then it truly comes from God.

thessalonian
Posted

The other claim I would like to address is the claim that infallibility didn't show up until a later date, i.e. the 1800's. True enough the doctrine was not formulated before that time the way we understand it that time. But Vatican I only put in to words what God had always done, just as the council of Nicea only put in to more explicit words the doctrine on the trinity that had always been a part of Church teaching in a more primitive way before that time. We can read Church Fathers before Nicea and see clear evidences for the trinity. We can also read the writings of the Church long before Vatican I in the 1800's and see evidences of papal infallibility. Ignatius of Antioch for instance in the early 2nd century speaks of the purity of the teachings of the Roman Chruch if you look at his letter to the Romans. There is a quote by one of the councils in the 5th or 6th century about Pope Agotho, can't remember it off the top of my head but it is signed by over 500 bishops and is a clear indication that infallibility was in a more primitive way believed in the Church long before Vatican I. Hope these two posts help you in your journey and you have my prayers. God bless.

thessalonian
Posted

I should sumarize the above. When a Pope or Council declares something infallibly they are not "inventing" new doctrine but setting a dispute with regard to what the Church has always believed. I can show you evidence of the assumption of Mary from very early on in Church history but it was not infallibly declared until 1960.

Posted

Thank you all for your responses.

I'd really like to be able to respond to them, but as I said, I'm in the middle of final exams. So I will try to respond as soon as possible.

Thank you again.

Posted

Okay to start off with, my reply may be a bit different from the others, because unlike them I am not a Roman Catholic. There's also the similiar background between the two of us, growing up Baptist, and basically now worshiping non-denominationally, so hopefully I come up with something of substance instead of something that raises more questions. However, you have just aired, almost verbatim, my laundry list of questions on Catholicism.

First of all, [u]Rome Sweet Home[/u] is a very good book. I enjoyed it too, although for a more...stuffy, but pretty informative approach, I'd recommend [u]Born Fundamentalist, Born Again Catholic[/u]. It's by a man named David Currie, who quite frankly, doesn't have Dr. Hahn's flair in writing, but still gives a good amount of information.

So...Apostolic Authority and infallibility. I am about to ramble, so please do forgive me. To believe in Apostolic Authority is to an extent, believe in infallibility on some issues at the least. After all, were not the Apostles rendered infallible by the Holy Spirit while writing the gospel? Why would this not continue to the successors of Peter, if one does believe in Apostolic authority? The book of Acts, in its entirety is like one giant guide to church hierarchy and authority for one thing, presbyters, councils, and such.

So some Scripture and other stuff:

Saint Ignatius of Antioch once wrote, "You must follow the bishop as Jesus Christ follows the Father, and the presbytery [that is, the council of priests] as you would the Apostles. Reverence the deacons as you would the command of God. Let no one do anything of concern to the Church without the bishop."

Part One, Section One, Chapter Two, Number Seventy-Seven of the Catechism of the Catholic Church states, "In order that the full and living Gospel might always be preserved in the Church the apostles left bishops as their successors. They gave them their own position of teaching authority. Indeed, "the apostolic preaching, which is expressed in a special way in the inspired books, was to be preserved in a continuous line of succession until the end of time."

John 20:20-23 says, "When he had said this, he showed them his hands and his side. The disciples rejoiced when they saw the Lord. (Jesus) said to them again, "Peace be with you. As the Father has sent me, so I send you." And when he had said this, he breathed on them and said to them, "Receive the holy Spirit. Whose sins you forgive are forgiven them, and whose sins you retain are retained."

Matthew 16: 17-29 states, quite famously, "Jesus said to him in reply, "Blessed are you, Simon son of Jonah. For flesh and blood has not revealed this to you, but my heavenly Father. And so I say to you, you are Peter, and upon this rock I will build my church, and the gates of the netherworld shall not prevail against it. I will give you the keys to the kingdom of heaven. Whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven; and whatever you loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven."

The verse in Matthew hearkens back of course to Isaiah 22, the symbol of the keys being for a Prime Minister of Israel. One whom has authority to rule in the stead of the King. Or in this case, the authority to teach on behalf of the Risen Christ.

Now, the Pope rarely makes claims that he says are infallible, and these are known as Ex Cathedra Statements. One of the most famous was already mentioned here in this thread, and that is the Assumption of Mary. Which, loathe as I am to admit it as a Protestant, has been commonly held and believed since the days of the early church. You might want to read through the document itself, because if nothing else, it does lay out a good case on how the belief was widespread... [url="http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/pius_xii/apost_constitutions/documents/hf_p-xii_apc_19501101_munificentissimus-deus_en.html"]The Apostolic Constitution Defining the Doctrine of the Assumption.[/url]

Anyhow my two cents. I'll be watching the thread though, because as I said, your questions contain many of my own.

Saint Therese
Posted

I also highly recommend the Comendium of the Catechism of the Catholic Church. Its a bit easier to read than the Catechism, but it still awesme. I would also recommend the Story of A Soul by St. Therese of Lisieux.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='sdenko' post='1503169' date='Apr 19 2008, 03:16 AM']Thank you to both for your replies. I will definitely take a look at the book by Gaillardetz.

Can either of your recommend some starter books that are written by the Church Fathers? I have Augustine's City of God, On Christian Doctrine, and Confessions for a university class, so I could start with those, but I'm wondering if there are any other ones I should take a look at.

Thanks![/quote]
[url="http://www.newadvent.org/fathers/"]http://www.newadvent.org/fathers/[/url]

Posted

I have found the book "The Holy Longing" by Fr. Ron Rolheiser to be excellent for spiritual formation.

Saint Therese
Posted

You really can't beat New Advent as far as websites go, I agree with the above poster.

LouisvilleFan
Posted (edited)

I'll try to be brief here, since I probably don't have much to add to what others have said.

[quote name='sdenko' post='1502984' date='Apr 18 2008, 11:13 PM']Infallibility of teachings...I know that this is kind of strange for me to ask since I have already mentioned how I feel that the Church does possess the Truth. But at the same time, looking at history, the Church hasn't been completely right in all regards. I know that the Church hasn't declared infallibility in all areas.[/quote]

But where the Church is infallible (faith and morals) she has always been right and never taught any contradiction.

[quote name='sdenko' post='1502984' date='Apr 18 2008, 11:13 PM']Infallibilty of the Pope...along the lines of the teachings. I'm just not convinced that a human can be infallible in certain areas (those which he declares to be infallible). Also, one of my friends who is deeply involved in theology (from a protestant perspective) mentioned that the idea of papal infallibility is very recent (e.g. 1800s if I remember correctly).[/quote]

It wasn't defined because there was no need to define it, just like the Scriptures were not finally defined until Council of Trent in response to the Protestant Reformation.

[quote name='sdenko' post='1502984' date='Apr 18 2008, 11:13 PM']The disagreements between Catholics in regards to Vatican II...I guess this is troublesome for me because this is exactly what I am trying to get away from in my protestant/evangelical world...that is, one Church united. I haven't read too much about Vatican II.[/quote]

That is a problem, but be assured that both "sides" love the Church very much and they simply want to see the Church healthy and growing with a strong faith. Most Catholics (i.e. those who have a life outside of blogging and message boards) are relatively indifferent. Those who are against Vatican II are associating many problems in the Church with that council, but they neglect the stronger influence of society and culture, which has affected Christians across all denominations.

[quote name='sdenko' post='1502984' date='Apr 18 2008, 11:13 PM']The seemingly knee-jerk "excommunicate them" attitude by some Catholics...I think I saw this best exemplified just the other day when I was on here reading about the pro-Choice Catholic lawmakers in the US government and how some people said they should be excommunicated. My question is, who are we to judge who should and who shouldn't be excommunicated. I guess I fear the idea that simply because someone doesn't line up on a particular issue means that they're subject to excommunication...what about grace and concern for those who may not line up with Church teachings? Shouldn't we try to love them back into the Church rather than reject them outright and say that they are not welcome here? (granted...it is abortion which is a pretty singificant issue in the Catholic Church, but I hope that you get my drift...)[/quote]

We should ultimately try to win them back to be faithful to the Church. Excommunication is basically the last resort in telling a Catholic that they are definitely not with the Church on some matter. You are right that it's not up to the laypeople to decide, which is why they appeal to the bishops on this stuff. Of course, bishops tend to be more pastoral and willing to offer grace. I prefer letting them handle the situation, seeing as I struggle enough with tending to the things God has given me to tend to.

[quote name='sdenko' post='1502984' date='Apr 18 2008, 11:13 PM']The Catholic Canon Law...can someone explain to me how this functions within the Church. At what point does the Canon Law become Pharisaical in nature? I am very concerned about small things becoming big issues...making mountains out of mole hills.[/quote]

That's an understandable concern and I think most Protestants feel that way when looking at Catholicism (as I did sometimes). FWIW, canon law is something lay Catholics hardly ever need to bother with, unless they choose to obtain the education to be a canon lawyer or whatever. Keep in mind that it does require a lot of rules to regulate all the various liturgies and traditions with Catholicism among virtually all the world's cultures. Your current church most likely has a set of rules that function in the same purpose as canon law, but if it's just a single congregation in one city in one country with several hundred people, then it doesn't get too complicated.

[quote name='sdenko' post='1502984' date='Apr 18 2008, 11:13 PM']Liturgical abuse...does the grounds for considering something a liturgical abuse come from the Canon Law? I guess on a very general level (and I think this is because I've grown up in evangelical praise and worship services) I'm concerned about those who say that we can't have praise and worship songs...or contemporary worship songs in Mass.[/quote]

Liturgical abuse is essentially a failure to follow the General Instruction of the Roman Missal (GIRM). It doesn't say that praise and worship is specifically outlawed, but it does call for reverent music within certain guidelines, which most praise and worship doesn't fit into. However, some of it does and if done appropriately, it can be used in the Mass just fine. The whole point is to maintain reverence for the Word of God in Scripture and the Word made Flesh in the Eucharist. The Mass/Divine Liturgy are unique to Catholicism/Orthodoxy and as such, there isn't a direct parallel within Protestantism because there is no true Eucharist.

Now, there is no problem at all with Catholics having a praise and worship service outside of Mass. In fact, such an event can be a great way to promote the sacrament of Reconciliation.

[quote name='sdenko' post='1502984' date='Apr 18 2008, 11:13 PM']I've heard it said that you're either Catholic or your not...in other words, some people claim to be Catholic, but they may disagree with certain teachings of the Church. Does that mean they are not Catholic? Are there certain "essentials" that must be agreed upon but "non-essentials" that are negotiable?[/quote]

They are Catholic since this the tradition and faith to which they lay claim, but they are also knowingly rebelling against the Church and therefore breaking their Confirmation vow to believe and uphold everything the Catholic Church professes to be true.

[quote name='sdenko' post='1502984' date='Apr 18 2008, 11:13 PM']But at the same time, I don't think that conservative lawmakers have the corner on exactly how to reduce abortions. I would say that some more liberal lawmakers (who may be pro-choice) want to reduce abortions by ensuring that the economic needs of the mothers are met (which is one reason why some mothers do get abortions). So would I be sinning if I voted for a liberal law maker who considers themselves to be pro-choice.[/quote]

I see what you're saying and that is a difficult decision to make. Still, liberal politicians are often saying such things to appear more conservative, just like conservatives tend to be more liberal than they appear. You are right that conservative lawmakers don't have the corner on how to reduce abortions. That's why the Church isn't "conservative" or "liberal." Both sides are morally right in some areas and morally wrong in others.

[quote name='sdenko' post='1502984' date='Apr 18 2008, 11:13 PM']Is it okay to be politically liberal (but not necessarily pro-choice and pro-homosexual marriage; perhaps civil-unions, but not marriage) and still be Catholic?[/quote]

More specifically, I think you mean fiscally liberal and socially conservative. That's more where I fall too, but not to the degree of supporting national health care. The problem with civil unions is that you're basically saying homosexuals can live like they are married without being married. It also skirts around the fundamental problem of homosexuality: that it's ultimately a self-seeking lifestyle that doesn't point to the mystery of God as the giver of life. Without openess to life, a couple (whether hetero- or homosexual) is turning inward toward each other, which ends in further broken relationships and a more broken society.

Allow God to invite you into the truth, which Christ opened to all of us by becoming one of us. A homosexual doesn't need a life partner any more than you need an xBox. What we need to live is love, and if we let God love us, we want nothing else. That's what living is all about.

Just to fill you in, I'm a former Lutheran who was slowly drawn into Catholicism over about four or fives years of experiencing the love of other Catholics and going to Mass with some family members. I attended a couple of a Baptist churches during the meantime and most of my friends are Baptist. Catholicism is definitely a different culture from Protestantism, and I'm still getting used to it, but underneath it all we aren't all that different. Simply ask God to show you the way and let him lead you.

Edited by LouisvilleFan
Posted

Thank you all for your replies...I'm still finishing up my final exams so I will hopefully have a chance to reply to your responses in a few days :-)

Thank you again!

Sdenko

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1503058' date='Apr 18 2008, 11:26 PM']First off, the church is perfect and the does hold the truth, but that doesn't mean that all the people in it or who run it are perfect. It is not just the pope who can produce a teaching that is considered infallible, certain councils of bishops can also produce infallible teachings. I assure you that they do not take these things lightly. Think of how you would feel trying to wrestle with that kind of decision. We have believed from the earliest time that the Holy Spirit will protect the church from error. You can read that in the writings of St. Irenaeus of Lyon, St. Augustine, and St. Vincent of Lerins.

I would highly recommend reading Richard Gaillardetz's book "By What Authority?" It will explain to you how the hierarchy of the church works, and what we have to believe, and which things we are allowed to question. There are four levels of doctrine in the church. Dogma is the core, and you must believe those things. The outer layer is for items of church discipline like priestly celibacy, where you are allowed to disagree with the church, but you are still called to examine your conscience and try to believe.

You have made a big step just in knowing the truth when you hear it. I have known two former Protestant ministers who have converted. They both told me their questions of their old denominations started when the read the writings of the Early Church fathers. Read Ignatius, Irenaeus, and Clement, and then come back with more questions. My favorite quote from St. Irenaeus is, "Here is the beginning and the end of life: faith is the beginning, the end is love; and when the two blend perfectly with each other, they are God. Everything else that makes for right living is consequent upon these."[/quote]

Phew...now that I'm done with my university studies for the year, I can reply to all these responses! Thank you for waiting patiently...I really appreciate it.

So dogma is the absolute essentials that all Catholics must believe. I'd assume that this would include things like the Trinity, Jesus' divinity, and such. But then the outer layer, there seems to be a little bit more freedom with in the confines of our conscience. So what if I can't submit to some of the outer layer things (I'm speaking hypothetically since I haven't examined this 'outer layer') in good consceince?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...