Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Brother Adam
Posted

I have to wonder who put together the two different Masses. It's almost a case study in "how not to do Mass" and "how to do Mass". The Holy Father seemed so much happier at the end of this Mass in Yankee Stadium.

CatholicCid
Posted

FOX News said that this Mass (NY) was organized by the Vatican's Masters of Ceremonies or some official sounding title.

Brother Adam
Posted

Hm...does that mean the USCCB put together the one at National's Stadium?

Posted

i believe each Mass was organized by each Archdiocese.

i was at Nationals Park...on the field two sections in front of the altar! the musical highlight for me was of course Panis Angelicus. sure, the music could have been like Yankee Stadium...but the music at Nats Park wasn't all that surprising considering the local choirs chosen.

it was well intentioned and the main choir director--believe it or not--reminded the choirs at rehearsal that they were not entertainers.

perhaps though, i think, more consideration for the Holy Father's musical preferences should have been taken. yes it revealed an ignorance about the Holy Father which was disappointing and [i]almost[/i] hurtful. aside from the music can anyone say it was irreverent? i can't.

Brother Adam
Posted

"it was well intentioned and the main choir director--believe it or not--reminded the choirs at rehearsal that they were not entertainers."

They do the same thing at Protestant mega-churches with rock bands.

"yes it revealed an ignorance about the Holy Father which was disappointing and almost hurtful."

I just cannot believe that a person preparing a papal Mass is ignorant of Pontiff's desires for the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass in God's Church. Especially a liturgist planning a Mass to this scale. It isn't about simply about preferences, but what is right, and the Holy Father has made that known very plainly.

"aside from the music can anyone say it was irreverent?"

I didn't see any need for using foreign languages for the readings. After all the readings are suppose to be in the vernacular. While I agree with the EWTN commentators that clapping is pretty much inevitable at a Mass like this, it is not reverent for what the Mass is. I'm sure that the Holy Father would agree that when the day is said and done it is not about 1 of 265 pope's but about Jesus. The Eucharistic liturgy and homily were beautiful, but then look at the celebrant.

Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' post='1504566' date='Apr 20 2008, 06:51 PM']"aside from the music can anyone say it was irreverent?"

I didn't see any need for using foreign languages for the readings. After all the readings are suppose to be in the vernacular.[/quote]

Spanish is vernacular. At Yankee Stadium there was also one reading in Spanish.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

Haha, the concept of a stadium Mass is a trip. lol. Not sure how reverent it could be when you get 600,000 people in a stadium, hahaha. Ya gotta make do with what ya got I suppose (AEIII ;) )

I wish I would have been able to go. :(

Seriously though, I kind of think that America is slowly becoming more traditional. The Holy Father rocks!!!

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1506337' date='Apr 22 2008, 12:24 AM']Haha, the concept of a stadium Mass is a trip. lol. Not sure how reverent it could be when you get 600,000 people in a stadium, hahaha.

I wish I would have been able to go. :(

Seriously though, I kind of think that America is slowly becoming more traditional.[/quote]

A stadium with a 600,000 seating capacity would be a sight to see! Fortunately, most stadiums tend to be under 100,000. Yankee Stadium is 57,545, while Nationals Park is 41,888 (doesn't take into account the number of people on the field).

However, I get what you're trying to say. ;) :lol:

Edited by Paladin D
Brother Adam
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Seven77' post='1506132' date='Apr 22 2008, 12:43 AM']Spanish is vernacular. At Yankee Stadium there was also one reading in Spanish.[/quote]

Okay, if that is true, I'll plead ignorance. I had no idea that the public Masses were Spanish Masses. I would have sworn that only a very minority of the people there would speak Spanish, and only a few of those as a first language. While Spanish is a vernacular language, it is not the vernacular language of the majority in attendance, and thus not appropriate because it abuses the intent of using the vernacular.

Edited by Brother Adam
Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Paladin D' post='1506349' date='Apr 21 2008, 10:31 PM']A stadium with a 600,000 seating capacity would be a sight to see!

Fortunately, most stadiums tend to be under 100,000. Yankee Stadium is 57,545, while Nationals Park is 41,888 (doesn't take into account the number of people on the field).[/quote]
LOL! I meant 60,000 hahaha. That would be nuts! Imagine how the Communion of the faithful would go down. Yikes!

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' post='1506352' date='Apr 21 2008, 10:31 PM']Okay, if that is true, I'll plead ignorance. I had no idea that the public Masses were Spanish Masses. I think that's insulting to the majority of Americans. I would have sworn that only a very minority of the people there would speak Spanish, and only a few of those as a first language.[/quote]
If you look at the demographics a very large percentage of American Catholics are native Spanish speakers. In Europe the large Masses of this sort often incorporate many vernaculars based on the people who are present and not necessarily 'official language' or political borders.

I wasn't there but I imagine if one were to gather statistics on the Mass attendence there were a great many Spanish speakers present. I know for a fact that lots of people even came from Mexico to be there for the Pope.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

Maybe I'm just biased because I think that linguistic pluralism is sweet and I wish the United States was more diverse in this regard. English is one of my least favorite languages and it happens to be my mother tongue. :(

littlesister
Posted

Regardless of who put them together, it is hard to imagine that both programs were not submitted in advance to Rome. Even the smallest detail of these trips is scrutinized, so how could something as important as the liturgy escape? It goes without saying that there are two trends in church music today, the contemporary and the traditional. Both have their advantages and both have their challenges. And in general they speak to different people and reflect their legitimate tastes. Both liturgies were living and heartfelt, and comparing apples to oranges rarely leads to viable conclusions. BTW, I've been an organist for years...raised on and loving the classics, but appreciating the ability of newer forms to gather assemblies together and give them one voice and one heart.

Autumn Dusk
Posted

About the Spanish...my friends a catholic youth minister in NYC...and has to speak spanish nearly fluently to be taken seriously by most of the parish.

LouisvilleFan
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Autumn Dusk' post='1506438' date='Apr 22 2008, 01:11 AM']About the Spanish...my friends a catholic youth minister in NYC...and has to speak spanish nearly fluently to be taken seriously by most of the parish.[/quote]

Some dioceses also require seminarians to be fluent in Spanish as a prerequisite for ordination.

Edited by LouisvilleFan
franciscanheart
Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' post='1506352' date='Apr 21 2008, 10:31 PM']Okay, if that is true, I'll plead ignorance. I had no idea that the public Masses were Spanish Masses. I would have sworn that only a very minority of the people there would speak Spanish, and only a few of those as a first language. While Spanish is a vernacular language, it is not the vernacular language of the majority in attendance, and thus not appropriate because it abuses the intent of using the vernacular.[/quote]
:rolleyes: get OVER it!

regardless of your [i]opinion[/i], the fact of the matter is that there are spanish-speakers in america! believe it or not, LOTS of people in the east speak spanish... some, yes, as a first language!

:doh: you really kill me sometimes.

Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' post='1504566' date='Apr 20 2008, 06:51 PM']I didn't see any need for using foreign languages for the readings. After all the readings are suppose to be in the vernacular. While I agree with the EWTN commentators that clapping is pretty much inevitable at a Mass like this, it is not reverent for what the Mass is. I'm sure that the Holy Father would agree that when the day is said and done it is not about 1 of 265 pope's but about Jesus. The Eucharistic liturgy and homily were beautiful, but then look at the celebrant.[/quote]


Speaking as someone who lives in Washington DC, all of those languages pretty much are the vernacular. In some neighborhoods it is actually uncommon to go out on the street and hear English spoken. Of course the majority of the non-English speakers speak Spanish but we also have very large communities of Asians, Africans, etc. Even if all of the other languages weren't strictly necessary, the Spanish was. I went to an event held at the National Shrine for the Holy Father's arrival and more than half of those there were of Latin American origin. Also, my school rented a jumbotron and hosted a large gathering to watch the mass for those who couldn't get tickets, and when CNN started commentating over the Spanish part of the homily, people completely freaked out, because most people here are either native speakers or they understand spanish. Basically what I'm trying to say is that Spanish is cool. :-)

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

Wow.. That D.C. Mass was unfortunate.. haha. Yikes! Poor Holy Father.

littlesister
Posted

Please, folks...whatever happened to "Welcoming the stranger?" Nothing says "Welcome" like having your own language/heritage acknowledged. Everyone does what they think is best in a given situation. This is getting painful.

1337 k4th0l1x0r
Posted (edited)

[quote name='littlesister' post='1507893' date='Apr 23 2008, 09:03 PM']Please, folks...whatever happened to "Welcoming the stranger?" Nothing says "Welcome" like having your own language/heritage acknowledged. Everyone does what they think is best in a given situation. This is getting painful.[/quote]
I don't seem to recall from history a nationwide deliberate effort to force parishes to perform masses in the native languages for Irish and Italian immigrants. When my ancestors and my wife's ancestors came over, they were expected to learn English. There is something to be said about heritage and celebrating heritage is great, but trying to replicate an entire culture in America is going to tear this country apart. The melting pot has cooled down and people coming to this country are being told that it's okay to not become an American in a cultural sense. My ancestry is predominantly Northern European, but I don't identify as a Northern European, or as a European-American. I'm an American, through and through. Sure, I enjoy a good German beer and pull for the Swedes during the Olympics, but that's about as far as it goes.

Edit: I've obviously forgotten masses used to be performed entirely in Latin, but the point is not lost as homilies were read in the vernacular. Sure there were and still are small enclaves of native speakers, but to interact outside your little group, you'd have to speak English.

Edited by 1337 k4th0l1x0r

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...