reelguy227 Posted April 21, 2008 Posted April 21, 2008 Hey all, I've been thinking about arguments to prove God exists. I'm not doubting my faith or anything, but when I look at counterarguments brought on by scientists, they usually debunk any arguments for God's existence. Primarily those brought on by Aquinas and Aristotle, the so called Cosmological arguments. The reason I'm curious, is that if I should encounter an atheist or what not, I want to be able to give a good argument, not ones that have been debunked already. I still believe in God regardless, I just would like a clearer picture on His existence and reasons for it. So what are some other arguments in support of God's existence? And, if anyone knows any good books to read that are credible, any suggestions would be great. Thanks Ricky
Kitty Posted April 21, 2008 Posted April 21, 2008 I don't think there is any definitive proof that God exists.
goldenchild17 Posted April 21, 2008 Posted April 21, 2008 (edited) [b]Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma - Dr. Ludwig Ott - p. 14, 15[/b] "2. The Possibility of a Proof of God's Existence The Existence of God can be proved by means of causality. (Sent. fidei proxima.) The traditionalists, L. E. Bautain ( 1867) and A. Bonnetty ( 1879), having been reproved by the Teaching Authority of the Church, signed the assertion that reason can with certainty, prove the existence of God. . . Pope Pius X extended the Vatican Definition of the natural knowability of God in the anti-Modernist oath (1910) by the more exact statement, that the existence of God can formally be proved through reason by means of the principle of causality. . . God, the beginning and the end of all things can be known with certainty, by the natural light of reason, as a cause is known by its effects, from those things that are made, that is by the visible works of creation and can equally be demonstrated (to be). D 2145." [b] Denzinger, Sources of Catholic Dogma 2145:[/b] "2145 I . . . firmly embrace and accept all and everything that has been defined, affirmed, and declared by the unerring magisterium of the Church, especially those chief doctrines which are directly opposed to the errors of this time. And first, I profess that God, the beginning and end of all things, can be certainly known and thus can also be demon strafed by the natural light of reason "by the things that are made" [cf. Rom. 1:20], that is, by the visible works of creation, as the cause by the effects. . ." Edited April 21, 2008 by goldenchild17
LouisvilleFan Posted April 21, 2008 Posted April 21, 2008 [quote name='reelguy227' post='1505278' date='Apr 21 2008, 03:49 AM']The reason I'm curious, is that if I should encounter an atheist or what not, I want to be able to give a good argument, not ones that have been debunked already.[/quote] In my conversations with atheists, every argument will be debunked by the mere fact that it's conclusion is that God exists. I think you can make some progress by clarifying the distinction between science and philosphy/religion. Challenge them to provide a reason why Intelligent Design is impossible. I suppose that could be a logical fallacy (proving that something doesn't exist), but in the end God is to be experienced and not proven, and only the experience of God can convert anyone.
ironmonk Posted April 22, 2008 Posted April 22, 2008 Please check these out... all free for download (mp3's)... [url="http://www.peterkreeft.com/audio.htm"]http://www.peterkreeft.com/audio.htm[/url] 8. Arguments for God's Existence — Five classic defenses for believing in God 18. God's Existence — A magnificent overview of the arguments Writings: [url="http://www.peterkreeft.com/featured-writing.htm"]http://www.peterkreeft.com/featured-writing.htm[/url] Can You Prove God Exists? Argument from Design Argument from First Cause Argument from Conscience Argument from History Argument from Pascal's Wager Argument from Desire The Divinity of Christ And.... [b]The Reasons to Believe[/b] In this article, Peter Kreeft outlines the arguments from cause and effect, from conscience, from history, and the argument known as “Pascal's Wager.” [url="http://www.catholiceducation.org/articles/apologetics/ap0002.html"]http://www.catholiceducation.org/articles/...ics/ap0002.html[/url] God is a Fact... proven by philosophy, physics, reason, and history. God Bless, ironmonk
reelguy227 Posted April 24, 2008 Author Posted April 24, 2008 Thanks guys, anyone else have any insight on the subject?
StColette Posted April 24, 2008 Posted April 24, 2008 Aquinas Five Ways The First Way: Argument from Motion Our senses prove that some things are in motion. Things move when potential motion becomes actual motion. Only an actual motion can convert a potential motion into an actual motion. Nothing can be at once in both actuality and potentiality in the same respect (i.e., if both actual and potential, it is actual in one respect and potential in another). Therefore nothing can move itself. Therefore each thing in motion is moved by something else. The sequence of motion cannot extend ad infinitum. Therefore it is necessary to arrive at a first mover, put in motion by no other; and this everyone understands to be God. The Second Way: Argument from Efficient Causes We perceive a series of efficient causes of things in the world. Nothing exists prior to itself. Therefore nothing is the efficient cause of itself. If a previous efficient cause does not exist, neither does the thing that results. Therefore if the first thing in a series does not exist, nothing in the series exists. The series of efficient causes cannot extend ad infinitum into the past, for then there would be no things existing now. Therefore it is necessary to admit a first efficient cause, to which everyone gives the name of God. The Third Way: Argument from Possibility and Necessity (Reductio argument) We find in nature things that are possible to be and not to be, that come into being and go out of being i.e., contingent beings. Assume that every being is a contingent being. For each contingent being, there is a time it does not exist. Therefore it is impossible for these always to exist. Therefore there could have been a time when no things existed. Therefore at that time there would have been nothing to bring the currently existing contingent beings into existence. Therefore, nothing would be in existence now. We have reached an absurd result from assuming that every being is a contingent being. Therefore not every being is a contingent being. Therefore some being exists of its own necessity, and does not receive its existence from another being, but rather causes them. This all men speak of as God. The Fourth Way: Argument from Gradation of Being There is a gradation to be found in things: some are better or worse than others. Predications of degree require reference to the “uttermost” case (e.g., a thing is said to be hotter according as it more nearly resembles that which is hottest). The maximum in any genus is the cause of all in that genus. Therefore there must also be something which is to all beings the cause of their being, goodness, and every other perfection; and this we call God. The Fifth Way: Argument from Design We see that natural bodies work toward some goal, and do not do so by chance. Most natural things lack knowledge. But as an arrow reaches its target because it is directed by an archer, what lacks intelligence achieves goals by being directed by something intelligence. Therefore some intelligent being exists by whom all natural things are directed to their end; and this being we call God. [url="http://www.mnstate.edu/gracyk/courses/web%20publishing/aquinasFiveWays_ArgumentAnalysis.htm"]http://www.mnstate.edu/gracyk/courses/web%...entAnalysis.htm[/url]
MC IMaGiNaZUN Posted April 24, 2008 Posted April 24, 2008 Speaking in terms of logic... When atheists contend the popular cosmological arguements, they are cntending the arguements. They can only shoe the arguements are problematic. Knocking down the arguement does not, therefore, logically show that God does not exist. BTW, people are not won over to love God by reasoning and rationality. Faith is a gift. It is always a mystery whom God will give the gift to. SHALOM Bro Mark
reelguy227 Posted April 25, 2008 Author Posted April 25, 2008 I'm just trying to figure out concrete reasons for God's existence over and above the cosmological arguments, since atheists refute them through scientific methods.
CatherineM Posted April 25, 2008 Posted April 25, 2008 I just go back to the old sage that if you need proof, you have no faith because if you have faith, you need no proof.
reelguy227 Posted April 25, 2008 Author Posted April 25, 2008 Ya, but you can't say that to someone who's an unbeliever, they just won't accept it. You have to beat them at their own game.
Ziggamafu Posted April 25, 2008 Posted April 25, 2008 (edited) I used to be an atheist. Not the "I-was-hurt-by-God-and-now-I'm-trying-to-hurt-Him" kind, but the real deal - and I spread my views via the net and my college newspaper. I was one the atheists that pointed out vulgarities, contradictions, atrocities, and absurdities in the Bible; how so many of the most prominent biblical characters and events (Jesus included) seem to be largely based on earlier myths / religions. I still know most of the arguments and still find many of them valid. Yet I am now a believer. Christ has conquered me. I learned all the reasons not to believe and became an atheist. I learned one reason to believe again and have never let go of it; I want the love in my life to be love, not mere chemical reactions. [i]Every fiber of my being[/i] [b]screams[/b] that there is more to art, music, poetry, conscience, the innate desire for God, human bodies and (especially) love than physical data. If there is no eternal consciousness - no eternal perfection - by which beauty, truth, and love may be discerned as such and judged, then music is noise, art is paint, love is hormones and life is meaningless. I suppose that's reason enough to believe in God for me. I have been debating and dialoguing with atheists for years, now. There are two atheistic errors that absolutely must be eradicated before any progress can be made. First, God is not a space alien. We do not believe that God is a material being, for that would mean that God is just another part of the universe and is himself in need of explaining. Unfortunately, most atheists' primary reason for rejecting God is precisely because they think God is in the same need of explanation as the (rest of the) universe. We must explain what we mean when we say that God is "eternal Spirit" - that spirit is more like an intangible principle and certainly not a tangible "thing". Second, we must admit (and even insist that) the Bible is full of problems and it is to be read theologically when it obviously fails to make sense literally; we must explain the difference between divine inspiration and divine dictation - what we mean when we say that the Bible is inerrant. The atheist sees the Bible as a fairly tedious collection of primitive myths. And certainly, if we are forced to take the Bible as literally inerrant in all instances - rather than only in the areas outlined by the Church - we do run into all sorts of problems. The atheist needs to be reassured that the Bible need not be treated as a science text or even a history text except where the Church explicitly instructs. Once divine inspiration is explained and the theological reading of the Bible is emphasized accordingly, all sorts of interesting things from Scripture may be pointed out that were previously inconsequential to the atheist. The typological, anagogical and mystical uses of Scripture actually spring to life; what was once a dead letter and stumbling block becomes an active pointer to God and even a means by which God's voice may be heard. The atheist must be reassured that in exploring the possibility of faith and especially when studying the Bible, he does not forfeit his use of reason. Finally, atheism is a miserable choice whose negative consequences automatically prove the innate desire for God in every man. The atheist forums in which I participate have, on an almost regular basis, an intelligent atheist who has become suicidal. There is a dark and pathetic humor in watching other atheists scramble to attention, trying to help, and coming up with absolutely no valid motive to prevent the tragedy. Atheism offers absolutely no meaning to life nor motivation to continue living. It is not hard to point this out and use it as proof that Man is wired for God. And of course at that point the argument from desire may be convincingly presented. In summary: 1. Explain what is meant by "spirit" and how it relates to God's causeless Be-ing. 2. Explain what the Bible is and what it isn't and how this relates to the apparent problems in Scripture (Dei Verbum may be of good use, here) 3. Point out the meaninglessness of atheism and how it is contradicted by the use of the terms art, music, love, etc. 4. Demonstrate how this relates to the argument from aesthetic experience and consequently to the argument from desire. Edited April 25, 2008 by Ziggamafu
Ziggamafu Posted April 25, 2008 Posted April 25, 2008 (edited) My last posted focused more on the God of the Bible rather than on his Church; here, briefly, are my reasons for trusting the Church: [b]1. Her testimony[/b] (written in blood and tears, bearing witness to historical miracles throughout the centuries) [b]2. Her accomplishments[/b] (Christendom, the sciences, education, agriculture, music, art, charity, globalized unity in diversity, etc.) [b]3. Her perseverance[/b] (through the most severe of internal and external conflicts) [b]4. Her practical benefits[/b] (the psychological / social value and brilliance of her community and sacraments) [b]5. Her moral superiority[/b] (the moral laws of the Church center around the most perfect and most happy society possible; her laws are more beneficial and brilliant than those of any competitors, least of all atheism, which provides no moral framework - or motivation for one - whatsoever.) As for #1: I would add that I am a member of the Blue Army for good reason; Our Lady of Fatima obtained a very great and convincing miracle for world. As for #2: For goodness sake, read Tom Woods' [i]How the Catholic Church Built Western Civilization[/i]. As for #3: For goodness sake, read a good Church history text! Edited April 25, 2008 by Ziggamafu
Paladin D Posted April 25, 2008 Posted April 25, 2008 Wow. Extremely insightful stuff, [b]Ziggamafu[/b]! Thank you for taking the time in sharing your experience with us.
Ziggamafu Posted April 26, 2008 Posted April 26, 2008 [quote name='Paladin D' post='1509472' date='Apr 25 2008, 10:50 AM']Wow. Extremely insightful stuff, [b]Ziggamafu[/b]! Thank you for taking the time in sharing your experience with us.[/quote] Coming from you, that means a lot! Thanks! I would also add that (in regards to the Church), the lives of the saints testify to each of the points mentioned.
reelguy227 Posted April 27, 2008 Author Posted April 27, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Ziggamafu' post='1510459' date='Apr 26 2008, 01:24 PM'] Coming from you, that means a lot! Thanks! I would also add that (in regards to the Church), the lives of the saints testify to each of the points mentioned.[/quote] Another thing that Atheists and scientists alike could never answer was how the universe was brought into being, what came before the big bang, what actually started that large explosion that created all matter in the universe of today. That's the hooker for me, that there must have been something that started this vast universe of ours, because if it had a start, it obviously didn't appear out of nothing, something had to have started it. If there was nothing before the big bang, than there should be nothing now, obviously the big bang couldn't have started itself. So God must have been that starter. I find it funny that atheists never ever really answer this question when referring to the beginning of time and space...it's like they're almost scared to. That's my two cents...thanks Ziggamafu, anyone else? Edited April 27, 2008 by reelguy227
goldenchild17 Posted April 27, 2008 Posted April 27, 2008 [quote name='Ziggamafu' post='1509349' date='Apr 25 2008, 05:51 AM']Second, we must admit (and even insist that) the Bible is full of problems[/quote] Sorry, definitely lost me after this one. But I suppose that is a whole different debate.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now