Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

South Park


Recommended Posts

Theologian in Training
Posted (edited)

So, I rarely ever watch South Park, but last year, when I was visiting my brother in Utah, he was watching this episode, which I thought very appropriate given where I was, and the museum I had visited earlier that day. Apparently, I have to come to find out that a lot of what South Park depicted was pretty accurate.

give it a look [url="http://www.i4m.com/think/southpark/"]http://www.i4m.com/think/southpark/[/url]

Edited by Theologian in Training
Posted

It's bound to be more accurate than the episode they did on Catholics where the Vatican was ruled by a large spider.

Theologian in Training
Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1505625' date='Apr 21 2008, 02:27 PM']It's bound to be more accurate than the episode they did on Catholics where the Vatican was ruled by a large spider.[/quote]

Perhaps, because it is so outlandish and as thus impossible to take serious, but I actually LOL when I read this...

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1505625' date='Apr 21 2008, 02:27 PM']It's bound to be more accurate than the episode they did on Catholics where the Vatican was ruled by a large spider.[/quote]

I think that episode was supposed to be so ridiculous and outlandish, that you would just throw your hands up and not care.

Posted

It made me throw something alright.

Guest sbros89
Posted

When I saw that episode it made me laugh alot, but I was also wondering if that was a true religion.

Farsight one
Posted

Yes, it's fairly accurate. I'm not sure about the accuracy of Joseph Smith's reason for not re-translating that one text. Other than that, it's pretty spot on. Though this is stuff that they don't typically teach to new members or those with interest in it.

As a Catholic, you ought to know how frustrating it is to be misrepresented(such as in the case of Jack Chick), so be careful how you might explain these things to others. Mormons are at least as much misrepresented as us.

Posted

South Park was only funny back when they would do satire of people. These days the episodes are all about how much sex, blood, and grossness can we get away with in each episodes. Bleep'n sellouts.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

Here is another weird cartoon presentation of Mormon mythology.

[url="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zy0d1HbItOo"]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zy0d1HbItOo[/url]

Madame Vengier
Posted

Best SP ep ever (dealing with religion) is the one where Tom Cruise and John Travolta get stuck in the closet. Brazilliant. It completely blasts Scientology.

Best SP ep ever in general: When Cartman gets an anal probe by space aliens. That's going waaaaaaay back to Season One.

Believe it or not there ARE actually some SP eps that are not mortally offensive. The SP guys actually do some eps with really good social commentary. Another brilliant one was with Al Gore and Manbearpig. I love that one. Especially when Cartman eats all the fake treasure.

But there are some that are so offensive I have to just turn it off.

ardillacid
Posted

[quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1516960' date='May 2 2008, 09:36 PM']Best SP ep ever (dealing with religion) is the one where Tom Cruise and John Travolta get stuck in the closet. Brazilliant. It completely blasts Scientology[/quote]
I disagree. The super-adventure club does a much better job mocking scientology than the Tom Cruise episode. It has way more venom and mockery and better jokes than the tom cruise episode.

Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='notardillacid' post='1517099' date='May 3 2008, 05:33 AM']I disagree. The super-adventure club does a much better job mocking scientology than the Tom Cruise episode. It has way more venom and mockery and better jokes than the tom cruise episode.[/quote]

I have no idea what the super-adventure club is. Is it Southpark? Because I was talking about Southpark.

ardillacid
Posted

Yeah, it is another south park episode making fun of scientology. Another one indirectly mocking them is the David Blane episode.

Galloglasses
Posted

Look up SP on Wikipedia, all the main characters are Catholic, (except the Jewish kid, I ALWAYS mix up their names, he's the one wearing the snazzy green hat), on the episode making fun of Catholicism, it actually BLASTS Athiesm, the episode was concerning the priestly scandals and all the parents of SP become Athiest and agnostic, and all begin to talk about how religion hurts their children while, literally, defacating from their mouths and a news reporter states that throwing up your do-do and eating your food through your rear was actually much helathier for you then eating it the naturally way. Actually, it had alot more venom for athiesm then it did for Catholicism. Especially the Richard Dawkins 2-part episodes which I really LOL'd at.

The Mormonism and Scientology episodes, wow, the SP guys REALLY disliked them. The guy who voiced chef quit because he was a scientologist and one of the later episodes made fun of him over it.

Also, the episode where it makes fun of the Da Vinci Code puts Pope Bennedict XVI in a rather good light, yet blasts the leader of the Catholic League of America and the Papacy itself, (I think it does because it shows Jesus Killing the 'New' Pope in Matrix fashion. that and the bunny on the throne of Peter was just rediculous. but I haven't analysed it properly)

Also, throughout this whole thing Jesus lives in a house on the outskirts of South Park, which, ironically, seems like the 'Elephant-in-the-middle-of-the-room' analogy.

/nerd-who-remembers-stuff-he-saw-YEARS-ago-when-he-really-should-have-forgotten-it-years-ago

Posted

I was actually partying with a Mormon kid the other night (who was drinking copious amounts of liquor). Earlier in life, I quasi-dated a Mormon (who wouldn't defile his pure temple with chocolate). One of them was lying (and neither were particularly attractive <_<).

Anyway, I remember that SP episode and just LoLing the entire time...

Galloglasses
Posted

Joeseph Smith was a prophet,
dum-dum-dum-de-dum

Posted

Producer/Creator/Writer/Actor Trey Parker grew up Mormon and his personal feelings are represented in both live-action films [b]Cannibal: The Musical [/b]and [b]Orgasmo[/b].

Posted

[quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1516960' date='May 2 2008, 10:36 PM']Best SP ep ever (dealing with religion) is the one where Tom Cruise and John Travolta get stuck in the closet. Brazilliant. It completely blasts Scientology.

Best SP ep ever in general: When Cartman gets an anal probe by space aliens. That's going waaaaaaay back to Season One.

Believe it or not there ARE actually some SP eps that are not mortally offensive. The SP guys actually do some eps with really good social commentary. Another brilliant one was with Al Gore and Manbearpig. I love that one. Especially when Cartman eats all the fake treasure.

But there are some that are so offensive I have to just turn it off.[/quote]

"Mom Tom Cruise won't come out of the closet!"

What a beautiful episode, especially when Stan finds out it's all a scam and everyone goes lawsuit happy on him.

Posted

I swa the episode in question about the mormons and comedy aside and all I didn't enjoy it. I found it to be somewhat disrespectful of mormons.

they may be incorrect in several ways, and what they believe may seem ridiculous; but to an atheist eye they are at equal par to the virgin conception for example. The ridicule they extend to the mormons is one and the same as the ridicule they send towards catholics.

I felt sympathy for mormons as I watched the episode.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1516960' date='May 2 2008, 10:36 PM']Best SP ep ever (dealing with religion) is the one where Tom Cruise and John Travolta get stuck in the closet. Brazilliant. It completely blasts Scientology.

Best SP ep ever in general: When Cartman gets an anal probe by space aliens. That's going waaaaaaay back to Season One.

Believe it or not there ARE actually some SP eps that are not mortally offensive. The SP guys actually do some eps with really good social commentary. Another brilliant one was with Al Gore and Manbearpig. I love that one. Especially when Cartman eats all the fake treasure.

But there are some that are so offensive I have to just turn it off.[/quote]

I agree with you, Madame. South Park is probably my favorite show on television. I really enjoy the biting sarcasm and the peepee-poopoo humor. The sex stuff can be much and the depiction of some of the liberal social views can be pretty intense (the Christopher Reeves-stem cell episode comes to mind); however, overall, the political and social commentary is usually fairly equitable.

Best episode with politics-- The 9/11 Conspiracy Episode (...duke in the urinal....classic)
Best episode with religion-- Tom Cruise "trapped in the closet" episode
Best episode with social commentary-- Tie between the World of Warcraft and the Imaginationland Trilogy
Best episode in general-- The one where Cartman fights the midget!

[quote name='notardillacid' post='1517099' date='May 3 2008, 07:33 AM']I disagree. The super-adventure club does a much better job mocking scientology than the Tom Cruise episode. It has way more venom and mockery and better jokes than the tom cruise episode.[/quote]

I just enjoy how Chef poops when he dies....HILARIOUS!

[quote name='Galloglasses' post='1517509' date='May 3 2008, 07:32 PM']Look up SP on Wikipedia, all the main characters are Catholic, (except the Jewish kid, I ALWAYS mix up their names, he's the one wearing the snazzy green hat), on the episode making fun of Catholicism, it actually BLASTS Athiesm, the episode was concerning the priestly scandals and all the parents of SP become Athiest and agnostic, and all begin to talk about how religion hurts their children while, literally, defacating from their mouths and a news reporter states that throwing up your do-do and eating your food through your rear was actually much helathier for you then eating it the naturally way. Actually, it had alot more venom for athiesm then it did for Catholicism. Especially the Richard Dawkins 2-part episodes which I really LOL'd at.

The Mormonism and Scientology episodes, wow, the SP guys REALLY disliked them. The guy who voiced chef quit because he was a scientologist and one of the later episodes made fun of him over it.

Also, the episode where it makes fun of the Da Vinci Code puts Pope Bennedict XVI in a rather good light, yet blasts the leader of the Catholic League of America and the Papacy itself, (I think it does because it shows Jesus Killing the 'New' Pope in Matrix fashion. that and the bunny on the throne of Peter was just rediculous. but I haven't analysed it properly)

Also, throughout this whole thing Jesus lives in a house on the outskirts of South Park, which, ironically, seems like the 'Elephant-in-the-middle-of-the-room' analogy.

/nerd-who-remembers-stuff-he-saw-YEARS-ago-when-he-really-should-have-forgotten-it-years-ago[/quote]

Yeah, I always feel uncomfortable with the Catholic episodes because they're usually pretty instense. The one with the bleeding Virgin Mary statue was bad...and the one with the pedophile priests was less so. I found nothing wrong with the Da Vinci Code one. It was a funny concept that I don't think was too offensive. I didn't like how they made Pope Benedict out to be a chump, though (wasn't he supposed to be the "German Shepherd?").

All in all, I find they are pretty equal with all of their bashing of religions, Islam included. Some people will say that just because they make fun of everyone, doesn't make it right.

[quote name='Didacus' post='1521487' date='May 7 2008, 05:07 PM']I swa the episode in question about the mormons and comedy aside and all I didn't enjoy it. I found it to be somewhat disrespectful of mormons.

they may be incorrect in several ways, and what they believe may seem ridiculous; but to an atheist eye they are at equal par to the virgin conception for example. The ridicule they extend to the mormons is one and the same as the ridicule they send towards catholics.

I felt sympathy for mormons as I watched the episode.[/quote]

Yup. I can see this point....



.....but I still LOVE South Park.

Edited by kujo

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...