cappie Posted April 22, 2008 Posted April 22, 2008 The head of the schismatic Society of St Pius X says that "nothing has changed" in Rome's determination to follow Vatican II despite Pope Benedict's recent re-authorisation of the Tridentine Mass. "The time for an agreement has not yet come," SSPX head Bishop Bernard Fellay wrote in a letter to the society’s members, published in French last Saturday by the SSPX information service DICI, Catholic News Agency reports. Some commentators had interpreted Pope Benedict's permission last year for broader use of the Tridentine Latin Mass as a gesture to the SSPX seeking its reunion with the Church. But Bishop Tremblay said the liberalisation of the old Latin Mass was "not accompanied by logically co-related measures in the other areas of the life of the Church". "Nothing has changed in Rome's determination to follow the Council's orientation, despite 40 years of crisis, despite the deserted convents, abandoned rectories and empty churches." "Catholic universities persist in their ramblings, teaching of the Catechism remains unknown and Catholic school does not exist anymore as particularly Catholic. They have become an extinct species," Bishop Fellay wrote.
CatherineM Posted April 22, 2008 Posted April 22, 2008 Pope Benedict was obviously willing to compromise, but I guess they aren't. I'm not sure that Vatican II caused the convents to empty out, or that reverting to pre-Vatican II church would refill them, but I do agree that Catholic schools aren't as Catholic as they were when I was a kid. I also agree that far too many Catholics aren't properly catechized.
cappie Posted April 22, 2008 Author Posted April 22, 2008 Bishop Fellay Says No: The Scandal Continues Posted Apr. 22, 2008 3:20 PM || by Dr. Jeff Mirus Bishop Bernard Fellay, the schismatic and excommunicated head of the Society of St. Pius X, has stated that Pope Benedict XVI’s Summorum Pontificum, which mandated wider use of the 1962 Roman Missal, is not nearly enough to bring about a reconciliation between the SSPX and the Holy See. This is exactly the same, of course, as stating that his group will not reconcile with the Catholic Church. It’s a continuing scandal. Bishop Fellay states that nothing has really changed under Benedict, because what he regards as the doctrinal deficiencies of the Church have not been corrected (see SSPX leader rejects hopes for reconciliation with Rome). Specifically, Bishop Fellay rejects Vatican II’s teaching that the one true church of Christ “subsists in” the Catholic Church, insisting on the word “is” instead of “subsists in”, no matter how many times the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith explains to him what the expression means. He also rejects Vatican II’s teaching on religious liberty, a freedom to which, one can only presume, Bishop Fellay believes people have no right. Let’s pause on this point for a moment, for Catholics emphasizing the need to combat error used to be very fond of stating that “error has no rights”. I grant that even if all Catholics understood that expression today, they would be reluctant to make it their slogan. But we might at least expect those who are still fond of saying it to know what it means. In my experience this is generally not the case with members of the SSPX, who imagine that the modern emphasis on religious liberty violates some long-standing teaching of the Church. Surely rights come from God, for they are invested by Him in the very nature of the things He has created. And surely God imparts no positive right to any person to adhere to error. But what does this mean? All it means is that nobody can rightly claim to reject truth and deliberately adhere to error as a matter of personal right. But all persons have the right to be free of coercion in their beliefs. And so they may be permitted to live unmolested in an error, not because they have a personal right in God’s eyes to adhere to what is false even when they know what is true, but simply because they have a right in God’s eyes to be free of human coercion in forming their religious beliefs. Let me get at this another way: If I am wrong about anything significant, I hope to be able to explain to God at the Judgement that I held my error because I believed it to be true. But I equally hope I would not be so foolish as to try to tell God that, though I knew what was true and what He wanted me to believe, I elected to exercise the right He had given me to adhere to a more delightful error instead. It is precisely in this sense that error has no rights. It is astonishing that this is still a sticking point for Traditionalists today, especially in view of the problems with Islam, a religion whose political adherents frequently exercise coercion in religion, and in view of Pope Benedict’s stellar effort to get Muslims to think deeply about the freedom required by reason with regard to religious assent. This freedom is necessary to the very nature of belief; it derives, like all rights, from how human nature was designed. The problems we face with Islam should be sufficient to shock Bishop Fellay and his followers into thinking again about what all this means, and into expending a greater effort to reconcile any confusing Magisterial texts on the subject. In truth, all apparent contradictions between later and earlier statements of the Magisterium on this point have long since been thoroughly explained in the usual way: by seeking an understanding which is compatible with every inspiration of the Holy Spirit in both Scripture and the Magisterium on each given topic, and conversely by resolutely refusing to accept any facile understanding of a particular Magisterial statement which would force us to reject the clear meaning of another such statement. Many Traditionalists, including many former adherents of the Society of St. Pius X, have paved the way for Bishop Fellay by freely admitting that this is so, and by seeking the very reconciliation with the Church which Bishop Fellay so roundly rejects. Thus was the Priestly Fraternity of Saint Peter formed with pontifical approval in 1988, the Personal Apostolic Administration of Saint John Mary Vianney in 2002, and the Good Shepherd Community in 2006. It is worth noting that some very traditional Catholics never left the fold at all, finding deep spiritual fulfillment in the Institute of Christ the King Sovereign Priest beginning in 1990. But Bishop Fellay announces he “cannot sign an agreement” with the Holy See. In other words, he cannot accept the authority of the Successor of Peter. In other words, he does not choose to be in communion with the Church of Christ. This may not be grounds for coercsion, but it really is a continuing scandal.
goldenchild17 Posted April 22, 2008 Posted April 22, 2008 I left a comment for Dr. Mirus on his blog regarding this article. I would be interested to see if he replies.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted April 23, 2008 Posted April 23, 2008 Despite the fact that he probably would not have ordered a cheesesteak during Communion at Nationals Stadium last week, he should still consider that the Pope has a better understanding of traditional liturgy than any SSPXer.
goldenchild17 Posted April 23, 2008 Posted April 23, 2008 (edited) I'm not so sure the liturgy is AS MUCH the problem any more. The SSPX has acknowledged the Motu Proprio. As a matter of fact they recently have closed down their church in Moscow, Russia and have told their former parishioners to go back to the parishes in communion with Rome, where it's available. Granted it may not mean a full-out endorsement, but it is notable considering we have a CMRI mass in the area. It's more so the religious liberty and "subsistit in" that they are struggling with. Edited April 23, 2008 by goldenchild17
jeffpugh Posted April 23, 2008 Posted April 23, 2008 (edited) In response to OP, I'd like to know is how the SSPX Chapels are doing. How about their vocations? Are their pews full? Or is it "The Holy See's fault" again... grr Edited April 23, 2008 by Sacred Music Man
goldenchild17 Posted April 23, 2008 Posted April 23, 2008 [quote name='Sacred Music Man' post='1507121' date='Apr 22 2008, 09:41 PM']In response to OP, I'd like to know is how the SSPX Chapels are doing. How about their vocations? Are their pews full? Or is it "The Holy See's fault" again... grr[/quote] 65 priests, 2 deacons, 11 brothers, 63 seminarians, 24 sisters, 850 Third Order members, 103 chapels, 18 priories, 3 houses of formation, 4 retreat houses, 25 schools & 1 college, 1 publishing house: Angelus Press That's for the USA, I don't know the numbers worldwide, but they have a strong presence outside the US, especially with their main center in Europe.
jeffpugh Posted April 23, 2008 Posted April 23, 2008 That's great... but... is that good? 2 deacons? doesn't it take that many for a TLM? lawl... (I know the answer... my sarcasm is attempting to take the mic tonite)
goldenchild17 Posted April 23, 2008 Posted April 23, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Sacred Music Man' post='1507133' date='Apr 22 2008, 10:03 PM']That's great... but... is that good? 2 deacons? doesn't it take that many for a TLM? lawl... (I know the answer... my sarcasm is attempting to take the mic tonite)[/quote] I dunno. For one order I'd say that's pretty decent considering they have to do their own fundraising, but we're looking at it from two different directions so I guess it could be seen either way. As far as outside the US, I don't have individual numbers but they have their General House in Switzerland. Seminaries in the US, Switzerland, Germany, Argentina, France, Australia and the Philippines. District headquarters in in Gabon, Kenya, South Africa and Zimbabwe in Africa; Singapore and the Philippines in Asia; Australia; Toronto Ontario, Canada; Austria, Belgium/Luxembourg, France, Germany, Great Britain, Ireland, Italy, the Netherlands, Spain/Portugal, and Switzerland in Europe. and houses in India, Mexico, and and South America. Edited April 23, 2008 by goldenchild17
jeffpugh Posted April 23, 2008 Posted April 23, 2008 I'm sorta mad at them... how do they spread so fast without the church? How do they HOLD TOGETHER without the Church? guh... the mysteries of life...
Laudate_Dominum Posted April 23, 2008 Posted April 23, 2008 63 seminarians for one religious society in one country! Not bad at all. I hope and pray that the SSPX will be fully reconciled with Rome soon. And SSM, even if they are in schism I suppose they do have Peter as the principle of unity since they swear by the dogmas of the Church and the teachings of the Popes, just not post-Vatican II stuff. haha. They're an interesting lot anyway. [quote]Specifically, Bishop Fellay rejects Vatican II’s teaching that the one true church of Christ “subsists in” the Catholic Church, insisting on the word “is” instead of “subsists in”, no matter how many times the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith explains to him what the expression means. He also rejects Vatican II’s teaching on religious liberty, a freedom to which, one can only presume, Bishop Fellay believes people have no right.[/quote] I can understand the desire for clarification on these somewhat ambiguous and perhaps problematic aspects of the Vatican II documents, but I can't help but think that the real issues here are deeper. I have to pause and wonder what Bishop Fellay is really all about. All those souls under his care and he's going to turn his back on the Pope because of some esoteric quibbles? Get real man! I don't see Pope Benedict running around saying that error is equal to the truth or that Catholicism is just another denomination. Sheesh, we don't even call Protestant ecclesial communities 'churches' in the 'new church.' hehe I am inclined to agree with the author of that article on this. Those issues have been dealt with to my satisfaction but of course I have never considered them to be show stoppers as far as acceptance of the Pope is concerned. Quite frankly I've come to appreciate the wisdom of those Vatican II teachings. Maybe I'm a Neo-cath, 'New Church', modernist? Although to be fair I must assume that Bp. Fellay's issues are more complicated than that article would suggest. It is hardly an objective presentation of Fellay's stance. I just wish that the society could work for the cause of tradition from within the Church and not in this adversarial and suspicious way.
goldenchild17 Posted April 23, 2008 Posted April 23, 2008 [quote name='Sacred Music Man' post='1507158' date='Apr 22 2008, 10:31 PM']I'm sorta mad at them... how do they spread so fast without the church? How do they HOLD TOGETHER without the Church? guh... the mysteries of life...[/quote] yeah their success annoys me a little bit since the CMRI hasn't done quite as well just yet, but it's a good annoying feel for me.
goldenchild17 Posted April 23, 2008 Posted April 23, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1507193' date='Apr 22 2008, 11:04 PM']63 seminarians for one religious society in one country! Not bad at all. I hope and pray that the SSPX will be fully reconciled with Rome soon. And SSM, even if they are in schism I suppose they do have Peter as the principle of unity since they swear by the dogmas of the Church and the teachings of the Popes, just not post-Vatican II stuff. haha. They're an interesting lot anyway. I can understand the desire for clarification on these somewhat ambiguous and perhaps problematic aspects of the Vatican II documents, but I can't help but think that the real issues here are deeper. I have to pause and wonder what Bishop Fellay is really all about. All those souls under his care and he's going to turn his back on the Pope because of some esoteric quibbles? Get real man! I don't see Pope Benedict running around saying that error is equal to the truth or that Catholicism is just another denomination. Sheesh, we don't even call Protestant ecclesial communities 'churches' in the 'new church.' hehe I am inclined to agree with the author of that article on this. Those issues have been dealt with to my satisfaction but of course I have never considered them to be show stoppers as far as acceptance of the Pope is concerned. Quite frankly I've come to appreciate the wisdom of those Vatican II teachings. Maybe I'm a Neo-cath, 'New Church', modernist? Although to be fair I must assume that Bp. Fellay's issues are more complicated than that article would suggest. It is hardly an objective presentation of Fellay's stance. I just wish that the society could work for the cause of tradition from within the Church and not in this adversarial and suspicious way.[/quote] I dunno, I can understand it. It's probably the biggest (or at least right at the top of the list) stumbling-block overall for myself as well. That's actually the passage I sent the comment to Dr. Mirus about. But it should be interesting to see how things play out. Edited April 23, 2008 by goldenchild17
goldenchild17 Posted April 23, 2008 Posted April 23, 2008 (edited) double post Edited April 23, 2008 by goldenchild17
Laudate_Dominum Posted April 23, 2008 Posted April 23, 2008 [quote name='goldenchild17' post='1507224' date='Apr 22 2008, 11:43 PM']I dunno, I can understand it. It's probably the biggest (or at least right at the top of the list) stumbling-block overall for myself as well. That's actually the passage I sent the comment to Dr. Mirus about. But it should be interesting to see how things play out.[/quote] Cool bro. Sorry if I trivialized an issue that is very important to some people. It would be interesting to hear what Bishop Fellay has to say from his own mouth instead of second hand from a critical article. At the very least I think that the SSPX shows that an emphasis on traditional liturgy and the hierarchical priesthood does foster serious vocations. I'm hoping that there will be greater continuity with tradition and orthopraxy (as well as orthodoxy of course) in the Church at large which will help form future generations of priests. If the SSPX could truly be reconciled with Rome I believe they could bear a lot of fruit within the Church. Perhaps it will take decades and a change in leadership.. Or maybe they will become more radical and distant.. Oremus I suppose.
goldenchild17 Posted April 23, 2008 Posted April 23, 2008 no it's cool, but you're right I would be interested to hear more from the bishop himself instead of trying to interpret everything. His most recent letter from April 8 is online. That's probably the one Dr. Mirus used for his article. I can send you a link if you haven't read it yet, or just go to the "what's new" section their site.
goldenchild17 Posted April 23, 2008 Posted April 23, 2008 (edited) maybe if you have some free time you can stop by the other forum where we have the sede thread and see if you can help me understand it the way you do, because that's one of the things we're on, well moreso the 'subsistit in' phrase right now. peace Edited April 23, 2008 by goldenchild17
puellapaschalis Posted April 23, 2008 Posted April 23, 2008 Could we perhaps have some links to these articles? I'd like to show them to others but I'm not going to send on a link to Phatmass as a source. My only experience with SSPX so far are a priest in Belgium and some enthusiasts in this country. They descended upon a forum and created hell - being judgemental, putting people down, writing posts that would have induced a tl;dr reaction in Methuselah and then getting snippy when asked to be...well, a bit nicer to people.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now