Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

My Debate With James Mccarthy


Recommended Posts

thessalonian
Posted

Here it is.

[url="http://www.kkmslive.com/MP3/15041808-James%20McCarthy.MP3"]http://www.kkmslive.com/MP3/15041808-James%20McCarthy.MP3[/url]

I called in about 1/3 of the way through scripture and remained on for quite some time.

If nothing else I kept him from talking more. I would like to have been more prepared but he kind of impromptu asked me to be on. Give me the good, the bad, and the ugly comments. As I said over in open mic they asked me to be on again and if I am going to do it I must be accountable.

Also remember that I knew I had limited time. There are tons of things I could have said but didn't have the time. The first caller was funny because he said I kept going back to James. I only mentioned it once and wish I could have responded because I wanted to re-emphasize romans 2:4-8 so that he couldn't wiggle out by dispensationalism

Thanks folks

God bless

Posted

I thought you did alright. I would have liked to hear you ask the more pointed questions, rather than just answer the Prots. At one point it sounded like you stumped them, so they went to a commercial. :)

When it comes to faith-alone, I really try to get them to admit that salvation depends on at least one "work" - that is, the initial prayer for salvation. This of course compromises the whole doctrine, which is the fun part. I also try to get them to admit that there is a Law of Christ (the new law, which reaffirms the Decalogue) and a Law of Moses (the old law). When you follow up by questioning which works of the law are being condemned in the NT, you get to enjoy a stunned expression.

For scriptural support for communion of the saints, I always turn to Hebrews 12, which clearly tells us that by the blood of Christ, we have not only gained access to the Father but also all of Heaven. McCarthy clearly demonstrated his ignorance of Catholic doctrine when we provided the infantile rational of a saint's intercession requiring omni-everything. I would respond to that by pointing out Heaven's transcendence of time/space, along with the perfected soul's biblically apparent abilities.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted
:lol:

Oh man, haha.. Yikes.. Painful show to listen to because of all the asinine comments. Nice job thessalonian.
Posted

My favorite line:

"If you take Catholicism seriously, and some people do...."

lol

Posted

I kinda wish you would have clarified a little bit more on praying to Mary. They seemed to equate praying with worshipping and implied that since we pray to her we worship her. Perhaps you could have differentiated among dulia, hyperdulia, and latria.

Overall you rocked 'em, nice job!

Archaeology cat
Posted

[quote name='notardillacid' post='1510492' date='Apr 26 2008, 06:40 PM']My favorite line:

"If you take Catholicism seriously, and some people do...."

lol[/quote]
That was my favourite line, too. :lol:

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1506943' date='Apr 22 2008, 05:51 PM']Give me the good, the bad, and the ugly comments. As I said over in open mic they asked me to be on again and if I am going to do it I must be accountable.[/quote]
I thought you did a great job but since you desire some constructive criticism I would say that you were weakest on the Marian issue. Maybe you could work on your Marian apologetics before being on the show again since they may try to zero in on this issue to try and trip you up.
Your disposition was great and your verse slanging was quite good on the salvation topic even if they evaded your points quite a bit.

I noticed that after you gave a strong presentation of Catholic teaching and pretty much undermined their caricatures they went to a break and then came back with the old barrage tactic to make sure you weren't making any listeners question their rejection of Catholicism. I would have been tempted to give it right back in a list of problems and absurdities in Protestantism but I believe your approach was more constructive. Plus if you had turned the focus onto Protestantism they probably wouldn't have invited you back. haha.

That is so typical though - when these professional anti-Catholics engage a Catholic who can actually defend the faith they will just spew out a bunch of red herrings knowing full well that you couldn't possibly address all the issues in the amount of time available. It is a pretty cheap tactic. They also have the advantage in that they always get the first move and you are always the one on the defensive. They hardly even presented their beliefs and much less were they in the position of defending their beliefs. I doubt those two hosts even believe the same thing and I'm sure those Protestant callers have some wild beliefs. haha. As long as it isn't Catholicism I guess it is okay. lol.

I will say that throughout the show a recurring theme in my mind was to consider that things they were condemning ("unbiblical Catholic errors") were most often universal features of historical Christian belief prior to the Protestant reformation. Some of the doctrines that they criticized as unbiblical Catholic nonsense were things believed by such men as Martin Luther and/or Jean Calvin.
Perhaps it is not your style but I would be inclined to put them on the defensive for a change. Within Christianity, generally speaking, popular Protestantism is the ultimate tradition of men; and for being the self-proclaimed bearers of pristine Biblical truth they are perhaps the most unbiblical bunch. Even compared with world religions in general I would say it is one of the most banal, superficial and ugly religions of all time. In my opinion it is only relevant, interesting and compelling insofar as it resembles Catholicism.
If the popular Protestant traditions were the extent of Christianity I’d probably be inclined to side with Schopenhauer, Feuerbach, Nietzsche, et al. To be fair there are certainly some worthwhile Protestant theologians, I'm speaking of the Protestantism of the rabble.

thessalonian
Posted

Thanks for your responses guys. I will take your input in to consideration the next time I do things like this. I do wish I had been able to stay on a bit more and answer some of that last caller. The marian apologetics would have hit it over the fence on that guy. Also keep in mind that I did have a limited amount of time in order to make only a small part of the case. I could have talked the whole program. I did note one period of time where Mr. McCarthy was shut out by a rather long segment in which I tallked with Jeff about works. That made me smile. I am working on a blog to fill in the gaps.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...