thessalonian Posted April 23, 2008 Posted April 23, 2008 Steve Gregg claims that the Francisicans were historicists like Luther and the early reformers. Anybody know any thing about this. He puts the categories as historicists, pretorists, futurists, and idealists. I actually think that Catholicism is kind of a mix of all of them. Thoughts?
CatherineM Posted April 24, 2008 Posted April 24, 2008 My spiritual director is a Franciscan. She's mostly a curmudgeon. She's a missionary, so if I had to pigeon hole her, she's an idealist. She's in trouble with her mother superior a lot, so she may not be the best Franciscan either.
LouisvilleFan Posted April 24, 2008 Posted April 24, 2008 Well, whichever one is correct... Catholicism is that one. With the help of wikipedia to tell me what historicism is, yeah, I think it only makes sense unless you're some endtimes looney. I've never heard anything about Franciscans of any time holding to a particular eschatological theory. I do know there used be a strong debate between Franciscans and Dominicans about whether the Incarnation was part of God's plan before the Fall. In other words, we know Jesus is eternal and always had a dual human-divine nature, but would he have come to earth if there were no need to save us from sin? Of course, I don't remember which side the two orders were on in this debate.
CatherineM Posted April 24, 2008 Posted April 24, 2008 I don't remember which side each was on either, but I did just read something about it during the Council of Trent. The bishops were trying so hard to keep one or the other from leaving in schism, that they went kind of wishy-washy on some stuff. Went through so much during the last month with term papers and studying for final exams that I wouldn't even know where to begin looking for the reference.
thessalonian Posted April 24, 2008 Author Posted April 24, 2008 Honestly I don't think any of them were on either side. The views in Catholicism are not neccessarily contradictory and that a franciscan may have written an idealist article that does not mean he denies the other views. Same thing with the Jesuit that wrote a futurist article. We say in the Mass Christ has dies (preterist) Christ is risen (historician) Christ will come again (futurist) and gleen moralist (idealist) views from scripture all the time.
LouisvilleFan Posted April 24, 2008 Posted April 24, 2008 True... all of this is basically in the realm of speculation. What's important isn't the conclusion, but the thinking and theology used to get there.
Apotheoun Posted April 25, 2008 Posted April 25, 2008 [quote name='thessalonian' post='1507708' date='Apr 23 2008, 03:45 PM']Steve Gregg claims that the Francisicans were historicists like Luther and the early reformers. Anybody know any thing about this. He puts the categories as historicists, pretorists, futurists, and idealists. I actually think that Catholicism is kind of a mix of all of them. Thoughts?[/quote] I don't really subscribe to any of the eschatological theories. When the parousia happens it happens.
CatherineM Posted April 25, 2008 Posted April 25, 2008 That's how I feel about it too. I just hope I'm wearing clean underwear.
Paddington Posted April 26, 2008 Posted April 26, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1509181' date='Apr 25 2008, 01:16 AM']That's how I feel about it too. I just hope I'm wearing clean underwear.[/quote] Silly-head!
Laudate_Dominum Posted April 26, 2008 Posted April 26, 2008 [quote name='thessalonian' post='1507708' date='Apr 23 2008, 04:45 PM']Steve Gregg claims that the Francisicans were historicists like Luther and the early reformers. Anybody know any thing about this. He puts the categories as historicists, pretorists, futurists, and idealists. I actually think that Catholicism is kind of a mix of all of them. Thoughts?[/quote] Ha! I think lumping all Franciscans together in one neat category is the first mistake. There was a good bit of apocalypticism in the air during the time of Saint Francis and one can find trends and ideas in early Franciscan writings that could be labeled “historicist” although I don’t think that terminology is entirely appropriate. Saint Bonaventure is quite fond of invoking prophetic words from Daniel and Revelation in his narratives on the life of Saint Francis... I'd say there was a good bit of historicism involved in the Joachim of Fiore fad that was popular among many early Franciscans. This statement just rubs me the wrong way though: "the Franciscans were historicists like Luther and the early reformers." Um… No. The fad of applying prophetic passages to events of the day or hagiographical accounts can be found a good bit earlier than this and I would be quite hesitant to say that it is Protestant historicism in anything but a superficial analogous sense. Lumping "the Franciscans" together with Luther and the early reformers is a bit silly too. One might find uses of the prophetic books reminiscent of Luther among the Spirituals but the differences between these men and Luther is more striking than such a banal and vague similarity. I would say it is similarly misleading to force Franciscans (early or otherwise) into this historicist category since it is too general, anachronistic and wholly inadequate in describing what Franciscan theologians have actually taught over the centuries. I’ll invoke the name of Bonaventure once again as an example. Bonaventure’s exegetical method and theology of history are way outside the scope of what is typically meant by historicist eschatology. It would take some radical superficiality to read a few early Franciscan anti-Papal polemics (such as Jacopone da Todi’s lovely poems in honor of Pope Boniface VIII *sarcasm*), or a few early references to the “Whore of Babylon” rhetoric, and conclude that the early Franciscans “were historicists like Luther.” I guess there is something mildly interesting here; I’ve never really given it much thought. Although I must say, my instincts tell me that this is ultimately asinine. I'm not sure who this Steve Gregg fellow is but I am inclined to think that he is perhaps some kind of anti-Catholic controversialist who is not particularly concerned with presenting history in a legitimate way but is perhaps interested in attacking the Church. Seems like the kind of thing that would come from either a liberal, so-called “Catholic” professor or a Protestant polemicist. I suppose it depends on what this person is really trying to assert; is it an admittedly crude and inaccurate analogy, or is it an actual claim that the early Franciscans were some sort of proto-Protestants? If it is the former than it is just a case of sloppy and irresponsible teaching, if it is the latter I’d say you’re dealing with ignorant anti-Catholicism. If this is really important to you I could give it some thought, maybe hit up a few books, and come up with a more comprehensive response - although it would be helpful to know more about what this person is actually trying to assert and on what basis.
Laudate_Dominum Posted April 26, 2008 Posted April 26, 2008 [quote name='thessalonian' post='1508321' date='Apr 24 2008, 11:58 AM']Honestly I don't think any of them were on either side. The views in Catholicism are not neccessarily contradictory and that a franciscan may have written an idealist article that does not mean he denies the other views. Same thing with the Jesuit that wrote a futurist article. We say in the Mass Christ has dies (preterist) Christ is risen (historician) Christ will come again (futurist) and gleen moralist (idealist) views from scripture all the time.[/quote] I tend to agree with this. Quite often Protestants (especially apologists and the like) will try to read modern Protestant theological paradigms into the medievals or fathers and this is ludicrous. As in Christology, Soteriology, Eschatology, et cetera, the historical Catholic faith is more theologically inclusive than this or that Protestant camp. I guess that's why I don't really like using those terms to begin with. In a crude sense one could perhaps describe the gleaning of moralist views from scripture as "idealist" interpretation but in fact this is not idealist eschatology in the proper sense. I would prefer to think of such things in terms of the classical Patristic and Medieval senses of Scripture; this would avoid the extreme anachronism of the above approach at the very least. I dunno.. It is hard to say without knowing more of what was claimed. Again, if the only claim was that the early Franciscans had a marked historicist tendency with respect to biblical prophecy and that the early reformers often had a similar tendency I might just agree and move on with my life. But if this is the extent of it I fail to see the controversy. In other words so what? I would call it an emphasis or preoccupation and not an actual doctrine of the Franciscans. Even if one can find Joachimite materials using biblical prophecy for polemical purposes reminiscent of Martin Luther the underlying reasons would be quite different and to jump from such a thing to a claim about Franciscans in general would be madness. You can find all kinds of jazz in the early Franciscan sources and you could label it in many different ways. I suppose my big issue is with reading modern Protestant concerns or disputes into the Franciscan sources. I mean, if one wanted to play that game I could glean a few things from the pre-reformation period and demonstrate that the Domincans were proto-protestants (I'm joking although I do believe that it could be done with similarly irresponsible and superficial methods).
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now