Odysseus Posted April 27, 2008 Posted April 27, 2008 I've been there, and I've read about it both pro and con and have come to the conclusion that it is phony. Does anyone agree with me? I know there have been good "fruits" but I have also seen the "nuts." And the good fruits could simply be because of the intention and all the masses, etc. If I had it to do over, I would have spent the money and time visiting Rome.
Deus te Amat Posted April 27, 2008 Posted April 27, 2008 There have been many threads about Medjegorie previously posted. You are going to get some interesting responses from the people here. If you go to the search bar at the top right of the page, you can locate the previous threads on this topic.
Adrestia Posted April 27, 2008 Posted April 27, 2008 it's been discussed a bit... here are a couple of the threads. [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=78487&view=findpost&p=1487908"]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?s...t&p=1487908[/url] [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=76972&view=findpost&p=1457698"]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?s...t&p=1457698[/url]
Odysseus Posted April 27, 2008 Author Posted April 27, 2008 Hey, I'm new here. Do you think I shouldn't have posted this topic? Has it already been beaten to death? I dindn't think to look for other posts about it.
Adrestia Posted April 27, 2008 Posted April 27, 2008 [quote name='Odysseus' post='1511591' date='Apr 27 2008, 01:16 PM']Hey, I'm new here. Do you think I shouldn't have posted this topic? Has it already been beaten to death? I dindn't think to look for other posts about it.[/quote] don't worry about it. there's nothing wrong with continuing the discussion. welcome to the pham.
Deb Posted April 27, 2008 Posted April 27, 2008 Nothing is ever beaten to death. I have been to Medjugorje twice. Once as a non believer of God and once giving thanks for that place bringing me to God. I have witnessed many miracles. Only time will tell how so many have been converted in that place. I believe Mary has been appearing there and still is. I also doubt if I will go back unless I am called as I was the first time.
Odysseus Posted April 27, 2008 Author Posted April 27, 2008 I was a new convert to Catholicism when I went to Medjugorge and gung ho about all that was Catholic, but Medjugorje was not a good experience for me overall, and I felt like I got taken for a ride. I think one of the problems was that all my Medjugorje friends were very dogmatic about it. They seemed to have a faith in the apparitions equal to our baptismal Faith. I realize now that the faith we should have in apparitions--even the approved ones--should be more of an assent of the intellect, and not on the same level as the faith we have in the Scriptures, the Church, the Sacraments, etc. Does anyobody know about the "great sign" we were supposed to get? Are the visionaries going to retire some day and will their children get daily visits from Mary? I rememember when I went how excited we were about climbing to the top of the mountain. We struck out early in the morning, and could't believe what we were seeing. At the top of the mountain there was a glow!! Hallelujah, we were finally seeing a miracle. A few of us raced to the top, only to discover that the glow was because of the cross being illuminated by many candles at the base. Yet, guess what? There were some from our party who went home and told about the "miracle" of the glow on the mountaintop. I realize that story doesn't disprove anything, but some people seem to be so hungry for a miracle that just about anything will do.
Odysseus Posted April 27, 2008 Author Posted April 27, 2008 I know a lot of people who I consider to be friends and who believe in Medjugorje, so I don't want to be too hard on it, but I wouldn't mind hearing from someone who has seen it from my perspective. Am I the only doubter? On a positive note, I did enjoy the pilgrimage aspect, and I did appreciate seeing all the masses in different languages and seeing people from all over the world. It made me realize how the Church is universal, and also that there is more to the world than just the US.
Proud2BCatholic139 Posted April 27, 2008 Posted April 27, 2008 I do not believe in it. For one, It is not approved by the Catholic Church. So, I don't even worry about it. I am a Fatima Cadet.
ardillacid Posted April 27, 2008 Posted April 27, 2008 [quote name='Proud2BCatholic139' post='1511775' date='Apr 27 2008, 04:41 PM']I do not believe in it. For one, It is not approved by the Catholic Church. So, I don't even worry about it. I am a Fatima Cadet. [/quote] It can't be approved until the apparitions stop.
mortify Posted April 27, 2008 Posted April 27, 2008 Some theologically questionable statements have been attributed to our Lady, and so its unlikely that it's a real apparition.
Noel's angel Posted April 27, 2008 Posted April 27, 2008 Is it for real? No one here will be able to answer that question.
Odysseus Posted April 27, 2008 Author Posted April 27, 2008 What troubles me most is how self-serving the apparitions are to those in Medjugorje. All they need to do is stay out of trouble, and they've got a gold mine until the last seer dies. But some of them have children, so I wouldn't be surprised if we soon have a second generation of "seers." And the messasges are so lame. Not that it's lame to go to daily Mass or pray the rosary, but any of us could come up with messages like these.
rizz_loves_jesus Posted April 27, 2008 Posted April 27, 2008 I don't think the messages are lame. But I'm not really sure about the apparitions, I don't have much experience with them. I am pretty sure, however, that Satan isn't appearing there because so many people's faith in God are strengthened there. -GratiaPlena
Lil Red Posted April 27, 2008 Posted April 27, 2008 [quote name='Noel's angel' post='1511844' date='Apr 27 2008, 03:41 PM']Is it for real? No one here will be able to answer that question.[/quote] +J.M.J.+ best answer ever on this subject!!
Odysseus Posted April 27, 2008 Author Posted April 27, 2008 I should quatlify that GP. The messages aren't truly lame. They just are not anything that seem to be of supernatural origin, and would not be hard for just about anyone to make up.
prose Posted April 27, 2008 Posted April 27, 2008 Wow. Another thread for the debate forum... Oh, and
Galloglasses Posted April 28, 2008 Posted April 28, 2008 I'm not gonna let rip here at the moment. But i'm a sceptic when it comes to Medjugorje, I have some SERIOUS problems with that place. My only advice is to wait till Holy Mother Church has finalised what it says about Medjugorje before you make your mind up completely either way.
Proud2BCatholic139 Posted April 28, 2008 Posted April 28, 2008 [quote name='notardillacid' post='1511778' date='Apr 27 2008, 03:43 PM']It can't be approved until the apparitions stop.[/quote] That is why I do not believe in it. It just does not feel right to me.
Proud2BCatholic139 Posted April 28, 2008 Posted April 28, 2008 (edited) [quote name='notardillacid' post='1511778' date='Apr 27 2008, 03:43 PM']It can't be approved until the apparitions stop.[/quote] That is why I do not believe in it. It just does not feel right to me. I was talking to an adult whom I trust and she told me that a very Holy priest told her back when these apparitions started to not worry about it and only stick to the church teachings. I don't want to believe in something that Satan might have a hold of. Besides, I heard some CRAZY, litterally CRAZY stories about some things that happned over there. Like for example a picture that someone took of "Blessed Mother" and she hung it up on her wall for several months. The Excorsist of our Archdiocese (at the time) (St. Paul) come over to my God father's house to do a blessing my sponsor showed Fr. (n) the picture and he said, "Burn it immediately". She asked, "Why?" Then he pointed out some demonic images in the picture... It was too creepy. That is why I do not believe in it. Edited April 28, 2008 by Proud2BCatholic139
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now