Brother Adam Posted April 28, 2008 Posted April 28, 2008 [url="http://www.catecheticsonline.com/forum/index.php?showtopic=5003"]http://www.catecheticsonline.com/forum/ind...?showtopic=5003[/url] We need help from anyone who is really good with early church fathers and professional anti-catholics. I don't have time to do the research to refute him, and our seminarian isn't studied enough to keep going in the debate. I don't want to close or delete the thread, but I need someone who is educated enough to keep debating him. Thanks!
Brother Adam Posted May 2, 2008 Author Posted May 2, 2008 Bump... No one has responded to him yet. If I didn't have a new baby, full time job, and full time school I would do the work to respond. Just hoping someone already maybe has done the work and can go after him.
thessalonian Posted May 5, 2008 Posted May 5, 2008 Not sure what needs answering there. I responded to his claim about Irenaus just now. I think I am on the right track with his little came but I am sure he will take me around some circles. I'll spar with him for a bit.
LouisvilleFan Posted May 6, 2008 Posted May 6, 2008 [quote name='Brother Adam' post='1516839' date='May 2 2008, 06:44 PM']Bump... No one has responded to him yet. If I didn't have a new baby, full time job, and full time school I would do the work to respond. Just hoping someone already maybe has done the work and can go after him.[/quote] Yeah, if I was unemployed with a maid and a cook and no family or friends, I'd be there too. The only way I spend so much time here is because work's been slow lately. I get the distinct impression (due to your desperate plea for help) that this guy isn't worth talking to. Those are the kind of people who get under others' skin with endless and sensely arguing. Granted, I often say things just to get an little friendly argument going, but some people will never admit defeat.
Brother Adam Posted May 7, 2008 Author Posted May 7, 2008 And its not really a desperate plea, I just don't like to see anti-catholics get the last laugh.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted May 7, 2008 Posted May 7, 2008 [quote name='Brother Adam' post='1521221' date='May 7 2008, 09:32 AM']And its not really a desperate plea, I just don't like to see anti-catholics get the last laugh.[/quote] Well, as I pointed out in my post to him, his points are really inconsequential to Catholics. Showing that the pope didn't push the Easter issue too much with Polycarp doesn't mean the pope isn't infallible, it simply means that the pope, for (I assume) pastoral reasons, didn't use his authority. I am convinced that none of his citations really contradict the faith, though I didn't look through the whole thread. That's the trouble you get into when you debate someone who knows their sources very well, but doesn't know the rules of logic very well. As I pointed out, for it to be of consequence to a Catholic, he would have to prove that the Catholic faith is irrefutably incompatible with the teachings of what would be the Magisterium among the Early Church Fathers (either the ordinary Magisterium through the Vincentian Canon, i.e. there was a full consensus of the ECF's believing such-and-such that the Catholic Church denies, or the Extraordinary Magisterium by showing that the ECF's, either in Council or through Ex Cathedra Papal Declaration, disagree with a teaching of the Catholic Church). Of course, we know that will never happen, but those are the only things he could prove that would really matter.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now