CatherineM Posted April 29, 2008 Posted April 29, 2008 I received a grade today that scaled equals a 3.3/B+ in Ecclesiology. I have never contested a grade before, and yes, I've made B's before, so that's not it. All the comments that the prof placed on my final exam essays and final paper that cost me points dealt with my not being willing to compromise on the Church's teachings. I knew that was going to cost me, but refused to capitulate. I am considering contesting my grade. Normally I wouldn't bother. Grades don't really matter to me, but it is the reason she docked me that is really bothering me. I knew it was going to be a problem the first week when I had to apologize to a Lutheran classmate for making the statement that the Catholic Church had the fullness of faith. This is a private Catholic theological college and seminary. My husband warned me about this problem. He quit taking classes out there several years ago because his instructor started talking about how they should support gay marriage. I don't know whether I should contest the grade to try to get things changed, just smell of elderberries it up and keep taking the classes and keeping my mouth shut, talk to the archbishop about it, or just transfer somewhere more orthodox.
goldenchild17 Posted April 29, 2008 Posted April 29, 2008 I'd contest it, even if a B+ is a pretty decent grade. But if the school is run by such people I don't see what success you'd have.
MissScripture Posted April 29, 2008 Posted April 29, 2008 I'd either contest becuase it's only going to feel worse if you don't, or I'd transfer. I went to a highschool that was a little less than par as far as theology goes, and I didn't say anything for a long time, but when I finally did, it was such a weight lifted. I'm not saying it won't be a big fight, and quite possibly on-going, but it feels much better to have it out than think what-if's.
MIKolbe Posted April 29, 2008 Posted April 29, 2008 I would contest it as well. And use the word 'capitulate' alot; college types like big words. Seriously though, I almost see you contesting it as an extension of your refusal to compromise on Church teachings. just my 2 cents.
CatholicCid Posted April 29, 2008 Posted April 29, 2008 Prepare the proper documents to back up your paper then go in and contest away. If it was "Christian Ecclesiology" or something general, I could see maybe letting it go, however, if it is Catholic Ecclesiology and your paper is in line with Church teaching, then there is no reason for you to lose marks. I'd start on the lower level and bring it up with your teacher first.
CatherineM Posted April 29, 2008 Author Posted April 29, 2008 She made it clear from the get go, that was the way the class was going to be. It was in her syllabus. On one of our assignments she commented, "theological debate around the ordination of women in the Catholic Church -- has been defacto blocked by the Holy See. That means, the highest levels of authority in the Catholic Church have pronounced that the question is no longer open for discussion and should no longer be debated. This attitude, to my mind, constitutes a true “injustice” (i.e. an unjust act) concerning the question of the ordination of women." I had questioned why we were discussing it in the first place. So appealing to her is not going to do anything. I'd take it up with the archbishop, but I'm ducking him right now. I actually had to sneak out the side door at the Basilica after the rite of election so he couldn't corner me. I think I'm going to let the grade go. I knew it would cost me to stand for what I believed in. I am going to transfer though.
cathoholic_anonymous Posted April 29, 2008 Posted April 29, 2008 Academic grades should be based on the quality of your thought, argument, and communication, not on the actual content of your paper. If somebody were to write a well-argued and lucid essay in support of female ordination, it should be marked highly. If somebody were to write an equally wll-argued and lucid defence of orthodox Church teaching, it should also be marked highly. What your tutor is doing is tantamout to censorship. It's also in opposition to how academia is supposed to work. I think this would be your best line of argument to take with her - she's unlikely to listen to you if you argue from a purely Catholic standpoint. Save that sort of argument for the archbishop when you write to him about the matter. Prayers for you.
Autumn Dusk Posted April 29, 2008 Posted April 29, 2008 On one hand you probably wrote a clear paper with a good argument, however, she made it clear where her loyalties fell and what she expected from you. Although I'd report the action to administration I wouldn't ask for a better grade. You KNEW she wouldn't like this going into this, its not her fault you got a bad grade.
StColette Posted April 29, 2008 Posted April 29, 2008 I would contest it as well. My question though, Is the entire college this way? If it is I'm not sure how far contesting will get you. It may not change your grade but it might get some people to start thinking.
StColette Posted April 29, 2008 Posted April 29, 2008 [quote name='Autumn Dusk' post='1513818' date='Apr 29 2008, 09:19 AM']You KNEW she wouldn't like this going into this, its not her fault you got a bad grade.[/quote] A student at a Catholic College should not have to compromise the teachings of the Church to get a better grade regardless of the personal opinions of a professor!
Lil Red Posted April 29, 2008 Posted April 29, 2008 [quote name='StColette' post='1513830' date='Apr 29 2008, 07:51 AM'] A student at a Catholic College should not have to compromise the teachings of the Church to get a better grade regardless of the personal opinions of a professor![/quote] +J.M.J.+ well said
CatherineM Posted April 29, 2008 Author Posted April 29, 2008 Yeah, I knew there were going to be consequences, so I'm prepared to accept them. I don't know if all the courses are going to be like this. My undergrad theology was run by the Adorers of the Sacred Blood, so it was orthodox. They were liberal about a lot of things, but knew where to draw the line. I guess what really worries me is that this is at the seminary where all the priests for Western Canada are being trained. I just can't allow myself to believe that all the professors are going to be like this. I'm only 2 semesters into my masters program, so I just don't have a gauge yet. I don't need the degree, I already have a doctorate, I just was taking the courses to fill time, and to expand my horizon and keep my mind active. It is so hard not to judge an entire institution based on one bad experience or on the actions of one person. I guess the fact that this professor received her MDiv from this college is also playing into my discernment.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted April 29, 2008 Posted April 29, 2008 [quote name='StColette' post='1513830' date='Apr 29 2008, 09:51 AM'] A student at a Catholic College should not have to compromise the teachings of the Church to get a better grade regardless of the personal opinions of a professor![/quote] Ditto. The teacher has no right to have opinions against Church teaching anyway, and especially not to be teaching those things or using orthodoxy against students faithful to the Magisterium. This is a blatent violation of Ex Corde Ecclesiae.
cmotherofpirl Posted April 29, 2008 Posted April 29, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1513208' date='Apr 28 2008, 09:56 PM']I received a grade today that scaled equals a 3.3/B+ in Ecclesiology. I have never contested a grade before, and yes, I've made B's before, so that's not it. All the comments that the prof placed on my final exam essays and final paper that cost me points dealt with my not being willing to compromise on the Church's teachings. I knew that was going to cost me, but refused to capitulate. I am considering contesting my grade. Normally I wouldn't bother. Grades don't really matter to me, but it is the reason she docked me that is really bothering me. I knew it was going to be a problem the first week when I had to apologize to a Lutheran classmate for making the statement that the Catholic Church had the fullness of faith. This is a private Catholic theological college and seminary. My husband warned me about this problem. He quit taking classes out there several years ago because his instructor started talking about how they should support gay marriage. I don't know whether I should contest the grade to try to get things changed, just smell of elderberries it up and keep taking the classes and keeping my mouth shut, talk to the archbishop about it, or just transfer somewhere more orthodox.[/quote] Don't you think the Archbishop needs to know about this? How many poor students are being ruined by her propagation of error? How many souls will she nead to hell?
picchick Posted April 30, 2008 Posted April 30, 2008 Sorry, I am reading this a little late. Continue to stand for your belief. If the reason you got docked was because of a bias and not a grammer or format you need to go to her and tell her that it is wrong. If not then you go above her. If not go above her. B is great but no teacher has a right to grade based off of a bias.
IcePrincessKRS Posted April 30, 2008 Posted April 30, 2008 If you're not going to contest the grade I still think you should take it to the Archbishop as others have suggested. You may have known that your grade might suffer for not writing what she wanted you to, but as you noted future priests are under her direction. Something should be done.
ardillacid Posted April 30, 2008 Posted April 30, 2008 (edited) I believe that your best option is taking a reasonable argument to your professor, and doing your best to make them feel stupid. Just my $0.02. That way you at least get some gratification out of it, even if they refuse to alter your grade! It's a win-win. Edited April 30, 2008 by notardillacid
CatherineM Posted May 19, 2008 Author Posted May 19, 2008 Just thought I'd update. I decided to wait until I had a cooler, clearer head. I contacted my professor first. I'm glad I did. Turns out that her whole PC thing was because of the woman in our class who was Lutheran. Apparently in the past she has threatened filing a complaint with the Human Rights Commission. She said that none of my grade reduction was due to my following a hard line on church teachings. I had misread the last essay question. It was to write 4 pages on a speech to be given at an interfaith conference on the meaning of the word "catholic." For some reason, my brain saw interfaith, and interpreted it as ecumenical. I used terms that Christians would understand, but perhaps not Muslim, Sikhs, or Jews. I had just gotten out of the hospital, and could have requested a deferral, but was stubborn and didn't want any special treatment. I feel like the business end of a horse right now. I probably didn't deserve the B+ she gave me.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now