Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

Ok, I suppose you could call me a lapsed catholic or a heretic or whatever, I don't really mind, but I've come to a place where I have too many questions and not enough answers, and my spiritual life is being constantly stirred up by my undergrad theology studies and now I need some answers, so...

My first question is can a person be Catholic but question points of doctrine?

Edited by In His Light
Posted

There is an area of church teachings that we are allowed to question. That section includes Provisional Applications of Church Doctrine, Church Discipline and Prudential Admonitions. The American Bishops have said that we should give them "serious attention and consideration," but you can disagree in good faith without falling into sin. At the other end of the spectrum is our core beliefs called Dogma, and you have to believe those teachings, or you really shouldn't call yourself a Catholic.

Posted

My input: something ex cathedra defined by the Pope is infallible, the rejection of which is heresy; also, definitions coming from General Councils, are infallible, the rejection of which is heresy. This is the Magisterium (teaching authority) of the Church teaching in the [i]solemn[/i] or [i]extraordinary[/i] sense.

Yet, not all dogma so to speak has been precisely defined by the Church in the precise sense. For example, I don't believe the Resurrection has been defined in the [i]solemn[/i] sense. Yet obviously, rejection of it is heresy. As seen, while the Church may not have defined something, this does not mean that one is free to reject it. Such are infallible truths, which, although undefined, have been always and universally accepted by the Church as being dogmas.

[b]Anybody with greater theological understanding, please make sure I have not erred in my phrasing above.)[/b]

A more complex treatment of this sort of question is below, taken from [url="http://www.catholictreasury.info/"]http://www.catholictreasury.info/[/url]

[quote]The Theological Grades of Certainty
- "Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma"
by Ludwig Ott.

1. The highest degree of certainty appertains to the immediately revealed truths. The belief due to them is based on the authority of God Revealing (fides divina), and if the Church, through its teaching, vouches for the fact it a truth is contained in Revelation, one's certainty is then also based on the authority of the Infallible Teaching Authority of the Church (fides catholica). If Truths are defined by a solemn judgment of faith (definition) of the Pope or of a General Council, they are "de fide definita."
2. Catholic truths or Church doctrines, on which the infallible Teaching Authority of the Church has finally decided, are to be accepted with a faith which is based on the sole authority of the Church (fides ecclesiastica). These truths are as infallibly certain as dogmas proper.

3. A Teaching proximate to Faith (sententia fidei proxima) is a doctrine, which is regarded by theologians generally as a truth of Revelation, but which has not yet been finally promulgated as such by the Church.

4. A Teaching pertaining to the Faith, i.e., theologically certain (sententia ad fidem pertinens, i.e., theologice certa) is a doctrine, on which the Teaching Authority of the Church has not yet finally pronounced, but whose truth is guaranteed by its intrinsic connection with the doctrine of revelation (theological conclusions).

5. Common Teaching (sententia communis) is doctrine, which in itself belongs to the field of free opinions, but which is accepted by theologians generally.

6. Theological opinions of lesser grades of certainty are called probable, more probable, well-founded (sententia probabilis, probabilior, bene fundata). Those which are regarded as being in agreement with the consciousness of Faith of the Church are called pious opinions (sententia pia). The least degree of certainty is possessed by the tolerated opinion (opinio tolerata), which is only weakly founded, but which is tolerated by the Church.[/quote]

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='In His Light' post='1513746' date='Apr 29 2008, 02:27 AM']Ok, I suppose you could call me a lapsed catholic or a heretic or whatever, I don't really mind, but I've come to a place where I have too many questions and not enough answers, and my spiritual life is being constantly stirred up by my undergrad theology studies and now I need some answers, so...

My first question is can a person be Catholic but question points of doctrine?[/quote]

Seminaries... takes a strong faith to get through those places without losing it.

A good, orthodox priest I know was recently asked about this because someone in our young adult group wasn't agreeing with a particular Church teaching related to sexuality. He told us that it's fine (and even encouraged, since we should always be honest in our relationship with God) to struggle with Church teachings. As long as we're struggling and working to understand it, we remain open to the Church's teaching, even if we aren't sure yet.

The line is drawn when you make a decision that you definitely do not believe whatever it is, after you've put forth a good faith effort to fully understand the teaching and why it is right or wrong. I don't think any intellectually honest person should come to that point quickly.

Otherwise, pray, read the Scriptures, and open your heart and ears to God. He is strongest when we are weakest.

Posted (edited)

[quote][b]Code of Canon Law for the Latin Rite [Excerpts][/b]
[b]Can. 212 §1[/b]. [u]Conscious of their own responsibility[/u], [b][u]the Christian faithful are bound to follow with Christian obedience those things which the sacred pastors[/u], [u]inasmuch as they represent Christ[/u], [u]declare as teachers of the faith or establish as rulers of the Church[/u][/b].
[b]§2[/b]. The Christian faithful are free to make known to the pastors of the Church their [u]needs[/u], [b]especially spiritual ones[/b], [u]and their desires[/u].
[b]§3[/b]. According to the knowledge, competence, and prestige which they possess, they have the right and even at times the duty to manifest to the sacred pastors their opinion on matters which pertain to the good of the Church and to make their opinion known to the rest of the Christian faithful, without prejudice to the integrity of faith and morals, with reverence toward their pastors, and attentive to common advantage and the dignity of persons.
( [url="http://www.vatican.va/archive/ENG1104/__PU.HTM"]http://www.vatican.va/archive/ENG1104/__PU.HTM[/url] )

[b]Can. 749 §1[/b]. By virtue of his office, the Supreme Pontiff possesses infallibility in teaching when as the supreme pastor and teacher of all the Christian faithful, who strengthens his brothers and sisters in the faith, [u]he proclaims by definitive act that a doctrine of faith or morals [b][color="#FF0000"]is to be held[/color][/b][/u].
[b]§2[/b]. The college of bishops also possesses infallibility in teaching when the bishops gathered together in an ecumenical council exercise the magisterium as teachers and judges of faith and morals [u]who declare for the universal Church that a doctrine of faith or morals is to be held definitively[/u]; or when dispersed throughout the world but preserving the bond of communion among themselves and with the successor of Peter and teaching authentically together with the Roman Pontiff matters of faith or morals, they agree that a particular proposition is to be held definitively.
[b]§3[/b]. [b][u]No doctrine is understood as defined infallibly unless this is manifestly evident[/u][/b].
( [url="http://www.vatican.va/archive/ENG1104/__P2H.HTM"]http://www.vatican.va/archive/ENG1104/__P2H.HTM[/url] )

[b]Can. 750 §1[/b]. [u]A person must believe with divine and Catholic faith[/u] [b]all those things contained in the [u]word of God[/u], [u]written[/u] or [u]handed on[/u], that is, in [u]the one deposit of faith[/u] entrusted to the Church, and at the same time proposed as divinely revealed either by the solemn magisterium of the Church or by its ordinary and universal magisterium which is manifested by the common adherence of the Christian faithful under the leadership of the sacred magisterium[/b]; [b][u][color="#FF0000"]therefore all are bound to avoid any doctrines whatsoever contrary to them[/color][/u][/b].
[b]§2[/b]. [u]Each and every thing which is proposed definitively by the magisterium of the Church concerning the doctrine of faith and morals, that is, each and every thing which is required to safeguard reverently and to expound faithfully the same deposit of faith[/u], [b][u]is also to be firmly embraced and retained[/u][/b]; [b][color="#FF0000"]therefore, one who rejects those propositions which [u][color="#FF0000"]are to be held definitively[/color][/u] is opposed to the doctrine of the Catholic Church[/color][/b]. [color="#C0C0C0"](See Canons 751 and 1364)[/color]
( [url="http://www.vatican.va/archive/ENG1104/__P2H.HTM"]http://www.vatican.va/archive/ENG1104/__P2H.HTM[/url] )

[b]Can. 751[/b] [b][color="#FF0000"]Heresy is the [u]obstinate denial[/u] or [u]obstinate doubt[/u] after the reception of baptism of some truth which is to be believed by divine and Catholic faith[/color][/b]; apostasy is the total repudiation of the Christian faith; schism is the refusal of submission to the Supreme Pontiff or of communion with the members of the Church subject to him.
( [url="http://www.vatican.va/archive/ENG1104/__P2H.HTM"]http://www.vatican.va/archive/ENG1104/__P2H.HTM[/url] )

[b]Can. 752[/b] Although not an assent of faith, [b][u]a religious submission of the intellect and will must be given to a doctrine which the Supreme Pontiff or the college of bishops declares concerning faith or morals when they exercise the authentic magisterium[/u][/b], [u]even if they do not intend to proclaim it by definitive act[/u]; [b][u][color="#FF0000"]therefore, the Christian faithful are to take care to avoid those things which do not agree with it[/color][/u][/b].
( [url="http://www.vatican.va/archive/ENG1104/__P2H.HTM"]http://www.vatican.va/archive/ENG1104/__P2H.HTM[/url] )

[b]Can. 753[/b] Although the bishops who are in communion with the head and members of the college, whether individually or joined together in conferences of bishops or in particular councils, do not possess infallibility in teaching, [u]they are authentic teachers and instructors of the faith for the Christian faithful entrusted to their care[/u]; [b][u][color="#FF0000"]the Christian faithful are bound to adhere with [u]religious submission of mind[/u] to the authentic magisterium of their bishops[/color][/u][/b].
( [url="http://www.vatican.va/archive/ENG1104/__P2H.HTM"]http://www.vatican.va/archive/ENG1104/__P2H.HTM[/url] )

[b]Can. 754[/b] [b]All the Christian faithful are [u]obliged to observe[/u][/b] the constitutions and decrees which the legitimate authority of the Church issues in order to propose doctrine and to proscribe erroneous opinions, particularly those which the Roman Pontiff or the college of bishops puts forth.
( [url="http://www.vatican.va/archive/ENG1104/__P2H.HTM"]http://www.vatican.va/archive/ENG1104/__P2H.HTM[/url] )

[b]Can. 1364 §1[/b]. [b][color="#FF0000"]Without prejudice to the prescript of[/color][/b] (can. 194 §1 n.2) [color="#FF0000"][b]an apostate from the faith, [u]a heretic[/u], or a schismatic [u]incurs a latae sententiae excommunication[/u][/b][/color]; in addition, a cleric can be punished with the penalties mentioned in (can. 1336 §1 n.1,2, and 3.)
( [url="http://www.vatican.va/archive/ENG1104/__P52.HTM"]http://www.vatican.va/archive/ENG1104/__P52.HTM[/url] )[/quote]As Catholics in Divine Faith we are to believe all that the Church proposes to our faith, for the Church was founded for this purpose. Thus, the reason why any Catholic ought to believe any teaching of the Church, in a Divine Faith, is for the Church so proposes it for our belief. In a human faith we would look for explanations that would give us reason to believe, this can even be from the Scriptures and Church Fathers. While human faith is not automatically “[i]intrinsically wrongful[/i]”, we are called to Divine Faith.

However, this is something different when it comes to the explanation for the purposes of reaffirmation of doctrine. [u]It is good and holy to understand these doctrines and moralities both to strengthen our faith and to assist us or others in living our lives according to God[/u]. The thing that we should at least attempt to avoid is a human faith in what we believe or do not believe, for we make ourselves our own judges and arbitrators of belief, reducing ourselves to one of the simplest errors of fundamental Protestantism, “Sola Scriptura” (by Scripture Alone). It becomes a question if we believe ourselves or if we believe God, Whom founded the Catholic Church to teach, sanctify, and govern the faithful.

The Church proposes that once one is Baptized there is left an indelible mark left upon the soul, unable to be removed in this world or in the next. For this reason one may sometimes hear the expression one can never stop being Catholic once being Catholic, for it is referring to this “indelible mark”. We profess the Catholic Church to be the True and Visible Church of Christ, Holy Mother Church, which she is in a special way the minister of all the Sacraments and all the Sacraments properly belong to her.

[u]To have disbelief or doubts are not necessarily wrongful in themselves[/u], [b]granted there is the honest intention and attempt to believe those things that are definitively proposed to our belief and otherwise[/b]. When our disbelief or doubt is intentional, knowingly, obstinately, and in a matter that is to be believed by all the faithful is when one endangers automatic excommunication granted one is aware of such a penalty.

Nonetheless, sometimes to have questions or doubts shows that we are exercising not only our faith but our reason. We are taught in the First Vatican Council that faith and reason cannot contradict each other, for they are different gifts from the same God and Truth. Thus to have faith and reason contradict is to suggest that truth could contradict truth and God could contradict God. Sometimes the questions that we come to help us to grow in our faith and understand more, if it were not for the heresies of ages past the Church would of not been forced to so clearly define the teachings of Christ that we now enjoy today. This does not justify heresy, but brings out a realization that honest questions can help bring about honest answers, which we all benefit from.

This Divine Catholic Faith cannot be believed in or practiced without the grace of the Almighty Triune Godhead, namely the grace of perseverance. It also requires that we practice the Theological, Cardinal, and moral virtues; namely the theological virtues of Faith, Hope, and Charity. We cannot separate the theological virtues from each other but at the same time we cannot replace them with each other, for example, Faith with Hope or Charity with Faith.

Thus I would advise anyone having problems in the faith to approach the Sacraments more frequently and where properly disposed, to make use of the Sacramentals of the Church, seek the intercession of the Communion of Saints namely with our Lady, Saint Joseph, the Angels, and the Saints. To likewise seek the ministry of your own Guardian Angel and the ministry of those sacred pastors over you, seeking their advise, instruction, and formation. In particular although I suggest the devotions of the Holy Rosary, the Brown Scapular, the medal of the Immaculate Conception, the Green Scapular, along with devotion to Our Lady of Sorrow.

[i]It would although would be useful to users attempting to reaffirm and confirm someone in the One Holy Catholic Apostolic Church if we knew what matters of the faith or morality they are having difficulties with...[/i] I hope this helps?

Edited by Mr.CatholicCat

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...