Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Which is worse?  

33 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Posted

I thought of this conundrum recently, but I can't decide which is worse.

goldenchild17
Posted

the second easily, in my opinion.

Posted

I voted null as I'm not sure exactly what "being oneself" actually means. Usually only practicing homosexuals go around saying that I've noticed.

xTrishaxLynnx
Posted

I don't know where you get that idea, Justin. I've said it before and know a lot of people who use that expression and I promise I'm not a homosexual and neither are they.

I chose the second option as being worse, but really I can't come to any real conclusion. The reason I chose the second is because I was thinking... If you try to act differently than you naturally do, isn't that potentially smothering the gifts God chose to give you?

The only time I would really say it'd be [i]better[/i] to try to be someone else is if they're a saint.

There are a lot of possible variables here... too many for me to really get my mind around it at 4:40am. Maybe I'll come back later. lol

LouisvilleFan
Posted

Conundrums are tasty with peanut butter.

Posted

mmm. high school.

Posted

Being rejected sucketh, I mean really really sucketh. But I don't think that being rejected is necessarily a sin. Trying to be someone else is generally a sin (I'm sure one could think of exceptions if one tried hard enough), because you are essentially lying to other about who you really are. And when you lie, you are usually trying to create a false reality that exists purely for the purpose of serving self.

I don't think that even the most repulsive person would be rejected by [i]everybody.[/i] And even the most popular person in the world is going to have a lot of critics, people who don't like him, etc. Even Bono has people who can't stand him. So I think it's better to be yourself.

That doesn't mean you can't ever change. God always calls us to progress in our relationship with God and with others. It would be foolish for me to say "I'm going to just keep being socially awkward, otherwise I'm just not being myself." There's nothing wrong with trying to improve yourself, and there are limitless way to improve yourself.

Come to think of it. being yourself really doesn't work unless you are working to unite that self with the Lord. It's kinda like following your heart. It is a great thought, but it doesn't work very well if your heart is attached things of this world. You could follow your heart straight into Hell! I think there's a Bible verse that says "where your treasure is, your heart will also be" or something along those lines. so you really have to give your heart to God prior to following your heart. Same with "being yourself." If your self is going to hell in a handbasket, then being yourself doesn't do you any good.

I think it's worth noting that growing in holiness is often seen as equivalent to "becoming yourself." I guess because when we sin, we are rejecting what God made us to be and replacing it with what we want to be.

Hope that made sense.

Posted

Worse for who? The person? The people around them? In general? In a spiritual sense? In a secular sense?

Posted

[quote name='Old_Joe' post='1516501' date='May 1 2008, 11:09 PM']I thought of this conundrum recently, but I can't decide which is worse.[/quote]
+J.M.J.+
depends on if we're talking about criminal acts/mental illnesses.

Noel's angel
Posted (edited)

Well, number 1 would be bad for the person, but number two would be worse in an objective sense, since other people are being fooled and the actual person is also being fooled. If you were being yourself, you might want to think why everyone rejects you, and if you find out that the reason is not because of negative acts on your behalf, then that wouldn't be so bad (if it was because you were a bit 'strange', then you could always change, not to be false but to become integrated). So I'm saying number 2.

Edited by Noel's angel
Posted

The second option can be better if we're dealing with someone who is trying to abandon a public vice. They may not fully understand why it's a sin but if they are motivated to conform to what is better, and they receive the initial benefit of acceptance, it will foster their growth in improving themselves. In time ideally the initial benefit of acceptance will wear off and they'll see the light of their new ways and reject the darkness of their old. So I guess it all depends how it relates to God. In the first case if we're dealing with a non-Christian becoming Catholic, and coming out publicly with their private beliefs even to the detriment of their friends and relatives, that would be quite the holy thing. And in fact, in both scenarios if they are directed towards God, can lead to sanctity.

CatherineM
Posted

Living a fully authentic life will lead to personal acceptance, and that always eventually leads to a circle of healthier friends.

Domine ut Videam
Posted

I definitely picked the second one from exerience. One will never be truly accepted by others unless they first accept and embrace themselves.

goldbug16
Posted

The latter. But still, the question is an odd one. :mellow:

icelandic_iceskater
Posted

I voted for the first but I meant to vote the second. Oops.

Posted

[size=1]Be yourself!
Everyone else can smell of elderberries it.
[/size]

goldenchild17
Posted

[quote name='CrossCuT' post='1520852' date='May 6 2008, 06:46 PM'][size=1]Be yourself!
Everyone else can smell of elderberries it.
[/size][/quote]

word

Posted

I too have been both and being oneself, even if others don't accept you, is very freeing. In my case, finding God has allowed me to be the person he created me to be and it doesn't always sit well with those who liked me better at the bar. :lol_roll: Those who couldn't handle it have been replaced with those who can.

I now really only have to worry about pleasing one in my lifetime and that is my Lord God.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...