Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

The Dark Knight Poll  

66 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Posted

I SAW IT!!!

IT WAS AWESOME!!!


Keith did an awesome job. And I agree with Didy

Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='picchick' post='1608096' date='Jul 25 2008, 01:54 AM']I SAW IT!!!

IT WAS AWESOME!!!
Keith did an awesome job. And I agree with Didy[/quote]


LOL @ "Keith". Too funny.

Posted

My mom said she'll never look at Heath (or "Keith") the same way again. She's always had a little crush on him.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Era Might' post='1607040' date='Jul 23 2008, 10:59 PM'][spoiler]I thought the lead up to the end was great, especially the scene with the Joker dangling from the side of the building, taunting Batman for choosing justice over vengeance. But the very end didn't leave me in expectation. At least Batman Begins ended with the Joker card. What are we left to wait for after The Dark Knight? We already saw Bruce Wayne battle his inner demons in Batman Begins, which was one of the reasons why I liked that movie, and we saw him mature into Batman in The Dark Knight, and face the most evil character possible. What is next?[/spoiler][/quote]
From what Mr. Nolan's said, he doesn't really seem to have a sequel planned at this point (though he has not said definitively one way or the other whether he'd direct one). From what he's said, he seems to have made [i]The Dark Knight [/i]as a complete work in itself, rather than as a middle chapter in a trilogy.
The fact that there's no "teaser" ending here doesn't make it a bad ending. I liked Gordon's speech at the end, though I was surprised that[spoiler] it ended with him "officially" opposing Batman, when he is generally the character who gives Batman public "legitimacy."[/spoiler]

[quote]Yes, I understand the purpose of that aspect of his character, but does that make it moral? I agree that it is not something unique to The Dark Knight. It is something which I have a problem with in a lot of movies, how plots are sometimes based on lies and similar choices which would be immoral in real life. I guess the question is whether there is a moral suspension of disbelief to a certain extent in movies and literature? I'm not sure. I went to see the movie with people who are not religious, so that is part of the reason why it bothers me, because I feel like I need to explain to them why those aspects of the movie would be morally wrong in the real world. It may be obvious to me, as a Christian, but others might conclude that those aspects of the movie are perfectly moral, even in real life.[/quote]
Why so SERIOUS?

I think quite a bit of suspension of disbelief is in order when watching a Batman movie, even one as "realistic" as [i]The Dark Knight[/i].
Obviously, living the kind of hedonistic lifestyle Bruce appears to would not be moral in real life, though I think it's left ambiguous as to whether Bruce is actually living a sexually promiscuous life or how much the babes and such are merely "props" to his act. (In Frank Miller's take, Bruce is apparently even a closet teetotaler, secretly substituting seltzer water for champagne.) After all, Bruce's job as the Batman would leave little time for a nightlife.

And Batman, while a hero, is not intended to be a morally flawless character, often walking a moral fine line in his crusade. He's the Dark Knight, not St. Bruce of Gotham.

Edited by Socrates
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Seven77' post='1607701' date='Jul 24 2008, 05:55 PM'][spoiler]i thought Batman seemed almost heartless, unlike Batman in Begins...probably part of that maturing process?[/spoiler][/quote]
I wouldn't go so far as to call him heartless, though I think this is deliberate. The idea is that Bruce is settling more and more into his role as the Dark Knight, and it is becoming clear that he is gradually having everything stripped from him that would allow him to lead "a normal life." He becomes more and more an avenging creature of justice, and loses something of his humanity in the process.

Edited by Socrates
Posted

JM + JT

Saw it twice last nite - went with the family and saw my friends arrive after and decided to stay.

Very cool - [b]loved[/b] Ledger's performance, by far the best Joker - though I'm still confused about a lot of things. I should probably watch the prequel again and finish it this time. Maybe it'll help clear things up that watching DK more than once cannot. :sweat:

I just wish they could've wrapped things up nicer with the Joker. It's obvious they didn't foresee Ledger's death (who could have?). :(

I'd love to see the Riddler! :D Besides the Joker he's my favorite.

Posted

Ya Riddler would be cool...

Posted

My ideas for "realistic" depictions of future Batman villains:

Riddler- cyberterrorist
Poison Ivy- radical environmentalist using biological weapons to attack Gothan
Penguin- uber-business mogul poisoning Gotham's economy with his greedy ways
Mad Hatter- crazy little circus freak

Posted

[quote]My ideas for "realistic" depictions of future Batman villains:

Riddler- cyberterrorist
Poison Ivy- radical environmentalist using biological weapons to attack Gothan
Penguin- uber-business mogul poisoning Gotham's economy with his greedy ways
Mad Hatter- crazy little circus freak[/quote]

...sounds good!

White Knight
Posted (edited)

There is always a possibilty they could bring back the side villian from Batman Begins, to conclude that storyline.

Edited by White Knight
Posted

[quote name='White Knight' post='1612162' date='Jul 29 2008, 10:08 PM']There is always a possibilty they could bring back the side villian from Batman Begins, to conclude that storyline.[/quote]

Who? Falcone?

Posted

Is the scare crow dead?

Posted

[quote name='Socrates' post='1610007' date='Jul 27 2008, 03:19 PM']From what Mr. Nolan's said, he doesn't really seem to have a sequel planned at this point (though he has not said definitively one way or the other whether he'd direct one). From what he's said, he seems to have made [i]The Dark Knight [/i]as a complete work in itself, rather than as a middle chapter in a trilogy.
The fact that there's no "teaser" ending here doesn't make it a bad ending. I liked Gordon's speech at the end, though I was surprised that[spoiler] it ended with him "officially" opposing Batman, when he is generally the character who gives Batman public "legitimacy."[/spoiler][/quote]
[spoiler]
yeah, especially when he mentions that Batman is running so that they can chase him. [/spoiler] I felt almost like I could have expected another hour to the movie at least.

White Knight
Posted

[quote name='Didymus' post='1612273' date='Jul 29 2008, 10:39 PM']Is the scare crow dead?[/quote]


Scarecrow didn't die in Batman Begins, and is in the beginning of The Dark Knight, hes barely in there, They could bring him back, also twoface's death was a coverup since hes still alive. There are many possibilities for the next installment.

Posted

batman has 8 pages? :o

Posted

I loved the movie. Heath did an awesome job, and I'm not just saying that because of what happened. Egad, I can't wait to see it again some time.

Posted

It was disturbing.

Posted

[quote name='White Knight' post='1612299' date='Jul 29 2008, 11:26 PM']Scarecrow didn't die in Batman Begins, and is in the beginning of The Dark Knight, hes barely in there, They could bring him back, also twoface's death was a coverup since hes still alive. There are many possibilities for the next installment.[/quote]


yeah my only problem was that I couldn't remember what Batman did after he tied up Scarecrow and the fake batman in the garage at the beginning. So it makes sense that he's still alive.

Is it undisputed that twoface's death was a coverup? They didn't really make it clear at the end of Dark Knight. He seemed dead, but I guess that would make him a very short lived criminal.

Pontifite 7 of 10
Posted

It depends...will Christifer Nolan stay on? Christan Bail? Will it be a good movie? We won't know until it comes out. I'm leaning toward a Pirates 3 type of thing. But We won't know until it comes.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='White Knight' post='1612299' date='Jul 29 2008, 10:26 PM']Scarecrow didn't die in Batman Begins, and is in the beginning of The Dark Knight, hes barely in there, They could bring him back, also twoface's death was a coverup since hes still alive. There are many possibilities for the next installment.[/quote]
Harvey Dent was dead at the end of the movie. It's unlikely he's coming back (at least not as long as Nolan's running the show).
In the word's of Batman-on-film's Jett (Bill Ramey):[quote]3. “Jett, did Two Face really die? Do you think Gordon and Batman hid him? Maybe he's at Arkham?”

JETT SAYS: Harvey died. End of story on that one. Frankly, I think it would be a little cheap for him to return in the next one. TDK story arc was Harvey’s and he died at the end because of his own actions.[/quote]
[url="http://www.batman-on-film.com/mailbag_TDK-sequel_7-21-08.html"]http://www.batman-on-film.com/mailbag_TDK-...el_7-21-08.html[/url]

Having Scarecrow come back yet again would be a bit redundant, and unlikely, as there's enough other Batman villains that have not been touched. I don't think he was[i] that[/i] great of a villain anyway (at least not worth 3 consecutive movies).
Unfortunately, I think about everything will pale after Heath Ledger's Joker.

While Chris Nolan hasn't said whether he'll direct another, storyman David Goyer has said they have a basic outline and a villain if Nolan decides to go through with it, though they refuse to say who it is.

Like others, I think the Riddler would we a good fit for Nolan's movies (sans the gay costumes, silly giggling, red flattops, etc.), however something tells me these guys have something unexpected up their sleeves.

Edited by Socrates

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...