TotusTuusMaria Posted May 6, 2008 Posted May 6, 2008 Boston, May. 5, 2008 (CWNews.com) - A Massachusetts hospital for children is providing hormone treatment for young people who wish to change their gender identity, reveals an article in the Anchor, the newspaper of the Fall River, Massachusetts, diocese. The "Gender Management Service Clinic" at Children's Hospital in Boston offers treatment for young people who have "no known anatomic or biochemical disorder who feel like a member of the opposite sex." The clinic treats children as young as 10 years old, reports Gail Besse for the Anchor. The program at Children's Hospital, which advertises itself as "unique in the Western hemisphere," provides hormone treatment as the first step in gender-reassignment. Young people may then undergo surgery elsewhere to alter their genital organs. "This is cooperating with psychosis," Father Anthony Mastroeni, a New Jersey priest who has studied sex-change surgery, told the Anchor. [url="http://www.cwnews.com/news/viewstory.cfm?recnum=58212"]http://www.cwnews.com/news/viewstory.cfm?recnum=58212[/url]
Galloglasses Posted May 6, 2008 Posted May 6, 2008 I know its morally wrong, but I always feel that the liberal nut-jobs who come up with this croutons really need to be dragged out onto the street and shot. I'm an angry person.
Deb Posted May 7, 2008 Posted May 7, 2008 Too bizarre. Are you sure that wasn't in the Onion? (At first I thought the thread said, Chicken, not children.)
Deb Posted May 7, 2008 Posted May 7, 2008 I think you have to come up with a new word because there isn't a single "liberal" person that I know that would find that acceptable. Can't you in invent something left of Liberal. I mean we came up with Neo-Con to show right of conservative and they are as bad in their respects as whomever goes along with this croutons.
picchick Posted May 7, 2008 Posted May 7, 2008 Yeah this is not right...at all....medicall or morally. To medically be able to get a gender change you must live a certain time in the life of the other gender. They you start with the therapy. How does a 10 year old know that it is what they want? They are not developmentally ready for this decision. At that time they are going through Erik Erickson's stage of industry vs. inferiority. They are working through school and finding out what they are good at vs. what they are not good at. Then after that they have to go through role confusion vs. identity. Even during this stage, they are finding out who they are and trying to fit in. It is not the right time or place to be deciding that they want to be a boy if they are a girl or visa versa. They are not ready to make that decision. Why is the medical field not getting back to the basic of childhood development???? Was it not beaten into them during school?
MissScripture Posted May 7, 2008 Posted May 7, 2008 [quote name='picchick' post='1521506' date='May 7 2008, 04:32 PM']Yeah this is not right...at all....medicall or morally. To medically be able to get a gender change you must live a certain time in the life of the other gender. They you start with the therapy. How does a 10 year old know that it is what they want? They are not developmentally ready for this decision. At that time they are going through Erik Erickson's stage of industry vs. inferiority. They are working through school and finding out what they are good at vs. what they are not good at. Then after that they have to go through role confusion vs. identity. Even during this stage, they are finding out who they are and trying to fit in. It is not the right time or place to be deciding that they want to be a boy if they are a girl or visa versa. They are not ready to make that decision. Why is the medical field not getting back to the basic of childhood development???? Was it not beaten into them during school?[/quote] Well, consider this: My brother has a friend who is a nurse who was dealing with a student nurse. The student nurse said her patient had a temp of 76 degrees. And the nurse said, "Don't you mean 97.6?" "No, it says 76 degrees!" "Okay, can you show me...?" The student takes the nurse to the room and points to the thermostat on the wall and says, "See? Right there it says his temp is 76 degrees!" Basically, what I'm saying, is that sadly, people can make it through a lot of schooling and still be really dumb. I don't know if this is due to poor schooling or what, but hearing some of the stories I have from my mom and brother (who both work at the hospital, mom is a nurse, brother wants to be), there are some really dumb people going into the medical field, which smells of elderberries for the good ones who need to work that much harder...
Archaeology cat Posted May 7, 2008 Posted May 7, 2008 [quote name='picchick' post='1521506' date='May 7 2008, 09:32 PM']How does a 10 year old know that it is what they want? They are not developmentally ready for this decision.[/quote] Exactly. I babysat this girl when she was 8-10, and she always said she wanted to be a boy (she was a tomboy). However, now that she is 18 and in college, she definitely enjoys being a girl. But at that point she felt that being a boy was cooler because they didnt play with dolls and got to play in the dirt. Once she figured out that girls could just as easily play in the dirt, she was over it. So, to sum up, kids that age have yet to figure out who they are, and cannot make such a decision as a gender change at that point.
picchick Posted May 7, 2008 Posted May 7, 2008 [quote name='MissScripture' post='1521528' date='May 7 2008, 04:57 PM']Well, consider this: My brother has a friend who is a nurse who was dealing with a student nurse. The student nurse said her patient had a temp of 76 degrees. And the nurse said, "Don't you mean 97.6?" "No, it says 76 degrees!" "Okay, can you show me...?" The student takes the nurse to the room and points to the thermostat on the wall and says, "See? Right there it says his temp is 76 degrees!" Basically, what I'm saying, is that sadly, people can make it through a lot of schooling and still be really dumb. I don't know if this is due to poor schooling or what, but hearing some of the stories I have from my mom and brother (who both work at the hospital, mom is a nurse, brother wants to be), there are some really dumb people going into the medical field, which smells of elderberries for the good ones who need to work that much harder...[/quote] Oh yeah I could tell you the stories that I have.....from nursing students who didn't make it et. al. But anyways. I am just saying that out of a whole hospital...there has got to be SOMEONE who knows SOMETHING about basic childhood development who can raise their hand and say, "HELLOOOO?!?!"
Socrates Posted May 8, 2008 Posted May 8, 2008 [quote name='Deb' post='1521320' date='May 7 2008, 11:36 AM']I think you have to come up with a new word because there isn't a single "liberal" person that I know that would find that acceptable. Can't you in invent something left of Liberal. I mean we came up with Neo-Con to show right of conservative and they are as bad in their respects as whomever goes along with this croutons.[/quote] 1) I guess I'm not real creative at that sort of thing. For left-of-liberal, there is the word "Communist," though that's not quite what I'm getting at, and I'm sure even hardened KGB chiefs would be shocked at parents taking their kiddies into the clinic to get their genitals mutilated. But let's face it; it's social liberals, not conservatives, that tend to be in favor of this sort of thing. I was actually thinking along the lines of the word "progressive," as people in favor of such sick causes tend to favor that word over "liberal," but the phrase "progressive progress" would sound redundant and silly. 2) For the hundredth time, "Neo-conservative" ("Neo-Con") does [b]NOT[/b] mean "to the right of conservative" or "ultra-conservative." "Neo-conservative" literally means "new conservative," and refers to largely Jewish former liberals who tend to support a powerful central government, "interventionalist" foreign policy, and the State of Israel. William Kristol, Norman Podhoretz, and the staff of The Weekly Standard, are typical of neo-cons. From Merriam-Webster[quote]Main Entry: neo·con·ser·va·tive Pronunciation: \ˌnē-ō-kən-ˈsər-və-tiv\ Function: noun Date: 1952 1 : a former liberal espousing political conservatism 2 : a conservative who advocates the assertive promotion of democracy and United States national interest in international affairs including through military means[/quote] They are opposed by old-school conservatives, or "paleo-cons" (also known as "traditionalist conservatives") who are opposed to large centralized government, favor "isolationist" foreign policy, and are for smaller, more decentralized government, strict constitutionalism, and traditional religious/social values. Pat Buchanan, Joe Sobran, and the late Samuel Francis are examples of paleo-cons. "Paleo-cons" generally do not consider neo-cons to be real conservatives, but a type of liberal. This should be pinned. If people are going to bash conservatives, they should at least get their terminology correct.
Deb Posted May 8, 2008 Posted May 8, 2008 (edited) You know, from the posts you have put on this week, it appears you have sat on a cactus or something. Why are you so negative and grumpy? Children getting a gender change is not a "liberals" cause. Jesus was a liberal if you want to get down to it and I think he is getting sick of people perverting it to mean anything they don't agree with or anything hideous or horrible. I know I am. So, get over it and find a new term for that kind of croutons. Hitler was the ultimate conservative but, no one calls the republican party the new nazis or anything. Find someone else to blame for all the ills of the world, this is getting so old. Edited May 8, 2008 by Deb
Socrates Posted May 8, 2008 Posted May 8, 2008 [quote name='Deb' post='1521913' date='May 7 2008, 09:58 PM']You know, from the posts you have put on this week, it appears you have sat on a cactus or something. Why are you so negative and grumpy?[/quote] Grumpy? I'm having a blast! I was laughing out loud posting my last post. [quote]Children getting a gender change is not a "liberals" cause. Jesus was a liberal if you want to get down to it and I think he is getting sick of people perverting it to mean anything they don't agree with or anything hideous or horrible. I know I am. So, get over it and find a new term for that kind of croutons. Hitler was the ultimate conservative but, no one calls the republican party the new nazis or anything. Find someone else to blame for all the ills of the world, this is getting so old.[/quote] So the "transgender" movement is not liberal? Really, now? I'm sure the majority of those in the "gay, lesbian, transgendered" (GLAD) movement would beg to differ with you on that! Tell me, is it conservatives or liberals which adamantly support abortion, homosexuality, "transgenderism," and other abominations as "rights"? Is it liberals or conservatives who support an abandonment of "traditional gender roles" and want to teach kids about homosexuality in kindergarten? After all, which political party has support for "abortion rights" and "gay rights" written into its party platform? These people consider their cause liberal or progressive, as do most other people (whatever their political persuasion). Even in this post, Galloglasses referred to this as liberal, and he's from Ireland! If you want to find some creative new term for it, go ahead, but that's up to you. And for the record, Hitler was no conservative, but a statist socialist. After all, "Nazi" is short for "National Socialist." It's obvious you nothing about either National Socialism or conservatism if you confuse the two. If reality is "getting old" for you, I'm sorry, but I'm not going to call things other than what they are.
CatherineM Posted May 8, 2008 Posted May 8, 2008 Instead of left and right, how about windward and leeward. Or how about an extreme liberal as being a port liberal and an extreme conservative as a starboard one. As to the topic, at 10 years of age, with only brothers, and boys in the neighborhood to play with, and since they didn't let me play football, I probably would have opted to become a boy. That was before puberty hit, and I no longer wanted to hit boys. That's why children have parents to make decisions for them. There is no way at 10 that I would have been capable of understanding all the implications involved.
Alycin Posted May 8, 2008 Posted May 8, 2008 I don't think children should be able to get elective surgeries, period! Hasn't that always been the rule? Like, you can't even get a nose job or a boob job until you're 18 with most doctors... I always wonder about those ever-so-rare cases where children are born with both genders' genitalia.. cause I mean... used to they just automatically "cut it off" because it was easier to "make them into a girl"... but yeah... I remember watching a video about that in health... Also... I can't WAIT until the political season is over... I used to be obsessed with politics and ran around *seriously* making it my life to oppose the right-wingers and what not... articles in newspapers, a political blog, hours upon hours of research on embryonic stem cell research and writing my term papers on why the right is wrong... meeting senators and congressmen and thinking being invited to study in DC in the summers was sooo cool... ulgh. I wish I would have spent those summers at the LAKE! Haha. Politics has a tendency to bring out the worst in people. I'm just sooooooo so so SO glad that I no longer spend every minute of the day blaming the problems of the world on a political party... cause the problems of the world revolve around [b]sin[/b] and the fall of man... NOT the right... NOT the left... /steps off soapbox.
Deb Posted May 8, 2008 Posted May 8, 2008 [quote name='Socrates' post='1522001' date='May 8 2008, 12:19 AM']Grumpy? I'm having a blast! I was laughing out loud posting my last post. So the "transgender" movement is not liberal? Really, now? I'm sure the majority of those in the "gay, lesbian, transgendered" (GLAD) movement would beg to differ with you on that! Tell me, is it conservatives or liberals which adamantly support abortion, homosexuality, "transgenderism," and other abominations as "rights"? Is it liberals or conservatives who support an abandonment of "traditional gender roles" and want to teach kids about homosexuality in kindergarten? After all, which political party has support for "abortion rights" and "gay rights" written into its party platform? These people consider their cause liberal or progressive, as do most other people (whatever their political persuasion). Even in this post, Galloglasses referred to this as liberal, and he's from Ireland! If you want to find some creative new term for it, go ahead, but that's up to you. And for the record, Hitler was no conservative, but a statist socialist. After all, "Nazi" is short for "National Socialist." It's obvious you nothing about either National Socialism or conservatism if you confuse the two. If reality is "getting old" for you, I'm sorry, but I'm not going to call things other than what they are.[/quote] You call things the way that you see them in such a generalized way that it eventually has no meaning at all, it turns into, I am Socrates, I don't like the color blue so I wil label it a liberal color. Are you even capable of discussing ANY issue that you are not in agreement with without calling it liberal in a NEGATIVE way? That is my point. It is like the F word for you. I am liberal. I am in liberal in my love for other people, I am liberal in that I believe we owe it to our fellow human beings to make sure all have the basic necessities of life, I am liberal in the amount of money I give to my church and to charities, I am liberal in the amount of butter I put on a potato. I do not support abortion in any case and I won't vote for people who do. Are those bad things? No. Try, just one week to actually post on any subject with out using Liberal as a swear word. See what else you could come up with. On this subject. Whomever is this deluded and nuts has a serious disconnect with society and with the value and beauty of the human body and should get some professional help. See how easy that was? Some realities are getting old. Your use of the term Liberal as a derogatory term is one of them.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now