Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Things Christians And Athiests Can Agree On.


Recommended Posts

Posted

[url="http://www.cracked.com/article_15663_10-things-christians-atheists-can-must-agree-on.html"]10 things Christians and Athiests can Agree on[/url]

okay so this is an article i found that compares Christianity with Athiesm. but with a twist. its not about how the beliefs(or lack thereof) are different but more on how the believers themselves are similar or the same.
anyways, i really liked the article, it does a good job of being fair to both sides and unoffensive(so you can show it to your non christian freinds without them saying its biased against them.)
the author does have some demotivational posters on there, but they mock both sides, and are an example of what not to do.
read on, let me know what you think!

CatherineM
Posted

The America Repent poster put Catholics right between evolutionists and satanists. The Atheists were between preachers and rich people. At least the Atheists were much further down on his list.

He is right about a bunch of stuff that he put. You would be surprised just looking around on the bus how many atheists there are. I found out that one of my husband's best friends is an atheist. I just don't get it. I can understand not believing in a certain religion, but how can you look around at this world and not see the magnificent hand of God in it.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1526784' date='May 13 2008, 12:14 AM']The America Repent poster put Catholics right between evolutionists and satanists. The Atheists were between preachers and rich people. At least the Atheists were much further down on his list.

He is right about a bunch of stuff that he put. You would be surprised just looking around on the bus how many atheists there are. I found out that one of my husband's best friends is an atheist. I just don't get it. I can understand not believing in a certain religion, but how can you look around at this world and not see the magnificent hand of God in it.[/quote]
Yeah, I work with some atheists and we have the "lights out" discussion quite often and it is funny (you know, the old what happens after you die topic). If I really believed what they profess I don't think I would bother getting out of bed in the morning. hehe. What kind of creeps me out a little is that it is weird to view other people as basically mechanical beasts that will turn off and sink into nothingness at some random point in an utterly arbitrary future. I suppose it makes sense that such people would generally have no real problem with abortion and things of that sort (although often they seem to be passionately in favor of such things which is curious). If people are nothing more than randomly generated blobs of biological matter and life is an absurd and nightmarish farce than who cares - or rather why care about much of anything at all? Of course they don't put forth such conclusions and often feign high morality, but really, if the human person is ultimately an illusion and we are all nothing, and destined to nothingness, than why care about anything? Caring about things would be an empty illusion and desire itself is just a joke. The totality of human existence is essentially devoid of content. Isn’t it just frivolous and even contradictory to assert values in anything but a most relativistic or pragmatic way? I also find the dogmatism of these friends of mine to be a subject of amusement. The fervor and vigor with which these absolute statements about existence are maintained strikes me as something of a contradiction. Why not just embrace the full implications and succumb to all-out absurdism and apathy? If I believed that human existence was an entirely arbitrary and empty farce without a telos of any kind (apart from total personal annihilation) I would probably consider such things as society and morality to be about as meaningful and binding as a stupid dream. Hmm.. I think I am somebody and that I exist for some reason but in fact I am nobody and will be erased momentarily after scratching about at this world like a rat in a trash heap. Yum.
How can this kind of world-view justify statements such as “I love you?” If somebody claimed to love me but in the same breath asserted that I am entirely analogous to my desktop computer and that all of my thoughts, actions, desires, et cetera are of no more value or significance than the algorithms that produce Microsoft Windows and that what I perceive to be the value of my person is just a byproduct of cold and mindless evolutionary processes I think I would not be particularly impressed. I love you too?
Yes ladies and gentlemen, death is like shutting off a computer and throwing out the hard drive. Perhaps some variation of the epicurean delusion can pacify such individuals and perhaps it is the mass media culture of meaninglessness that shelters this kind of existence in our times. And in my opinion the attack on religion is a cop-out. One does not need to embrace the asinine caricatures of religion that they popularly ridicule in order to be open to the mystery of being and the rich intimations inherent to the sheer fact of our existence. But if one is truly open to the mystery of our existential situation than why all the militant dogmatism?

Posted

im really not sure if you did or not laudate, but can everyone please read the article before commenting? there are plenty of other places to respond to each others views, try not to derail this one yet.

VeniteAdoremus
Posted

I read the article, and I thought it was great :) (A+++, Would Read Again). If people disagree with it because it isn't extra ecclesia nulla salus enough for them, they might consider the fact that this attitude wins more converts than waving Hell around.

Farsight one
Posted

Since this is about what Christians and atheists have in common and is the light-hearted open-mic, I thought this might be amusing to some:

[img]http://scottthong.files.wordpress.com/2008/04/atheistchristianscientol.jpg[/img]

Posted

[quote name='Farsight one' post='1526831' date='May 13 2008, 07:28 AM']Since this is about what Christians and atheists have in common and is the light-hearted open-mic, I thought this might be amusing to some:

[img]http://scottthong.files.wordpress.com/2008/04/atheistchristianscientol.jpg[/img][/quote]

:lol_roll:

Posted

I thought the article was hilarious and made some very good points. Thanks for sharing!

Posted

Great link! Thanks!!

CatherineM
Posted

Laud-I did have a funny thought. My dad told me once that hell is basically the absence of God, therefore nothingness. So I guess another thing we have in common is that potentially we will both get what we think is coming. Believers will find heaven, and be with God, and Atheists will find the nothingness they are expecting.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Jesus_lol' post='1526794' date='May 13 2008, 01:31 AM']im really not sure if you did or not laudate, but can everyone please read the article before commenting? there are plenty of other places to respond to each others views, try not to derail this one yet.[/quote]
Of course I read the article, but the link you provided only contains half of the article. I find the fundamentalist vs. athiest bigot debates to be tacky and tiresome anyway so I'm not particularly excited about the article, but I suppose it was okay. In my opinion both popular religion and popular "athiesm" are pretty lame.

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1526992' date='May 13 2008, 11:44 AM']Laud-I did have a funny thought. My dad told me once that hell is basically the absence of God, therefore nothingness. So I guess another thing we have in common is that potentially we will both get what we think is coming. Believers will find heaven, and be with God, and Atheists will find the nothingness they are expecting.[/quote]


Definitely! I think their nothingness will be so much worse than they could ever imagine though. They may not believe in God but, God still resides within them and when he is gone. they will know it.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

Maybe I'm infected by political correctness, but I have an aversion towards speculating about the salvation or damnation of other people. I know that G-d, all glory is His, desires the salvation of all and I do not believe I can judge whether or not an individual has or will respond to the grace that G-d, bless His Name, gives them. At least on an abstract level I believe that atheists can respond to the salvific grace of G-d, may He be praised, so I don't like to automatically create a believer/saved, non-believer/damned dichotomy. I am a believer in the Catholic Faith but I know from experience that I can turn away from G-d's grace. I was once a non-believer and I know that G-d, bless His Name, can break even the most hardened of hearts.

I do like asking atheists about death and personal annihilation, but when the category of salvation enters into the discussion they seem to go into anti-organized-religion mode; at least in my experience. hehe. This is an interesting subject actually - how to meaningfully discuss salvation with a staunch atheist. I would like to try this the next chance I get.

Posted

Interesting, warm and fuzzy article....

Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1527094' date='May 13 2008, 10:43 AM']Of course I read the article, but the link you provided only contains half of the article. I find the fundamentalist vs. athiest bigot debates to be tacky and tiresome anyway so I'm not particularly excited about the article, but I suppose it was okay. In my opinion both popular religion and popular "athiesm" are pretty lame.[/quote]
+J.M.J.+
L_D, :twitch: you need to use more spacing in your op on this topic. :twitch: the words all run together. i caught a good point in there about love, but :idontknow:

:weights:

Galloglasses
Posted

Ok, this made me laugh.

[img]http://cdn-www.cracked.com/articleimages/wong/xianmacro2.jpg[/img]

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' post='1527184' date='May 13 2008, 01:52 PM']+J.M.J.+
L_D, :twitch: you need to use more spacing in your op on this topic. :twitch: the words all run together. i caught a good point in there about love, but :idontknow:

:weights:[/quote]
That is the lovely 3:00 AM frivolous rant style of writing. haha.

Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1527254' date='May 13 2008, 01:44 PM']That is the lovely 3:00 AM frivolous rant style of writing. haha.[/quote]
+J.M.J.+
:hehe: totally gotcha. :thumbsup:

:weights:

Posted

[quote name='Galloglasses' post='1527237' date='May 13 2008, 01:36 PM']Ok, this made me laugh.

[img]http://cdn-www.cracked.com/articleimages/wong/xianmacro2.jpg[/img][/quote]
+J.M.J.+
:bigshock:
































:lol_pound:





























:mellow:

Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1526793' date='May 13 2008, 02:04 AM']Yeah, I work with some atheists and we have the "lights out" discussion quite often and it is funny (you know, the old what happens after you die topic). If I really believed what they profess I don't think I would bother getting out of bed in the morning. hehe. What kind of creeps me out a little is that it is weird to view other people as basically mechanical beasts that will turn off and sink into nothingness at some random point in an utterly arbitrary future. I suppose it makes sense that such people would generally have no real problem with abortion and things of that sort (although often they seem to be passionately in favor of such things which is curious). If people are nothing more than randomly generated blobs of biological matter and life is an absurd and nightmarish farce than who cares - or rather why care about much of anything at all? Of course they don't put forth such conclusions and often feign high morality, but really, if the human person is ultimately an illusion and we are all nothing, and destined to nothingness, than why care about anything? Caring about things would be an empty illusion and desire itself is just a joke. The totality of human existence is essentially devoid of content. Isn't it just frivolous and even contradictory to assert values in anything but a most relativistic or pragmatic way? I also find the dogmatism of these friends of mine to be a subject of amusement. The fervor and vigor with which these absolute statements about existence are maintained strikes me as something of a contradiction. Why not just embrace the full implications and succumb to all-out absurdism and apathy? If I believed that human existence was an entirely arbitrary and empty farce without a telos of any kind (apart from total personal annihilation) I would probably consider such things as society and morality to be about as meaningful and binding as a stupid dream. Hmm.. I think I am somebody and that I exist for some reason but in fact I am nobody and will be erased momentarily after scratching about at this world like a rat in a trash heap. Yum.
How can this kind of world-view justify statements such as "I love you?" If somebody claimed to love me but in the same breath asserted that I am entirely analogous to my desktop computer and that all of my thoughts, actions, desires, et cetera are of no more value or significance than the algorithms that produce Microsoft Windows and that what I perceive to be the value of my person is just a byproduct of cold and mindless evolutionary processes I think I would not be particularly impressed. I love you too?
Yes ladies and gentlemen, death is like shutting off a computer and throwing out the hard drive. Perhaps some variation of the epicurean delusion can pacify such individuals and perhaps it is the mass media culture of meaninglessness that shelters this kind of existence in our times. And in my opinion the attack on religion is a cop-out. One does not need to embrace the asinine caricatures of religion that they popularly ridicule in order to be open to the mystery of being and the rich intimations inherent to the sheer fact of our existence. But if one is truly open to the mystery of our existential situation than why all the militant dogmatism?[/quote]
That's a good post. I totally agree. I've said something along those lines to my atheist friend (I believe as of recent they're calling themselves "brights" :rolleyes:). I should bring it up again. I don't really know how I could argue this. I don't even think I could "win", but it would get people thinking.

[quote name='Farsight one' post='1526831' date='May 13 2008, 07:28 AM']Since this is about what Christians and atheists have in common and is the light-hearted open-mic, I thought this might be amusing to some:

[img]http://scottthong.files.wordpress.com/2008/04/atheistchristianscientol.jpg[/img][/quote]

Lawl... reminds me of the PC/Mac commercials.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...