Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Question For The Women


A question for the women...  

89 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

franciscanheart
Posted

[mod]Warning: Some content may be a source of temptation for some people. Please do not read any further if you are inclined to sins of the sexual nature based on reading about a person's lack of clothing. --hugheyforlife[/mod]

[b]Note: I've asked that men not vote in the poll but they may respond/ask questions below. I'm trying to get a feel for WOMEN in general, not men. Thanks![/b]

So here's a question for the ladies. We know that a lot of men have a hard time not staring at women with inappropriate clothing. But as a woman, do you find it hard to not notice that another woman is wearing something that probably she shouldn't?

Here's an example, you're sitting in a coffee shop working on something or reading. Someone you know walks in and notices you there. She's wearing a tank top with built in bra, but one that doesn't really work as a bra so much as a shield against potential see-through-ness. You notice it.

Here's the question, do you instantly look away and find yourself able to avoid noticing the shirt again? Do you notice it, look away, and fight against the natural inclination to notice the shirt? Do you catch yourself looking at it periodically and trying to observe it without being obvious (in a totally non-sexual way) so that you can finally stop looking?

I myself find shirts like that to be very distracting. I can't focus on what you're saying because your freakin cleavage is hanging out! I mean really...

Anyway, I'm wondering how common (or uncommon as the case may be) it is for women to be just as distracted by "skimpy" clothing as men, though likely in a different way (non-sexual vs sexual, respectively).

Posted

Very much so. It is like watching a car accident. I don't WANT to look, but I just can't seem to look away.

Posted

That was me. Chad forgot to log out....

Posted

Yep. Doesn't matter if they are young or old, thin, fat or hideous. It is like someone waving them in your face screaming, "look at me!" I have actually made comments to my neice that I feel like she is trying to serve her breasts up on a platter and I would rather have a steak, thank you very much.

It is done to get attention, pure and simple. Course, there are men out there who can't take their eyes off your chest even if you have a turtleneck and down jacket on. Those guys usually end up getting a poke in their eyes.

Minor cleavage, no biggie. Major cleavage, annoying. Push up bras and tottering boobs, give me a break please. I may just feel inclined to put my spoon in there or a carrot stick.

Noel's angel
Posted

No...why would I notice?

CatherineM
Posted

I think lately, at least since it has warmed up some, I've mostly been noticing belly buttons more than cleavage. I'm just amazed that beautiful young women would want as much crack showing in the back as a middle-aged carpenter with a big tool belt dragging down his pants.

I also seem to notice inappropriate clothing on young girls more because I'm so shocked by it. Shocked that you can buy that stuff in those small sizes, and that their mothers have bought it for them. I know that teenagers can and do buy their own clothes, but when an 8 year old girl is wearing it, chances are that someone else has bought it for her.

It's also possible I don't notice females shoving their cleavage into people's faces because I'm tall, and usually have a better view of the top of their heads. I've also never had cleavage except when pregnant, so that may be another reason I don't notice. When I do notice though, it is usually because it isn't just a little cleavage, but a lot. I just want to shake them and ask them if the pictures their friends are taking of them with their cell phone cameras are the kind of pictures you want to show off to your grandchildren. It's so sad that we seem to have an entire generation that think their bodies are their best commodity to be advertised and sold at a discount like something on a shelf at Walmart.

Posted

Yes and yes and agreed.

I try not to look...but I don't look in a "boy that's attractive" way. I more am amazed that they are dressed like it.
It is like a car accident. You don't want to look but you just do.
I also dislike the fact that women wear clothes that do not fit them. I think that it is much more attractive to find clothes that fit you regardless of the size than to go walking around with everything hanging out.

Women I think do it though fro attention so I try not to give it to them.

Posted

[quote name='picchick' post='1528495' date='May 14 2008, 02:05 PM']Yes and yes and agreed.

I try not to look...but I don't look in a "boy that's attractive" way. I more am amazed that they are dressed like it.
It is like a car accident. You don't want to look but you just do.
I also dislike the fact that women wear clothes that do not fit them. I think that it is much more attractive to find clothes that fit you regardless of the size than to go walking around with everything hanging out.

Women I think do it though fro attention so I try not to give it to them.[/quote]

yes, exactly like a car accident.

HisChildForever
Posted

Sadly, it's so common that, for the most part, I hardly notice. However, I will say that there are two instances where I really notice: in Church, and on younger girls. The shirts I can't stand in Church are the strappy ones that practically expose the entire back. Even if I feel like wearing a tank top, I always layer with a nice shirt or throw on a zip-up sweater. Now, on younger girls - I mean those 13 year old kids with short skirts and tube tops, prancing around for all the world to see. =/

Madame Vengier
Posted (edited)

No, I don't stare at things that are repulsive to me no matter what they are.

That said, I don't get freaked out if a woman's clothes are not quite as modest as my own or quite as modest as I think they should be. If I see cleavage I just think "that's not really in good taste" but I don't think anything else of it. I certainly don't run away or feel like I'm sinning because I notice it. I just don't get worked up over it. I feel there are more important things in life to worry about. It just doesn't bother me beyond the momentary realization of it.

I also think the more you fixate on something being wrong and not wanting to see it, the harder it is for you to tear your eyes away. That's my personal feeling on the matter. By constantly thinking about it you cause yourself to keep looking even though you don't want to.

I think some people might need to lighten up and then you won't keep experiencing these distractions and inability to look away.

Edited by Madame Vengier
Rosemary's Goddaughter
Posted

[quote name='picchick' post='1528495' date='May 14 2008, 02:05 PM']Yes and yes and agreed.

I try not to look...but I don't look in a "boy that's attractive" way. I more am amazed that they are dressed like it.
It is like a car accident. You don't want to look but you just do.
I also dislike the fact that women wear clothes that do not fit them. I think that it is much more attractive to find clothes that fit you regardless of the size than to go walking around with everything hanging out.

Women I think do it though fro attention so I try not to give it to them.[/quote]

You put it much better than I could have hoped to.

Archaeology cat
Posted

[quote name='picchick' post='1528495' date='May 14 2008, 07:05 PM']I also dislike the fact that women wear clothes that do not fit them. I think that it is much more attractive to find clothes that fit you regardless of the size than to go walking around with everything hanging out.[/quote]
Yeah. I'd say for me it's most often just being repulsed by someone very obviously not wearing a bra (you know, like wearing a thin, tight shirt and no bra), or wearing clothes that are way too small. From living in FL, I don't really react to tank tops (and I wear them if it's warm enough) or things like that.

Posted

[quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1528535' date='May 14 2008, 12:53 PM']I think some people might need to lighten up and then you won't keep experiencing these distractions and inability to look away.[/quote]
+J.M.J.+
some people are extremely scrupulous about this sort of thing, and it's not just a matter of 'lightening up'. :)

Posted

I can't help but notice if a girl is dressing like a -- well, not modestly. It disgusts me and makes me angry. Eventually I just ignore her, but knowing that people want to disgrace themselves just irritates the shinobi out of me. :ohno:

Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' post='1528564' date='May 14 2008, 02:19 PM']+J.M.J.+
some people are extremely scrupulous about this sort of thing, and it's not just a matter of 'lightening up'. :)[/quote]

Then those people will have to never turn on the telly and never leave their house, becuase all around us life is not perfect and people are not always in line with our own thinking. I don't have patience with victimization and the inability to cope in an imperfect world. There so much greater things happening that are a threat to our freedoms and our very way of life. Some immodest shirts are the very least of our worries.

Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='MissyP89' post='1528674' date='May 14 2008, 04:25 PM']I can't help but notice if a girl is dressing like a -- well, not modestly. It disgusts me and makes me angry. Eventually I just ignore her, but knowing that people want to disgrace themselves just irritates the shinobi out of me. :ohno:[/quote]

"Shinobi" :hehe:

hoosieranna
Posted

The shirts have to be pretty bad for me to notice. I try to be careful, as I am not flat-chested, but I don't usually worry about what others are wearing. I think the only time I might even say something is if one of my students had various bits hanging all about.

Posted

+J.M.J.+[quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1528684' date='May 14 2008, 03:39 PM']Then those people will have to never turn on the telly and never leave their house, becuase all around us life is not perfect and people are not always in line with our own thinking. I don't have patience with victimization and the inability to cope in an imperfect world. There so much greater things happening that are a threat to our freedoms and our very way of life. Some immodest shirts are the very least of our worries.[/quote]i don't think it's victimization if a person honestly struggles alot with a certain sin. i think we all should do what we can to promote the dignity of each person and help them if they are struggling with a certain sin (whether it be scrupulousity or immodesty)

[quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1528687' date='May 14 2008, 03:40 PM']"Shinobi" :hehe:[/quote]
it's the philter :hehe:

Lisieux Flower
Posted

[quote name='HisChildForever' post='1528524' date='May 14 2008, 02:31 PM']Sadly, it's so common that, for the most part, I hardly notice. However, I will say that there are two instances where I really notice: in Church, and on younger girls. The shirts I can't stand in Church are the strappy ones that practically expose the entire back. Even if I feel like wearing a tank top, I always layer with a nice shirt or throw on a zip-up sweater. Now, on younger girls - I mean those 13 year old kids with short skirts and tube tops, prancing around for all the world to see. =/[/quote]

I agree... I go to the mall and see high schoolers wearing tiny tank tops and super short shorts and I almost feel numb to it because it's not any different than what girls are wearing on tv or even what the next girl I'll pass is wearing. It's really sad...

And I completely agree that it's really amazing how some parents let their kids dress. Last summer I worked at the YMCA with middle schoolers and some days my kids wore tiny skirts and shirts. I can't help but wonder if we don't pay more attention to the "imperfections" of our world, how big could this get? I think it's a pretty big problem when 12 year olds are wearing tiny shorts with "hottie" written on the back and singing rap songs about things that are inappropriate for anyone to be singing about. Maybe we need to keep (respectfully and lovingly) showing society that this immodesty is a big problem in order to keep it from getting worse.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1528493' date='May 14 2008, 03:01 PM']It's also possible I don't notice females shoving their cleavage into people's faces because I'm tall, and usually have a better view of the top of their heads. I've also never had cleavage except when pregnant, so that may be another reason I don't notice. When I do notice though, it is usually because it isn't just a little cleavage, but a lot. I just want to shake them and ask them if the pictures their friends are taking of them with their cell phone cameras are the kind of pictures you want to show off to your grandchildren. It's so sad that we seem to have an entire generation that think their bodies are their best commodity to be advertised and sold at a discount like something on a shelf at Walmart.[/quote]

Considering how very short I am I do see somethings more than I would like. And it is exactly like a train wreck, except you are wondering if they simply glued their clothes on, if they take a deep breath there is gonna be a clothing "malfunction" or they are simply advertising their merchandise. Grandma always said if you have to flaunt it, you don't value it very much. You have to wonder what their grandmas would say if she saw them. I can't see how any woman expects to be taken seriously when she dresses provocatively.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...