jeffpugh Posted May 14, 2008 Posted May 14, 2008 [url="http://www.splendoroftruth.com/curtjester/archives/008921.php"]http://www.splendoroftruth.com/curtjester/...ives/008921.php[/url] There is commentary on this letter at these places as well: [url="http://www.cantemusdomino.net/"]http://www.cantemusdomino.net/[/url] [url="http://www.creativeminorityreport.com/2008/05/haugen-locuta-est-causa-finita-est.html"]http://www.creativeminorityreport.com/2008...finita-est.html[/url] (more links enclosed in the blogs). What do you all think?
kujo Posted May 14, 2008 Posted May 14, 2008 I did lots of music by Marty Haugen in my college choir. Never saw anything inappropriate about it liturgically.
CatherineM Posted May 14, 2008 Posted May 14, 2008 Wow, I guess I'm really out of it because I had no idea that people hated Haugen's music. I happen to love it. Oh right, it's modern music, I forgot that some people think that you aren't a really faithful Catholic if you prefer new music to stuff written 200 years ago in Latin. Our parish has been scrambling to find people who can play organ/piano/guitar at masses. We can't pay, and you can only overwork volunteers so much. We found a traditional organist and a cantor who was willing to work with him once a month, and he only does older music out of the old hymnals. At Pentecost services, not only were people not singing, but few ever bothered to pick up the book to try. Traditionalists might hate (don't hate, appreciate) Haugen's music, but when we play his songs in church people sing, are engaged and drawn into the worship. I know that shouldn't matter, that we are all supposed to be there for the Eucharist, but I guess I have to live in the real world. My real world is a small, poor church in a neighborhood filled with pawn shops, XXX video parlors, prostitutes and drug dealers. To me the most important thing is to get people's butts in the pews. I hope that something brings them back rather than sending them running to the doors.
Noel's angel Posted May 14, 2008 Posted May 14, 2008 3 points. Haugen...YUCK CatherineM, no pianos in Mass please (they're forbidden)! People in our Church sing much better when we play more 'traditional' hymns. They tend not to like these happy-clappy songs.
prose Posted May 14, 2008 Posted May 14, 2008 Gah... There is a debate about modern music in Mass in the debate section.
Madame Vengier Posted May 14, 2008 Posted May 14, 2008 Marty Haugen...honestly, I loved that stuff 18 years ago when I was brand-new at attending Mass, that's what was played in the parish where I attended and I literally didn't know any other kind of "liturgical music" existed. When I finally did hear REAL sacred music and I could see the difference, it became nearly unbearable (literally) for me to hear the Marty Haugen type of stuff. It's not horrible...just dreadfully inferior when it comes to music for the liturgy. I think it's fine for listening to at home while you clear the house or whatever or while you're in your car...if you like it, which I don't.
CatherineM Posted May 14, 2008 Posted May 14, 2008 From: Musicam Sacram, Sacred Congregation of Rites, March 5, 1967 9. In selecting the kind of sacred music to be used, whether it be for the choir or for the people, the capacities of those who are to sing the music must be taken into account. No kind of sacred music is prohibited from liturgical actions by the Church as long as it corresponds to the spirit of the liturgical celebration itself and the nature of its individual parts,7 and does not hinder the active participation of the people. 10. In order that the faithful may actively participate more willingly and with greater benefit, it is fitting that the format of the celebration and the degree of participation in it should be varied as much as possible, according to the solemnity of the day and the nature of the congregation present. 11. It should be kept in mind that the true solemnity of liturgical worship depends less on a more ornate form of singing and a more magnificent ceremonial than on its worthy and religious celebration, which takes into account the integrity of the liturgical celebration itself, and the performance of each of its parts according to their own particular nature. To have a more ornate form of singing and a more magnificent ceremonial is at times desirable when there are the resources available to carry them out properly; on the other hand it would be contrary to the true solemnity of the liturgy if this were to lead to a part of the action being omitted, changed, or improperly performed. 62. Musical instruments can be very useful in sacred celebrations, whether they accompany the singing or whether they are played as solo instruments. "The pipe organ is to be held in high esteem, for it is the traditional instrument of the Church, the sound of which can add a wonderful splendor to the Church's ceremonies and powerfully lift up men's minds to God and higher things. "The use of other instruments may also be admitted in divine worship, given the decision and consent of the competent territorial authority, provided that the instruments are suitable for sacred use, or can be adapted to it, that they are in keeping with the dignity of the temple, and truly contribute to the edification of the faithful."43 63. In permitting and using musical instruments, the culture and traditions of individual peoples must be taken into account. However, those instruments that are, by common opinion and use, suitable for secular music only, are to be altogether prohibited from every liturgical celebration and from popular devotions. In other words, do the best you can within your parish's capabilities in terms of resources both financial, logistical and personnel. We can't all live next door to a Cathedral with a 50 member choir, and an organist with a degree from Juliard.
Brother Adam Posted May 14, 2008 Posted May 14, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1528552' date='May 14 2008, 06:06 PM']From: Musicam Sacram, Sacred Congregation of Rites, March 5, 1967 9. In selecting the kind of sacred music to be used, whether it be for the choir or for the people, the capacities of those who are to sing the music must be taken into account. No kind of sacred music is prohibited from liturgical actions by the Church as long as it corresponds to the spirit of the liturgical celebration itself and the nature of its individual parts,7 and does not hinder the active participation of the people. 10. In order that the faithful may actively participate more willingly and with greater benefit, it is fitting that the format of the celebration and the degree of participation in it should be varied as much as possible, according to the solemnity of the day and the nature of the congregation present. 11. It should be kept in mind that the true solemnity of liturgical worship depends less on a more ornate form of singing and a more magnificent ceremonial than on its worthy and religious celebration, which takes into account the integrity of the liturgical celebration itself, and the performance of each of its parts according to their own particular nature. To have a more ornate form of singing and a more magnificent ceremonial is at times desirable when there are the resources available to carry them out properly; on the other hand it would be contrary to the true solemnity of the liturgy if this were to lead to a part of the action being omitted, changed, or improperly performed. 62. Musical instruments can be very useful in sacred celebrations, whether they accompany the singing or whether they are played as solo instruments. "The pipe organ is to be held in high esteem, for it is the traditional instrument of the Church, the sound of which can add a wonderful splendor to the Church's ceremonies and powerfully lift up men's minds to God and higher things. "The use of other instruments may also be admitted in divine worship, given the decision and consent of the competent territorial authority, provided that the instruments are suitable for sacred use, or can be adapted to it, that they are in keeping with the dignity of the temple, and truly contribute to the edification of the faithful."43 63. In permitting and using musical instruments, the culture and traditions of individual peoples must be taken into account. However, those instruments that are, by common opinion and use, suitable for secular music only, are to be altogether prohibited from every liturgical celebration and from popular devotions. In other words, do the best you can within your parish's capabilities in terms of resources both financial, logistical and personnel. We can't all live next door to a Cathedral with a 50 member choir, and an organist with a degree from Juliard.[/quote] So how did the poor Irish do it 100 years ago when a piano was totally unheard of at Mass, and the organ usually a novelty? It can be done, easily, we're just too selfish and spoiled to be willing to. If you give a moose a cookie...We don't care about how God wants us to worship, we only care about what makes us feel good. While some of their stuff is actually pretty good, that is the problem with H&H. Americans grossly rip those paragraphs out of context and out of the intent in which they were written.
StColette Posted May 14, 2008 Posted May 14, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1528552' date='May 14 2008, 03:06 PM']From: Musicam Sacram, Sacred Congregation of Rites, March 5, 1967 9. In selecting the kind of sacred music to be used, whether it be for the choir or for the people, the capacities of those who are to sing the music must be taken into account. No kind of sacred music is prohibited from liturgical actions by the Church as long as it corresponds to the spirit of the liturgical celebration itself and the nature of its individual parts,7 and does not hinder the active participation of the people. 10. In order that the faithful may actively participate more willingly and with greater benefit, it is fitting that the format of the celebration and the degree of participation in it should be varied as much as possible, according to the solemnity of the day and the nature of the congregation present. 11. It should be kept in mind that the true solemnity of liturgical worship depends less on a more ornate form of singing and a more magnificent ceremonial than on its worthy and religious celebration, which takes into account the integrity of the liturgical celebration itself, and the performance of each of its parts according to their own particular nature. To have a more ornate form of singing and a more magnificent ceremonial is at times desirable when there are the resources available to carry them out properly; on the other hand it would be contrary to the true solemnity of the liturgy if this were to lead to a part of the action being omitted, changed, or improperly performed. 62. Musical instruments can be very useful in sacred celebrations, whether they accompany the singing or whether they are played as solo instruments. "The pipe organ is to be held in high esteem, for it is the traditional instrument of the Church, the sound of which can add a wonderful splendor to the Church's ceremonies and powerfully lift up men's minds to God and higher things. "The use of other instruments may also be admitted in divine worship, given the decision and consent of the competent territorial authority, provided that the instruments are suitable for sacred use, or can be adapted to it, that they are in keeping with the dignity of the temple, and truly contribute to the edification of the faithful."43 63. In permitting and using musical instruments, the culture and traditions of individual peoples must be taken into account. However, those instruments that are, by common opinion and use, suitable for secular music only, are to be altogether prohibited from every liturgical celebration and from popular devotions.[/quote] Wow I remember reading this document in my Liturgy class
Brother Adam Posted May 14, 2008 Posted May 14, 2008 Was that with Fr. Dominic? Our class was one giant battle between charismatics and traditinalists. the poor man hardly got in a word edge wise. Typically a traditionalist would quote a document and a charismatic would say "its flexible"
CatherineM Posted May 14, 2008 Posted May 14, 2008 My great-grandmother played violin in church in Ireland in the 1870's. My dad said she much preferred singing in St. Patrick's in New York after she immigrated, but then wouldn't we all. Sorry if I seem cranky, I cooked 500 hotdogs and 250 footlongs for a bunch of Beckam soccer nuts last night. I know that we should all aspire to the ideal, but sometimes that is beyond our reach. I know that many of you traditional guys can't or won't understand that, but I'm just hoping that our worship is accepted by the Lord as humbly as we can offer it next to our more wealthy or larger parishes.
StColette Posted May 14, 2008 Posted May 14, 2008 [quote name='Brother Adam' post='1528612' date='May 14 2008, 04:08 PM']Was that with Fr. Dominic? Our class was one giant battle between charismatics and traditinalists. the poor man hardly got in a word edge wise. Typically a traditionalist would quote a document and a charismatic would say "its flexible"[/quote] It was with Fr. Dominic. We didn't have too much traditionalist vs. charismatic debate. I did enjoy reading all the documents on the Liturgy, which I had never done before. I remember him telling us though that his opinion was that Gregorian Chant is and will always be the highest form of music in the liturgy and should be used more often.
Noel's angel Posted May 14, 2008 Posted May 14, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1528617' date='May 14 2008, 10:20 PM']My great-grandmother played violin in church in Ireland in the 1870's. My dad said she much preferred singing in St. Patrick's in New York after she immigrated, but then wouldn't we all. Sorry if I seem cranky, I cooked 500 hotdogs and 250 footlongs for a bunch of Beckam soccer nuts last night. I know that we should all aspire to the ideal, but sometimes that is beyond our reach. I know that many of you traditional guys can't or won't understand that, but I'm just hoping that our worship is accepted by the Lord as humbly as we can offer it next to our more wealthy or larger parishes.[/quote] Ahh, the violin. A noble instrument. It's perfectly fine to play a violin during Mass. It comes under the 'small stringed instrument, played with a bow' category. Fair enough, not all parishes can afford an organ, and maybe some won't be able to find someone to play it...but....it doesn't mean it's okay to use a piano. If you have singers, that is all that is needed.
kujo Posted May 14, 2008 Posted May 14, 2008 I really hate (don't hate, appreciate) how some people look down their nose at non-traditional music. It seems like it always happens when people "grow deeper in your faith" or whatever. It's bologna. I love traditional music, but I always find some of the new stuff almost equally beautiful. Further, I've found that people tend to participate more actively in the mass when the music is in English. It's all a matter of taste, of course.
Seven77 Posted May 14, 2008 Posted May 14, 2008 [quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1528547' date='May 14 2008, 02:04 PM']Marty Haugen...honestly, I loved that stuff 18 years ago when I was brand-new at attending Mass, that's what was played in the parish where I attended and I literally didn't know any other kind of "liturgical music" existed. When I finally did hear REAL sacred music and I could see the difference, it became nearly unbearable (literally) for me to hear the Marty Haugen type of stuff. It's not horrible...just dreadfully inferior when it comes to music for the liturgy. I think it's fine for listening to at home while you clear the house or whatever or while you're in your car...if you like it, which I don't.[/quote] a first! [i]i agree with you![/i]
Noel's angel Posted May 14, 2008 Posted May 14, 2008 It's not really a matter of taste. It is a matter of what will bring people closer to God. I agree, there are some beautiful modern hymns, but a lot of what we hear is Protestant and not even pleasant to listen to. Our Church has such a wealth of beautiful music. Why reject it for songs that aren't even theologically sound? We also need to encourage people nowadays to write good, suitable liturgical music.
Madame Vengier Posted May 14, 2008 Posted May 14, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1528552' date='May 14 2008, 02:06 PM']From: Musicam Sacram, Sacred Congregation of Rites, March 5, 1967[/quote] That was written in 1967. That tells me a lot.
Lil Red Posted May 14, 2008 Posted May 14, 2008 [quote name='Noel's angel' post='1528772' date='May 14 2008, 05:05 PM']Why reject it for songs that aren't even theologically sound?[/quote] +J.M.J.+ and this is why i don't like haugen, haas, hurd or schutte.
kujo Posted May 14, 2008 Posted May 14, 2008 [quote name='Noel's angel' post='1528772' date='May 14 2008, 08:05 PM']It's not really a matter of taste. It is a matter of what will bring people closer to God. I agree, there are some beautiful modern hymns, but a lot of what we hear is Protestant and not even pleasant to listen to. Our Church has such a wealth of beautiful music. Why reject it for songs that aren't even theologically sound? We also need to encourage people nowadays to write good, suitable liturgical music.[/quote] While I agree that music ministers need to be vigilant to make sure that the music they select is theologically sound, I find it odd that it being written by a Protestant has anything to do with it. I mean, if they're singing about God's love...go for it. I mean, didn't Pope Benny say that the good things that the Prots do belong to us [i]anyway[/i]?
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now