Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Salvation Of Extraterrestial Souls


Recommended Posts

LouisvilleFan
Posted (edited)

So, this [url="http://www.cwnews.com/news/viewstory.cfm?recnum=58428"]Jesuit Vatican astronomer[/url], who actually seems to have his head here on planet Earth, says it is possible for Christians to believe that intelligent life may exist on other planets (in fact, if you believe intelligent life exists at all, that may be your only option... ba-doom ching).

Of course, he leaves open to speculation as to whether extraterrestial beings would require salvation. For all we know, they may be humans just like us... wouldn't that be a surprise?!

But what if they aren't? Seems to me, whether they exist in friendship with God or not, if they aren't human or divine, yet still have free will to obey or disoeby God, then Christ must also share their nature. Since Christ is eternal and uncreated, he existed before Adam and Eve and he existed while they were in friendship with God. In other words, Christ was human and divine before there was any need for him to be incarnated, suffer, and die for our sins.

If that's the case for us, then it must be the same for any alien race. Thus the question is begged, is it possible for Christ to have more than two natures?

P.S. Couldn't help but notice that I am a PM Super Alien. :cyclops:

Edited by LouisvilleFan
kenrockthefirst
Posted

For posts on this topic, I always direct folks to CS Lewis "[url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Space_Trilogy"]Space Trilogy[/url]," which deals directly with the question of a) non-Earth, intelligent life and b) its relationship to Jesus.

Posted

Jesus cannot have more than two natures.

all that we know about salvation is only applicable to the sons of Adam.

the incarnation must be a unique event, there cannot be multiple incarnations (if you read between the lines, the Vatican astronomer said as much)... no alien Jesus as an incarnation of the Second Person of the Blessed Trinity.

Jesus had two natures from eternity because of His incarnation at a point in time... that's the way dealings between eternity and a time line work.

now, we'd assume they have free will. but they don't have to... perhaps there would be an intelligent being without free will... that's a fascinating concept. perhaps they could have free will in the manner of the angels: they are given only one choice in their lives to be good or be evil... and then those who chose evil would have no shot because they must follow through their one choice. (I smell a really good science fiction premise, with a big space war against the evil ones). or perhaps they have free will and never chose to disobey God :cyclops:... maybe they know Jesus as a human... their friendship with God would not necessarily mean that they would live a beatific vision on their planet, though they'd live some type of utopia and in the presence of God, they may not know about His incarnation and the story of salvation for planet earth.

and no matter what, man is still the center of the universe, created in the Image and Likeness of God. If these intelligent beings are not Sons of Adam (unlikely that they are) they do not offset our place in the center of God's creation.

now, we know that man's fall affected the whole world. perhaps man's fall affected the whole universe, and their natures are damaged because of Adam's choice. would salvation then be offered to them through Christ? perhaps... though animals are not offered salvation through Christ... perhaps their fate is tied to our own and it is only through our work of building the kingdom that their natures are restored.

CatherineM
Posted

I don't have a problem with the idea of ET's. God made the universe the way he wanted it, not the way I want it.

Maybe this is what he meant by the lost tribes of Israel.

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1528515' date='May 14 2008, 03:22 PM']Jesus cannot have more than two natures.

all that we know about salvation is only applicable to the sons of Adam.

the incarnation must be a unique event, there cannot be multiple incarnations (if you read between the lines, the Vatican astronomer said as much)... no alien Jesus as an incarnation of the Second Person of the Blessed Trinity.[/quote]

I guess my question is, has it ever been definitively defined that Jesus has only two natures? Like you said, all we know about salvation is only applicable to the sons of Adam. We don't know about any other race's salvation since we have no need to know.

Obviously the Incarnation of God taking on human flesh must be a unique historical event, but if there's an alien race, could God also take on the flesh of their race? Or is that actually impossible?

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1528515' date='May 14 2008, 03:22 PM']Jesus had two natures from eternity because of His incarnation at a point in time... that's the way dealings between eternity and a time line work.[/quote]

Now this is starting to sound like some Lost-related theory... :detective:

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1528515' date='May 14 2008, 03:22 PM']now, we'd assume they have free will. but they don't have to... perhaps there would be an intelligent being without free will... that's a fascinating concept. perhaps they could have free will in the manner of the angels: they are given only one choice in their lives to be good or be evil... and then those who chose evil would have no shot because they must follow through their one choice.

or perhaps they have free will and never chose to disobey God :cyclops:... maybe they know Jesus as a human... their friendship with God would not necessarily mean that they would live a beatific vision on their planet, though they'd live some type of utopia and in the presence of God, they may not know about His incarnation and the story of salvation for planet earth.[/quote]

That all seems plausible. I thinking if they can sin, then there must be some offer of salvation for them through Christ.

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1528515' date='May 14 2008, 03:22 PM']and no matter what, man is still the center of the universe, created in the Image and Likeness of God. If these intelligent beings are not Sons of Adam (unlikely that they are) they do not offset our place in the center of God's creation.[/quote]

And that's another part of this that's in my mind. If any alien race is out there that requires salvation, they must have also been created in the image of God. But, they obviously wouldn't be the pinnacle of God's creation... hmmm

Maybe I should read those C.S. Lewis books. :)

kenrockthefirst
Posted

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1528565' date='May 14 2008, 02:20 PM']I guess my question is, has it ever been definitively defined that Jesus has only two natures? Like you said, all we know about salvation is only applicable to the sons of Adam. We don't know about any other race's salvation since we have no need to know.

Obviously the Incarnation of God taking on human flesh must be a unique historical event, but if there's an alien race, could God also take on the flesh of their race? Or is that actually impossible?
Now this is starting to sound like some Lost-related theory... :detective:
That all seems plausible. I thinking if they can sin, then there must be some offer of salvation for them through Christ.
And that's another part of this that's in my mind. If any alien race is out there that requires salvation, they must have also been created in the image of God. But, they obviously wouldn't be the pinnacle of God's creation... hmmm

Maybe I should read those C.S. Lewis books. :)[/quote]
The nature of the Fall and Salvation within the context of non-terrestrial life forms are dealt with in the aforementioned "Space Trilogy," especially the first two books, "Out of the Silent Planet" and "Perelandra." They're obviously the product of one man's opinion but are entertaining and though-provoking reads.

It's a big universe out there. I have no problem with the thought that God may have created other intelligent lifeforms elsewhere for a) His own enjoyment and b) the benefit of His creatures, i.e. to know and worship Him.

Posted

I do have a problem with some incarnation into alien flesh of the Second Person of the Blessed Trinity. a big problem. the definition that Christ has two natures IS what makes more than two natures impossible. they didn't say Christ has at least two natures, they said He had two natures. that's de fide, and adding more natures in is a definitive contradiction to it.

Posted

What if the "aliens" were human beings who were placed in another version of the Garden of Eden and didn't disobey God? They have free will, but chose/choose God like they were/are supposed to.

mommas_boy
Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1528515' date='May 14 2008, 02:22 PM']Jesus cannot have more than two natures.[/quote]

This is assuming that if Christ would have been incarnated as an alien, that this would be a different nature than Christ incarnated as a human. What if Christ's two natures are heavenly and earthly (here, earthly meaning of any planet :P), and this one, single earthly nature takes on the "form" of whatever species he is preaching the gospel to? That is to say, we have seen the homo sapiens "form" of Christ's earthly nature, but there may very well be extraplanetary "forms" of this same earthly nature. Of course, I am making the assumption in this thought experiment that Christ's "form" can be separated from his nature, and that might very well be heresy. :D

Christ oft compared the work of the Father -- the salvation of souls -- to harvesting. To carry on with this metaphor, it makes sense that a farmer would have multiple fields from which to harvest. God, the Lover of Souls, desires as many souls to be in union with him in heaven as possible; it would be fitting, but by no means necessary, for God to have multiple worlds where he planted the seed of life to reap ever more souls for the glory of his kingdom.

Pretty much, all I'm really, truly saying: all things are possible for God. Let's have an open mind.

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1528616' date='May 14 2008, 05:18 PM']I do have a problem with some incarnation into alien flesh of the Second Person of the Blessed Trinity. a big problem. the definition that Christ has two natures IS what makes more than two natures impossible. they didn't say Christ has at least two natures, they said He had two natures. that's de fide, and adding more natures in is a definitive contradiction to it.[/quote]

That's a good point. However, can we be sure the Creed means there are exactly two natures? It says "true God and true man," but makes no mention of anything beyond that.

For example, it's true that I have five fingers. Yet, it's also true that I have ten fingers.

Or, we can turn to Scripture, where it's said that Joseph and Mary had no relations "until" Jesus was born. Protestants like to use this as evidence that Mary bore children after Jesus, and while the word "until" may imply that in current linguistic usage, it's more synonymous with saying "at least."

Is it possible a similar kind of thing is the case with Christ's nature?

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='mommas_boy' post='1528987' date='May 14 2008, 11:43 PM']This is assuming that if Christ would have been incarnated as an alien, that this would be a different nature than Christ incarnated as a human. What if Christ's two natures are heavenly and earthly (here, earthly meaning of any planet :P), and this one, single earthly nature takes on the "form" of whatever species he is preaching the gospel to? That is to say, we have seen the homo sapiens "form" of Christ's earthly nature, but there may very well be extraplanetary "forms" of this same earthly nature. Of course, I am making the assumption in this thought experiment that Christ's "form" can be separated from his nature, and that might very well be heresy. :D[/quote]

I wonder what that does about humans being made in the image of God? I would presume that any race of God's Creation that would require salvation must also be made in the image of God. Maybe there is more to being human in nature than being a homo sapien, just like there is more to being a person than being a homo sapien (since the Father and Holy Spirit are persons, but not human).

kenrockthefirst
Posted

[quote name='kujo' post='1528804' date='May 14 2008, 06:28 PM']What if the "aliens" were human beings who were placed in another version of the Garden of Eden and didn't disobey God? They have free will, but chose/choose God like they were/are supposed to.[/quote]
See CS Lewis' "[url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perelandra"]Perelandra[/url]," which deals with exactly this question.

mommas_boy
Posted

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1529010' date='May 14 2008, 11:08 PM']I wonder what that does about humans being made in the image of God? I would presume that any race of God's Creation that would require salvation must also be made in the image of God. Maybe there is more to being human in nature than being a homo sapien, just like there is more to being a person than being a homo sapien (since the Father and Holy Spirit are persons, but not human).[/quote]

I had always been brought up to think that God's image was not the physicality of human nature, but rather the spirituality of it; ie: an intellect and a will, which together comprise the soul. Thus, it's possible, at least from a philosophical standpoint and ignoring any other theologies that might also be relevant, that this spiritual soul could reside in a non-human if God so willed to create other such species. Thus, this non-human would be "in the image and likeness of God", under this argument. Thus, I would posit that the soul is what you speak of when you say "Maybe there is more to being human in nature".

Also, gramatical note: the singular form of homo sapiens is also homo sapiens. So we can say: that (one) homo sapiens, and those (many) homo sapiens. Just FYI. :)

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='mommas_boy' post='1529299' date='May 15 2008, 10:30 AM']I had always been brought up to think that God's image was not the physicality of human nature, but rather the spirituality of it; ie: an intellect and a will, which together comprise the soul. Thus, it's possible, at least from a philosophical standpoint and ignoring any other theologies that might also be relevant, that this spiritual soul could reside in a non-human if God so willed to create other such species. Thus, this non-human would be "in the image and likeness of God", under this argument. Thus, I would posit that the soul is what you speak of when you say "Maybe there is more to being human in nature".[/quote]

After studying Theology of the Body, there's no doubt that our physical bodies must be part of God's image. The idea that we could separate our physical existence from spiritual existence is how things like homosexuality become accepted, even among Christians. It exalts the soul to the point of making the body irrelevant, or so they think.

To be sure, I'm not saying you believe that, but that's where the road leads.

kenrockthefirst
Posted

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1529385' date='May 15 2008, 10:34 AM']After studying Theology of the Body, there's no doubt that our physical bodies must be part of God's image. The idea that we could separate our physical existence from spiritual existence is how things like homosexuality become accepted, even among Christians. It exalts the soul to the point of making the body irrelevant, or so they think.

To be sure, I'm not saying you believe that, but that's where the road leads.[/quote]
Now that I think about it, part of the Risen Lord's nature is His human body, just as at the Resurrection we will be restored to our physical bodies.

The Joey-O
Posted (edited)

I think that if we want answers to these questions we need to answer a few others first:

1) Is sin a generative disorder? That is, in our conception of Original Sin, is it necessarily something that we inherit as a consequence of who are parents are?
If it is, then it would seem that the only way that extraterrestrial intelligent life could see the beatific vision was if they were either our descendants or we theirs.

2) How do we understand the essential human nature? Aristotle said that Man was the rational animal. It's clear that if use this as our definition for human nature, then extraterrestrials would also fit the definition. The question becomes is this then correct for identifying the nature of a species or does the standard definition for Man become a genus and is there consequently a new definition needed to differentiate the nature of Man from the nature of other rational animals? I would suggest we resist the urge to use the typical contemporary view of "species" and "genus" when discussing this issue. We are talking about essences, souls, nature, etc. We are not talking about whether Man and extraterrestrial are capable of procreation.

3) What can we learn from human evolution?
If we believe that humans can evolve and will always be saved, then we have to believe that there's some flexibility in the material expression of human nature. For example, if we evolve into winged creatures, we still ought to say that Christ's atonement is sufficient for winged Man. Or if we evolve the ability to communicate via pheromones, then we must say Christ's atonement is still sufficient for that Man. Or if we evolve into short, gangly, bulb-headed and compound-eyed, gray people, then Christ's atonement is still sufficient for that Man. We say this because we believe that there is an essential continuity between current and previous expressions of Man from the time of ensoulment to today and to any future evolutionary expression Man may take on. (I think I remember the Vatican saying something about this a while ago. Can't find now, if anyone can, that would be a bonus.) This then should inform our understanding of how we might share the same nature as extraterrestrials. We can't learn anything from evolution, if we don't believe in evolution. With that said, I hope we do not discuss whether or not evolution is real.

4) Is it possible that humans are of extraterrestrial descent or vice versa?
If we share a common lineage with extraterrestrials, then we should share a common nature. They would also potentially share our Original Sin. This would simplify this issue, if it were true.

Basically, we need to determine if we share and how we share a common nature with extraterrestrials. We also need to determine the relationship between Original Sin and procreation. I believe Augustine had 5 possibilities concerning the transmission of Original Sin.

Another interesting note: If we find definitive answers to these questions it would have a significant bearing on other fun sci/fi questions: Do Chimeras have a soul? Would an AI have a soul? etc.

Edited by The Joey-O
mommas_boy
Posted

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1529385' date='May 15 2008, 11:34 AM']After studying Theology of the Body, there's no doubt that our physical bodies must be part of God's image. The idea that we could separate our physical existence from spiritual existence is how things like homosexuality become accepted, even among Christians. It exalts the soul to the point of making the body irrelevant, or so they think.

To be sure, I'm not saying you believe that, but that's where the road leads.[/quote]


Hmm. Interesting point.

I'm beginning to think that all of Earth constitutes a chosen race in that Christ came to earth, and that in the event of discovery of extraterrestrial life that we even remotely suspect of possessing a soul, it will be on us evangelize them. Christ did not share the gospel with all peoples of the Earth, why should we expect him to have shared it with all peoples of the universe? Similarly, it was the duty of the early Church to evangelize all peoples of the earth, and assuming the discovery of an extraterrestrial race, it should be the duty of the Church to evangelize them.

In short, I believe in this line of thinking where Christ only became incarnated on Earth, and nowhere else, because of the limitations imposed by having only two natures. I believe that *if* other species capable of possessing a soul (either on earth or on other planets) were to be discovered, then it would be on the human population of earth, as God's chosen people, to evangelize them, because Christ did not become incarnate in their flesh.

That said, the Church also teaches that other religions possess an innate dignity, and are themselves an expression (albeit incomplete) of God's will for them. While Christ may not have become incarnated as an alien, he would likely have been making himself known to their cultures in the same manner that he made himself known through other religions. The purpose of these imperfect self-revelations through other religions has never been an end unto itself, but was rather as a means of preparing that culture to receive the fullness of the Truth as completely manifest by Christ's Church.

The Joey-O
Posted

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1529385' date='May 15 2008, 10:34 AM']After studying Theology of the Body, there's no doubt that our physical bodies must be part of God's image. The idea that we could separate our physical existence from spiritual existence is how things like homosexuality become accepted, even among Christians. It exalts the soul to the point of making the body irrelevant, or so they think.

To be sure, I'm not saying you believe that, but that's where the road leads.[/quote]

I think you're right. But I think we need to ask: Is the human body the only possible body that could be made in the image of God?

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='The Joey-O' post='1530242' date='May 16 2008, 11:37 AM']I think you're right. But I think we need to ask: Is the human body the only possible body that could be made in the image of God?[/quote]

I was asking myself the same question.

Fr. Roderick's been talking about this on the Daily Breakfast too. I haven't read Peleandra, but apparently if you read the entire interview with the Vatican astronomer proposes a metaphor with Jesus' parable of the lost sheep. Could there be "99 sheep" out there in the universe who are all "found," and could be we be the "one lost sheep," which the Shepherd goes out to rescue?

If I had to pick a theory, I'd say that any alien race shares our human nature, if not our human form. Yet, I don't imagine them being weird looking things with eight arms, no legs, and 100 eyeballs... or whatever. Being a created species like everything we know on earth, their physical structure will be sensical. They will be unfamiliar and perhaps unusual, but not strange, because strangeness (in my mind, anyway) is correlated with disorder.

goldenchild17
Posted

Somewhat on this subject, has anyone read Poul Anderson's "The High Crusade". I've only started but I think it will be going in a similar direction to the subject of this thread. Very interesting.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...