Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

let_go_let_God
Posted

In my own experience, I have known many people blessed with Charismatic Gifts of the Spirit. They don't always know what to do with them but realize that they have them for the greater good of the Church.

Many gifts are based of the "primary" Gifts of the Spirit, Wisdom, Understanding, Knowledge, Fortitude, Counsel, Fear of the Lord, and Piety. All gifts are based from these seven.

Now for a gift being "charismatic" in nature, as I understand, means that the gift approaches others or is more "out there" than gifts that are usually shared between you and God. My parents have commented that before our generation, those who have been born, raised, Confirmed, et cetera since the Second Vatican Council, have been more open to gifts and to sharing the gifts that have been bestowed upon us by the Holy Spirit.

My two cents, I guess...

God bless-

LGLG

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Maggie' post='1529453' date='May 15 2008, 12:31 PM']Ouch!

The "exterior" gifts of speaking in tongues or prophesying don't profit us anything if they don't come with the far greater gifts of charity and patience. Please don't think this is just aimed at you, if anything I am typing it out for my own benefit :blush:

Many people, like alicemary, don't "get anything out of" charismatic prayer meetings or tongues etc. This isn't a bad thing. The charismatic movement, in its externals, is not meant for the entire Church; we are all called to accept the Holy Spirit, but for the majority of Catholics this doesn't mean being "batpized in the Holy Spirit" or experiencing the more exotic gifts.

I know when I discover a wonderful devotional or spiritual practice that really helps my interior life, I want to share it with other people, after all, if I am benefiting I want the people I care about to reap the good fruit, too! But at the same time I have to realize that just because it is helpful to me doesn't mean it is for everyone. I love the Divine Mercy Chaplet, for instance, but there are some people who can't stand the DMC (too repetitive, etc) and that doesn't mean they are a bad Catholic or are "stiff-necked." When you have had such a wonderful experience it is easy to take it personally when other people don't like it so well. But souls have different complexions, as George Elliot put it.[/quote]

Many people do not get anything out of the gifts of the holy spirit. One must be receptive to the Holy Spirit in the first place. A priest said that what he discerns from people who come for prayer, even though they are there, the spirit isn't flowing because the person is afraid, they don't believe, they are too closed off to even imagine letting themselves go (my mother) and there were a couple other reasons.

I do not consider opening myself to the Holy Spirit a devotion. I don't dismiss the actions of the Holy Spirit in my life as something I can accept or not. I can refuse them and turn away but, I would be turning my back on God. He came up with this, not me and it wasn't a little prayer that has been handed down.

This was given to us by our Lord Jesus. This was a powerful and incredible gift and it certainly was meant for the entire church. The church just forgot that somewhere along the way. I didn't even know what the Holy Spirit was a year ago. My introduction was definitely an eye opener.

If someone doesn't want to unleash the power of the Holy Spirit, that is certainly their right to refuse God's gift. But, when they refer to it as making them laugh, is circus like and then says that if God speaks to them it had best be in English or they "ain't" listening and that they "do not believe in it," they are saying more than that is a devotion they don't care for.
To not believe in the gifts of the Holy Spirit is to deny the Holy Spirit and to deny the very thing that built up the Catholic Church in the first place. I believe Jesus had something to say about denying the Spirit of God.


I know I am being converted and all and I get really enthusiastic about everything our Lord has done for me. I so want everyone to be able to experience the incredible peace and joy and love that flows through the gifts of the Holy Spirit. I don't think you can get that if you don't really understand that they are just sitting there waiting for each person to grab them. You have to know that they exist and you have to believe they exist.

My conversion began, then I was led to be baptized in the Holy Spirit and I received much grace, THEN I was confirmed. I go to Mass at least once a month that is dedicated for spiritual and physical healing and each time, I am renewed. I can't imagine not doing that anymore than I could imagine not going to Mass every day or missing adoration time. Everything moves me foward and gives me knowledge and truth of my Lord Jesus.

Edited by Deb
Lilllabettt
Posted

[i]
Many people do not get anything out of the gifts of the holy spirit. One must be receptive to the Holy Spirit in the first place. [...] The church just forgot that somewhere along the way. [...]
[/i]
Just because a person doesn't persue or experience charismatic gifts does not mean they are closed off to the Holy Spirit. Some people spend their whole lives in dryness, faithfully serving the God they cannot see or feel. Their desolation does not mean they are somehow less holy, or less open.

Is it really likely that the Church just "forgot" this stuff? Isn't it more likely that certain graces are assigned to certain times/places/persons in Salvation History?

[i]This was a powerful and incredible gift and it certainly was meant for the entire church. [/i]

God gives gifts to everyone. Those gifts typically described as "charismatic" are EXTRAordinary (tongues, etc.) They are meant for the [i]common good [/i]of the Church. That does not mean that everyone is meant to experience them.

[i]"To not believe in the gifts of the Holy Spirit is to deny the Holy Spirit and to deny the very thing that built up the Catholic Church in the first place [...] You have to know that they exist and you have to believe they exist."[/i]

The gifts of the Holy Spirit include Knowledge, Understanding, Wisdom, Fear of the Lord, Piety, Counsel and Fortitude. I'm pretty sure alicemary believes in these things. She might doubt the gifts as interpreted/practiced by the modern charismatic movement. For example, I wouldn't be suprised if alicemary believed in the biblical description of Pentecost, when the apostles were understood by people who spoke different languages. But perhaps she is more skeptical of the angelic language, unintelligble to anyone present, which is commonly referred to as tongues.

Posted (edited)

Deb,

Your zeal and enthusiasm jumps off the page! I am so glad that the Lord has blessed you and that you are open to following His lead.

I experienced similar consolations when I came back to the Church. Returning to Jesus feels good, doesn't it? Don't feel bad or despair when you eventually stop "feeling" the peace, joy and love of the Lord. This is normal and it usually signifies spiritual progress. Often people who have previously spoken in tongues, etc, no longer experience this gift or stop experiencing it for a time. I am sure you have heard this before, but take care not to fall into the trap of associating sensible consolation with spiritual enlightenment!

Zeal can sometimes make us less gentle than Our Lord Himself would be. That is understandable and I am sure He smiles at our misdirected vigor and turns everything to work for the good.

You are correct that being open to the Holy Spirit is not correctly categorized as "a devotion." However, actual participation in the Charismatic movement specifically is similar to participation in the Fatima movement, or the New Liturgical Movement, or Focolare, or Communion and Liberation. There are many ways of being open to the Holy Spirit and the Charismatic movement is a wonderful way! But it is not the only one.

One of the dangers of the new movements which have sprung up in the Church after the Second Vatican Council is that they could devolve into factions and wound the Church. This happens when people in one movement believe that they have the "true way" to the Lord and that if the whole Church does not capituate to their practices or way of life, then these non-co-operators are inferior Catholic Christians. I believe Pope Benedict wrote about this a little in his days as a cardinal. This danger can be mitigated by episcopal oversight and guidance, which the Church is anxious to provide.

Speak to those at your church who have been involved in the Charismatic movement for many years and I am sure these mature leaders would tell you that folks like alicemary are not denying the Holy Spirit, their souls simply encounter God in a different way. The priest you mention, who said that some people are too afraid to "let the Spirit flow" does not sound that great to tell you the truth. I strongly dislike when people say they have "discerned" things about other people's feelings or motivations. That's not the Holy Spirit telling him "Ooo, I won't come down there tonight, that person is too uptight!" which is ridiculous, as though the Holy Spirit was like television reception or a picky party guest.

Edited by Maggie
Posted (edited)

JM + JT

I just freaked out a little when watching since one of the guests said something along the lines of:

"Well, I told her: 'Yes, you've been baptised, but have you been baptised in the Spirit?'"

It [u]seemed[/u] a little too... [i]detached[/i] from the Catholic Church. :/

Edited by salterrae
Posted

[quote name='Maggie' post='1529768' date='May 15 2008, 05:11 PM']Deb,

Your zeal and enthusiasm jumps off the page! I am so glad that the Lord has blessed you and that you are open to following His lead.

I experienced similar consolations when I came back to the Church. Returning to Jesus feels good, doesn't it? Don't feel bad or despair when you eventually stop "feeling" the peace, joy and love of the Lord. This is normal and it usually signifies spiritual progress. Often people who have previously spoken in tongues, etc, no longer experience this gift or stop experiencing it for a time. I am sure you have heard this before, but take care not to fall into the trap of associating sensible consolation with spiritual enlightenment!

Zeal can sometimes make us less gentle than Our Lord Himself would be. That is understandable and I am sure He smiles at our misdirected vigor and turns everything to work for the good.

You are correct that being open to the Holy Spirit is not correctly categorized as "a devotion." However, actual participation in the Charismatic movement specifically is similar to participation in the Fatima movement, or the New Liturgical Movement, or Focolare, or Communion and Liberation. There are many ways of being open to the Holy Spirit and the Charismatic movement is a wonderful way! But it is not the only one.

One of the dangers of the new movements which have sprung up in the Church after the Second Vatican Council is that they could devolve into factions and wound the Church. This happens when people in one movement believe that they have the "true way" to the Lord and that if the whole Church does not capituate to their practices or way of life, then these non-co-operators are inferior Catholic Christians. I believe Pope Benedict wrote about this a little in his days as a cardinal. This danger can be mitigated by episcopal oversight and guidance, which the Church is anxious to provide.

Speak to those at your church who have been involved in the Charismatic movement for many years and I am sure these mature leaders would tell you that folks like alicemary are not denying the Holy Spirit, their souls simply encounter God in a different way. The priest you mention, who said that some people are too afraid to "let the Spirit flow" does not sound that great to tell you the truth. I strongly dislike when people say they have "discerned" things about other people's feelings or motivations. That's not the Holy Spirit telling him "Ooo, I won't come down there tonight, that person is too uptight!" which is ridiculous, as though the Holy Spirit was like television reception or a picky party guest.[/quote]

Yes I do know that I tend to go overboard when expressing my religious conversion and when I get all excited about it, I do not always use the fiddler between my brain and my mouth. (in this case, my hands)

I believe that the graces the Lord is pouring out upon me now are so that I will be able to be strong in my beliefs and my love for him, when the consolations end. They may or may not end depending what path God will lay out for me. I would rather die than go back to who I was before the Lord rescued me.

I do not have the gift of tongues, healing, discernment of spirits, prophecy or gifts that as I see it, can be used for the building up for the church. I do know people who have those gifts. They use them for building up the church. I was given the gift of faith and knowledge so that I can know, without doubt, the truth of the Word and I firmly believe it is my duty to proclaim that truth. So far, the Lord is using me as an example of the transforming power of his Love. He takes those he has extreme pity on, the worst of the worst and he turns them to follow him and him only. It is a beautiful thing.

I cannot say I have the true way to the Lord or even if there is another way. This is the only way I have known. I was dragged to Medjugorje, my conversion began there, When I got home I was brought to a healing mass where every wound of my life was removed from me, freeing me from any concern with my past and the Holy Spirit began his work in transforming me into a completely different person. That is the way I was brought to the Lord.

This is the way the Lord has taken me. Interestingly enough, the Lord then brought me to a Charismatic Church twelve miles from my house (the one I joined is four blocks away) where he performed a miracle for me during communion and made it clear that that was where I was go to go church. There are still occasions where I question some of the before and after mass music though. :rolleyes:
This church has an amazing respect and reverence for the Liturgy of the Mass and the Eucharist far exceeds what I have witnessed in other "traditional" churches. The only difference is that parishioners are urged to develop a personal relationship with God. To pray always for an outpouring of the Holy Spirit. The way to obtain that is to empty one's self and make the Lord the center of your life. The way taught in my church is Mass always, once a week at the minimum. Eucharistic adoration. Respect for the Eucharist. (children bow when the walk past the door of the perpetual adoration chapel) Freely giving of your time, your treasure and your talents for the benefit of the parish community and those less fortunate. Homilies that actually discuss sin and how much it offends the Lord. Homilies that teach and are always within the confines of the readings and the doctrine of the church. A church with many missions and programs and no debt. Spiritual retreats.

I have not witnessed anyone I have met involved in the Charismatic movement, as it is done in my area, looking on anyone else as an inferior Catholic. In fact, I only even discuss charisms when other people try to make the charismatic movement look like it is a group of deranged, irreligious people or refer to it as a Circus. That tells me that they are the ones who assume that people who go to charismatic churches or prayer meetings etc are the inferior Catholics. Then, I feel I have to set the record straight. If a person feels like they are inferior when around people who are in the Charismatic movement, that is coming from something within them, not us. Do I wish that every soul could experience what I do? You bet. Do I think that is possible. Yes. Do I think it is worth everyone to see if it is possible? Yes. Then again, I think every person on this earth should know the blessing of being a Catholic.

As for the priest who was talking about things he discerns from time to time, he is a priest who I feel will be a saint some day. (if he isn't already) His discussing this came in a lecture on being open to God. If you come and asked to be prayed over and you do not believe for one second that God even exists, it is doubtful you will receive an outpouring of the Holy Spirit. If you are so terrified that you may actually rest in spirit, you won't. (again, my mother) She has even told me that she thought she was going to fall so she stepped back so she would not be prayed over anymore. She is too proper and would be embarrassed.

So, you just let your disbelief in the charisms come out by saying you strongly dislike anyone who says they can discern. You might want to check out Fr. Zlatko Sudac. You might want to read up on St. Pio. You might not want to judge any priest too quickly who has the gift of discernment and prophecy or the reading of souls. All gifts of the Spirit and just as alive today as they were 2,000 years ago. There is no mandate that one has to believe in any of it. But, if you have seen and then you don't believe, you have to answer to God. I have seen and I do believe. I will tell everyone I can get to listen to me about it too. I think I am supposed to.

Lilllabettt
Posted (edited)

EDIT: This is Maggie, my sister forgot to log out!

Deb, I did not let my disbelief in the charisms "come out." In the past I have received some of the more dramatic gifts myself. I am not against the Charismatic movement at all and I have even participated all though not deeply.

I do not strongly dislike when people can discern, I strongly dislike when people claim to be able to discern other people's feelings or motivations. Surely everyone has run into the Sincere Christian Friend who will explain to you that the Lord really laid it on their heart to tell you XYZ, or the Lord has helped them to discern that the deep seated psychological basis for your behavior has its roots in XYZ. And you can sense that your Sincere Christian Friend should more accurately be called your Insecure and Somewhat Manipulative Christian Friend, who for some reason can't give you their honest opinion without presenting it as a command from on high.

I hope that your priest will be a saint one day (may we all!) but quite frankly it doesn't require the ability to read souls to be able to tell that people are uncomfortable. So your priest, noticing that some newcomers are not at ease with a particular prayer style, "discerns" (IOW makes up his own mind) that they must be closed to the Holy Spirit, rejecting God's gifts, etc. etc. Not only that but the presence of these doubters at the same meeting as the prayer team wrecks the Spirit's flow. Sort of the same way a medium supposedly can't conjure spirits if there is an unbeliever in the room. This is silly and I am sure the priest meant to say something else and just didn't phrase it correctly.

It's great that Fr. Zlatko Sudac can read souls and prophesy. I am not particularly impressed or in awe of him or any other person with gifts, however, because after all it's not any of their doing, it's God's. It is not like he has some kind of powerful magic before which I need to tremble. Your mom may not be comfortable with Charismatic spiritual practices but she may actually be further along on the path to holiness than you are, or Fr. Sudac. I hope that doesn't sound harsh, I don't mean to suggest that you aren't holy, only to point out that the lack of external signs does not indicate a lack of extraordinary sanctity. I bet that Fr. Sudac has a ways to go, as do we all.

Edited by Lilllabettt
Posted

The above was me... sorry Lilla!

Lilllabettt
Posted

[quote name='Maggie' post='1530064' date='May 16 2008, 12:55 AM']The above was me... sorry Lilla![/quote]


Digging deep here. Okay I forgive you. :P

Posted (edited)

I thought "speaking in tongues" meant either being miraculously gifted with the ability to speak another language, or being able to somehow communicate with angles. As far as I understand what we see today as speaking in tongues, being slain in the spirit, etc are things that originated in the Pentecostal movement and then found their way into Catholicism.

Edited by mortify
Posted

[quote name='mortify' post='1530268' date='May 16 2008, 12:13 PM']I thought "speaking in tongues" meant either being miraculously gifted with the ability to speak another language, or being able to somehow communicate with angles. As far as I understand what we see today as speaking in tongues, being slain in the spirit, etc are things that originated in the Pentecostal movement and then found their way into Catholicism.[/quote]

St. Paul refers to the "tongues of angels." The standard explanation for unrecognizable languages in the modern Charismatic movement is that basically they are using the language of angels to praise God.

LouisvilleFan
Posted (edited)

It can mean that too, but Paul also speaks about speaking in tongues and says that its practice should be controlled because outsiders don't understand what people are saying when they speak in tongues.

Edit: Posted this at the same time as the above post, so didn't mean to repeat the same point :)

Edited by LouisvilleFan
Noel's angel
Posted

We have a small prayer group in our parish, and some of them sometimes 'speak in tongues' but they won't socialise with other people. I'm sure there are some people who may speak in tongues, but I think a lot of people make it up. People will do what they want. If they want to be able to speak in tongues, they'll convince themselves that they can.

Posted (edited)

I was doing some reading today and found that the Holy Father just spoke at a Bishops' seminar on the topic of the "movements" -

[quote]Beginning with the theme of the seminar that has just concluded - a phrase that the pope had addressed to the German bishops in 2006, "Approach the movements with great love" - the pope exhorted the bishops to "approach with great love the movements and new communities . . . in order to gain an adequate understanding of their reality, without superficial impressions or reductionist judgments". A number of times, the pope repeated that "the ecclesial movements and the new communities are not a problem or an extra risk, added to our already weighty responsibilities. No! They are a gift from the Lord, a precious resource to enrich with their charism as the entire Christian community . . . Difficulties or misunderstandings on particular issues do not bring the right of isolation".

What might be feared is a journey along parallel lines, each for himself, the bishops on one side, the movements on the other. This would mean an impoverishing of both. Thus Benedict XVI exhorts the pastors to "a service of discernment" and to "correction" of the values of the movements, and at the same time to resist "[b]the temptation of making uniform what the Holy Spirit wants to be multiform[/b], to contribute to the building and growth of the one Body of Christ, which the Spirit himself makes firm in unity".[/quote] (Emphasis mine)

[url="http://www.asianews.it/index.php?l=en&art=12283&size=A"]Link[/url]

Edited by Maggie
Posted

I'm not really all that interested in the so-called Charismatic movement in the Catholic Church. In fact, most of the Charismatics that I've known have tended to be rather Protestant in their theology, and -- as a former Protestant -- that has always been a big problem, since I find Protestantism boring.

LouisvilleFan
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Noel's angel' post='1530450' date='May 16 2008, 02:54 PM']We have a small prayer group in our parish, and some of them sometimes 'speak in tongues' but they won't socialise with other people. I'm sure there are some people who may speak in tongues, but I think a lot of people make it up. People will do what they want. If they want to be able to speak in tongues, they'll convince themselves that they can.[/quote]

You can think that all you want, and they can make it up all they want (if that is actually the case, which nobody knows but God), but the truth is the Holy Spirit does offer the gift of tongues to some believers for the good of the Church. Just because a gift is abused doesn't mean we censor it, like Puritans censored alcohol and Shakers censored sex.

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1532328' date='May 18 2008, 02:04 PM']I'm not really all that interested in the so-called Charismatic movement in the Catholic Church. In fact, most of the Charismatics that I've known have tended to be rather Protestant in their theology, and -- as a former Protestant -- that has always been a big problem, since I find Protestantism boring.[/quote]

If every Catholic you knew was basically a nominal Christian who only went through the motions for Mass and lived a secular lifestyle the rest of the week, would you figure all Catholics must be like that?

Edited by LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1533011' date='May 18 2008, 07:02 PM']If every Catholic you knew was basically a nominal Christian who only went through the motions for Mass and lived a secular lifestyle the rest of the week, would you figure all Catholics must be like that?[/quote]
Such a person would not be a good Catholic.

But your comparison is a poor one, because my distrust of the Charismatic movement is founded upon the Protestant holiness theology that is its source.

Posted

I expressed my views about the "Charistmatic" movement in a couple of posts from a few years ago, and I haven't changed my position since that time:

[quote][size=3]In the Western theological tradition a distinction is made between grace which is called gratiae gratum faciens, that is, the grace that makes one holy and pleasing to God (also known as sanctifying grace), and that which is called gratiae gratis datae, that is, grace in the form of particular gifts given in order to edify the Church and sanctify others. The latter "type" of grace, is further divided into ordinary (hierarchic) and extraordinary (charismatic) gifts, and as far as the ordinary gifts are concerned, they are intrinsically connected to the ecclesiastical hierarchy and the priestly, prophetic, and kingly role of the ordained ministers of the Church; while the extraordinary or charismatic gifts can be given to anyone within the Church. Now, obviously the first "type" of grace (i.e., gratiae gratum faciens) is necessary for salvation, because a man must be in a state of grace in order to be saved; while the latter "type" of grace (gratiae gratis datae), although important in its own way -- especially in the form of the hierarchic gifts mentioned in association with sacred orders -- is not absolutely necessary in the same way that sanctifying grace is necessary for salvation. In fact a person can be in a state of mortal sin and still receive the gifts of grace "gratis datae," and that is why it is vital that a man not focus upon the extraordinary charismatic gifts, nor even seek them out per se, but seek instead God's gift of sanctifying (i.e., deifying) grace. Now, if a man receives any extraordinary manifestation of God's presence given for the edification of others he should accept it in humility and use it only for God's purposes (bearing in mind that it is extraordinary), and not in order to draw attention to himself, nor to rejoice in the gift itself, but to rejoice only in God (the giver of all good things).

That being said, the concern that I have in connection with the charismatic gifts -- as they tend to be experienced today -- is that there is an inordinate focus upon oneself as the recipient of the gift. Thus, there seems to be a self-aggrandizing focus today, which sees the extraordinary manifestation of a gift as somehow making the person receiving it an "important person" within the community (or prayer group). In my own experience with "Charismatics" I have often seen a tendency toward a desire for things that are sensationalistic, that is, a desire for that which is extraordinary, simply because it is extraordinary and because it somehow makes a man feel important in relation to those around him. Moreover, it must always be borne in mind that the charismatic gifts are extraordinary, not ordinary, and so to focus upon them is to emphasize a minor gift over the most important gift of all, that is, sanctification or what the East calls theosis. Now in saying this I am reminded of the words of St. John of the Cross, who, in connection with extraordinary gifts of vision, once said: "[Now] since these imaginative apprehensions, visions, and other forms or species are presented through some image or particular idea, individuals should neither feed upon them nor encumber themselves with them. And this is true whether these visions be false and diabolical or if they be recognized as authentic and from God. Neither should people desire to accept them or keep them. Thus these persons can remain detached, divested, pure, simple, and without any mode or method as the union demands." [St. John of the Cross, The Ascent of Mount Carmel, Book II, Chapter 16] St. John gives further warnings later on in the third book of the Ascent (see Chapters 31 and 32) when he speaks about the dangers associated with the exercise of the charismatic gifts, and there are three dangers in particular: (1) the danger of deceiving others or of being deceived, (2) the danger to the soul "with respect to faith," and (3) the danger of vainglory or some other type of vanity (See Ch. 31, no. 1). Thus, St. John clearly warns against rejoicing in the charismatic gifts, and instructs the person receiving such a gift to use it with extreme caution. Now, in my own experience of the modern charismatic movement there seems to be a focus upon rejoicing in the gift itself, even if it serves no purpose in edifying others; and in addition, there seems to be a desire (at least on the part of some) to draw attention to the recipient of the gift as if he is somehow special, and this shows a real lack of spiritual maturity. Finally, it is important to remember that the real focus of the spiritual life is God Himself, and so a man must not focus upon the gifts that he believes he has received from God (whether real or imagined), because he can receive these extraordinary gifts even while he is in a state of mortal sin.[/size][/quote]

My response to the assertion made by some people at this forum several years ago that the spirituality of the Charismatic movement is related to the theological tradition of the Byzantine Churches:

[quote][size=3]There is nothing Eastern about the modern charismatic movement, and in fact quite the contrary, it is based upon an utterly foreign theology that is inimical to Byzantine spirituality. The modern charismatic movement is founded upon the holiness and pentecostal movements of 19th and 20th century Protestantism, and has nothing to do with the spirituality of the Hesychastic mystics of the East, which is always focused upon the reintegration of mind and heart in prayer through dispassion and ascesis, and which has no interest in sensationalistic displays of so-called "charismatic" gifts. The Hesychastic "Prayer of the Heart" is focused upon entering into communion with God by participating in His uncreated energies, and this should not be confused with the modern emotionalism of the charismatic movement in the Western Catholic Church, or in the Protestant ecclesial communities that gave birth to this movement in the first place.

Furthermore, I must emphasize the fact that it is not even possible to understand Eastern mystical experience without first understanding and accepting the Triadological distinctions made within the theological tradition of the Byzantine Church. Now this, of course, necessarily entails accepting the fundamental realities of essence (ousia), person (hypostasis), and energy (energeia) in God, while also accepting the synergistic communion that is made possible by the incarnation of the eternal Logos, because it is only through the sacraments instituted by God incarnate -- which have the effect of extending His saving action throughout history until He returns at the end of the age -- that man can experience a true mystical encounter with the tri-hypostatic Godhead. Thus, the use of terms like "fire" and "light," and other terms of that kind, which may be common to the charismatic movement and the Byzantine tradition, reveals only superficial similarities between the two theological approaches. That being said, it is clear that the charismatic movement presently popular in the Latin Church is basically a modern Western movement, which is founded upon the anti-sacramental theology of some of the more radical groups that came out of the 16th century Protestant Reformation, and as such it has nothing in common with the Byzantine doctrinal and spiritual tradition.

Finally, I would simply reiterate what I said earlier in this thread, that is, that a Byzantine Christian should avoid the charismatic movement, because it does not represent the liturgical, spiritual, or doctrinal tradition of his sui juris Church.[/size][/quote]

Posted

[quote name='prose' post='1529443' date='May 15 2008, 12:23 PM']I have heard it explained to me this way (which made sense)

PRAYING in tongues is how your soul speaks to God. It is a stand-alone gift. It is from us to God.

SPEAKING in tongues will always have someone else given a gift of interpretation. It is from God to us.[/quote]
Interesting distinction. I'll keep that in mind.

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1532328' date='May 18 2008, 01:04 PM']I'm not really all that interested in the so-called Charismatic movement in the Catholic Church. In fact, most of the Charismatics that I've known have tended to be rather Protestant in their theology, and -- as a former Protestant -- that has always been a big problem, since I find Protestantism boring.[/quote]

lawl, boring. You're an interesting fellow. Btw, I like the posts you quoted from a couple years back. Quite informative. Thanks :)

Autumn Dusk
Posted

This may sound funny...but on occasion I've been blessed with the gift of toungs....in sign-language. I used to know several deaf and hard of hearing kids...who couldn't fully participate in the youth group, esp worship, because they couldn't hear. And while I know a medium about of sign I know no where NEAR enough to understand long conversations, moreover translate.

Yet, I have. Its not like I'm being operated by strings...I just know how so my brain tells my hand.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...