Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

I'm having a debate/discussion with a strong Christian friend of mine about the Apocrypha. I told him that when the bible was "composed" by the Church, you know, when they put it all together and they discerned which books were inspired and which were not, that the Apocrypha were included at that time, but later taken out by Luther.

He told me that they were never officially included at that council (Which council was it, by the way?), but were debated among Christians until Luther definetly removed them. Neither of us had ever heard the other's argument and neither of us knows for sure which is true, so I was hoping someone on here could supply us some answers. Also, he didn't want us to have only Catholic arguments, but rather to see both sides of the argument, which is understandable. So maybe someone could point out the truth of the matter, and supply some resources too?

Maybe I should add that, to him, this is a big deal, because it pertains to the infallibility of the Church: he thinks that if the Apocrypha was not insipred than the Church would not be infallible, since it claims they were inspired. So any other interesting info about the Apocrypha would be helpful too, such as: did Christ ever reference it? Do the Jews accept it? Did the earliest Christians accept and use it?

I hope these aren't too many questions or that I'm being to vauge, but I don't have the time to do my own research, and don't know where to go for answers anyways. Thanks!!!

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

First, Catholics call them the Deutero-canonical books (Deutero for Short), because Apocrypha means non-canonical (basically).

Both Books in the Old and New Testament refer to the Deutero, however the Letter of St. Jude quotes from something that both Protestant and Catholics would consider apocrypha. (Specifically the story of Moses being assumed into Heaven.)

The Earliest Christian (at least an overwhelming majority), i.e. the orthodox, like Ignatius, Justin, and Iraneaus did accept them, while the heretics like Marcion did not. I must however admit that Eusibieus, the first major Church Historian, did not think that the Book of Revelation should be Canonical. So, there was a lingering question of canonicity of even the New Testament books. It is supposed by scholars that 1rst Clement was often included in the New Testament in the Early Church. It took the Magisterium to settle both the Canon of the New Testament and the Old Testament.

Some Jews accept them, some do not. It depends, though most, from my understanding do not seem them as canonical now...However again, I had a Rabbi tell me this was in response to the Christian understanding of the Old Testament.

Luther originally held them to canonical and inspired, but dropped them when debating Eck, because the Deutero proves the doctrine of purgatory.

If there is anything I missed head over to the transmundane lane for more responses.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...