Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

catholicinsd
Posted

[quote]No one of illegitimate birth, nor any of his descendants may enter the assembly of the Lord, even down to the tenth generation.[/quote]

Posted

I'll see if someone will get you a t shirt or something from the assembly

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

Keep in mind that most of Deuteronomy is the Law of Moses, not the Divine Law, and often had things that weren't ideal, but had more practical purposes as concessions to the people, who consistently failed to follow divine law.

From StColette, who took a class in Pentateuch: "most of the laws in Deuteronomy were scare tactics, meant to keep certain sins from occuring, in this case, extra-marital or pre-marital affairs. Deut. 22 ends with sexual sins, Deut. 23 begins with them. The purpose is to keep the situation from happening, not to punish those who are illegitimate."

Further, I would add that fidelity to God is tied to fidelity in marriage, and there's probably a theological reason that anyone born of infidelity could be unfaithful in the assembly (not the best reasoning, but it does make some sense figuratively).

Lastly, this law no longer applies to us.

God bless,

Micah

catholicinsd
Posted

[quote name='Raphael' post='1529343' date='May 15 2008, 10:30 AM']Further, I would add that fidelity to God is tied to fidelity in marriage, and there's probably a theological reason that anyone born of infidelity could be unfaithful in the assembly[/quote]

I like to think I've been a good Catholic boy, despite the circumstances of my birth.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='catholicinsd' post='1529350' date='May 15 2008, 10:42 AM']I like to think I've been a good Catholic boy, despite the circumstances of my birth.[/quote]
I would like to think that, too. That's why I said it wasn't the best reasoning. Regardless, that's just one possible interpretation of the symbolic meaning of the passage.

It wasn't meant to say that you were a bad Catholic.

Jen's looking at the original Hebrew at the moment. I'll let you know if she finds anything that gives us a better idea of what it really says.

Posted

so


no t shirt?

Posted

[quote name='hot stuff' post='1529358' date='May 15 2008, 10:51 AM']so
no t shirt?[/quote]Greatness...

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

Okay, Jen looked at it and guess what...the Hebrew is ambiguous. A more correct term (though I hate (don't hate, appreciate) (don't hate (don't hate, appreciate), appreciate) using it) would be "bastard," and in the Hebrew, it can mean different things. It can mean illigimate child, but it can also mean "child of incest" (which is more specific and not as general) or even the child of one Hebrew and one foreigner (which could mean that the child is a foreigner). The last interpretation would be entirely irrelevant to the modern day. As for the other interpretations, we're in the New Covenant now, so the whole thing is just irrelevant to us today.

However, it's interesting that the different meanings of the word relate to the matters discussed at the end of the previous chapter, which ends forbidding incest. It's probably meant more as a warning to parents that they should not enter into these types of relationships because they will bring bad things on their children.

Also, St. Jerome transliterated the word and then followed it with a clause specifying what he believed it meant (that clause is missing from the Hebrew), indicating that he may not have known what the word meant or may not have had an adequate translation, and decided just to keep the Hebrew word, although in Latin characters, and follow it with what he thought was the basic meaning of the word. That definition may be incomplete, depending on how accurate he was trying to be, and could have tainted the ideas of scholars down the ages on the meaning of the word.

God bless,

Micah

Posted

It is also really important to keep in mind that those of use not born into a marriage may become holy because Christ offers His love to all.

  • 1 month later...
catholicinsd
Posted

[quote name='Theoketos' post='1529381' date='May 15 2008, 11:33 AM']It is also really important to keep in mind that those of use not born into a marriage may become holy because Christ offers His love to all.[/quote]

To me this passage re-enforces the mid-evil notion that I'm some-how a second class citizen.

Vincent Vega
Posted

[quote name='catholicinsd' post='1588754' date='Jul 1 2008, 10:08 PM']To me this passage re-enforces the mid-evil notion that I'm some-how a second class citizen.[/quote]
1. It's medieval.
2. How on earth did you get that out of it? It seemed very charitable and a lot like the truth to me. He just said that Christ extends his love to all...

catholicinsd
Posted

[quote name='USAirwaysIHS' post='1588765' date='Jul 1 2008, 11:18 PM']1. It's medieval.
2. How on earth did you get that out of it? It seemed very charitable and a lot like the truth to me. He just said that Christ extends his love to all...[/quote]

I was talking about the actual verse.

ardillacid
Posted

Six or seven?

Posted

If you had any worries about the passage at all, I'd think of Baptism and what it does. When someone is baptized they are ready to enter the Kingdom of Heaven. Anything prior to Baptism wouldn't hold you back. Although, as was said earlier, this reading doesn't really seem to apply to modern times anyway, but I just wanted to remind you of another reason why it wouldn't be anything to worry about.

Posted

[quote name='catholicinsd' post='1588754' date='Jul 1 2008, 10:08 PM']To me this passage re-enforces the mid-evil notion that I'm some-how a second class citizen.[/quote]The devil wants you to think that... some weak stupid tempter that smells of elderberries. Our heavenly father (in baptism we all have the same dad) is [i]so[/i] much better and He fills us with love.

LouisvilleFan
Posted (edited)

Does anyone here want to argue that children are not affected by the sins of their parents? This verse, and the many other ones like it, aren't saying that God is going to curse the next ten generations just out of spite. It's a warning of the effect a parent's sin will have on their children and that this sin will pass on through several generations. The number ten shouldn't be taken literally, just like the common occurence of 40 isn't meant literally. More important is what the number means.

Not so much unlike how children born into poverty typically grow up to live in poverty themselves. The reasons they were born into it are usually the same reasons they struggle to escape it.

Edited by LouisvilleFan
EstoVir_TheWay_4
Posted

[quote]Does anyone here want to argue that children are not affected by the sins of their parents? This verse, and the many other ones like it, aren't saying that God is going to curse the next ten generations just out of spite. It's a warning of the effect a parent's sin will have on their children and that this sin will pass on through several generations.[/quote]

Many of Deut.'s rules are practical rather than spiritual. Look at the example of incest. Obviously when applied to this passage, it warns against the biological reprucussions of such actions. The parents' actions directly affect the genetic diversity of the next generation and possibly more generations until acceptable genetic diversity can be attained. Remeber that Deut.'s rules about clenliness are not neccessarily spiritual, but practical.

Posted

[quote name='EstoVir_TheWay_4' post='1589074' date='Jul 2 2008, 11:34 AM']Many of Deut.'s rules are practical rather than spiritual. Look at the example of incest.[/quote]

Very true. Many of the Laws found in the Torah are there for practical purposes not necessarily for spiritual purposes. When taken this verse in the context of the whole, it warns against sexual sin in general. Micah and I addressed this earlier in the thread. There's a law in the Torah that says not to have relations with your wife during her period and this time is called unclean. Not because a woman is unclean during this time but practically speaking it is not as comfortable for a woman to have relations during this time and the likelihood of conception is very low. The same section goes on to say to wait 7 days until resuming relations, anyone who knows how a woman's body functions will know that 7 days after the end of a period is likely to be prime time for conception.

[quote]The number ten shouldn't be taken literally, just like the common occurence of 40 isn't meant literally. More important is what the number means.[/quote]

Biblical exegesis will tell you that the number 40 and 10 used in Scripture has both a spiritual as well as a literal meaning (Dei Verbum)

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='StColette' post='1589090' date='Jul 2 2008, 12:52 PM']Biblical exegesis will tell you that the number 40 and 10 used in Scripture has both a spiritual as well as a literal meaning (Dei Verbum)[/quote]

Everything in the Bible has a spiritual meaning :) You mean it's both metaphorical and literal? I've never read anything from a Catholic or non-fundamentalist Protestant point of view that says we should believe the Israelites wandered for exactly 40 years, or that Jesus was in the desert for exactly 40 days. Maybe it was, but is that something we're required to believe?

Perhaps God's laws for the Israelites are for both physical and spiritual health. We can see the physical benefits, but knowing that God is both human and divine in Christ and that our physical and spiritual existence are intimately tied together, what's to say that there isn't just as much of a spiritual benefit to obeying laws that are good for our physical health?

EstoVir_TheWay_4
Posted (edited)

[quote][i]EstoVir_TheWay_4[/i]: Many of Deut.'s rules are practical rather than spiritual.[/quote]

[quote][i]LouisvilleFan[/i]: Everything in the Bible has a spiritual meaning[/quote]

I meant "as well as" spiritual. I agree that obeying laws that have physical health benefits also has spiritual benefits.

And Deut. is first and foremost a spiritual writing. (Meaning, intended for the benefit of the spiritual health of God's people)

Edited by EstoVir_TheWay_4

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...