Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

If a few here would enlighten and indulge me please, I'd like to create a list of the possible positions one as a Catholic may hold concerning unbaptized infants and what happens to their soul after death.

New Advent from 1907 says the following which I found particularly intriguing - "Finally it must be borne in mind that unbaptized infants, if deprived of heaven, would not be deprived unjustly. The vision of God is not something to which human beings have a natural claim. It is a free gift of the Creator who can make what conditions He chooses for imparting it or withholding it. No injustice is involved when an undue privilege is not conferred upon a person. Original sin deprived the human race of an unearned right to heaven. Through the Divine mercy this bar to the enjoyment of God is removed by baptism; but if baptism be not conferred, original sin remains, and the unregenerated soul, having no claim on heaven, is not unjustly excluded from it."

So anyone willing to do my homework for me, please proceed and offer thoughts :)

thessalonian
Posted

Here is what I understand can be the outcomes.

1) God can just automatically baptize them and they go to heaven.
2) They go to a state such as limbo where they are happy but have no beautific vision of God.
3) They go to hell.
4) God illuminates their minds and gives them the choice of heaven or hell at death.

I think all of these would be considered orthodox.

Posted

Thanks Thessalonian! Hmmm now if anyone has interest in discussing any of these 4 options or others please go for it!

thessalonian
Posted

One thing that I will say is that I find the option that they just go to hell unlikely. The reason I say this is because in December there is the feast of the Holy Innocents which is a celebration of those who were killed when Herod tried to kill Jesus in his infancy.

Posted

I think the Catholic Encyclopedia encapsulates a Catholic attitude to this issue very well.

I believe Limbo must be considered a [i]default[/i] position regarding the issue. While it is indeed possible for God, for instance, to enlighten the infant's mind at the time of death to exercise free will for or against God, this would be an [i]extraordinary[/i] thing, a miracle. We should not presume this to be the case, especially when God has not revealed this is what happens. However, given from what God has revealed (i.e.: Baptism the only way for infants to have remission of original sin, dying in original sin means no beatific vision etc) Limbo is the logical deduction. Moreover, some form of Limbo has virtually universally been upheld in the Church throughout the ages...

Regarding the Holy Innocents, they received the baptism of blood (i.e.: because they were killed out of hatred for Christ, meaning they receive the effect of the remission of original sin, even if they were not water baptised). Obviously, nearly all cases of infants dying would not fit that category.

Totus Tuus
Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1530827' date='May 16 2008, 08:26 PM']One thing that I will say is that I find the option that they just go to hell unlikely. The reason I say this is because in December there is the feast of the Holy Innocents which is a celebration of those who were killed when Herod tried to kill Jesus in his infancy.[/quote]

I was thinking the same thing. Though we deserve hell because of original sin, I'm sure God takes into account the fact that the infants in no way cooperated with sin personally. I think the other three options are WAY more plausible.

Paddington
Posted

[quote name='Hirsap' post='1531769' date='May 17 2008, 10:13 PM']Regarding the Holy Innocents, they received the baptism of blood (i.e.: because they were killed out of hatred for Christ, meaning they receive the effect of the remission of original sin, even if they were not water baptised). Obviously, nearly all cases of infants dying would not fit that category.[/quote]

Is this correct? I think of martyrs as choosing martyrdom instead of another option.

Posted

The point is this: the holy innocents, like all children before they reach the age of reason, are innocent.

No one is damned who does not deserve, through his own actions, to be damned (Pius IX, [i]Quanto Conficiamur Moerore[/i], no. 7).

Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1532365' date='May 19 2008, 05:29 AM']The point is this: the holy innocents, like all children before they reach the age of reason, are innocent.

No one is damned who does not deserve, through his own actions, to be damned (Pius IX, [i]Quanto Conficiamur Moerore[/i], no. 7).[/quote]

Though I suppose that would depend on what you mean by "damned". It's certainly true that no infant is culpable of any personal sin, so there can be no positive punishment so to speak. Yet the joys of Heaven are not owed to human nature, and God can attach any conditions he pleases to the reception of such gifts (i.e.: the Beatific Vision). But perhaps infants dying without baptism can be regarded as "damned", if by that you mean the simple absense of the supernatural joys of Heaven. I believe Pius IX was speaking of "damnation" in terms of punishment for actual (personal) sin.

Posted

[quote name='Paddington' post='1532361' date='May 19 2008, 05:19 AM']Is this correct? I think of martyrs as choosing martyrdom instead of another option.[/quote]

Yes this is correct.
I suppose one can compare this to how infants are water baptised, receiving all the effects of the sacrament (e.g.: sanctifying grace, indeluble character on the soul) despite not opting with their wills to receive the sacrament.

Posted

[quote name='Hirsap' post='1533259' date='May 18 2008, 11:23 PM']Though I suppose that would depend on what you mean by "damned". It's certainly true that no infant is culpable of any personal sin, so there can be no positive punishment so to speak. Yet the joys of Heaven are not owed to human nature, and God can attach any conditions he pleases to the reception of such gifts (i.e.: the Beatific Vision). But perhaps infants dying without baptism can be regarded as "damned", if by that you mean the simple absense of the supernatural joys of Heaven. I believe Pius IX was speaking of "damnation" in terms of punishment for actual (personal) sin.[/quote]
There is no such thing as a "natural" end for man; thus all men, including the damned, receive a "supernatural" end. God is the sole beginning and end of creation.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Hirsap' post='1533259' date='May 18 2008, 11:23 PM']Though I suppose that would depend on what you mean by "damned". It's certainly true that no infant is culpable of any personal sin, so there can be no positive punishment so to speak. Yet the joys of Heaven are not owed to human nature, and God can attach any conditions he pleases to the reception of such gifts (i.e.: the Beatific Vision). But perhaps infants dying without baptism can be regarded as "damned", if by that you mean the simple absense of the supernatural joys of Heaven. I believe Pius IX was speaking of "damnation" in terms of punishment for actual (personal) sin.[/quote]
My views on this issue can be found in the thread linked below:

[url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=79951&st=60"][u]Limbo And Extra Ecclesiam[/u][/url]

Edited by Apotheoun
Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1533282' date='May 19 2008, 06:46 PM']There is no such thing as a "natural" end for man; thus all men, including the damned, receive a "supernatural" end. God is the sole beginning and end of creation.[/quote]

This may well be a simple misunderstanding of what I mean. Indeed, God is the beginning and end of all creation, no question. The highest angel to the lowest rock has God as its origin and end.

When I say natural end of man, I mean still God being that end, but in a natural way, according to the nature of man, [i]only[/i]. Whereas, we know in fact that God pleases to elevate mankind through grace, and God is still our end, but in a way beyond (yet not contrary to) our nature.

Of course, it is improper to speak as though the natural and supernatural ought to seperated; for we know that God as as our supernatural end encompasses (yet goes beyond) God as our natural end.

BUT, in the case of infants, it is possible that they enjoy God in a 'natural' way after death, in not having the grace to enkjoy the Beatific Vision, i.e.: in a similar or identical way that the rightious would enjoy God after death had God not willed to elevate mankind to the supernatural order.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Hirsap' post='1533294' date='May 19 2008, 03:54 AM']This may well be a simple misunderstanding of what I mean. Indeed, God is the beginning and end of all creation, no question. The highest angel to the lowest rock has God as its origin and end.

When I say natural end of man, I mean still God being that end, but in a natural way, according to the nature of man, [i]only[/i]. Whereas, we know in fact that God pleases to elevate mankind through grace, and God is still our end, but in a way beyond (yet not contrary to) our nature.

Of course, it is improper to speak as though the natural and supernatural ought to seperated; for we know that God as as our supernatural end encompasses (yet goes beyond) God as our natural end.

BUT, in the case of infants, it is possible that they enjoy God in a 'natural' way after death, in not having the grace to enkjoy the Beatific Vision, i.e.: in a similar or identical way that the rightious would enjoy God after death had God not willed to elevate mankind to the supernatural order.[/quote]
This is a Western way of looking at things, and I rejected it when I changed sui juris Churches more than three years ago.

There is no "natural" way of enjoying God in the next life, as if nature can be separated from the supernatural gift of God's uncreated energies. Unbaptized babies will share in the glory of God given through the incarnation, which means that they will see God, and grow more and more divine throughout eternity. Divine glory, appropriate to the personal reality each individual, awaits all those who have committed no sins. Only the damned will experience any suffering or loss in relation to God, for they will have only a discursive knowledge of the good in the next life, since they separated themselves from the good through their actions during their earthly life.

Edited by Apotheoun
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Hirsap' post='1533294' date='May 19 2008, 03:54 AM']When I say natural end of man, I mean still God being that end, but in a natural way, according to the nature of man, [i]only[/i]. Whereas, we know in fact that God pleases to elevate mankind through grace, and God is still our end, but in a way beyond (yet not contrary to) our nature.[/quote]
[i]Theosis[/i] is according to man's nature, because God created man to transcend himself by the power of His uncreated energies, for "in Him we live and move and have our being" (Acts 17:28).

Edited by Apotheoun
Posted

[quote name='Hirsap' post='1533294' date='May 19 2008, 03:54 AM']BUT, in the case of infants, it is possible that they enjoy God in a 'natural' way after death, in not having the grace to enkjoy the Beatific Vision, i.e.: in a similar or identical way that the rightious would enjoy God after death had God not willed to elevate mankind to the supernatural order.[/quote]
Your hypothetical statement, i.e., "had God not willed to elevate mankind to the supernatural order," has no basis in divine revelation. Although there is a distinction between the natural and the supernatural, they are in fact inseparable, because even the damned will experience God's uncreated energies, but for them the experience will be a painful one because they failed, during their earthly life, to liken themselves to God.

That said, as an Eastern Catholic, I do not recognize the existence of "natural way" of enjoying God that is separate from His supernatural life and glory.

Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1533282' date='May 19 2008, 04:46 AM']There is no such thing as a "natural" end for man; thus all men, including the damned, receive a "supernatural" end. God is the sole beginning and end of creation.[/quote]


[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1533330' date='May 19 2008, 10:20 AM']This is a Western way of looking at things, and I rejected it when I changed sui juris Churches more than three years ago.

There is no "natural" way of enjoying God in the next life, as if nature can be separated from the supernatural gift of God's uncreated energies. Unbaptized babies will share in the glory of God given through the incarnation, which means that they will see God, and grow more and more divine throughout eternity. Divine glory, appropriate to the personal reality each individual, awaits all those who have committed no sins. Only the damned will experience any suffering or loss in relation to God, for they will have only a discursive knowledge of the good in the next life, since they separated themselves from the good through their actions during their earthly life.[/quote]

I am glad you took this approach to the ? and brought up this important point. In reading the old school new advent article that I first posted, this was one of the main issues that was of interest to me.

Apotheoun - which then of the above 3 "options" Thessalonian offered to you most closely adhere to?
Your stmt that they will "grow more and more divine throughout eternity" concerns me. For instance, once in eternity there is no change, correct? I am off to read the thread you linked so perhaps you already answered my ?'s there.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='-I---Love' post='1534129' date='May 19 2008, 06:47 PM']Apotheoun - which then of the above 3 "options" Thessalonian offered to you [do you] most closely adhere to?[/quote]
None of them, because they are all based upon an Augustinian view of the nature of man after the ancestral sin, which is a theological perspective that is foreign to the doctrinal tradition of the Eastern Churches.

P.S. - Of the four options presented, no. 4 itself is the least problematic, but I prefer my own Church's tradition over that of the Western Augustinian / Scholastic viewpoint.

Edited by Apotheoun
Posted

The Eastern tradition holds that there will be degrees of glory for those who participate in the vision of God, and that the divine vision entails a never-ending movement (i.e., [i]epektasis[/i]) or infinite progression into the tri-hypostatic God, who is infinitely beyond the infinite, but there is no "limbo" nor is an innocent man ever damned.

Thus, I believe:

1. That an unbaptized baby that dies in infancy experiences the vision of God received through the incarnation of the eternal Logos, but does not receive the glory given through baptism, chrismation, and eucharist, or through the practice of ascetic virtue.

2. That a baptized baby that dies before reaching the age of reason receives the glory given through the sacraments of baptism, chrismation, and eucharist, but does not receive the glory given through ascetic practice.

3. That a man who is fully initiated into the Church through baptism, chrismation, and eucharist, and who goes on to live a life of virtue receives the glory of the sacraments, and the glory achieved in cooperation with God’s energy through the practice of ascesis.

Finally, as St. Gregory Palamas said: "Sensible light shows things to our senses. The intellectual light is to manifest the truth which is contained in thoughts. But those who receive the spiritual or supernatural Light, perceive what is beyond all intellect. They participate in the divine energies and become themselves, in a sort, Light. When they unite to the Light, they see with it in full all that is hidden from those who have not seen the grace of Light. The Uncreated Light is the Light where God makes Himself manifest to those who enter into union with Him."

Posted

Thanks for sharing...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...