Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Recently I was having a conversation with a lady I work wtih. She's a non-denominational Christian who made a trip to the Holy Land a few years back. Anyway, she was telling me about all the beautiful things she saw and then she was like, "And my minister baptized us in the Jordan River...it was exhilirating." And it was kinda one of those things people say and it sounds like a bad note being struck in your ear. I heard the Nicene Creed in my head..."one baptism for the forgiveness of sins..."

Are vanity baptisms okay? Lets just assume the best case scenario that it wasn't a 'full' baptism and it was just dunking. I mean if the triune formula isnt' invoked and its just kind of a 'getting dunked' by a preacher in the Jordan because thats where Jesus was dunked...is it still a big bad thing? I've heard actually getting re-baptized is a pretty big deal. Just wanted an answer from a credible source.

I felt like I should have said something to my co-worker...but I couldn't really think of what to say...

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Veridicus' post='1533177' date='May 18 2008, 11:33 PM']Recently I was having a conversation with a lady I work wtih. She's a non-denominational Christian who made a trip to the Holy Land a few years back. Anyway, she was telling me about all the beautiful things she saw and then she was like, "And my minister baptized us in the Jordan River...it was exhilirating." And it was kinda one of those things people say and it sounds like a bad note being struck in your ear. I heard the Nicene Creed in my head..."one baptism for the forgiveness of sins..."

Are vanity baptisms okay? Lets just assume the best case scenario that it wasn't a 'full' baptism and it was just dunking. I mean if the triune formula isnt' invoked and its just kind of a 'getting dunked' by a preacher in the Jordan because thats where Jesus was dunked...is it still a big bad thing? I've heard actually getting re-baptized is a pretty big deal. Just wanted an answer from a credible source.

I felt like I should have said something to my co-worker...but I couldn't really think of what to say...[/quote]

Well, chances are that she doesn't believe Baptism is efficacious, in other words, she probably believes it's more a sign than a sacrament that actually has an effect. With that in mind, together with what you said about it not being in the Trinitarian formula, I'm inclined to say that it was similar to what we do when we cross ourselves with holy water. The similarity is that it was, for her, probably a reminder of her Baptism and conversion, which is what holy water reminds us of. The difference is that we believe in sacramentals, and sacramentals do have an effect in the order of grace, they help make us holier, as long as we're open to the grace. Since she most likely doesn't believe in sacramentals, she probably wouldn't think the same thing about holy water, much less about Jordan River water.

If I were to approach this issue with her, I'd probably just try to start up a friendly conversation about how her actions sound similar to the times you use holy water, and then go into a little conversation on reminders of Baptism and baptismal grace. It could be a great moment for evangelization, letting a non-denominational Christian see that we Catholics really do care about Baptism and celebrating our Baptisms all through life as a serious thing.

That said, I don't think I see anything wrong with her having gone through this, since she clearly means something different by "Baptism" than we do. In fact, I think it could be argued that Catholics could do this, so long as we made it clear that it was not Baptism, but a blessing with water from the River Jordan, symbolically reminding us of Baptism.

God bless,

Raphael

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...