Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

I'm Confused, But Maybe I'm Just Dense


Recommended Posts

Brother Adam
Posted

I'm even more confused now. Given the clarification between Arinze and Pell, I don't see how anyone could justify kneeling after receiving Communion as being the normal posture when their answers state it simply isn't to be forbidden (like kneeling to receive the Eucharist), not that we are suppose to kneel.

Where is the closest Latin Mass to Williamston, MI?

Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' post='1539103' date='May 23 2008, 04:49 PM']I'm even more confused now. Given the clarification between Arinze and Pell, I don't see how anyone could justify kneeling after receiving Communion as being the normal posture when their answers state it simply isn't to be forbidden (like kneeling to receive the Eucharist), not that we are suppose to kneel.[/quote]

I agree with you Adam. It seems after reading the Cardinals responses that the normal posture is to stand after receiving Communion until the sacred silence has begun. However, the Cardinals state that one is allowed to kneel if one wishes after receiving Communion, without having to wait for the sacred silence to begin.

journeyman
Posted

From the Archdiocese of Louisville:

Communion Rite
The faithful stand for the Lord’s Prayer, the Sign of Peace, and the Fraction Rite with its Lamb of God litany.

After the Breaking of the Bread/Lamb of God litany, the faithful customarily kneel until the distribution of Holy Communion begins. For the Communion procession and distribution of Holy Communion all stand until the entire assembly has received Holy Communion, in attendance to the body of Christ receiving the Body and Blood of Christ. (GIRM #43, 160)

[url="http://images.acswebnetworks.com/2019/226/GIRM2002Posture.pdf"]http://images.acswebnetworks.com/2019/226/...2002Posture.pdf[/url]

Spokane (does not directly answer the question, but provides more of a "why" than many other summaries I have seen

[url="http://www.dioceseofspokane.org/liturgy/GIRM%20Directory.htm"]http://www.dioceseofspokane.org/liturgy/GIRM%20Directory.htm[/url]

Article at Ministry and Liturgy

7 After communion, the priest and people may spend some time praying silently. If desired, either a psalm or other canticle of praise or a hymn may be sung by the entire congregation (88).

I wish I could find the music director who invented the phrase “meditation song.” There is no such animal in the liturgy, and certainly not after communion. This is not new either. There wasn’t a “meditation song” in the 1972 instruction and there still isn’t. [i]Some of us were taught in our grade-school religion classes that the few moments right after communion were a special time to be spent alone in prayer with the Lord who was now within us. That is directly contrary, however, to the very “Amen” we proclaim in response to the communion minister’s acclamation: “The Body (Blood) of Christ.” We are saying “Amen” to the real presence of Christ in the consecrated elements but also to the Body of Christ we have become one with and symbolized by all the other members of the Body of Christ all around us. [/i]To focus on only one member of the Body — myself, all alone with Jesus — is an actualization of Western individualism that must be exorcised from every aspect of our liturgy.

8 The faithful should stand [from after the Great Amen at the end of the Eucharistic Prayer] to the end of the Mass … . They should sit …, if this seems helpful, during the period of religious silence after communion” (43).

I would suggest it does not seem helpful for the assembly to sit at this point. Sitting (or kneeling, which is not allowed) after communion too easily permits us to slip into our individual moments of personal meditation — clearly not intended by the rite. If there is to be a hymn of praise after communion, the instruction expects the assembly to remain standing from the Great Amen (in the United States) to the end of Mass. If there is to be a time of silence, the instruction expects the assembly to remain standing until all have shared in communion. Then, the assembly may remain standing for the silence (my preference) or may be seated, all together, if it seems helpful to sit. The practice of kneeling is not allowed for the Lamb of God or for individual prayer immediately after returning from the communion procession. This is the way the directive on posture appears in the 1972 instruction as well.

[url="http://www.rpinet.com/ml/2805girm.html"]http://www.rpinet.com/ml/2805girm.html[/url]


USCCB

88. [i]When the distribution of Communion is finished[/i], as circumstances suggest, the priest and faithful spend some time praying privately. If desired, a psalm or other canticle of praise or a hymn may also be sung by the entire congregation.

[url="http://www.usccb.org/liturgy/current/chapter2.shtml"]http://www.usccb.org/liturgy/current/chapter2.shtml[/url]



"It's only a 'suggestion' from the bishop"
[url="http://forums.catholic.com/showthread.php?t=222497"]http://forums.catholic.com/showthread.php?t=222497[/url]


The presence of God: The GIRM is intended to help us get there. It is not a distraction to keep us from there.
[url="http://www.paulturner.org/germ_of_the_girm.htm"]http://www.paulturner.org/germ_of_the_girm.htm[/url]

LouisvilleFan
Posted (edited)

[quote name='journeyman' post='1539359' date='May 23 2008, 09:54 PM']From the Archdiocese of Louisville:

Communion Rite
The faithful stand for the Lord’s Prayer, the Sign of Peace, and the Fraction Rite with its Lamb of God litany.

After the Breaking of the Bread/Lamb of God litany, the faithful customarily kneel until the distribution of Holy Communion begins. For the Communion procession and distribution of Holy Communion all stand until the entire assembly has received Holy Communion, in attendance to the body of Christ receiving the Body and Blood of Christ. (GIRM #43, 160)[/quote]

In practice, most parishes stand for the whole thing: Lord's Prayer until the priest sits following distribution of Communion. That's allegedly what our former archbishop (Thomas Kelly) instructed us to do beginning about a year ago.

However, many parishioners choose to kneel following the Lamb of God until Communion is completed. At some parishes, nearly everyone is kneeling, at mine it's split, and at others nearly everyone stands. Since the GIRM affirms that we are allowed to kneel, and that feels more appropriate to me at the time, I kneel.

Edited by LouisvilleFan
LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' post='1539103' date='May 23 2008, 05:49 PM']I'm even more confused now. Given the clarification between Arinze and Pell, I don't see how anyone could justify kneeling after receiving Communion as being the normal posture when their answers state it simply isn't to be forbidden (like kneeling to receive the Eucharist), not that we are suppose to kneel.[/quote]

There is no "normal" posture. Some dioceses like mine have apparently instated some "normal" posture, but you're always free to kneel.

FWIW, this stuff will be a distant memory in due time. Don't allow it to mess with offering ourselves in the Mass and throughout the week.

Posted

Not sure if this has been posted. It comes from Catholic Answers

POSTURE AFTER COMMUNION


The new GIRM provides that the faithful should “sit while the readings before the Gospel and the responsorial psalm are proclaimed and for the homily and while the Preparation of the Gifts at the Offertory is taking place; and, as circumstances allow, they may sit or kneel while the period of sacred silence after Communion is observed” (43).

Regarding sitting or kneeling during the silence after Communion, some interpreted this as meaning that the faithful should stand until the last communicant had received Communion, which was contrary to the traditional practice of the faithful assuming their preferred postures immediately upon returning to the pews.

A controversy ensued, in which Francis Cardinal George, chairman of the Bishops’ Committee on Liturgy, queried the CDWDS: “In many places, the faithful are accustomed to kneeling or sitting in personal prayer upon returning to their places after having individually received Holy Communion during Mass. Is it the intention of the [new Roman Missal] to forbid this practice?”

The response was as follows: “Negative, et ad mentem [No, and for this reason]. The mens [reason] is that the prescription of [GIRM] no. 43 is intended, on the one hand, to ensure within broad limits a certain uniformity of posture within the congregation for the various parts of the celebration of Holy Mass, and on the other, to not regulate posture rigidly in such a way that those who wish to kneel or sit would no longer be free” (responsum of Francis Cardinal Arinze, June 5, 2003 [Prot. 855/03/L], as published in the July 2003 BCL newsletter).

CatherineM
Posted

I'm having a fuss with the liturgy committee right now about the GIRM. They recently changed from the choir taking communion last to having them take it with the Eucharistic Ministers. We basically have to choke it down quickly, and immediately start singing. Two weeks ago, I spit a particle out accidentally, and since I can not physically bend over that far, I had to have another member of the choir help me retrieve it. I basically put my foot down that I would no longer do that. I now sit until I have finished my communion prayers, and they can just start without me. I'm a large woman, and stand out at the front. People are starting to notice and ask questions. It's a good opportunity to educate people about the problems with our liturgy. I'm tired of holding my tongue. Just because the head of the liturgy committee is a nun doesn't make her right. She's practically turned the RCIA into a new age free for all. Wow, I think I had too much caffeine today.

johnnydigit
Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1547220' date='May 28 2008, 06:57 PM']I'm having a fuss with the liturgy committee right now about the GIRM. They recently changed from the choir taking communion last to having them take it with the Eucharistic Ministers. We basically have to choke it down quickly, and immediately start singing. Two weeks ago, I spit a particle out accidentally, and since I can not physically bend over that far, I had to have another member of the choir help me retrieve it. I basically put my foot down that I would no longer do that. I now sit until I have finished my communion prayers, and they can just start without me. I'm a large woman, and stand out at the front. People are starting to notice and ask questions. It's a good opportunity to educate people about the problems with our liturgy. I'm tired of holding my tongue. Just because the head of the liturgy committee is a nun doesn't make her right. She's practically turned the RCIA into a new age free for all. Wow, I think I had too much caffeine today.[/quote]

the choir receives first at the local TLM. i think it's a good idea, so that they can sing for the people. one thing i don't like about serving, whether it's altar, minister, choir, etc., is that i don't get to meditate as much. it smells of elderberries the most when i've had a long hard day (usually from snowboarding - ya hard!), and i just want to absorb the Mass in peace. it's a sacrifice, but a worthy one i think..


as far as kneeling after Communion, i do find it awkward sometimes when a person has to ask or nudge the person kneeling (sometimes with eyes closed) to return to their seat. sometimes the order gets out of que when someone doesn't drink the precious blood, or is an EMHC, or whatever the reason. standing seems to correct this. unfortunately, many priests don't even allow more than a few seconds of silence..

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...