kujo Posted May 23, 2008 Posted May 23, 2008 Interesting article I just read and thought I'd share about the politics of a post-abortion America. [quote]During the long, long arguments about the implicit pro-life messages, or lack thereof, in films like Knocked Up and Juno, my interlocutors frequently made the point that even if the movies were mildly pro-life, they weren't effective arguments for an anti-abortion position, because neither film’s storyline actually reflected the experience of most American women who consider terminating their pregnancy. Which is fair enough so far as it goes - but if that’s the case do I really have to endure the suggestion, from J. Hoberman among others, that a film set in Ceauşescu's Romania has more relevance than any of them to the American abortion debate? Hoberman's piece seems as good a peg as any to hang an argument that I don’t think either side in the abortion debate has contemplated seriously enough – namely, that any successful attempt, in a post-Roe world, to ban or strictly regulate abortion in the United States would amount to an epic social experiment, with no obvious antecedents in our own history or any other country’s. The U.S. isn’t a Communist hellhole or a patriarchal Third World society, and it isn’t at all the same country that it was the last time abortion was widely illegal. It’s a post-feminist, post-sexual revolution society, and any attempt at restricting abortion that hopes to succeed – whether legally, politically or morally – would have to take these realities into account to a far greater degree than, say, the hapless attempt at a blanket ban that South Dakota passed two years ago. Designing abortion restrictions for contemporary America would require compromises on the part of pro-lifers, obviously – not only on rape and incest but also probably on the availability and distribution of the morning-after pill. But more than that, it would almost certainly require large-scale (and expensive) experimentation with the American welfare state, to address the needs of the hundreds of thousands of pregnant women each year who would suddenly no longer have the option of aborting their unborn - and the hundreds of thousands of children who would come into the world as a result. What exact form this sort of experimentation would take I'm not sure; it's a thorny enough subject to make a topic for a long essay or even a book. But over the short term, there's no question that it would require conservatives to temporarily table many of their longstanding policy goals - from cutting illegitimacy rates to reducing welfare dependency to limiting the size of government – in the name of the pro-life cause. (This goes for me as much as for anyone else: While Grand New Party assumes that the GOP will remain a staunchly pro-life party, the agenda it proposes also assumes that the landscape of abortion politics will remain roughly as it is today for the foreseeable future.) Over the long run, my assumption is that a ban on abortion, by changing the incentives of sexual behavior and family formation, would actually end up reducing out-of-wedlock births, welfare spending, and all the rest of it, and that a short-term investment in a pro-life welfare state (and an acceptance of the short term spike in illegitimacy, dependency and government spending that would presumably accompany it) would prove a boon to conservatism in the end. But that's a long-term hope, not a short-term plan - and even if that assumption weren’t borne out, I still think that a higher illegitimacy rate and a more expensive and intrusive welfare state would be a small price to pay for a country where every human being enjoyed the protection of the laws. Obviously, not everyone on the Right would agree, which is one reason why the abortion debate ultimately cuts across party lines, if not across party platforms. (As Reihan notes, Will Saletan’s Bearing Right is the book to read on the subject.) And just as obviously, the scenario I just sketched out probably never come to pass; even if Roe disappears, I suspect that the country will settle into an equilibrium more pro-choice than pro-life, with more chances for experimentation with abortion policy but not all that many more. But if real opportunities do arise and the pro-life movement seizes them, I think it's safe to say that the results will look, in policy and practice alike, unlike any abortion regime that now exists, or has ever existed before.[/quote] Source: [url="http://rossdouthat.theatlantic.com/archives/2008/01/imagining_a_prolife_america.php"]The-Atlantic.com[/url]
Justin86 Posted May 23, 2008 Posted May 23, 2008 I believe that is why the Church teaches to save yourself for marriage, but I agree that the welfare state simply can't survive in a pro-life environment.
Alycin Posted May 26, 2008 Posted May 26, 2008 If a bill were presented to the public that said that abortion would be illegal except in the case of rape or incest, could catholics vote yes on it, even though in a round-about way it would be supporting abortion in the case of rape or incest?
kujo Posted May 26, 2008 Author Posted May 26, 2008 [quote name='Alycin' post='1542333' date='May 25 2008, 10:48 PM']If a bill were presented to the public that said that abortion would be illegal except in the case of rape or incest, could catholics vote yes on it, even though in a round-about way it would be supporting abortion in the case of rape or incest?[/quote] I think it would be an incremental improvement of the situation, so I would say yes. The bill would have to make a provision that the woman would have to be able to prove that she had been raped or been the victim of incest in the court of law. Again, the circumstances of the conception don't change the fact that all life should be protected. But I think, overall, this would be a HUGE step forward and a responsible pro-life legislator would have to support it.
Alycin Posted May 26, 2008 Posted May 26, 2008 [quote name='kujo' post='1542339' date='May 25 2008, 09:53 PM']I think it would be an incremental improvement of the situation, so I would say yes. The bill would have to make a provision that the woman would have to be able to prove that she had been raped or been the victim of incest in the court of law. Again, the circumstances of the conception don't change the fact that all life should be protected. But I think, overall, this would be a HUGE step forward and a responsible pro-life legislator would have to support it.[/quote] I agree, just wanted to make sure that it was okay.
kujo Posted May 26, 2008 Author Posted May 26, 2008 [quote name='Alycin' post='1542341' date='May 25 2008, 10:55 PM']I agree, just wanted to make sure that it was okay. [/quote] I am not an authority on the subject, so don't think I'm 100% correct on this one.
Fidei Defensor Posted May 26, 2008 Posted May 26, 2008 If only it were possible without the horrible ideas in other areas that pro-life politicians usually have.
kujo Posted May 26, 2008 Author Posted May 26, 2008 [quote name='fidei defensor' post='1542857' date='May 26 2008, 02:16 AM']If only it were possible without the horrible ideas in other areas that pro-life politicians usually have.[/quote] ??
kujo Posted May 26, 2008 Author Posted May 26, 2008 [quote name='Justin86' post='1542873' date='May 26 2008, 02:40 AM']He was probably referring to global warming. [/quote] I think being pro-life is a lot more than being opposed to abortion, or being against the death penalty, or against euthanasia, or for chastity-based sexual education. Being pro-life is about improving the quality of life for everyone, from the time they are born until the time that they die naturally. It involves improving education, strengthening the economy, taking progressive steps towards stopping man's contribution to global warming, changing our foreign policy so that our energy resources aren't held captive by madmen and fundamentalists. That's what being pro-life means to me.
Justin86 Posted May 26, 2008 Posted May 26, 2008 Good to know. The Church just has it being against abortion, euthanasia, and contraception, however.
kujo Posted May 26, 2008 Author Posted May 26, 2008 [quote name='Justin86' post='1542986' date='May 26 2008, 07:07 AM']Good to know. The Church just has it being against abortion, euthanasia, and contraception, however.[/quote] Huh?
Alycin Posted May 26, 2008 Posted May 26, 2008 [quote name='Justin86' post='1542986' date='May 26 2008, 06:07 AM']Good to know. The Church just has it being against abortion, euthanasia, and contraception, however.[/quote] no, really?
Justin86 Posted May 26, 2008 Posted May 26, 2008 Just that you're attaching things to the pro-life movement that really aren't infallibly taught. Global warming is not a non-negotiable.
kujo Posted May 26, 2008 Author Posted May 26, 2008 [quote name='Justin86' post='1543027' date='May 26 2008, 07:48 AM']Just that you're attaching things to the pro-life movement that really aren't infallibly taught. Global warming is not a non-negotiable.[/quote] Well of course. I'm attaching things to my view of being pro-life that include making sure that ALL people are treated with the dignity and respect that befits a child of God. The effect of global warming (man-made or otherwise) on Third World nations is obvious, as are unfair trade arrangements, multinational businesses, etc.
Alycin Posted May 26, 2008 Posted May 26, 2008 [quote name='Justin86' post='1543027' date='May 26 2008, 06:48 AM']Just that you're attaching things to the pro-life movement that really aren't infallibly taught. Global warming is not a non-negotiable.[/quote] Nobody said it was. Do you like to start arguments or cause controversy or something? Just curious.
kujo Posted May 26, 2008 Author Posted May 26, 2008 [quote name='Alycin' post='1543029' date='May 26 2008, 07:51 AM']Nobody said it was. Do you like to start arguments or cause controversy or something? Just curious.[/quote] Something doesn't need to be "infallibly taught" in order to be believed. He may not know that. JK dude
Justin86 Posted May 26, 2008 Posted May 26, 2008 Not really. It just seemed weird to attach all that to the pro-life cause.
Alycin Posted May 26, 2008 Posted May 26, 2008 [quote name='Justin86' post='1543027' date='May 26 2008, 06:48 AM']Just that you're attaching things to the pro-life movement that really aren't infallibly taught. Global warming is not a non-negotiable.[/quote] Not to mention the fact that "The pro-life movement" is made up of a heck of a lot more than Catholics, who don't care what the Catholic non-negotiables are, and last time I checked, you weren't speaking for the entire pro-life movement. Correct me if I'm wrong, though.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now