Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Two Species...two Different Things?


Recommended Posts

Knight of the Holy Rosary
Posted

My Grandmother asked me a question regarding the Eucharist. She went to Mass with my family this morning and was somewhat taken aback (almost scandalized) that many Catholics (myself included) did not receive the Precious Blood. I tried to explain that both species are fully the Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity of Jesus Christ...but she said "No. Because Jesus took bread and said this is my Body [i]then[/i] took the cup and said this is my Blood". I really didn't know what to say here.

Any thoughts?

Posted

Christ cannot be divided. The whole Christ is present in each species.

Knight of the Holy Rosary
Posted

Why then did he consecrate each species with a different address (wine to blood and bread to body)?

I don't disagree...I'm just trying determine a good response.

Posted

the separation represents his death, the separation of flesh from blood. Christ is not now dead, therefore His flesh and blood cannot be divided. the two distinct species remind us of His death, but the Risen Christ is present in the unbloody sacrifice and thus the full body, blood, soul, and divinity of Christ is fully present under each species.

Archaeology cat
Posted

I can't give a theological answer, but I think of the various Eucharistic miracles where the Host has bled. To me, that is confirmation enough that Christ is fully present in the bread and the wine. And isn't it a more recent thing (with the advent of the Novus Ordo) that the Latin Rite has even offered both species to the congregation? People who attend the TLM and are only offered the Host are not being denied part of Christ.

Posted

[quote name='Archaeology cat' post='1546664' date='May 28 2008, 03:49 PM']I can't give a theological answer, but I think of the various Eucharistic miracles where the Host has bled. To me, that is confirmation enough that Christ is fully present in the bread and the wine. And isn't it a more recent thing (with the advent of the Novus Ordo) that the Latin Rite has even offered both species to the congregation? People who attend the TLM and are only offered the Host are not being denied part of Christ.[/quote]

What about daily Masses when the priest doesn't offer the congregation the Precious Blood. The people are still receiving the Body and Blood of Christ through the Eucharist.

I agree with Al it's a representation of his death. I wonder if the influence on the blood is also to help speak to the Jew or is bring forth the Jewish idea that to them life was found in the blood.

mommas_boy
Posted

I remember receiving my first communion in second grade, back when the parish NEVER gave the congregation the option to receive the Precious Blood. The second grade class was very distraught at not being able to receive the Precious Blood (in part, I think, because we as second graders were enchanted with the idea of drinking (sic) wine).

Anyway, after our first communion, the priest came into the classroom and tried to comfort us. He told us that in every bit of any piece of flesh, there is always some blood, and in every bit of blood, there were cells of the body present. He was speaking practically and non-sacramentally. His goal was to assure us that even though we had "only" received the Precious Body, we had also received the Precious Blood, because there is always blood in flesh.

Hope this helps, if only on a non-theological level.

CatherineM
Posted

We had a woman with Celiac disease two years ago in RCIA, and she only receives from the cup. Both are the true body, blood, soul and divinity of Jesus Christ.

Posted

In scripture I thought it was because the bread was consumed at the start of the meal and the wine after the meal?

Posted

[quote name='StColette' post='1546799' date='May 28 2008, 04:26 PM']wonder if the influence on the blood is also to help speak to the Jew or is bring forth the Jewish idea that to them life was found in the blood.[/quote]

lol sorry having to add to this. But I was thinking about John 6 and how after Christ says "and drinks my blood will have eternal life" is bringing in the Jewish belief that blood was a symbol of life. Also the dietary laws forbade the eating of meat with blood still remaining in it because they were afraid that it would somehow transmit the "life" of the cow and the cows "unclean life" into themselves. So that being said since blood is a symbol of life, when Christ is saying "drink of my blood" we are bringing him into ourselves, his life is brought into us, especially if you look at it from the Jewish understanding of blood.

Did anyone understand that? lol

Archaeology cat
Posted

[quote name='StColette' post='1548108' date='May 29 2008, 03:09 PM']lol sorry having to add to this. But I was thinking about John 6 and how after Christ says "and drinks my blood will have eternal life" is bringing in the Jewish belief that blood was a symbol of life. Also the dietary laws forbade the eating of meat with blood still remaining in it because they were afraid that it would somehow transmit the "life" of the cow and the cows "unclean life" into themselves. So that being said since blood is a symbol of life, when Christ is saying "drink of my blood" we are bringing him into ourselves, his life is brought into us, especially if you look at it from the Jewish understanding of blood.

Did anyone understand that? lol[/quote]
:yes: I've love thinking about it that way, too.

Oh, and sometimes we receive the Blood at the daily Mass here, as well. In fact, I think every daily Mass I've been to here has offered both species.

Posted

Below is the answer I gave to a somewhat related question concerning the Eucharist and the Trinity:

[url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=50636&st=0&p=950361&#entry950361"][u]Here's a doozy... Is the Trinity Present in the Eucharist?[/u][/url]

Posted

Can someone please review the following explanation for any doctrinal errors. I'm having a discussion on a Protestant forum, and don't want to say anything that is doctrinally incorrect:




The Eucharist is a unique kind of presence. Here is a brief explanation from the Catechism of the Catholic Church:

[quote]The mode of Christ's presence under the Eucharistic species is unique. …In the most blessed sacrament of the Eucharist "the body and blood, together with the soul and divinity, of our Lord Jesus Christ and, therefore, [i]the whole Christ is truly, really, and substantially contained.[/i]" "This presence is called 'real' - by which is not intended to exclude the other types of presence as if they could not be 'real' too, but because it is presence in the fullest sense: that is to say, it is a substantial presence by which Christ, God and man, makes himself wholly and entirely present."

--Paragraph #1374[/quote]
The presence of Christ in the Eucharist is “substantial.” As I said before, it is not that one part of the Eucharist is a leg, another part an arm, etc. Rather, each particle is entirely the body and blood of Christ, his entire bodily substance.

When Our Lord was talking with the Apostles at the Last Supper, he was present in a different way. His two arms were distinct from one another. The Apostles could touch one arm, and not touch the other. He remains present in this way in Heaven.

The presence of Our Lord in the Eucharist is just as real as his presence while he walked on earth, but as I said, it is a different kind of presence. Pope Paul VI writes:

[quote]…once the substance or nature of the bread and wine has been changed into the body and blood of Christ, nothing remains of the bread and the wine except for the species—beneath which Christ is present whole and entire in His physical "reality," corporeally present, [b]although not in the manner in which bodies are in a place.[/b]

--Encyclical Letter “Mysterium Fidei”[/quote]
The Eucharist is not cannibalism. Cannibalism would be ripping apart a body and eating it. In the Eucharist, we do not consume Our Lord in this way, but rather in a substantial way. That is, we consume the entire substance of his body, not part of an arm and part of a leg.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1558971' date='Jun 4 2008, 11:42 PM']Rather, each particle is entirely the body and blood of Christ, his entire bodily substance.[/quote]

Good until I got to this point. Be more clear...each and every particle is the WHOLE Christ, Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity, the whole person in both natures. It is not just His bodily substance, but His whole (and living) substance. The fact that it is His whole, living substance is what especially keeps it from being cannibalism.

[quote]When Our Lord was talking with the Apostles at the Last Supper, he was present in a different way. His two arms were distinct from one another. The Apostles could touch one arm, and not touch the other. He remains present in this way in Heaven.[/quote]

Good demonstration of the difference between local and sacramental presence.

[quote]The presence of Our Lord in the Eucharist is just as real as his presence while he walked on earth, but as I said, it is a different kind of presence. Pope Paul VI writes:[/quote]

Good.

[quote]The Eucharist is not cannibalism. Cannibalism would be ripping apart a body and eating it. In the Eucharist, we do not consume Our Lord in this way, but rather in a substantial way. That is, we consume the entire substance of his body, not part of an arm and part of a leg.[/quote]

Very good, just be sure to use my above clarification.

Posted

[quote name='Raphael' post='1559017' date='Jun 4 2008, 11:51 PM']Good until I got to this point. Be more clear...each and every particle is the WHOLE Christ, Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity, the whole person in both natures. It is not just His bodily substance, but His whole (and living) substance.[/quote]
The reason why I said "bodily substance" is because his soul and divinity are not physical. They are present, but the species itself is changed into his body and blood, which is united to his soul and divinity. But it seems to me incorrect to say that the species "is" his soul and divinity, because they are not physical things. What do you think?

Posted

Just to add, I explained earlier in the discussion that when I speak of the "body and blood" of Christ, it is assumed that his body and blood are united to his soul and divinity.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1559024' date='Jun 4 2008, 11:54 PM']The reason why I said "bodily substance" is because his soul and divinity are not physical. They are present, but the species itself is changed into his body and blood, which is united to his soul and divinity. But it seems to me incorrect to say that the species "is" his soul and divinity, because they are not physical things. What do you think?[/quote]

I think it's semantics, but I'd rather use the wording I expressed. If we touch a person's body and say, "what am I touching," they will say "you're touching me." It doesn't matter that you're actually really only touching the body, the soul (and in Christ's case, the divinity) is infused into the body through and through. While the soul is not material and you can't "touch" it, the soul and divinity are just as truly present in the Eucharist as they would be in His hand if you touched it.

It's also incorrect to say that the species "is" His Body and Blood and leave it at that. The fullest expression is that the species "is" Jesus Christ, present entirely in a sacramental way, under both natures, in His Hypostatic Union, Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity.

[quote name='Era Might' post='1559059' date='Jun 5 2008, 12:06 AM']Just to add, I explained earlier in the discussion that when I speak of the "body and blood" of Christ, it is assumed that his body and blood are united to his soul and divinity.[/quote]

Since you're in an argument, though, I'd go with the fullest expression of the faith, which is technically the most accurate.

Posted

Okay. Thanks. I'll have to think about how best to word that part.

Posted

What do you think of this revised explanation:




The Eucharist is a unique "mode," or way, of being present. Here is an explanation from Pope Paul VI:

[quote]"...after the consecration of the bread and wine, Our Lord Jesus Christ, true God and man, is really, truly and substantially contained in the Blessed Sacrament of the Holy Eucharist under the outward appearances of sensible things." And so Our Savior is present in His humanity not only in His natural manner of existence at the right hand of the Father, but also at the same time in the sacrament of the Eucharist "in a manner of existing that we can hardly express in words but that our minds, illumined by faith, can come to see as possible to God and that we must most firmly believe." ...once the substance or nature of the bread and wine has been changed into the body and blood of Christ, nothing remains of the bread and the wine except for the species—beneath which Christ is present whole and entire in His physical "reality," corporeally present, [b]although not in the manner in which bodies are in a place.[/b]

--Encyclical Letter “Mysterium Fidei”[/quote]
The presence of Christ in the Eucharist is “substantial.” As I said before, it is not that one part of the Eucharist is a leg, another part an arm, etc. Rather, each particle is entirely the body and blood of Christ (and just to reiterate, when I speak of his body and blood, it is assumed that his body and blood are united to his soul and divinity, so that the Eucharist is entirely Christ: his body, blood, soul, and divinity).

When Our Lord was talking with the Apostles at the Last Supper, he was present in a different way. His two arms were distinct from one another. The Apostles could touch one arm, and not touch the other. He remains present in this way in Heaven.

The presence of Our Lord in the Eucharist is just as real as his presence while he walked on earth. As I said, it is a different way of being present, but the same Christ is fully present: his body, blood, soul, and divinity.

The Eucharist is not cannibalism. Cannibalism would be ripping apart a body and eating it. In the Eucharist, we do not consume Our Lord in this way, but rather in a substantial way. That is, we consume him entirely, not part of an arm and part of a leg. Even a crumb of the host, or a drop from the chalice, is entirely Christ: his body, blood, soul, and divinity.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1562980' date='Jun 7 2008, 10:18 PM']What do you think of this revised explanation:
The Eucharist is a unique "mode," or way, of being present. Here is an explanation from Pope Paul VI:
The presence of Christ in the Eucharist is “substantial.” As I said before, it is not that one part of the Eucharist is a leg, another part an arm, etc. Rather, each particle is entirely the body and blood of Christ (and just to reiterate, when I speak of his body and blood, it is assumed that his body and blood are united to his soul and divinity, so that the Eucharist is entirely Christ: his body, blood, soul, and divinity).

When Our Lord was talking with the Apostles at the Last Supper, he was present in a different way. His two arms were distinct from one another. The Apostles could touch one arm, and not touch the other. He remains present in this way in Heaven.

The presence of Our Lord in the Eucharist is just as real as his presence while he walked on earth. As I said, it is a different way of being present, but the same Christ is fully present: his body, blood, soul, and divinity.

The Eucharist is not cannibalism. Cannibalism would be ripping apart a body and eating it. In the Eucharist, we do not consume Our Lord in this way, but rather in a substantial way. That is, we consume him entirely, not part of an arm and part of a leg. Even a crumb of the host, or a drop from the chalice, is entirely Christ: his body, blood, soul, and divinity.[/quote]

This is entirely doctrinally orthodox and I would say pretty understandable.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...