Seven77 Posted May 27, 2008 Posted May 27, 2008 I'm writing a business letter for someone -- the sentence in question is: She lives in the same town as [u][i]I[/i][/u]. Not [u][i]me[/i][/u]. Is this correct? I'm pretty sure it is.
Archaeology cat Posted May 27, 2008 Posted May 27, 2008 I'm fairly certain I was taught that it would be "I", because the full thought would be "She lives in the same town as I [u]do[/u]". You can't put "do" after "me", and therefore it would be incorrect.
icelandic_iceskater Posted May 27, 2008 Posted May 27, 2008 (edited) nvm Edited May 27, 2008 by icelandic_iceskater
salterrae Posted May 27, 2008 Posted May 27, 2008 JM + JT [quote name='Archaeology cat' post='1545199' date='May 27 2008, 05:09 PM']I'm fairly certain I was taught that it would be "I", because the full thought would be "She lives in the same town as I [u]do[/u]". You can't put "do" after "me", and therefore it would be incorrect.[/quote] Ditto.
Seven77 Posted May 27, 2008 Author Posted May 27, 2008 [quote name='Archaeology cat' post='1545199' date='May 27 2008, 04:09 PM']I'm fairly certain I was taught that it would be "I", because the full thought would be "She lives in the same town as I [u]do[/u]". You can't put "do" after "me", and therefore it would be incorrect.[/quote] that would make sense... thanks! I should just write "as i do"
Autumn Dusk Posted May 27, 2008 Posted May 27, 2008 (edited) I think you could say "She lives in the same town as myself" it sounds odd, tho... but "She lives in the same town that I do" sounds kinda hick-like Edited May 27, 2008 by Autumn Dusk
Laudate_Dominum Posted May 27, 2008 Posted May 27, 2008 [quote name='Seven77' post='1545197' date='May 27 2008, 04:05 PM']I'm writing a business letter for someone -- the sentence in question is: She lives in the same town as [u][i]I[/i][/u]. Not [u][i]me[/i][/u]. Is this correct? I'm pretty sure it is.[/quote] I think the most formal use of the personal pronoun in this particular kind of "as" construction would be the subjective case ("I"), but it is perfectly normal in colloquial English to use the objective case ("me"). I suppose the question to ask is whether this second "as" is being used prepositionally or whether a verb is implied. In my opinion this particular sentence calls for the subjective/nominative personal pronoun but I would not be a stickler about it.
prose Posted May 27, 2008 Posted May 27, 2008 (edited) How about "We live in the same town"? (PS. It would be "I" - I is used for subject nouns, me is used for object nouns.) Edited May 27, 2008 by prose
franciscanheart Posted May 28, 2008 Posted May 28, 2008 yes, you are correct. the longer form of the same sentence (and the way to double check yourself without posting on phatmass ) is : she lives in the same town as i do. eta: it may sound funny (as someone mentioned above) but usually this is because our language is so mauled that what is proper is commonly taken to be "funny-" or "silly-" sounding.
Laudate_Dominum Posted May 28, 2008 Posted May 28, 2008 Yeah, because the verb "to do" is implied the "as" construction calls for the subjective form of the personal pronoun, however, I still believe that in colloquial English the objective case is acceptable. On this particular grammatical point I would avoid excessive dogmatism. English lives!! "Grammar is for the sake of the language and not the language for the grammar." - Jesus Christ (not really)
franciscanheart Posted May 28, 2008 Posted May 28, 2008 he has stated this is a business letter. considering the nature of the writing, i would not even give consideration to colloquial English. this is not to say, however, that your argument carries no weight. i disagree, especially in this case, but i suppose it is arguable.
Laudate_Dominum Posted May 28, 2008 Posted May 28, 2008 [quote name='hugheyforlife' post='1545525' date='May 27 2008, 07:44 PM']he has stated this is a business letter. considering the nature of the writing, i would not even give consideration to colloquial English. this is not to say, however, that your argument carries no weight. i disagree, especially in this case, but i suppose it is arguable.[/quote] I hear ya. I'm no grammarian but I think one can be excessively formal in a business letter. Perhaps it depends on where you live, but I can't remember the last time I heard someone use textbook grammar in regular speech with "as I" phrases of this kind unless they were trying to parody Shakespeare or something. I'm probably just a hick.. In spite of what appears to be acceptable English these days I suppose there are people who take textbook grammar quite seriously so perhaps it is best to play it safe. hehe. Good call hughey.
Archaeology cat Posted May 28, 2008 Posted May 28, 2008 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1545967' date='May 28 2008, 08:55 AM']I hear ya. I'm no grammarian but I think one can be excessively formal in a business letter. Perhaps it depends on where you live, but I can't remember the last time I heard someone use textbook grammar in regular speech with "as I" phrases of this kind unless they were trying to parody Shakespeare or something. I'm probably just a hick.. In spite of what appears to be acceptable English these days I suppose there are people who take textbook grammar quite seriously so perhaps it is best to play it safe. hehe. Good call hughey.[/quote] I'm one of those who prefers to use textbook grammar (as my husband can verify) when speaking. And if I were the recipient of a business letter, I would definitely be a stickler for proper grammar.
franciscanheart Posted May 28, 2008 Posted May 28, 2008 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1545967' date='May 28 2008, 02:55 AM']I hear ya. I'm no grammarian but I think one can be excessively formal in a business letter. Perhaps it depends on where you live, but I can't remember the last time I heard someone use textbook grammar in regular speech with "as I" phrases of this kind unless they were trying to parody Shakespeare or something. I'm probably just a hick.. In spite of what appears to be acceptable English these days I suppose there are people who take textbook grammar quite seriously so perhaps it is best to play it safe. hehe. Good call hughey.[/quote] i bet it comes from my being one of those people who is quite conscious of grammar when speaking or writing, even informally. there are times that i cringe at using a prepositional phrase at the end of a sentence. << check that out. three in a row! lol. anyway, call me a nerd, i just think we should be conscious of how we're speaking.
homeschoolmom Posted May 28, 2008 Posted May 28, 2008 [quote name='Autumn Dusk' post='1545245' date='May 27 2008, 05:49 PM']I think you could say "She lives in the same town as myself" it sounds odd, tho... but "She lives in the same town that I do" sounds kinda hick-like[/quote] Why people use "myself" to sound formal is beyond me. It just sounds.... wrong. "She lives in the same town as I" is correct. But "She and I live in the same town" is better.
franciscanheart Posted May 28, 2008 Posted May 28, 2008 [quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1546035' date='May 28 2008, 08:13 AM'] Why people use "myself" to sound formal is beyond me. It just sounds.... wrong.[/quote] I feel ya homeschoolmom...
homeschoolmom Posted May 28, 2008 Posted May 28, 2008 For clarification: "Myself" is either a reflexive pronoun (I hurt myself) or and intensive pronoun (I did it myself). It is not used when you don't know if you should use "I" or "me."
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now