FreeSoul Posted May 30, 2008 Posted May 30, 2008 Sigh. I didn't say that men are unable to be nurturers. I said they are taught not to be. They are taught to rule and dominate - to be the boss of earth lol. A priest adopts a role quite different from this. As for teaching women to make babies...you bettah watch out! This is a Catholic site! I'm not saying that Church is discriminating, I'm just saying that given the mainstream order of things that the world has more to learn from men adopting the role of priest than women - because they are not socialized to do these things - but fully capable. Like a woman who in the 1970's was a feminist who decided to stay at home - good for her - but nearly indistinguishable from those who are not lol
Deb Posted May 30, 2008 Posted May 30, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1549557' date='May 30 2008, 01:55 PM']The house I grew up in, my father was the main nurturer. To say men can't do that is kind of sexist too. I was born white, female, tall with very big feet. Well they weren't that big when I was born, but that was quickly remedied. I could have been born in Africa or Asia, but I wasn't. God made me a certain way, in a certain place and time. How we are born and where can't be changed anymore than I can change my skin color. I was born as a woman, into a certain role. I don't find that limiting, I find it liberating. I will never be a priest, so I don't have to worry or think about becoming one. I will also never be elected president of the NAACP, or chief of the Cherokee tribe. I don't sit around worrying that I'm being discriminated against because of that either. I wasn't born with the capacity to be a gymnast, a horse jockey, or a ballerina. That doesn't mean I am being discriminated against because they won't name me to the Olympic team. I don't sit around thinking about what a great priest I could have made, because it would be as big a waste of time as sitting around thinking about playing football in the NFL. I've got sweet hands, and I'm not afraid of going over the middle. If some women want to waste their energy thinking of what they are owed or deserve that they aren't getting, I can't stop them. I don't think I am owed anything except a pew to warm. The church doesn't discriminate against me because I'm a women, the church saves me.[/quote] Wow. That was most impressive. What a great way to articulate the joy of just being who you are, and liking it! You are my hero of the day!!!
StColette Posted May 30, 2008 Posted May 30, 2008 [quote name='FreeSoul' post='1549581' date='May 30 2008, 02:10 PM']As for teaching women to make babies...you bettah watch out! This is a Catholic site! I'm not saying that Church is discriminating, I'm just saying that given the mainstream order of things that the world has more to learn from men adopting the role of priest than women - because they are not socialized to do these things - but fully capable. Like a woman who in the 1970's was a feminist who decided to stay at home - good for her - but nearly indistinguishable from those who are not lol[/quote] I don't have to watch out, I'm already expecting. But I also work, have a degree in an area that is mostly dominated by men, I don't place nice all the time, my husband doesn't rule and dominate over me, as for cooking and clean I learned those things from my father and my husband does a lot of the cleaning since I've been having a tough pregnancy, when I wasn't pregnant we equally split the cooking and cleaning. As for men being taugh to fight to rule the planet, lol you haven't met many southern women lol The world has more to learn from both men and women fulfilling the roles they were meant to do.
FreeSoul Posted May 30, 2008 Posted May 30, 2008 (edited) Well, congrats to all of you. You are a testament to the abilities of women everywhere. However Catholic women all over the world are still denied access to realize that ability, and so I think i'll have to stick to the argument male priests are counter-cultural for that reason. Edited May 30, 2008 by FreeSoul
StColette Posted May 30, 2008 Posted May 30, 2008 [quote name='FreeSoul' post='1549595' date='May 30 2008, 02:23 PM']However Catholic women all over the world are still denied access to realize that ability[/quote] How so?
FreeSoul Posted May 30, 2008 Posted May 30, 2008 Well, we are both university educated women, but many women around the world are denied access to education, the gender parity in literacy rate statistics, the reality that prevalence of hiv/aids is directly related to the woman's ability to negotiate in relationships (in both core and peripheral states)....etc, etc. To illustrate this more clearly, I had a friend, a Sister (religious) who went to peru and they were teaching women to practice local crafts to sell and they came across a woman who drowned her baby and was wracked with guilt because her husband told her 'either you do it....or I do it'. The male priesthood is counter cultural because sexism does not exist in a vacuum. It exists along with class and racial parities around the world. When a man chooses to make these vows he is placing these things aside and adopting characteristics which in secular societies are expected - or almost - demanded from women. Can you only imagine what the world would be like if Donald Trump valued poverty, chastity and obedience, listened to people with charity and supported a preferential option for the poor??? You and I may be blind to this because we live in developed nations and have access to income and privilege that others only dream of..but for many other women around the world this is not the case.
HisChildForever Posted May 30, 2008 Posted May 30, 2008 These wouldn't be [b]valid[/b] ordinations though, right?
StColette Posted May 30, 2008 Posted May 30, 2008 [quote name='HisChildForever' post='1549680' date='May 30 2008, 04:03 PM']These wouldn't be [b]valid[/b] ordinations though, right?[/quote] Correct
HisChildForever Posted May 30, 2008 Posted May 30, 2008 Okay, so technically they'd be getting excomm. for attempting ordinations against the Church's teachings/doctrine/etc.
StColette Posted May 30, 2008 Posted May 30, 2008 [quote name='HisChildForever' post='1549704' date='May 30 2008, 04:15 PM']Okay, so technically they'd be getting excomm. for attempting ordinations against the Church's teachings/doctrine/etc.[/quote] Correct This is the text of the actual decree: "The Congregation for Religious Doctrine, to protect the nature and validity of the sacrament of the holy order, in virtue of the special faculty to be consecrated by the supreme authority decrees that both the one [b]trying[/b] to consecrate a woman in the holy order, and the woman [b]who has tried [/b]to receive the holy order, will be excommunicated 'latae sententiae', reserved to the Apostolic See." The decree says "tried" not that they were ordained, but that they "tried" to be ordained. Always pay attention to the actual decree and not the wording of some who paraphrase it because they can come across as saying something that the decree does not. The decree does not say that they are ordained, while the rest of the article makes it sound as such.
CatherineM Posted May 30, 2008 Posted May 30, 2008 I guess I'm kind of dense, but how does a male priesthood deny women in the third world the opportunity to attend college?
FreeSoul Posted May 30, 2008 Posted May 30, 2008 (edited) It doesnt! LOL That's totally not my point at all! lmao It encourages it by reserving for men an idealized role traditionally reserved for women! By that I mean...the role of nurturer...not the role of priest. Edited May 30, 2008 by FreeSoul
Winchester Posted May 30, 2008 Posted May 30, 2008 [img]http://www.oicr.on.ca/portal/pablum_top.jpg[/img]
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now