Paladin D Posted May 30, 2008 Posted May 30, 2008 [url="http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,360361,00.html"]Brazil Discovers Uncontacted Indian Tribe in Amazon Jungle[/url] [quote]RIO DE JANEIRO, Brazil — One of Brazil's last uncontacted Indian tribes has been spotted in the far western Amazon jungle near the Peruvian border, the National Indian Foundation said Thursday. The Indians were sighted in an Ethno-Environmental Protected Area along the Envira River in flights over remote Acre state, said the government foundation, known as Funai. Funai said it photographed "strong and healthy" warriors, six huts and a large planted area. But it was not known to which tribe they belonged, the group said. "Four distinct isolated peoples exist in this region, whom we have accompanied for 20 years," Funai expert Jose Carlos Meirelles Junior said in a statement. Funai does not make contact with the Indians and prevents invasions of their land, to ensure total autonomy for the isolated tribes, the foundation said. Survival International said the Indians are in danger from illegal logging in Peru, which is driving uncontacted tribes over the border and could lead to conflict with the estimated 500 uncontacted Indians now living on the Brazilian side. There are more than 100 uncontacted tribes worldwide, most of them in Brazil and Peru, the group said in a statement. "These pictures are further evidence that uncontacted tribes really do exist," Survival director Stephen Corry said. "The world needs to wake up to this, and ensure that their territory is protected in accordance with international law. Otherwise, they will soon be made extinct."[/quote]
Thy Geekdom Come Posted May 30, 2008 Posted May 30, 2008 I've heard that these tribes exist, but had never heard of any actually being found. This interests me. I think we should make every effort to coexist with them, but I can't say I'm in favor of not really making contact. I'm fine with allowing them to keep their culture (whatever is not immoral, anyway), but I also think we should be evangelizing them and sharing knowledge (teaching them what we know about health, for instance, and perhaps learning anything they have to offer us).
Paladin D Posted May 30, 2008 Author Posted May 30, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Raphael' post='1548946' date='May 30 2008, 01:18 AM']I've heard that these tribes exist, but had never heard of any actually being found. This interests me. I think we should make every effort to coexist with them, but I can't say I'm in favor of not really making contact. I'm fine with allowing them to keep their culture (whatever is not immoral, anyway), but I also think we should be evangelizing them and sharing knowledge (teaching them what we know about health, for instance, and perhaps learning anything they have to offer us).[/quote] Exactly. I don't think it's a wise idea to not try and coexist with these tribes. I mean, if I was living in a muddy hut with no A/C in 100+F degree weather, with sub-par living conditions, and nasty misquitos... I better beaver dam would appreciate it if the people next door offered a room for rent, with a decent meal and bath, and some bug repellent. Just imagine this scenario: *Tribesmen discover a modern town while on a hike, and discover all its wonders, before they encounter the town mayor* "Holy croutons, where have you guys been?" - Tribe Chief "Oh, we've always been here. We just didn't wanna bother your way of life, thought you guys were content the way you were." - Mayor "Our people have been living in a s**t hole for the past 100 years, and you didn't even bother giving us a heads up? What the fudge is that!?" - Tribe Chief Edited May 30, 2008 by Paladin D
CatherineM Posted May 30, 2008 Posted May 30, 2008 I wonder how long it will take before they are wearing t-shirts and ball hats.
Paladin D Posted May 30, 2008 Author Posted May 30, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1549080' date='May 30 2008, 02:21 AM']I wonder how long it will take before they are wearing t-shirts and ball hats.[/quote] And testing their hunting skills on the Wii.
Kitty Posted May 30, 2008 Posted May 30, 2008 [quote name='Paladin D' post='1549057' date='May 30 2008, 12:58 AM']Exactly. I don't think it's a wise idea to not try and coexist with these tribes. I mean, if I was living in a muddy hut with no A/C in 100+F degree weather, with sub-par living conditions, and nasty misquitos... I better beaver dam would appreciate it if the people next door offered a room for rent, with a decent meal and bath, and some bug repellent.[/quote] Don't forget that these people have not had contact with the outside world for about 10,000 years, and so this is their way of life, this is all they know. The pictures show the tribes shooting arrows at the airplane flying over them because they had no idea what it was; for all they knew, it could be a spirit, a god, or a giant bird. Also, because of their lack of exposure to other people, they have no defenses against mild sicknesses like the common cold. If one of their tribesmen came in contact with the virus, it could easily spread and wipe them all out. Personally, I believe they should be left alone. I think it is very fascinating to see such a primitive way of life still existing in 2008.
Jesus_lol Posted May 30, 2008 Posted May 30, 2008 [quote name='Paladin D' post='1549057' date='May 29 2008, 10:58 PM']Exactly. I don't think it's a wise idea to not try and coexist with these tribes. I mean, if I was living in a muddy hut with no A/C in 100+F degree weather, with sub-par living conditions, and nasty misquitos... I better beaver dam would appreciate it if the people next door offered a room for rent, with a decent meal and bath, and some bug repellent. Just imagine this scenario: *Tribesmen discover a modern town while on a hike, and discover all its wonders, before they encounter the town mayor* "Holy croutons, where have you guys been?" - Tribe Chief "Oh, we've always been here. We just didn't wanna bother your way of life, thought you guys were content the way you were." - Mayor "Our people have been living in a s**t hole for the past 100 years, and you didn't even bother giving us a heads up? What the fudge is that!?" - Tribe Chief[/quote] that didnt really work with the native americans. compared to a lot of the sludge and general lameness in western life, i wouldnt mind being a tribesman!
Paladin D Posted May 30, 2008 Author Posted May 30, 2008 [quote name='Kitty' post='1549094' date='May 30 2008, 02:30 AM']Also, because of their lack of exposure to other people, they have no defenses against mild sicknesses like the common cold. If one of their tribesmen came in contact with the virus, it could easily spread and wipe them all out. Personally, I believe they should be left alone. I think it is very fascinating to see such a primitive way of life still existing in 2008.[/quote] Make a good point about the health risks that would be involved; however, is it not our obligation as Catholics to spread the message of Christ and His Truth to those who have yet to even hear it? Of course, do so in prudence and in the right setting... not just walk out in the field and say "Alright heathens, bow before Christ or be cast into the pits of Hell!!!"
Alycin Posted May 30, 2008 Posted May 30, 2008 [quote name='Paladin D' post='1549057' date='May 30 2008, 12:58 AM']I mean, if I was living in a muddy hut with no A/C in 100+F degree weather, with sub-par living conditions, and nasty misquitos... I better beaver dam would appreciate it if the people next door offered a room for rent, with a decent meal and bath, and some bug repellent. Just imagine this scenario:[/quote] That's a bit presumptuous. It would be one thing to offer them the "amenities" of the modern world and let them partake if they wanted to, but it is quite another to assume that they aren't doing just fine with things the way they are. And if you haven't noticed, everything we have these days comes with a price. Sure, we have technology such as computers and televisions and video games, but we also have little kids that no longer go outdoors and run and play and get natural exercise from it. The list goes on.
Paladin D Posted May 30, 2008 Author Posted May 30, 2008 [quote name='Jesus_lol' post='1549095' date='May 30 2008, 02:34 AM']that didnt really work with the native americans. compared to a lot of the sludge and general lameness in western life, i wouldnt mind being a tribesman![/quote] That's because we broke agreements we made with them, and kicked them out of their own lands. I'm not saying we do the same with these tribesmen, just at least make contact and spread the Good News. Also offer some Hershey Kisses with milk.
Kitty Posted May 30, 2008 Posted May 30, 2008 (edited) You might want to read this article if you're interested: it is more in-depth than the Fox article. [url="http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1022822/Incredible-pictures-Earths-uncontacted-tribes-firing-bows-arrows.html"]http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10...ows-arrows.html[/url] On the topic of evangelizing these people, I don't really support it. It's like going to another planet and trying to talk about Jesus and God to aliens. These people have a completely different life, language and religion then the rest of the world. Not only would they not welcome strangers, but they may have their own spirit or god that they pray to. Honestly, leading such a life seems tempting. Think about it: no cars, no causing pollution, no bills, no TV, no computers, internet, or any modern technology; no celebrities, no magazines, no newspapers. Living in a grass hut in the middle of the Amazon, with no awareness of the rest of the world, sounds quite peaceful to me. I'm sure God understands them. Edited May 30, 2008 by Kitty
Paladin D Posted May 30, 2008 Author Posted May 30, 2008 [quote name='Alycin' post='1549098' date='May 30 2008, 02:36 AM']That's a bit presumptuous. It would be one thing to offer them the "amenities" of the modern world and let them partake if they wanted to, but it is quite another to assume that they aren't doing just fine with things the way they are. And if you haven't noticed, everything we have these days comes with a price. Sure, we have technology such as computers and televisions and video games, but we also have little kids that no longer go outdoors and run and play and get natural exercise from it. The list goes on.[/quote] True. You can't miss what you already don't have. Though we still have an obligation to make contact for at least one important reason.. to spread the message of Christ and His Church. That is our moral obligation as not only Catholics, but as Christians (in one capacity or another).
Paladin D Posted May 30, 2008 Author Posted May 30, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Kitty' post='1549102' date='May 30 2008, 02:41 AM']You might want to read this article if you're interested: it is more in-depth than the Fox article. [url="http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1022822/Incredible-pictures-Earths-uncontacted-tribes-firing-bows-arrows.html"]http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10...ows-arrows.html[/url] On the topic of evangelizing these people, I don't really support it. It's like going to another planet and trying to talk about Jesus and God to aliens. These people have a completely different life, language and religion then the rest of the world. Not only would they not welcome strangers, but they may have their own spirit or god that they pray to. Honestly, leading such a life seems tempting. Think about it: no cars, no causing pollution, no bills, no TV, no computers, internet, or any modern technology; no celebrities, no magazines, no newspapers. Living in a grass hut in the middle of the Amazon, with no awareness of the rest of the world, sounds quite peaceful to me. I'm sure God understands them.[/quote] That didn't stop St. Francis Xavier from traveling to the Far East. I'm not proposing that we send everyone and their grandma with a rosary to the Amazon to talk to these people, but somehow with upmost prudence, sensitivity, and caution, to evanglize to these people. If it be today, or years down the road. Personally, I don't go around and ask everyone on the street "Do you know Jesus?", I just do the best I can to live my life in accordance to what the Church teaches. Be an example, and if someone is interested or if a topic comes up that needs to be addressed, I do so. I'm not advocating that we bum rush these people. Edited May 30, 2008 by Paladin D
Aloysius Posted May 30, 2008 Posted May 30, 2008 it is very likely that this tribe has indeed had contact with western civilization in some way, it simply wasn't a lasting contact, it may have happened centuries ago but I would assume it probably has happened. If it has not, that would be amazing... it is so implausible that there has never been any contact. We generally say in anthropology that there are no un-contacted peoples in the world. to think that they have not is a fanciful idea, especially considering all we've done is spot them and no one has actually asked if they've ever seen us before. the picture painted of them waiting for the wonders of modernity to save them from a terrible and unbearable existence is nothing more than modernism and ethnocentrism. I also got a tone here that you're viewing these people as if they are not a fully modern people who have evolved to the point that they are currently in... they are not living the way our ancestors lived, they're not a magic window to the past, they're a culture which has continuously evolved and advanced to this point in their history. they have not advanced the same way we have, but it is likely that on many things they could be quite a bit more advanced than us. There are tribes in the amazon with a mastery of using poisons for hunting that we have never developed, for instance. nothing good would come from absorbing them into our modernist culture, but sure a cultural exchange ought to happen (though I am sure that they have probably been effected by our culture in ways already, but probably not positive ways) and we ought to share ideas and medicine and such where possible; but it's something we ought to be very careful about and in some instances it might be preferable to not interfere even when some technologies we could offer might seemingly be helpful to them, because it can create harms that we cannot foresee which might be greater than the harms they alleviate. if you change one aspect of a culture, you change all aspects of a culture; in social science it's called the law of unintended effects. the prime directive is important even on the planet earth however, as regards to evangelizing them, if you do not believe evangelizing them is important then you are not a Catholic. that is essential to the role of the Church and to believe that the Church does not have the right and obligation to spread the faith to every people, or that Jesus does not apply to them, you are a heretic plain and simple. obviously great care must be made to integrate their culture into the faith (protestant missionaries are usually the worst at this and go into places trying to advance their entire culture along with their religion), but it is a moral obligation for the Church to offer the gospel to these people. Actually, to do any less would be a form of racism, for the Church says God wishes all to be saved through Jesus Christ so any peoples that we refuse to offer the gospel to we are discriminating against. Either we have a message that ought to be shared with them, or we all ought to abandon it ourselves. Those are the only two options, the absolute only two options... because to believe in Jesus is to believe in His mandate to us to "baptize all nations". when you reject that mandate, you reject Christ. Aliens would be another issue. We cannot be sure that aliens would be Sons of Adam, and Christ's redemptive work only applies to sons of Adam. The Church holds that all human beings have equal dignity and a common source (to hold anything else is racist) so no matter where humans are found, they have a right to know about Jesus.... if/when aliens were found, the determination would have to be made 1) are they rational/sentient 2) do they have a fallen nature 3) do they have an eternal soul and 4) are they in need of salvation. with every human being on the planet we can say yes to all four of those questions, though.
Aloysius Posted May 30, 2008 Posted May 30, 2008 oh, and I'm sorry if I come off as harsh, but these are our brothers and sisters and it just irks me a lot when a fellow Christian thinks it's okay to withhold the gospel from them. it is a form of racism, albeit one that is not as nasty as an outright belief in their inferiority. the only non-racist attitude is one which holds them as completely equal in human dignity... if it's good enough for us it's good enough for them. unless you yourself are a hebrew, I would have just as much of an argument against you believing in Jesus as you would have against bringing them the news about Jesus. if evangelizing them is wrong, then St. Paul was wrong to bring it to any gentiles and Patrick was wrong to bring it to the Irish and Francis Xavier was wrong to bring it to the Orient and we were wrong to bring it to the Americas at all and, well, the entire worldwide Church ought to really be disassembled. cultures interact with each other; it is inevitable, it is natural, it is human, it is good. we must avoid the type of modernist error which absorbs cultures and puts them at the peripheral edges of our own culture, of course, but a good missionary (like the way the Jesuits used to be, they were great missionaries back in the day) could come in and learn their culture completely and live much like them and learn their language and their stories (and record them for posterity) and learn from them and, in exchange, offer them Christ as the capstone to their whole culture.
Kitty Posted May 30, 2008 Posted May 30, 2008 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1549145' date='May 30 2008, 06:33 AM']cultures interact with each other; it is inevitable, it is natural, it is human, it is good. we must avoid the type of modernist error which absorbs cultures and puts them at the peripheral edges of our own culture, of course, but a good missionary (like the way the Jesuits used to be, they were great missionaries back in the day) could come in and learn their culture completely and live much like them and learn their language and their stories (and record them for posterity) and learn from them and, in exchange, offer them Christ as the capstone to their whole culture.[/quote] That's great, but until someone like that is found, it is pretty much useless to try and even make contact with them now. For instance, take this excerpt from the news article I posted: [size=1]"The uncontacted tribes, which are located in the jungles of South America, New Guinea and a remote and the beautiful and remote North Sentinel island in the Indian Ocean (the inhabitants of which have also responded to attempts at contact with extreme aggression) all have one thing in common - they want to be left alone. And for good reason. The history of contact, between indigenous tribes and the outside world, has always been an unhappy one."[/size] So unless we find some way to present ourselves as unthreatening, the only way these uncontacted tribes will greet us is with arrows to the head.
Aloysius Posted May 30, 2008 Posted May 30, 2008 and that is where martyrs come from. this is clearly a case that requires a lone holy priest with apostolic charity to go in and gain their respect and learn their culture.
Jesus_lol Posted May 30, 2008 Posted May 30, 2008 [quote name='Kitty' post='1549364' date='May 30 2008, 09:31 AM']So unless we find some way to present ourselves as unthreatening, the only way these uncontacted tribes will greet us is with arrows to the head.[/quote] nice! yep, if i was a tribesman, and had a knowledge of how these sort of contacts end up, i would be blowdarting every uninvited white boy that came a calling.
Aloysius Posted June 24, 2008 Posted June 24, 2008 like I said... this romanticized idea of discovering some new uncontacted pristine tribe is just... well... not going to happen. [url="http://buzz.yahoo.com/buzzlog/91536"]http://buzz.yahoo.com/buzzlog/91536[/url] We've pretty much found everyone... and probably had interaction in some form or another with pretty much everyone.
prose Posted June 24, 2008 Posted June 24, 2008 [quote name='Kitty' post='1549094' date='May 30 2008, 12:30 AM']Don't forget that these people have not had contact with the outside world for about 10,000 years, and so this is their way of life, this is all they know. The pictures show the tribes shooting arrows at the airplane flying over them because they had no idea what it was; for all they knew, it could be a spirit, a god, or a giant bird.[/quote] Why do we assume because they don't have computers that they are idiots that think an airplane is a "spirit"? They very well may not have been in contact with our society because they don't want to. They may know modern man. We don't know they are an uncontacted tribe. We are making a lot of assumptions just because of a flyover. Maybe they were throwing spears because they think we are jerks and want to make it clear that they don't want us near them. Maybe they know who Christ is already. Maybe they HAVE been evangelized. We just don't know, and if we do not contact them, then we never will know. One more thing, I think that regardless of the "comforts" of modern society, it would be good to give them access to medications and medical treatment that they may not have if they would like it. I know if my child was dying from some sort of treatable illness, and the person who could help didn't come because they wanted to maintain my "tribe" as a museum exhibit, I would be pissed off.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now