Deb Posted May 30, 2008 Posted May 30, 2008 From CNN.......( I guess I forgot that we weren't there to set them up as a free country. ) A U.S. Marine in Iraq has been removed from duty amid complaints that he was handing out coins with Bible verses at an American checkpoint, the military said Thursday.A military spokesman said Iraqis in Falluja complained that the Marine was giving the coins, which were printed in Arabic, to people at an entry control point in Falluja. U.S. military regulations prohibit religious proselytizing. "This has our full attention," said Col. James L. Welsh, chief of staff of Multi-National Force, West. "We deeply value our relationship with the local citizens and share their concerns over this serious incident." At least one of the coins is stamped with the words "Where will you spend eternity?" according to a report published Thursday by McClatchy Newspapers. The other side of the coin reportedly contains a verse from John 3:16 that reads, "For God so loved the world that he gave his only begotten son, that whoever believes in him shall not perish, but have eternal life."Several Falluja residents said they were given the coins over a two-day period and complained that U.S. troops, whom they consider foreign occupiers, were acting as Christian missionaries. "Regulations prohibit members of the coalition force from proselytizing any religion, faith or practices," said Col. Bill Buckner, a coalition spokesman. "Our troops are trained on those guidelines before they deploy." A military statement said "appropriate action" will be taken if the reports are substantiated. The reports stoked religious concerns in Iraq just weeks after Iraqi police discovered that a U.S. soldier had used the Quran, Islam's holy book, for target practice. The U.S. commander in Baghdad took the unusual step of holding a public ceremony and reading a letter of apology from the soldier, a sniper section leader, to local Iraqi leaders. Many in attendance were members and leaders of Sunni militias that the U.S. military has courted to help fight [url="http://topics.cnn.com/topics/Al_Qaeda_in_Iraq"][b][color="#004276"]al Qaeda in Iraq[/color][/b][/url] and other insurgents. Sunnis often face criticism from other Iraqis for cooperating with American troops. Falluja, also a mostly Sunni city, was the scene of bitter and bloody fighting early in the Iraq war between U.S. troops, al Qaeda in Iraq and Sunni insurgents loyal to Saddam Hussein.
StColette Posted May 30, 2008 Posted May 30, 2008 Well, the soldier did violate several guidelines. I woud have to ask my brother for more info on the specifics of the guidelines in regards to passing out religious material, especially while in uniform and overseas. Our soldiers are in a very tricky situation over in the middle east. From what my brother has told me you are not allowed to have religious objects of any kind on your person, at least when you are on duty, except if you are a chaplin of course.
Didacus Posted May 30, 2008 Posted May 30, 2008 [quote name='StColette' post='1549323' date='May 30 2008, 09:54 AM']Well, the soldier did violate several guidelines. I woud have to ask my brother for more info on the specifics of the guidelines in regards to passing out religious material, especially while in uniform and overseas. Our soldiers are in a very tricky situation over in the middle east. From what my brother has told me you are not allowed to have religious objects of any kind on your person, at least when you are on duty, except if you are a chaplin of course.[/quote] I agree, he violated guidelines and done more in my opinion. Like Iraq is not versatile enough, his actions can cause anger amongst the locals and in the life and death sitaution that often arises in the region, may cost lives. I'm all for spreading the good Word of our Lord, but it must be done in proper place and proper time and in proper method. For example, bible thumping in an atheist circle will do not good for the cause but simply strengthen the resolve that religious people are bible crazy idiots.
StColette Posted May 30, 2008 Posted May 30, 2008 [quote name='Didacus' post='1549363' date='May 30 2008, 11:30 AM']I agree, he violated guidelines and done more in my opinion. Like Iraq is not versatile enough, his actions can cause anger amongst the locals and in the life and death sitaution that often arises in the region, may cost lives. I'm all for spreading the good Word of our Lord, but it must be done in proper place and proper time and in proper method.[/quote] The situation over there is very delicate and actions like this could possibly throw things off balance. I'm sure the soldier's intentions were good, but he could have endangered several others and possibly cause a big uproar from the locals. They take their faith very seriously as do we.
Deb Posted May 30, 2008 Author Posted May 30, 2008 So are soldiers not allowed to wear a crucifix or anything like that or is all types of "jewelry" period, not allowed? I am just curious as really don't know.
CatherineM Posted May 30, 2008 Posted May 30, 2008 My son wasn't allowed his 4 way cross in bootcamp, but that might just have been for safety reasons, or he could just have sent it home in fear it would get broken or lost. As far as I know they are allowed to wear them. After bootcamp, I tried to give it back to him, but he said he wanted me to keep wearing it for him. They can certainly have large religious tattoos, so long as they aren't on the hands, neck or face. Handing out religious things like that in such a volatile area would come under going against good order and discipline. He could start a riot or something that might cost the lives of other soldiers. That's as stupid as the guy who was caught shooting a copy of the Qur'an. There is a time and place for evangelization, and in uniform, with a gun in your hand, walking streets where you are not wanted, is not the best place for that.
Deb Posted May 30, 2008 Author Posted May 30, 2008 I guess if he was in direct violation of military policy, he will have to suffer whatever discipline they mete out. I was really shocked by the soldier who used the Qu'ran for target practice. That is so very disrespectul. I wonder if there is a handbook on what you can and cannot do for specific countries you are in?
CatherineM Posted May 30, 2008 Posted May 30, 2008 I don't think they have a specific hand book, but they are supposed to be briefed before going. My son got briefed before being allowed to go on shore leave when their ship was in foreign ports. As to general travel, there are books on protocol.
Deb Posted May 30, 2008 Author Posted May 30, 2008 I would be in big trouble. I don't really remember rules all that much.
StColette Posted May 30, 2008 Posted May 30, 2008 [quote name='Deb' post='1549373' date='May 30 2008, 11:42 AM']So are soldiers not allowed to wear a crucifix or anything like that or is all types of "jewelry" period, not allowed? I am just curious as really don't know.[/quote] From what my brother has told me, they are not allowed to wear any religious objects
Thy Geekdom Come Posted May 30, 2008 Posted May 30, 2008 [quote name='StColette' post='1549596' date='May 30 2008, 02:24 PM']From what my brother has told me, they are not allowed to wear any religious objects[/quote] I've heard of some of them getting rosary tattoos around their necks, though, lol.
StColette Posted May 30, 2008 Posted May 30, 2008 [quote name='Raphael' post='1549598' date='May 30 2008, 02:28 PM']I've heard of some of them getting rosary tattoos around their necks, though, lol.[/quote] Well, I don't think the military will chop off their necks to get rid of the religious article lol They might make them have the tattoo removed if it causes enough stir I guess.
Autumn Dusk Posted May 30, 2008 Posted May 30, 2008 the idea is to impart as little of our culture, including religion, on them as possible to avoid occupier status.
IcePrincessKRS Posted May 30, 2008 Posted May 30, 2008 [quote name='Deb' post='1549373' date='May 30 2008, 12:42 PM']So are soldiers not allowed to wear a crucifix or anything like that or is all types of "jewelry" period, not allowed? I am just curious as really don't know.[/quote] I'm not 100% certain about when they are in Iraq, but normally they are allowed to wear a religious article (like a necklace or scapular) as long as its under your uniform. (Under because its not a part of the uniform.) As for other jewelry only wedding bands are allowed as far as I know. (My husband is sitting here next to me so I keep shooting random questions at me.) [quote name='Deb' post='1549421' date='May 30 2008, 01:26 PM']I guess if he was in direct violation of military policy, he will have to suffer whatever discipline they mete out. I was really shocked by the soldier who used the Qu'ran for target practice. That is so very disrespectul. I wonder if there is a handbook on what you can and cannot do for specific countries you are in?[/quote] My husband said the soldier will likely either get counseled (which is basically a written statement on file in his record), or an article 15, which, if they think he's acted badly enough, can result in having part of his pay taken or even a reduction in rank. [quote name='StColette' post='1549596' date='May 30 2008, 03:24 PM']From what my brother has told me, they are not allowed to wear any religious objects[/quote] When my brother was in Iraq the first time he sewed scapulars on the inside of his uniforms... I'm not sure if he just doesn't like wearing them or if he wasn't allowed to, though.
Justin86 Posted June 1, 2008 Posted June 1, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1549418' date='May 31 2008, 02:23 AM']My son wasn't allowed his 4 way cross in bootcamp, but that might just have been for safety reasons, or he could just have sent it home in fear it would get broken or lost.[/quote] When I went through Boot Camp we were allowed to wear one religious medallion with our dogtags. I've never heard anything saying we weren't allowed to wear them since. [quote]They can certainly have large religious tattoos, so long as they aren't on the hands, neck or face. Handing out religious things like that in such a volatile area would come under going against good order and discipline.[/quote] Sailors aren't allowed to have tattoos that can be seen while wearing the uniform unless they had them before they joined the Navy, and got a waiver. It applies for all tattoos, not just religious ones. As for wearing religious medallions might offend the local population, how would anyone even know you're wearing one underneath your uniform anyway?
Autumn Dusk Posted June 1, 2008 Posted June 1, 2008 [quote name='Justin86' post='1552838' date='Jun 1 2008, 06:09 PM']As for wearing religious medallions might offend the local population, how would anyone even know you're wearing one underneath your uniform anyway?[/quote] the problem with that is some people don't know how not to "ooops" have it fall out. Punishing the many for the one, stinks, but when its life or death it has to be that way.
Justin86 Posted June 2, 2008 Posted June 2, 2008 Dogtags can't really "fall out" while in uniform. The chain is way to long for that to happen, and the uniform is way too tight.
Autumn Dusk Posted June 2, 2008 Posted June 2, 2008 [quote name='Justin86' post='1554129' date='Jun 2 2008, 10:55 AM']Dogtags can't really "fall out" while in uniform. The chain is way to long for that to happen, and the uniform is way too tight.[/quote] I know that...but it dosn't mean that some idiot (for the lack of a better term) wouldn't try something stupid. For everything that someone does right there's a private who's found a way to do it his way.
Justin86 Posted June 2, 2008 Posted June 2, 2008 Some stupid PFC for the Marines more than likely. But yeah, I get what you're saying.
kujo Posted June 2, 2008 Posted June 2, 2008 [quote name='Autumn Dusk' post='1549784' date='May 30 2008, 06:44 PM']the idea is to impart as little of our culture, including religion, on them as possible to avoid occupier status.[/quote] I think this is the key here. Our soldiers have enough troubles trying to kep the peace between the various sects of Islam while trying to get them to set up a functioning democracy. If we add evangelizing and promoting Christianity to the mix, it undercuts our efforts. This guy deserves whatever punishment he gets for violating an obvious (and intelligent) rule.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now