Alycin Posted June 6, 2008 Posted June 6, 2008 [quote]For those who aren't aware yet, Alex's teacher, Wendy Portillo, apparently became frustrated with his behavior and decided to discipline him. Her chosen method was to shame him, Survivor style, by having the other children in the class say what they didn't like about him and then vote on whether or not they wanted him in the class with them. The children called him "disgusting" and "annoying" and voted 14 to 2 to kick him out of the class.[/quote] [url="http://mamampj.blogspot.com/2008/05/alex-barton.html"]Full story and source[/url]
Alycin Posted June 6, 2008 Author Posted June 6, 2008 [quote name='kujo' post='1561475' date='Jun 6 2008, 07:38 PM']Ugh.....[/quote] I know, it's awful.
Madtown Sem. Posted June 6, 2008 Posted June 6, 2008 assuming my own particular judgement during the eschaton goes well, would it be wrong to chuckle at people who clearly acted like jerks in this life and finally have to pay for it?
Alycin Posted June 6, 2008 Author Posted June 6, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Madtown Sem.' post='1561488' date='Jun 6 2008, 07:47 PM']assuming my own particular judgement during the eschaton goes well, would it be wrong to chuckle at people who clearly acted like jerks in this life and finally have to pay for it?[/quote] yes. (I don't really know... it is just my personal opinion that it would be wrong to laugh at them.) ETA: To be clear, I would want to see her get reprimanded big time. Edited June 6, 2008 by Alycin
CatherineM Posted June 6, 2008 Posted June 6, 2008 I wonder what college this teacher went to? It must be some kind of new education theory that humiliating kids is good for them.
Galloglasses Posted June 7, 2008 Posted June 7, 2008 That kid is going to have major trauma problems after that. The cane would've been kinder and THATS NOT KIND!
Jesus_lol Posted June 7, 2008 Posted June 7, 2008 wow, that is cold. to a teenager, this might not be so bad, but who in their right mind could think of doing something like this to a five year old? this is the type of croutons that messes people up for life.
picchick Posted June 7, 2008 Posted June 7, 2008 The teasing done to me in school was not that bad. I am going to start praying for that kid
lilac_angel Posted June 7, 2008 Posted June 7, 2008 [quote name='Jesus_lol' post='1561573' date='Jun 6 2008, 08:03 PM']wow, that is cold. to a teenager, this might not be so bad, but who in their right mind could think of doing something like this to a five year old? this is the type of croutons that messes people up for life.[/quote] i think there are better disciplinary ways of dealing with unruly teens... this kind of treatment to any individual is pointless and cruel, and people can be deeply effected at any age, since everyone is different.
Alycin Posted June 7, 2008 Author Posted June 7, 2008 (edited) IMO this is a good reason for cloning... if you could clone my kindergarten teacher and have her teaching all the kids in America, it would be a better country, no lie. ETA: I don't really believe in cloning, btw. Edited June 7, 2008 by Alycin
melporcristo Posted June 7, 2008 Posted June 7, 2008 JMJ [quote]The children called him "disgusting" and "annoying" and voted 14 to 2 to kick him out of the class.[/quote] What the heck. That teacher needs to get ousted. And then they can hire me because I'm looking for a teaching position. My 5 year olds don't say disgusting, either. I think that was a misquote. Psh.
Archaeology cat Posted June 7, 2008 Posted June 7, 2008 (edited) Here's another article about it. And of course this happened in FL. [url="http://www.tcpalm.com/news/2008/may/24/30gtteacher-lets-students-vote-out-classmate-5/?feedback=1#comments"]http://www.tcpalm.com/news/2008/may/24/30g...back=1#comments[/url] I don't understand what kind of teacher would not only allow this, but [i]encourage [/i]it! I worked so hard to make sure my students didn't insult each other (3rd grade), and didn't tolerate any kind of insults/slurs/etc. I certainly hope the principal takes disciplinary action. How long has the teacher been there, anyway? Edited June 7, 2008 by Archaeology cat
Not A Mallard Posted June 7, 2008 Posted June 7, 2008 (edited) I've seen this story on the news before. That's mean. Edited June 7, 2008 by Not A Mallard
jmjtina Posted June 7, 2008 Posted June 7, 2008 This is heartbreaking. I'm not condoning her behavior. It just breaks my heart to see that this probably could have been prevented. The child and the teacher could have been successful. Handling an autistic child in a full classroom is difficult. But I'm wondering if she had the support you need to handle a special needs child like that. Not having the support needed happens more often than I'd like to admit. Firing a teacher is not fixing the problem but putting a bandaid on an already leaky dam. Fixing the dam is alot harder. How can a school system ensure that this won't happen again? That teacher may be gone, but it won't be the last autistic child that will be in the system.
Autumn Dusk Posted June 7, 2008 Posted June 7, 2008 [quote name='jmjtina' post='1562636' date='Jun 7 2008, 03:25 PM']This is heartbreaking. I'm not condoning her behavior. It just breaks my heart to see that this probably could have been prevented. The child and the teacher could have been successful. Handling an autistic child in a full classroom is difficult. But I'm wondering if she had the support you need to handle a special needs child like that. Not having the support needed happens more often than I'd like to admit. Firing a teacher is not fixing the problem but putting a bandaid on an already leaky dam. Fixing the dam is alot harder. How can a school system ensure that this won't happen again? That teacher may be gone, but it won't be the last autistic child that will be in the system.[/quote] In some articles and blogs, one by another parent who had a kid in the class, the kid may not be autistic but simply badly behaved. The writer suggested he could be both. The article said that the mom was in the process of getting him tested...apparently has used this in a long line of excuses. The other parent said that the boy was prone to hitting other children, incessant screaming and talking and refused to do any work assigned to him...even simple crafts. The author's stated that her child (like most kinder gardeners) was eager to learn and the boy wouldn't be quiet...he wouldn't even play by himself but insisted on disrupting his classmates. And the parent would do virtually nothing but try to get a diagnosis. Now, that behavior is one of a child in trouble...and with over a dozen other kids in class should one adult, ONE? really be handling this? She did something foolish and stupid, something that was cruel to a child who may be acting in his best capacity, but honestly, I can't say as a teacher I wouldn't of wanted one afternoon of peace from this kid. They really need to recognize self-contained classrooms...8-12 kids with a teacher, and an aid and 2 or 3 other helpers. But no, self-contained isn't good for self-esteem of the kids. We're creating these problems and putting young teachers in no-win situations.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now