Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Another Question On Catholic Charismatic Groups


Recommended Posts

Posted

I know there is another thread on here regarding charismatic prayer groups, and I found it very interesting. So sorry if a new thread is unnecessary, but I had a slightly different question about them.

So first, some background: The guy I am seeing is a strong Charismatic Christian and he feels very drawn towards the Catholic Church(!!), but he worries because he feels like the gifts of the Holy Spirit aren't as present or obvious, I guess, in the Church, and he feels like he is called to minister specially in those types of areas of the Spirit. Next fall he is even going to the Bethel school of Supernatural Ministry for a year to learn more about them (and maybe become a minister, I'm not sure). He is probably sticking around Bellingham, Washington with me during the summer, and I really want to take him to a Catholic charismatic group, because we'll be continuing our dives into Catholic stuff and it's very important to him to discover if the Spirit really is moving in those ways in the Catholic Church. I've been to a few charismatic Catholic things when I was younger, and have seen people slain in the Spirit and heard of some healings, but other than that I'm really not very familiar with this aspect of Catholicism.
So question: Does anyone know how the Catholic groups compare to a charismatic non-denom. Christian group? Will he be dissapointed? He likes the rosary and loves Mass, but I think he's hoping for some speaking in tounges and praise and worship type stuff.

And bonus question! Is there anyone from the west side of Washington state who knows some sweet Catholic charismatic groups?

Thanks :)

Posted

I guess it depends on the charismatic group. Some groups exhibit the gifts quite openly and frequently, which has sometimes led more traditional Catholics to dismiss the charismatic movement as Catholics pretending to be Protestant or some such nonsense. Others are little more than prayer meetings with praise and worship music. Your mileage may vary (YMMV).

For example:
In New Orleans, the Center of Jesus the Lord exhibits all sorts of word gifts, prophecy, tongues, interpretation of tongues, etc. Whereas CCRNO (particularly its youth group) is somewhat more toned down by comparison. They both have their place, however.

LouisvilleFan
Posted

Speaking in tongues and "praise-and-worship stuff" are pretty universal experiences across all of the charismatic movement. I'd be surprised if you went to a meeting and didn't see those things. As scardella said, I think the same thing applies with Catholic and Protestant charismatics in that some groups are more "charismaniac" than others. Regardless, if he's truly open to the Holy Spirit and the love of God, he won't be disappointed with any gathering that also exhibits God's love regardless of the tangible signs.

Posted

I believe it's a grave error to only worship with people who have the gifts... isn't that "pentecostalism" or something? that only true believers have outward signs? Maybe if that's a problem for him (needing to see these outward signs), you might wanna kindly ask your friend why these are really really so important? St Paul did say certain rolls and certain gifts were given to different people. And it's not all about feelings. NOTE I'M NOT DISSING THE CHARISMATIC GATHERING. I'm just pointing out that if he's disappointed (which I really really hope not) then, it's something worth addressing. God bless

Posted
:yawn:
LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1568422' date='Jun 11 2008, 03:28 PM']:yawn:[/quote]

Care to elaborate, or are you just trying to say you don't care for the charismatic movement?

Posted

I think I have a bias because a Charismatic group my cousin belonged to pulled his entire family out of the Catholic church. That's a hard hurdle for me.

LouisvilleFan
Posted

So, I take it that wasn't a Catholic Charismatic group, was it?

Posted

Thanks Scardella and LouisvilleFan, that's very helpful information! and I'm not too worried about him being disappointed now, it sounds like the type of thing he would like, even if it's just praise and worship. Personally, I'm hoping when we find one to go to he'll be really impressed, but that's cause I'm biased towards him becoming Catholic and it would be one more mark for us in his book. :)


[quote name='Sacred Music Man' post='1568143' date='Jun 11 2008, 10:14 AM']I believe it's a grave error to only worship with people who have the gifts... isn't that "pentecostalism" or something? that only true believers have outward signs? Maybe if that's a problem for him (needing to see these outward signs), you might wanna kindly ask your friend why these are really really so important? St Paul did say certain rolls and certain gifts were given to different people. And it's not all about feelings. NOTE I'M NOT DISSING THE CHARISMATIC GATHERING. I'm just pointing out that if he's disappointed (which I really really hope not) then, it's something worth addressing. God bless[/quote]

Oh no, I'm pretty sure he doesn't rely on only outward signs. As I said, he loves the Mass (where he has a hard time NOT raising his hands when he sings and prays, but he controls himself so as to not distract others around him ;) ) and I think he is well aware that not everyone is given all those outward gifts. I certainly have never had them (the outward ones) :) But thank you for the advice - if he is disappointed for some reason, then maybe I will talk to him about it.

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1568494' date='Jun 11 2008, 01:37 PM']I think I have a bias because a Charismatic group my cousin belonged to pulled his entire family out of the Catholic church. That's a hard hurdle for me.[/quote]

Wow :mellow: That's so sad. I'll be sure and pay attention to what kind of stuff whatever group we go to is preaching. I got this link [url="http://www.wwccr.org/prayer_groups/prayer_groups.htm"]http://www.wwccr.org/prayer_groups/prayer_groups.htm[/url] from my mom, it's for Western WA Catholic Charismatic Renewal groups (what a mouthful!), and the stuff they have on their website looks pretty solid.

Posted

coolio. :)

I think I know why Apotheoun yawns. But I'll let him talk about it.

Posted

It was a Catholic Charismatic group. They just got so wild, that the pastor asked them to find somewhere else to have their meetings, so my cousin bought an old American Legion hall, and started his own church.

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1569171' date='Jun 12 2008, 01:08 AM']It was a Catholic Charismatic group. They just got so wild, that the pastor asked them to find somewhere else to have their meetings, so my cousin bought an old American Legion hall, and started his own church.[/quote]

:(

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1569171' date='Jun 12 2008, 01:08 AM']It was a Catholic Charismatic group. They just got so wild, that the pastor asked them to find somewhere else to have their meetings, so my cousin bought an old American Legion hall, and started his own church.[/quote]

Hmm... doesn't sound like they were very Catholic to begin with. Even the one group I've been to that promoted some Protestant theology on forgiveness of sins and praying for Jesus to come into your heart (it still cracks me up that they talked about Benny Hinn liked he should be taken seriously... being there, it would've been hilarious if it weren't true). But then they'd do very Catholic stuff, like pray around the tabernacle (everyone held hands with the people on each end laying a hand on the tabernacle, so Jesus becomes part of the circle... it's like the intersection of touchy-feely flower children with Jesus freaks and sacramental theology).

Although, at the root of all this, I think, has been a pervasive disconnect between Catholic hierarchy and laypeople, especially when the Protestant plain and simple approach to the Gospel and living a Christian life is so inviting.

  • 2 weeks later...
Saint Therese
Posted

Since the groups themselves aren't uniform in practice I don't think you cangeneralize. There are some that have wackos,but so does any group. Two of my favorite people in the Church today either are charismatic, or were: Mother Angelica and Sr. Briege Mckenna

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...